forum

Neru x Rib - Jinsei wa Hoeru [Osu|OsuMania]

posted
Total Posts
250
show more
Topic Starter
puxtu
and about the metadata
- t/202584/hilit=vocaloid&start=0
- http://www.jvcmusic.co.jp/riboot/
-

priti, your move pls
neonat
your picture of tracklist =/= anywhere in the official site. Not getting you.
Topic Starter
puxtu
llmao neo
Bara-

Rebubbled

Avena
Qualified!
Topic Starter
puxtu
all aboard the hype train
Okoratu
gl o/

Edit: @baraatje: wouldnt conclude that stuff that fast
Bara-
Hoorayyy!
Congratz!!
First bubble which eventually got ranked, woohoo
Mint
omg yesssshhh

wheres senritsu get the camera
Senritsu

appleeaterx wrote:

omg yesssshhh

wheres senritsu get the camera
hi im hereee <33

gratz! wwwww
Haruto
Congratulations Everyone! :)
toybot
gratz puxtu! i think thats also the first time you got a nonmania diff qualified, lol


rip enmei chiryou
Shiranai
What did I miss hereeee? apparently I missed too many things hahaha :p
Anyway congrats kaa~
Bara-
YunoFanatic
wakawakawakawakawakawakawakawakak
Topic Starter
puxtu
wkwakwkwwkwkwwfokyouwkwkwkwawk
thanks for all your hard work guys, it is much appreciated!

and nice pass rate by the way
Kyousuke-
wow nice dude :^)
grats!

YunoFanatic wrote:

wakawakawakawakawakawakawakawakak
nya10
Wow no DQ pls
Nomination Assessment Team

Disqualification Notice



Hello!

Unfortunately, the Quality Assurance Team has decided to disqualify this beatmap. The following is a list of reasons and examples for the disqualification. We do not outline every issue in detail, so make sure to take the idea behind each reason and apply it to the entire beatmap as issues might be found in more than the spots mentioned below. If you have any questions, please reply to this post and we will do our best to clarify any misunderstandings.

General

Snapping conflicts in the mania difficulties

  • Usagi's MX and HD currently have a few snapping conflicts between them and they must be resolved.
  1. MX at 00:02:902 -, HD at 00:02:937 - (Left side MX, Right side HD) http://puu.sh/jygTy/b1f4223645.png
  2. MX at 00:04:650 -, HD at 00:04:615 - http://puu.sh/jygWa/c566b6bd9b.png
  3. MX at 00:09:860 -, HD at 00:09:825- http://puu.sh/jygYy/0316c8f9a1.png etc.
Useless uninherited timing point in all difficulties

  • Considering the BPM is now 286, there is no need for the uninherited timing point at 00:39:755 - and it should be removed.
Usagi's MX

Mapping Quality

  • The LN usage within this difficulty needs to be polished further before entering the ranked beatmaps section. Whilst the concept behind them is fine - they often contain inconsistencies and unnecessary extensions (which affects gameplay greatly) make the usage inappropriate.
  1. 00:09:545 (9545|2,9615|3,9860|2,9965|3,10175|2,10384|3) - Unnecessarily tricky as all of the LNs here are on 1 hand only.
  2. 00:36:189 - Inconsistent - are you missing an LN here for the sounds 00:34:930 (34930|3,35349|3) - ? It becomes unclear to what you are mapping to here.
  3. 00:39:755 - This timing point should be removed, but either way, the usage of the neutral soft sampleset is inconsistent. ( http://puu.sh/jyhR3/fcf9f73d31.png )
  4. 01:30:734 - same as 00:36:189 -
  5. 02:00:629 (120629|0) - Again, not clear to what you are mapping to and why this should be extended for so long.
  6. Our main gripe is with the section at 02:03:671 - to 02:12:796 - A lot of the LNs used here are inconsistent, and they can confuse players easily due to it's inconsistent usage.
  7. 02:04:090 (124090|1,124090|3) - No need to be extended for so long.
  8. 02:04:195 - A sound that is represented by 2 LNs here is now represented by 2 normal notes 02:05:873 - here, which is an example of the inconsistent usage. This applies for the rest of the section 02:03:671 - to 02:12:796 -.

If you happen to have concerns about this disqualification, you can contest the decision with this form. Before using this form, please read the instructions carefully.

The Beatmap Nominators may handle this mapset after the issues have been addressed.

Good luck!

###AM
Topic Starter
puxtu
So damn rekt lmao
Thanks starry o/
Mint
Since it's DQ'ed, can you please make the slider tick rate consistent with the others in my diff?
Bara-
Rib
Arzenvald
xD old map.. of course..
yeah i get it.. the extended LN in bridge phase is really unnecessary.. i will do my best to re-map most of LN part for quality sake, without changing the originality of my mapping style..

Quality Assurance Team wrote:

Disqualification Notice



Hello!

Unfortunately, the Quality Assurance Team has decided to disqualify this beatmap. The following is a list of reasons and examples for the disqualification. We do not outline every issue in detail, so make sure to take the idea behind each reason and apply it to the entire beatmap as issues might be found in more than the spots mentioned below. If you have any questions, please reply to this post and we will do our best to clarify any misunderstandings.

