This came into my mind yesterday after playing this map : https://osu.ppy.sh/b/246397
I started playing it . then after ~5:30 mins i assumed the map finished but to my surprise it didn't. A new song started.
When i clicked to play that mapped i was assuming i was playing this : https://osu.ppy.sh/b/152078 but i wasn't .
The map was a compilation of https://osu.ppy.sh/b/152078 + https://osu.ppy.sh/b/181253 + https://osu.ppy.sh/s/90803
Let's get to the point now. The first 2 song/s of that map have already their own ranked maps by the same mapper and are 100% identical. 0 changes made.
Plain Copy+ Paste . Only the 3rd song in that compilation is not ranked so i guess its acceptable . That makes the map 2/3 (Copy+ Paste) + 1/3 ( new map)
How is that even allowed?
The 2 maps already exists and only the 3rd one is unique. This should be forbidden . If every mapper would start to fuse their maps into a new one chaos would occur in osu and maps would get ranked every 30 seconds, why ? Because if a mapper with 3 ranked maps decides to make a compilation of these 3 maps it should get ranked right away since the 3 maps it consists of are already ranked and passed the quality check . Now imagine 1000 mappers doing that in a period of 1 week. Boom. We end up filling the osu server with the same maps again and people playing the same thing AGAIN ,gaining pp for the exact same maps. Even if the mapper uses 2 ranked and 1 unranked this would be crazy . Just map it separately And 1 ranked + 2 unranked it still makes no sense coz you can simply make a compilation with jsut the 2 unranked maps.
This feels like promoting laziness, coz to make such maps it takes extremely little to no effort.
If someone still want's to make a compilation with his already ranked maps then he can still do it and keep it unranked or a new category could be created.
TL;DR : Disallow ranking whole maps or parts(100% copy paste) of another already ranked map in a new maps."Title"
I started playing it . then after ~5:30 mins i assumed the map finished but to my surprise it didn't. A new song started.
When i clicked to play that mapped i was assuming i was playing this : https://osu.ppy.sh/b/152078 but i wasn't .
The map was a compilation of https://osu.ppy.sh/b/152078 + https://osu.ppy.sh/b/181253 + https://osu.ppy.sh/s/90803
Let's get to the point now. The first 2 song/s of that map have already their own ranked maps by the same mapper and are 100% identical. 0 changes made.
Plain Copy+ Paste . Only the 3rd song in that compilation is not ranked so i guess its acceptable . That makes the map 2/3 (Copy+ Paste) + 1/3 ( new map)
How is that even allowed?
The 2 maps already exists and only the 3rd one is unique. This should be forbidden . If every mapper would start to fuse their maps into a new one chaos would occur in osu and maps would get ranked every 30 seconds, why ? Because if a mapper with 3 ranked maps decides to make a compilation of these 3 maps it should get ranked right away since the 3 maps it consists of are already ranked and passed the quality check . Now imagine 1000 mappers doing that in a period of 1 week. Boom. We end up filling the osu server with the same maps again and people playing the same thing AGAIN ,gaining pp for the exact same maps. Even if the mapper uses 2 ranked and 1 unranked this would be crazy . Just map it separately And 1 ranked + 2 unranked it still makes no sense coz you can simply make a compilation with jsut the 2 unranked maps.
This feels like promoting laziness, coz to make such maps it takes extremely little to no effort.
If someone still want's to make a compilation with his already ranked maps then he can still do it and keep it unranked or a new category could be created.
TL;DR : Disallow ranking whole maps or parts(100% copy paste) of another already ranked map in a new maps."Title"