1. banvi's Hoshi (2.88 stars, 162 notes)
2. eveless' Tsuki (4.45 stars, 194 notes)
3. Hard (4.7 stars, 257 notes)
4. Insane (4.99 stars, 341 notes)

Selee wrote:

[banvi's Hoshi]
00:41:940 (5) - 2 grid down+1 grid left to make a symmetry? ok
00:43:540 (3) - move to the vertical axis? no
01:39:540 (5) - 1 grid down + 1 grid left? ok
This mod mulutiples with Clare's mod.

Mokou_Fujiwara wrote:

[banvi]
I can't read Chinese!!! lol
Tags I wrote something to add my mod.
01:47:540 音量线可以删除(或者这根完全没用到?) I don't know what you mean. Please fix , Clement?
01:53:940 这slider我认为4拍比较好lol ok
01:57:140 ^ ok
或许某些CLAP用的不好 反正我没仔细去听 clap数量貌似多了点?
Clement don't like whistle. So I ask change all whistle to clap. But I think so too many clap.
I don't have hitsound sense. Please delete some crap and add or change whistle , Clement... No whistle is not good.
Please understand.
But I don't want change chorus(kiai) part.

Astom wrote:

Hi =)
In red maybe important, In blue suggestions

[General]
-comboburst.png Max width is 500 pixels
-Use same kiai time in Hard and Insane

[Insane]
-01:36:340 (1) finish this in 01:36:740, move this 01:37:740 (1) to 01:37:140 and finish it in 01:39:540
-01:41:140 (1) finish it in 01:42:540.

Nice song ^^
Star~

100pa- wrote:

(ﾉﾟдﾟ)ﾉ　彡☆

insane
00:34:540 (4) - 陷阱moemoe

104,64,100140,5,0
256,136,100340,1,0
104,192,100540,1,0
256,272,100740,1,0
104,328,100940,1,0
256,192,101140,12,0,102740
176,208,103340,5,0
264,120,103540,1,0
320,224,103740,1,0
240,312,103940,1,8
104,200,104140,5,0
184,112,104340,1,0
240,216,104540,1,0
160,304,104740,1,8
384,224,105140,1,0
384,104,105340,1,0
488,168,105540,2,0,B|392:168|392:168,3,80,8|0|0|0
288,168,106340,5,4
168,168,106540,1,4

LKs wrote:

只有一些小的nazi问题，对map无影响
打分的话可以打8分，(不是指游戏后打的评分，那个分都是有水分的。我指我实际对这map的感觉至少在8分左右，GD和你的难度都不错，这是很难能可贵的
只加星不要kud

Pokie wrote:

8-) c-chu

ignorethis wrote:

- add composer to tag

- "thanks for playing" should appear after the song ends, and the colour of the text makes it hard to read
That's right. I will fixed it
- are the pics in background SB moving a bit too fast? >_>
^

star'd

ignorethis wrote:

- add composer to tag

- "thanks for playing" should appear after the song ends, and the colour of the text makes it hard to read

- are the pics in background SB moving a bit too fast? >_>

<Banvi's Hoshi>
00:19:933 (4) - remove whistle
00:50:733 (3) - up + left one grid in lv3
01:22:333 (2) - down one grid in lv3
01:27:333 (1,2,3,4,5) - remove 1,3,5 or use sliders
01:37:933 (1) - up one grid in lv3
01:38:333 (2) - left + down one grid lv3
(don't forget to mirror them)
01:40:133 (1,2,3,4,5) - same as above
01:58:733 (2,3,4,5,6) - down one grid lv3

<eveless' Tsuki>
oa+1
00:17:940 (1,2,3) - copy, paste and rotate 120° will look better
01:15:540 (3) - new combo
01:20:333 - add spinner?

<Hard>
00:36:733 (1,2) - this jump doesn't fit the rhythem at all, remove
00:49:133 (2,3,4,5,6) - arrange like this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/14713
01:21:133 (7) - this 0.5x slider is weird o.o
01:26:733 (4) - add this to 0.5x
01:39:133 (8) - add clap
01:47:933 (2,3,4,5) - remove

<Insane>
00:28:333 - add a note here
00:45:733 (1,2,3,4) - two grids up in lv3
01:04:333 (3) - right one grid in lv3
01:04:733 (5) - up two grids
01:29:333 (8) - left one grid
01:47:533 - add a spinner until here

star'd

tsukamaete wrote:

Easy:
00:57:133 (2) - new combo
just like the 01:09:133 (1)

01:59:533 (4,5,6) - soft whistle
02:00:333 (1) - soft finish
volume 80%

eveless' Tsuki:
fine
nice one

hard:
01:22:011 & 01:22:013 - why there are two same timing sections?????? remove the one of them


Insane:
00:29:633 (4,5) - awful distance =w=
01:20:333 (1,2,3,4) - could you make the jumps more closed ? its really harder than others ....just a suggestion

good job