General

Snapping conflicts in the mania difficulties

  • Usagi's MX and HD currently have a few snapping conflicts between them and they must be resolved.
  1. MX at 00:02:902 -, HD at 00:02:937 - (Left side MX, Right side HD) http://puu.sh/jygTy/b1f4223645.png // using hd.. erm
  2. MX at 00:04:650 -, HD at 00:04:615 - http://puu.sh/jygWa/c566b6bd9b.png // using hd snapping tho.. .-.
  3. MX at 00:09:860 -, HD at 00:09:825- http://puu.sh/jygYy/0316c8f9a1.png etc. // using hd as well.. oh well


// 'If you have any questions, please reply to this post and we will do our best to clarify any misunderstandings.' which diff that has correct snapping? o3o pls reply

Useless uninherited timing point in all difficulties

  • Considering the BPM is now 286, there is no need for the uninherited timing point at 00:39:755 - and it should be removed. // here comes the unsnap.. xD
Usagi's MX

Mapping Quality

  • The LN usage within this difficulty needs to be polished further before entering the ranked beatmaps section. // will do

    Whilst the concept behind them is fine.. // i love you
    - ..they often contain inconsistencies and unnecessary extensions (which affects gameplay greatly) make the usage inappropriate. // <3 fine map is not fine
  1. 00:09:545 (9545|2,9615|3,9860|2,9965|3,10175|2,10384|3) - Unnecessarily tricky as all of the LNs here are on 1 hand only. // hmm ok
  2. 00:36:189 - Inconsistent - are you missing an LN here for the sounds 00:34:930 (34930|3,35349|3) - ? It becomes unclear to what you are mapping to here. // ok, at the 1st i map some varied polyrhythm from keyboard, hi-hat, & guitar bass (which its synced with vocal).. its simplified now
  3. 00:39:755 - This timing point should be removed, but either way, the usage of the neutral soft sampleset is inconsistent. ( http://puu.sh/jyhR3/fcf9f73d31.png ) // o_O yeah its removed
  4. 01:30:734 - same as 00:36:189 - // ok
  5. 02:00:629 (120629|0) - Again, not clear to what you are mapping to and why this should be extended for so long. // oook
  6. Our main gripe is with the section at 02:03:671 - to 02:12:796 - A lot of the LNs used here are inconsistent, and they can confuse players easily due to it's inconsistent usage. // ;'3 good bye retarded LN.. and at least a mod based playability as reason <3
  7. 02:04:090 (124090|1,124090|3) - No need to be extended for so long. // ok
  8. 02:04:195 - A sound that is represented by 2 LNs here is now represented by 2 normal notes 02:05:873 - here, which is an example of the inconsistent usage. This applies for the rest of the section 02:03:671 - to 02:12:796 -. // yuss.. all done

If you happen to have concerns about this disqualification, you can contest the decision with this form. Before using this form, please read the instructions carefully.

The Beatmap Nominators may handle this mapset after the issues have been addressed.

Good luck!

###AM
o~o that timing section tho.. well, i promise i will fix all stuff that addressed in the QAT post.. but later.. im still at office right now (haven't open osu! since yesterday)
also yuss.. at least, because even people thinks this map is overall-y.. 'bad' because the LN usage, i feel so happy, because the concept i tried to implement inside my chart is appreciated by QAT.. x33 thanks

update :
> all snapping is now following HD diffs..
> redefine some over-lengthed LN, while keep some in few stanzas (
> removed most ghost notes that i feel doesn't sync with bga (even there's sound on it)
Akasha-
Personally i think this song BPM is 143, it's really fit with that BPM, not with doubled-BPM
But, your choices

Anyway, good luck! I love this map
Bara-
Listen to the claps
They are every otger beat at 286 making that correct
Akasha-

Baraatje123 wrote:

Listen to the claps
They are every otger beat at 286 making that correct
i don't think it so . . .
PatZar
sedih
Furryy
I'm such a big fan on whoever made Extra :D
Bara-
PISHI <3
pishifat
!!!!
Mint
Btw, no comment on metadata from the QAT? I have the official CD here, and I don't know if it can be used as 'official source', but the embedded CD text just says "りぶ"



EDIT: @neonat it's not a rip, it's embedded cd text from the disc itself, pure raw untouched data. Neru is only mentioned in the composer field, but not in the artist field.
neonat

neonat wrote:

I would have artist be just りぶ if I were you. The Artist for the album Riboot is りぶ, they just then placed who made the Music & Lyrics individually for each song
I said this on page 10, but really, what you got would be what the ripper would decided to have it listed, depending on whether he wanted the composer/arranger in their own specific column. I mean yeah, I would rip it under りぶ as the artist, but I don't know about others.
blissfulyoshi
I'm probably going to say the artist as is (Neru feat.Rib) fine as is for osu!.

Reason: http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm22987299 lists the song as Neru×りぶ , but since we don't usually use the x in osu!, feat. is fine.
Topic Starter
puxtu
problem solved.
Arzenvald
pe have you update my diff (in case you forgot)
Bara-
Go priti
Shohei Ohtani
Oh shit I posted in the wrong thread.

Uhhh AutoMod says that there's unsnapped sliders in pishi'ss diff

Whoops.

Topic Starter
puxtu
high cdfa is high.
Bara-
;w;
Avena
pishi's Extra
Unsnapped Slider ends:
01:46:261 -
01:46:575 -
01:47:100 -
01:47:414 -
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply