TicClick wrote:

it's desire drive which is kaku seiga's theme, make your background right, please (example of a correct picture)
cba to check the map itself right now but maybe later

mercury2004 wrote:

Normal
did you forgot to put proper hitsounding on normal difficulty? all of them are at default soft-hitsound Oh... Oops
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
General placements.
00:48:230 (2,3) - put it like this for better reading? The flow will get worse, and i think it's fine like this.

SPOILER

00:55:628 (4,5) - follow your snap? anti jump isnt actually good on normal Fixed!
01:56:039 (1) - suggest it to put near the center, beginner eye tend to stay over there. Wut. That's why i put it here :p
02:31:176 (3,4) - can you move this down a bit, it goes into hp bar even on default skin Fixed!
03:06:929 - how about add spinner here and end it here 03:08:573 Fixed!
03:22:751 (1) - this spinner end hitsound is kinda out of place, how about silencing it Fixed!

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nazis
00:04:463 (1) - put it on : x440 y212 for perfect diamond shape, then move 00:05:491 (2) - this up to follow your snap True, but it's fine like this.
00:07:751 (1) - put it on : x148 y228 for perfect line up with 00:06:518 (4) - . dont forget to fix other snapping Same as above
00:41:449 (2,3,4) - line these up to form perfect triangle Same as above
02:49:463 (1,2) - how about line this 2 parallel to each other Same as above
03:21:723 (5) - move this to x200 y360 and this to 03:22:134 (6) - x316 y360 for perfect triangle Same as above xD

Hard
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
General placements.
00:06:723 (3,4,5,6) - spamming 4 note at one place is kinda awkward, how about use fill sliderFixed!
00:13:710 (2) - move this under this 00:12:477 (1) - slider end and add 00:14:121 another note under it what @.@
00:19:258 (1,2,3,4) - this way has better flow and reading i think Fixed!
00:43:915 (5) - nc? and remove this nc 00:45:559 (1) - ? Fixed!
01:02:408 (6) - nc? Fixed!
01:10:833 (5,6,7) - arrange this in triangle shape has better feel into music i think. Fixed!
01:31:997 (2) - put it on x216 y60 has better flow I think it's better like it is now.
02:04:463 (5) - nc here? to warn player about inconsistence space and rhythm? Fixed!
02:22:956 (2) - how about put this on x216 y144 Better like this.
02:28:915 (4) - nc? Fixed!
02:37:956 (5) - nc this and remove this 02:38:984 (1) - nc? , and then nc this one 02:39:806 (1) - Fixed!
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nazis
01:24:189 (6,7,8,1) - arrange this to perfect square? naah, the flow is fine like this.

Insane
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
General placements.
00:10:217 (4,5,6) - i highly suggest you to put it on x60 y76. this way you can follow your slider flow It's out of place for the next object
00:11:039 (1) - dont put this under 00:10:628 (6) - . rhythm flow feel out of position. Idk what you mean, but it feels fine.
try this? (and dont forget to fix your snapping afterward)

SPOILER

00:21:518 (4,5) - how about triplet slider then jump? Feels weird imo
00:23:573 (5,6,7) - 6 and 7 has inconsistence spacing I don't think so
00:31:381 (3) - ctrl g? Bad flow
00:37:134 (4,5,1) - do it like this? Same as above, bad flow.

SPOILER

00:41:860 (5) - i highly suggest you to put it under 3 that's so random
00:57:066 (1) - put this directly under 10. since you were using this spacing for stream, could be tricky to read with hidden mod This is natural when the beat is like this.
01:34:463 (5) - tilt this to the right for 3 tiny gird: try to avoid straight vertical or horizontal jump. path is unnatural for our hand to follow Fixed!
02:26:449 (6) - nc this? no need to
02:29:121 (2) - nc for speed change No need to when it's circles, only sliders, i might change it later if someone other else point it out
02:34:463 (3) - put this on x380 y312. better flow i think 02:34:669 (1) - you can also curve up slightly to improve the flow I think it's better like this
02:56:244 (1) - no need to nc this one True, but i've done it so many times D:

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nazis
none for insane.

kudololasalwaysforqualitymademap

1. Using a pure white is not recomended, since it's too bright and flashy when played on kiais, maybe make it more grey
2. normal-hitclap2.wav and normal-hitwhistle2.wav not in use I guess, so how about delete them?
3. 03:22:751 (1) - You can add more green lines and adjust some volume so it fit with the fade out effect on music
4. Nowadays, the source from touhou music should be 東方Project instead, you can check the latest https://osu.ppy.sh/s/178968

• Hitsound:

1. 00:17:203 - Missing clap?
2. 01:22:956 - Better to add clap imo
3. 01:33:641 - The clap better on there instead on here imo 01:34:052 -
4. 02:11:655 - Imo, the clap on there, better put on here imo 02:11:860 - then you can delete clap on here 02:12:271 - and here 02:13:093 -
5. 02:14:943 - Imo, the clap on there, better put on here imo 02:15:148 -
6. 02:16:792 - How about add clap there?
7. 03:22:545 (1) - How about delete the finish? a bit distracting before the fade out imo or use whistle instead
   
   
   Gampelay:
8. Imo, it's not recomended on the lowest diff to have diffrent SV (e.g. 01:03:641 - and 01:11:655 - ), because beginners might be confused becuse of that, unless you have an easy diff that might be fine
9. Use AR 5 instead? the curent kinda too fast imo
10. 00:13:710 (5,6) - 00:54:395 (2,3) - 01:21:312 (6,1) - Wrong spacing? more than 0.5 diffrent is quite too far imo, you can check the others
11. 00:13:710 (5,6) - How about change them into 1/1 slider, to fit with "whusss" sound from the music?
12. 00:32:408 (3) - Make that one a curve? so flow will smother here 00:30:765 (1,2,3) - http://puu.sh/i7MmC/f49faddfab.jpg
13. 02:07:751 (1,2) - The polarity between them feel so bad imo, it's too hard for beginner to notice the transition of (1) while ending on blue tick then move to (2) that start on red tick, feels weird and hard. Maybe change the rhythm into something like this might be better http://puu.sh/i7N5t/a8a5315af3.jpg
14. 02:45:559 (5,1) - The rhythm kinda not fit imo, how about change rhythm on into something like this? http://puu.sh/i7NLl/1d786185c3.jpg
15. 02:50:491 (2) - Just a minor, a bit readjust the end node to x:371 y:210 http://puu.sh/i7NR3/4c79f0623c.jpg
16. 03:09:395 (1) - For a better flow maybe you can flip that one? feels weird the movement on here 03:08:573 (1,1) -

• Hitsound:

1. 00:01:586 - I think the clap is better to put on red tick here 00:01:792 - it's somewhat more fit imo
2. 00:06:723 (2) - 00:07:134 (4) - How about to add clap on there?
3. 00:12:271 (5) - Add clap?
4. 00:35:491 (3) - Add clap there? it's somewhat same as 00:28:710 (3,4,5) -
5. 01:01:175 (3) - Better use N:C1 clap there like 01:02:819 -
6. 01:17:614 (7) - Delete clap? imo the strong drum sound is only on 01:17:819 (8,9) -
7. 01:26:039 (4) - Add clap? somewhat same as 01:17:614 (7,8,9) -
8. 01:29:737 (4) - Delete clap? Feels not fit with music or drum
9. 01:33:436 - The clap on there should be put on here 01:33:641 - imo then you can delete clap here 01:33:847 - , 01:34:052 (4) - and 01:34:258 (5) - Because I think that'll make the hitsound better
10. 01:42:888 - and 01:43:710 - Consider to delete clap there?
11. 01:59:840 - and 02:00:148 - Forget to put clap?
12. 02:46:381 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - That hitsound feels so odd imo, consider to change that?
13. 03:22:545 (7) - How about delete the finish? a bit distracting before the fade out imo or use whistle instead
    
    Gameplay:
14. 00:13:915 - Add circle there with a finish maybe? for better stopping effect before the music changing here 00:14:326 (1) -
15. 00:17:203 (5,2) - Reverse arrow is almost not seen while playing, consider to check on that, maybe you can move (2) somewhere else
16. 00:20:285 (4,5,6) - The flow kinda bad imo, as you stacking (4) underneath (3), yet it flows fluently before
17. 00:40:217 (8) - Tbh in my opinion that slider should be end on big tick instead, it's like you kinda force the rhythm there because the rhythm transition on
18. 00:40:217 (8,1) - kinda bad imo
19. 02:00:354 (2,3,1) - How about rotate them 10degree then move to x:292 y:252?
20. 02:08:984 (3) - How about not stacking under (2)? because the flow become unnatural imo while (2) is stoping at blue tick

• Hitsound:

1. 00:12:271 (5) - Add clap there? then delete clap here 00:12:477 - ? It'll sound better imo
2. 00:48:128 - How about delete clap there? kinda not fit with next two claps
3. 00:51:415 - I guess for a better hitsounding that one can be add clap, then the clap on this one 00:51:518 (4) - can be deleted
4. 01:04:463 - 01:01:175 - Better use N:C1 clap on that one imo
5. 03:22:545 (5) - How about delete the finish? a bit distracting before the fade out imo or use whistle instead
   
   Gampelay:
6. 00:13:299 (5) - I think that slider can be extend to here 00:13:915 - following the ""whuuss" sound and might be good if removed the whistle and lower the volume
7. 00:49:771 - Add circle there? so try this kind of rhythm instead http://puu.sh/i8rjG/b89f5c283a.jpg and following the drum sound, how about delete clap on this 00:49:669 (4) - and add clap here 00:49:771 - instead, I think it's more fit with the song
8. 00:54:189 (2,3) - The movement from (2) to (3) is kinda odd imo, it's like too far and hard to follow
9. 01:59:532 (1,2,3) - The rhythm on those feels not fit imo, why don't you make it same rhythm as 01:58:093 (2,3,4,5) - ?
10. 03:07:751 (1,2,3) - That 1/3 part prety tricky hahaha XD especialy 03:08:470 (3) - because what can I hear that (3) is should be snapped on 03:08:436 - instead

1. source: 東方project
   and move "touhou" to tags
2. tags suggetion:
   desire drive

1. because of easiest diff, make consistent spacing
2. because of easiest diff, I suggest not to change SV
3. 01:05:080 ~ 01:09:189- too long 1/2 chain... I suggest to add some break. how about this for following vocal?
   
4. 01:18:025- I highly recommend to add a note
5. 01:21:312 (6,1) - awkward spacing?
6. 01:43:093 (4,1) - I prefer to remove circle and start spinner at 01:43:093
7. 03:06:107 (1,1) - ^
8. 01:55:628- I prefer to follow this sound
9. 02:07:751 (1,2) - blue line rhythm is very difficult. how about following drum sound?
   
10. 02:33:230 (1) - I prefer to follow vocal by use of starting red line
11. 03:17:614 (3) - I suggest to avoid blue line. just a suggetion
    

1. 00:14:121- I prefer to follow this clap sound
2. 00:20:285 (4) - avoid stack. a little confusing
3. 00:21:723 (3) - end at 00:21:929- . Keep 1/2 rhythm
4. 01:06:723 (5,1) - I suggest to combine into 1 slider in order to follow finish sound
5. 02:04:463 (1,2) - hard to find rhythm. suggetion~
   
6. 02:56:449 (6,7) - 1/2 slider is better, because after stream

1. 02:03:641 (2) - delete. no sound
2. 01:34:874 (1,2,3,4,5) - hard to find rhythm. I suggest to add several NCs
   
3. 02:52:956 (7,1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^
4. 02:04:463 (1,2) - combine into 1 slider. keep 3/4 rhythm like 02:05:080 (2) -

Mako Sakata wrote:

Helloooo M4M from your queue~
Some small sugestion from me,

[General]

1. Using a pure white is not recomended, since it's too bright and flashy when played on kiais, maybe make it more grey Not when almost all the players play with at least 50% bg-dim.
2. normal-hitclap2.wav and normal-hitwhistle2.wav not in use I guess, so how about delete them? Fixed!
3. 03:22:751 (1) - You can add more green lines and adjust some volume so it fit with the fade out effect on music I don't think it's necessary
4. Nowadays, the source from touhou music should be 東方Project instead, you can check the latest https://osu.ppy.sh/s/178968

[Normal]

• Hitsound:

1. 00:17:203 - Missing clap? Fixed!
2. 01:22:956 - Better to add clap imo Fixed!
3. 01:33:641 - The clap better on there instead on here imo 01:34:052 - Fixed!
4. 02:11:655 - Imo, the clap on there, better put on here imo 02:11:860 - then you can delete clap on here 02:12:271 - and here 02:13:093 - I think it sounds better like this.
5. 02:14:943 - Imo, the clap on there, better put on here imo 02:15:148 - Same as above
6. 02:16:792 - How about add clap there? Sounds out of place.
7. 03:22:545 (1) - How about delete the finish? a bit distracting before the fade out imo or use whistle instead Not when it's custom hitsounds that is not aggressive.
   
   
   Gampelay:
8. Imo, it's not recomended on the lowest diff to have diffrent SV (e.g. 01:03:641 - and 01:11:655 - ), because beginners might be confused becuse of that, unless you have an easy diff that might be fine I will talk to a BAT about that
9. Use AR 5 instead? the curent kinda too fast imo Naah, i think this is better to fit in as best as possible
10. 00:13:710 (5,6) - 00:54:395 (2,3) - 01:21:312 (6,1) - Wrong spacing? more than 0.5 diffrent is quite too far imo, you can check the others I was told to use higer DS sinc eit will be too cramped with lower DS.
11. 00:13:710 (5,6) - How about change them into 1/1 slider, to fit with "whusss" sound from the music? It starts earlier, and i think it\s fine, also i changed this part in irc mod, i haven\t updated that yet.
12. 00:32:408 (3) - Make that one a curve? so flow will smother here 00:30:765 (1,2,3) - http://puu.sh/i7MmC/f49faddfab.jpg Fixed!
13. 02:07:751 (1,2) - The polarity between them feel so bad imo, it's too hard for beginner to notice the transition of (1) while ending on blue tick then move to (2) that start on red tick, feels weird and hard. Maybe change the rhythm into something like this might be better http://puu.sh/i7N5t/a8a5315af3.jpg This fits better imo
14. 02:45:559 (5,1) - The rhythm kinda not fit imo, how about change rhythm on into something like this? http://puu.sh/i7NLl/1d786185c3.jpg Fixed!
15. 02:50:491 (2) - Just a minor, a bit readjust the end node to x:371 y:210 http://puu.sh/i7NR3/4c79f0623c.jpg I curved it instead.
16. 03:09:395 (1) - For a better flow maybe you can flip that one? feels weird the movement on here 03:08:573 (1,1) - Or just move the circle before lol

[Hard]

• Hitsound:

1. 00:01:586 - I think the clap is better to put on red tick here 00:01:792 - it's somewhat more fit imo Seems pointless for me.
2. 00:06:723 (2) - 00:07:134 (4) - How about to add clap on there? Fixed!
3. 00:12:271 (5) - Add clap? Fixed!
4. 00:35:491 (3) - Add clap there? it's somewhat same as 00:28:710 (3,4,5) - Fixed!
5. 01:01:175 (3) - Better use N:C1 clap there like 01:02:819 - Fixed!
6. 01:17:614 (7) - Delete clap? imo the strong drum sound is only on 01:17:819 (8,9) - sounds good like this
7. 01:26:039 (4) - Add clap? somewhat same as 01:17:614 (7,8,9) - Fixed!
8. 01:29:737 (4) - Delete clap? Feels not fit with music or drum I don't think it's not fit.
9. 01:33:436 - The clap on there should be put on here 01:33:641 - imo then you can delete clap here 01:33:847 - , 01:34:052 (4) - and 01:34:258 (5) - Because I think that'll make the hitsound better Sounds weird imo
10. 01:42:888 - and 01:43:710 - Consider to delete clap there? Sounds good imo.
11. 01:59:840 - and 02:00:148 - Forget to put clap? Fixed!
12. 02:46:381 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - That hitsound feels so odd imo, consider to change that? I don't know, it seems fine to me
13. 03:22:545 (7) - How about delete the finish? a bit distracting before the fade out imo or use whistle instead I think it fits better since it's custom HS
    
    Gameplay:
14. 00:13:915 - Add circle there with a finish maybe? for better stopping effect before the music changing here 00:14:326 (1) - That's a bit overmap, so no
15. 00:17:203 (5,2) - Reverse arrow is almost not seen while playing, consider to check on that, maybe you can move (2) somewhere else I see it perfectly.
16. 00:20:285 (4,5,6) - The flow kinda bad imo, as you stacking (4) underneath (3), yet it flows fluently before The flow is better like this than other ways here.
17. 00:40:217 (8) - Tbh in my opinion that slider should be end on big tick instead, it's like you kinda force the rhythm there because the rhythm transition on There's no sound there
18. 00:40:217 (8,1) - kinda bad imo i don't think so.
19. 02:00:354 (2,3,1) - How about rotate them 10degree then move to x:292 y:252? It's fine like this.
20. 02:08:984 (3) - How about not stacking under (2)? because the flow become unnatural imo while (2) is stoping at blue tick Fixed!

[Insane]

• Hitsound:

1. 00:12:271 (5) - Add clap there? then delete clap here 00:12:477 - ? It'll sound better imo not imo
2. 00:48:128 - How about delete clap there? kinda not fit with next two claps Sounds good imo.
3. 00:51:415 - I guess for a better hitsounding that one can be add clap, then the clap on this one 00:51:518 (4) - can be deleted Naah.. i think it's better like this.
4. 01:04:463 - 01:01:175 - Better use N:C1 clap on that one imo Fixed!
5. 03:22:545 (5) - How about delete the finish? a bit distracting before the fade out imo or use whistle instead Same as the others.
   
   Gampelay:
6. 00:13:299 (5) - I think that slider can be extend to here 00:13:915 - following the ""whuuss" sound and might be good if removed the whistle and lower the volume again, there's no sound there.
7. 00:49:771 - Add circle there? so try this kind of rhythm instead http://puu.sh/i8rjG/b89f5c283a.jpg and following the drum sound, how about delete clap on this 00:49:669 (4) - and add clap here 00:49:771 - instead, I think it's more fit with the song this is overmap, because there's no sound right there for an object.
8. 00:54:189 (2,3) - The movement from (2) to (3) is kinda odd imo, it's like too far and hard to follow No problem here, already tested it.
9. 01:59:532 (1,2,3) - The rhythm on those feels not fit imo, why don't you make it same rhythm as 01:58:093 (2,3,4,5) - ? Because the slider is longer.
10. 03:07:751 (1,2,3) - That 1/3 part prety tricky hahaha XD especialy 03:08:470 (3) - because what can I hear that (3) is should be snapped on 03:08:436 - instead I tried to make the playback rate to 50, and it start on the blue tick.

[]
Edit: Done~
A moment will take a look on Lunatic later, I have something to do today

The structure is very good, but in my opinion a bit lack on hitsounding
Goodluck Tochi, I hope it help

RandomEffect wrote:

From your queue~
M4M!

[General]

1. source: 東方project
   and move "touhou" to tags Fixed!
2. tags suggetion:
   desire drive Fixed!

[Normal]

1. because of easiest diff, make consistent spacing Fixed!
2. because of easiest diff, I suggest not to change SV Fixed!
3. 01:05:080 ~ 01:09:189- too long 1/2 chain... I suggest to add some break. how about this for following vocal? Fixed!
   
4. 01:18:025- I highly recommend to add a note There already is, lol
5. 01:21:312 (6,1) - awkward spacing? Fixed!
6. 01:43:093 (4,1) - I prefer to remove circle and start spinner at 01:43:093 Fixed!
7. 03:06:107 (1,1) - ^ Not here, because the beat is stronger.
8. 01:55:628- I prefer to follow this sound I follow the vocal
9. 02:07:751 (1,2) - blue line rhythm is very difficult. how about following drum sound? Fixed!
   
10. 02:33:230 (1) - I prefer to follow vocal by use of starting red line Naah, this is fine.
11. 03:17:614 (3) - I suggest to avoid blue line. just a suggetion It's better here, so i'll keep it.
    

[Hard]

1. 00:14:121- I prefer to follow this clap sound No need to.
2. 00:20:285 (4) - avoid stack. a little confusing Fixed!
3. 00:21:723 (3) - end at 00:21:929- . Keep 1/2 rhythm I did the same a bit later, so it's fine.
4. 01:06:723 (5,1) - I suggest to combine into 1 slider in order to follow finish sound I like it better as it is.
5. 02:04:463 (1,2) - hard to find rhythm. suggetion~ heh, lol
   
6. 02:56:449 (6,7) - 1/2 slider is better, because after stream Fixed!

[Insane]

1. 02:03:641 (2) - delete. no sound Fixed!
2. 01:34:874 (1,2,3,4,5) - hard to find rhythm. I suggest to add several NCs Fixed!
   
3. 02:52:956 (7,1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^ Fixed!
4. 02:04:463 (1,2) - combine into 1 slider. keep 3/4 rhythm like 02:05:080 (2) - Feels/sounds better this way.

good touhou song!
~Good Luck~

Come[Back]Home wrote:

Normal

00:31:792 (3,4) I think those two should be replaced by a slider since you dont expect a Vocal to be 00:31:792 here. That can be a bit confusing. I think it's better to have circles here.
00:41:449 (2,3,4) Try to do a perfect triangle here by moving (4) too 264/224 Bad flow.
00:46:792 (4) Delete NC here since 00:47:203 (1) this is stronger to place a NC already edited in last mod.
01:14:943 (1,4) Slidertails are not perfectly stacked Fixed!
02:40:422 (2) I think this one was by accident. Shouldnt it end here 02:41:039 ? Fixed!
03:22:545 (1) Place this one here 344/260 for a better square No reason to.


Hard

00:21:723 (3,4) No 3/4 necessary, feels overmapped. (3) should be a normal 1/2 sliderI don't think so...
01:21:518 (9) Move this one a bit down, nearly touching hp bar I'll consider this, i might change after some other people mention it.

Insane

00:14:737 (2,3) Try this instead Fixed!

SPOILER

Feels better to play


Thats it, really awesome mapset. Good Luck :3

1. 00:13:299 (4,5,6) - I think you shouldn't do jumps in Normal but it's up to you
2. 00:14:326 (1) - you could move this bit to right so it looks a bit better places
3. 00:47:203 (1,2,3) - This rhythms feel imo better, try it out:
   img

   
4. 01:43:093 (1) - This spinner has really little time to spin. I think Spinner should end at 01:44:737 - . Beginners may not manage to spin it.

1. 00:12:477 (1) - make it look a bit symmetrical
   for example

   
2. 01:44:326 (4,5,6,7,8) - Maybe this should be replaced with reverse slider. It maybe be too hard for this diff. It's up to you.
3. 02:10:628 (3,4,5,6) - As above
4. 02:16:792 (1,2,3,4) - I think you know...
5. 02:55:422 (1,2,3,4) - Yep
6. 03:16:278 (3) - this start at blue tick... I don't really recommend to do this in hard. It's a bit confusing. Maybe you could try this rhythm
   for example

   
7. 03:22:134 (3,4,5,6,7) - ^you know...

1. 00:18:847 (7,8,1) - this is confusing, or so it was for me. (8) is so close to (7) that players would thought that it starts quickly. I suggest to move (8) lower.
   for example

   
2. 02:10:217 (3) - (just a minor thing) It's a bit too close to (4) when watching stream as whole
3. 03:22:545 (1) - NC maybe

smsh150 wrote:

M4M

[Normal]

1. 00:13:299 (4,5,6) - I think you shouldn't do jumps in Normal but it's up to you I think it's fine, also because the bpm is so low.
2. 00:14:326 (1) - you could move this bit to right so it looks a bit better places I don't know what you mean, but it looks fine for me.
3. 00:47:203 (1,2,3) - This rhythms feel imo better, try it out: Fixed!
   img

   
4. 01:43:093 (1) - This spinner has really little time to spin. I think Spinner should end at 01:44:737 - . Beginners may not manage to spin it. Fixed!

[Hard]

1. 00:12:477 (1) - make it look a bit symmetrical Fixed!
   for example

   
2. 01:44:326 (4,5,6,7,8) - Maybe this should be replaced with reverse slider. It maybe be too hard for this diff. It's up to you. It's fine with some streams.
3. 02:10:628 (3,4,5,6) - As above Same as above.
4. 02:16:792 (1,2,3,4) - I think you know... You know too....
5. 02:55:422 (1,2,3,4) - Yep Mhm
6. 03:16:278 (3) - this start at blue tick... I don't really recommend to do this in hard. It's a bit confusing. Maybe you could try this rhythm It fits well with the music, so it's easy to hit, and not so confusing.
   for example

   
7. 03:22:134 (3,4,5,6,7) - ^you know... I know, u do too :3

[Insane]

1. 00:18:847 (7,8,1) - this is confusing, or so it was for me. (8) is so close to (7) that players would thought that it starts quickly. I suggest to move (8) lower. Fixed!
   for example

   
2. 02:10:217 (3) - (just a minor thing) It's a bit too close to (4) when watching stream as whole what? @.@
3. 03:22:545 (1) - NC maybe sure

Sorry I didn't find much from Insane ;~;

Good luck with map!

-Tochi wrote:

.

1. fuk u your bg is 1365x768 why do you do this to me
2. as the damn mp3 suggests artist could also be lily-an instead of Liz Triangle, though using the circle as artist should be fine here, i mean i never heard of lily-an but i knew Liz Triangle songs before looking at this
3. you could cut the damn silence out of normal-hitwhistle (make sure to stay over 100ms kk soft-hitclap2 same )
4. do i question why both soft-hitfinishes are the soft-hitnormal like wot
5. letterboxing during breaks is ehh especially since it cuts of part of bg characters headddd
6. would avoid the kind of white combocolor and instead make it something like a lighter blue or a pink color because t/242087&start=0 was a thing and was thoroughly discussed but never appended decided on, i would just avoid whitish combocolors for the reasons given in this thread
7. 02:29:942 - metroneome resets here, add a red line with 4/4 and a green with 1.2x sv in insane to asjust things

1. 00:01:792 (2,3) - according to the way you follow piano with holds it would make more sense to have 2 as the slider and 3 as a circle in 00:02:203 - or just same rhythm as 00:04:463 (1,2) -
2. 00:14:737 (2,3) - this is weird considereing you don't really do it again in the section and there's a sound on the red tick 00:20:902 (1,2,3) -
3. 00:16:997 (4,5) - 00:21:518 (4,5) - are really weird since the strongest impact out of the triplet there is on the white tick and you ignore it for a slider, you map something similar in 00:25:217 (4,5,6) - how it should be done (make normal triplets pls)
4. 00:29:121 (1) - this one is seemingly random because there's no real stressed and extended sounding sound in that part so using a 3/4 slider doesn't fit as much and you mapped other similar things with 1/2 sliders :// 00:38:778 (1,3) - are different because they have a clearly prolonged piano sound and fit well due to that
5. 00:44:737 (3,4) - this is also weird because you ignore these sounds for most of the section but map it one time in here and in 00:51:107 (2,3,4) -
6. 02:04:463 (1,2,3,4) - following a mix of instruments and vocals is pretty weird, anyway i'd suggest this because it follows both vocal and instruments so it could be potentially easier to comprehend than what you currently have
7. 00:46:175 (3) - btw this one is kind of uh because the vocal it supposedly follows with that 1/1 ends in 00:46:381 -
8. 02:52:751 - should be clickable because 01:34:669 -
9. 03:02:408 (7) - current one works but would probably be better as 2 circles
10. 03:13:299 (2,3) - see in 03:10:011 (2,3,4,5) - why this is bleh

1. 00:06:107 (1,2) - space is bigger for no reason at all and then becomes smaller just after for no reason but 'i have to stack these objects in edit' and stuff, since that's kind of unreasonable with the music i'd recommend to redo them in a matter that stresses the most dominant sounds with jumps and has the parts with equal intensity at approx equal spacing because that would make sense the next timestamps are basically the same issue as this one together with either more or less space to indicate the direction this pattern should take when changing:
2. 00:03:025 (2,3) - more
3. 00:03:641 (5,6) - more, synth in 6
4. 00:08:984 (5,1) - either this more or 00:08:573 (4,5) - less and 5,1 more
5. 00:16:381 (2,3) - more even with next pattern intensity is same imo
6. 00:17:614 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - just saying that this one follows the intensity of the sounds her quite nicely, gj
7. 00:25:833 (1,2,3) - should be overall more even in spacing
8. 00:28:504 (4,5) - should definetely be a bit smaller and 00:27:888 (2,3) - bigger current placement puts a lot more emphasis on 5 than it really has / deserves
9. 00:32:408 (1) - more, reason here is quite obv
10. 00:37:340 (1,2,3) - just saying that while it makes sense with your system and stuff that it should probably be better off with 00:37:751 (2,3) - having higher spacing because 00:36:929 (3,4,5,1) - is much higher spacing for the same kind of sound, but you do that quite a few times and somewhat consistently so i didn't mention things up until now
11. 00:41:449 (3,4) - less, current jump stresses 4 too much and makes distance to 5 feel a bit weird
12. 00:59:943 (1) - there's no real drop in intensity that would suggest it being slower sv, i think the current one is just so that people like me have difficulties reading it :/
13. 01:06:723 (7,1) - jump should be from 6 to 7 and not from 7 to 1 also the nc should be swapped because it's same thing as 01:05:080 (1) -
14. 01:11:655 (1,2,3) - 1,2 more 2,3 less because reasons
15. 01:14:326 (4,5,1) - jump should be from 5 to 1 and not 4 to 5 imo
16. 01:16:586 (1,2,3,4) - could work better if distance between objects was more even and not fluctuating by ~0.5x
17. 01:22:134 (3,4) - idk giant space puts way more emphasis on 4 than it really has imo
18. 01:25:628 (3,4,5) - spacing in / decreases look random
19. 01:28:093 (7,1) - nc swap pls
20. 01:27:888 (6,7) - a bit less btw
21. 01:30:354 (2,3,4) - spacing in / decreases like that look really random :/ especially since the vocals are just a single word here
22. 01:33:436 (2,3) - more to normalise spacing in 01:34:258 (4,5) -
23. 01:50:902 (6,1) - would avoid overlap since you don't do it i n the who le rest of the section
24. 01:55:628 (3) - more space to prev because that would look better in combination with 01:55:833 (4,1) -
25. 02:14:121 (10,11,1) - moving this one like this may end up looking nicer
26. 02:21:929 (5,6,1) - this jump emphasizes 6 while the song emphasizes 5 and 1 :/
27. 02:23:778 (6,7) - space decrease is kinda random
28. 02:24:189 (1) - could then use a bit more spacee
29. 02:33:025 (7,1) - nc swap for logical reasons
30. 02:33:847 (9,1,2,3) - space seems random and out of control just because NC *which shouldn't even be there rererr rdklafsj*
31. 02:35:696 (4,5,1) - jump should be from 5 to 1 and not 4 to 5
32. 02:39:600 (7,1) - nc swap because new phrase in vocals
33. 02:41:244 (5) - nc because of same reason (alternatively at least nc 02:41:449 (6) - if you don't want to follow vocals with combos)
34. 02:39:600 (7,1) - distance should be a jump because of previous reasoning
35. 02:40:422 (3,4) - less to emphasize
36. 02:41:244 (5) - more
37. 02:46:176 (6,1) - nc swap for reasons also space higher would not hurt here
38. 02:50:491 (1,2) - swap nc for reasons
39. 03:00:354 (1,2,3) - if at all jump should be from 2 to 3
40. 03:03:436 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - spacing in this pattern is a tad higher than in most standard patterns in this section so it'd fit in better if nerfed

1. 00:04:463 - add whistle
2. 00:05:080 - -finish +whistle
3. 00:07:134 (6) - -whistle and tail of 7 -whistle
4. 00:07:751 - +whistle
5. ... and so on, basically you can use a lot of whistles in this section which you currently dont do but i won't mention them for at least this section anymore since it's just the same shit over and over
6. 00:11:039 - kinda sad that you don't use soft hitclap 2 and soft hitclap 3 together in one sampleset without the finish to hitsound both tracks in the music accordingly and in one part just miss out on the claps or in the other on the finishes dunno :/
7. 00:27:477 - just saying that for this part it can sound kind of nice if you follow 1) the vocal with whistles 2) the main piano as well just as i told you for the last section
8. 00:27:477 - things like this should have clapfinishes btw
9. 00:34:052 (1) - a
10. 00:42:271 (1) - you finish pattern is kind of inconsistent with this one (see 00:40:628 (1) - )
11. 00:43:915 (1) - adsf
12. 01:04:463 - should have same hitsound as 01:02:819 -
13. 01:19:874 (1) - misses finish
14. btw why do you not mute the sliderslides of the normal sampleset but only of the soft one ??
15. 02:33:025 (7) - 01:14:943 (1) - has a finsih
16. 02:59:121 - silencing this spinner end makes not much sense lol

1. 00:14:121 - not mapping this is kind of weird :/
2. 00:21:723 (3,4) - this is literally just randomly extended, not even the insane does that here and you should prolly stick to the 1/2 rhythm you had
3. 00:29:121 (5) - nc because you don't 2 bar combos in this section actually idk just 1 measure combos pls
4. 00:20:285 (4,5,6) - this is a bit weird to play because you have to read the stack under the sliderend and the next stack and then move, movement could be smoother if you stacked 6 on 1 instead of under 5
5. 00:57:066 (1,3) - overlapping these doesn't look that nice
6. DECIDE IF YOU WANT 2 OR ONE MEASURE COMBOS IN KI AI REALLY
7. 01:26:039 (4) - stacking this on 5 would give a similar feeling to 01:12:888 (3,4) -
8. 01:32:306 (4) - would avoid this one, or add more triplets here and there right now it's the first and only triplet in the section which is kind of inconsistent and gives off a random feeling
9. 01:56:860 (3) - would look a bit better like this imo
10. 02:06:312 (1,2) - could be better off as a slider since the rhythm is already quite complicated in this part so no need to make it even harder with additional circle patterns
11. 02:33:949 (8) - 02:50:388 (4) - same comment as the last seemingly random triplet
12. 02:55:833 (5) - take away one repeat to do a rhythm like http://puu.sh/if13d/97050049d6.jpg the reason is that hte current rhythm is unexpected and this one would be more obvious

Okoratu wrote:

apparently we m4m

-Tochi wrote:

.

dude nice

and i'm bored and have nothing better to do

[general]

1. fuk u your bg is 1365x768 why do you do this to me Hehehehe, ofc
2. as the damn mp3 suggests artist could also be lily-an instead of Liz Triangle, though using the circle as artist should be fine here, i mean i never heard of lily-an but i knew Liz Triangle songs before looking at this Already considered to change
3. you could cut the damn silence out of normal-hitwhistle (make sure to stay over 100ms kk soft-hitclap2 same ) Fixed!
4. do i question why both soft-hitfinishes are the soft-hitnormal like wot I don't have the soft-hitnormal any longer, and the hitfinsh is eeeeh... There's no really finish in this song, that's why i use this custom one because it's short :p
5. letterboxing during breaks is ehh especially since it cuts of part of bg characters headddd Fixed!
6. would avoid the kind of white combocolor and instead make it something like a lighter blue or a pink color because t/242087&start=0 was a thing and was thoroughly discussed but never appended decided on, i would just avoid whitish combocolors for the reasons given in this thread Fixed!
7. 02:29:942 - metroneome resets here, add a red line with 4/4 and a green with 1.2x sv in insane to asjust things Fixed!

[metadata]
where is eba
tag fhe fucking album

can tag デザイアドライブ
as far as i can see you cut the song down to 3:30 or something (?)
if you did that you may tag that it's cut etc Fixed!

[Insane]
your mapping atm reminds me of sjoy
Rhythms

1. 00:01:792 (2,3) - according to the way you follow piano with holds it would make more sense to have 2 as the slider and 3 as a circle in 00:02:203 - or just same rhythm as 00:04:463 (1,2) - Fixed!
2. 00:14:737 (2,3) - this is weird considereing you don't really do it again in the section and there's a sound on the red tick 00:20:902 (1,2,3) - Fixed!
3. 00:16:997 (4,5) - 00:21:518 (4,5) - are really weird since the strongest impact out of the triplet there is on the white tick and you ignore it for a slider, you map something similar in 00:25:217 (4,5,6) - how it should be done (make normal triplets pls) Sorry but, i changed the other parts too, and since i use the "not normal" triplets most in the map, it would be better to just always do it in these kinda parts.
4. 00:29:121 (1) - this one is seemingly random because there's no real stressed and extended sounding sound in that part so using a 3/4 slider doesn't fit as much and you mapped other similar things with 1/2 sliders :// 00:38:778 (1,3) - are different because they have a clearly prolonged piano sound and fit well due to that Fixed!
5. 00:44:737 (3,4) - this is also weird because you ignore these sounds for most of the section but map it one time in here and in 00:51:107 (2,3,4) - Fixed!
6. 02:04:463 (1,2,3,4) - following a mix of instruments and vocals is pretty weird, anyway i'd suggest this because it follows both vocal and instruments so it could be potentially easier to comprehend than what you currently have True, but i think the one i have now fits much better.
7. 00:46:175 (3) - btw this one is kind of uh because the vocal it supposedly follows with that 1/1 ends in 00:46:381 - Fixed!
8. 02:52:751 - should be clickable because 01:34:669 - Fixed!
9. 03:02:408 (7) - current one works but would probably be better as 2 circles might change later on.
10. 03:13:299 (2,3) - see in 03:10:011 (2,3,4,5) - why this is bleh Fixed!

Placement
oops some nc things got in there apply these only after going through all placement things so that links still make sense

1. 00:06:107 (1,2) - space is bigger for no reason at all and then becomes smaller just after for no reason but 'i have to stack these objects in edit' and stuff, since that's kind of unreasonable with the music i'd recommend to redo them in a matter that stresses the most dominant sounds with jumps and has the parts with equal intensity at approx equal spacing because that would make sense the next timestamps are basically the same issue as this one together with either more or less space to indicate the direction this pattern should take when changing: Remember the dots and comma
2. 00:03:025 (2,3) - more Fixed!
3. 00:03:641 (5,6) - more, synth in 6 Fixed!
4. 00:08:984 (5,1) - either this more or 00:08:573 (4,5) - less and 5,1 more
5. 00:16:381 (2,3) - more even with next pattern intensity is same imo Fixed!
6. 00:17:614 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - just saying that this one follows the intensity of the sounds her quite nicely, gj Thanks! >.<
7. 00:25:833 (1,2,3) - should be overall more even in spacing Fixed!
8. 00:28:504 (4,5) - should definetely be a bit smaller and 00:27:888 (2,3) - bigger current placement puts a lot more emphasis on 5 than it really has / deserves Fixed!
9. 00:32:408 (1) - more, reason here is quite obv Fixed!
10. 00:37:340 (1,2,3) - just saying that while it makes sense with your system and stuff that it should probably be better off with 00:37:751 (2,3) - having higher spacing because 00:36:929 (3,4,5,1) - is much higher spacing for the same kind of sound, but you do that quite a few times and somewhat consistently so i didn't mention things up until now Fixed!
11. 00:41:449 (3,4) - less, current jump stresses 4 too much and makes distance to 5 feel a bit weirdFixed!
12. 00:59:943 (1) - there's no real drop in intensity that would suggest it being slower sv, i think the current one is just so that people like me have difficulties reading it :/ noob :^)
13. 01:06:723 (7,1) - jump should be from 6 to 7 and not from 7 to 1 also the nc should be swapped because it's same thing as 01:05:080 (1) - Fixed!
14. 01:11:655 (1,2,3) - 1,2 more 2,3 less because reasons Fixed!
15. 01:14:326 (4,5,1) - jump should be from 5 to 1 and not 4 to 5 imo Fixed!
16. 01:16:586 (1,2,3,4) - could work better if distance between objects was more even and not fluctuating by ~0.5x Fixed!
17. 01:22:134 (3,4) - idk giant space puts way more emphasis on 4 than it really has imo Fixed!
18. 01:25:628 (3,4,5) - spacing in / decreases look random Fixed!
19. 01:28:093 (7,1) - nc swap pls Fixed!
20. 01:27:888 (6,7) - a bit less btw Fixed!
21. 01:30:354 (2,3,4) - spacing in / decreases like that look really random :/ especially since the vocals are just a single word here Fixed!
22. 01:33:436 (2,3) - more to normalise spacing in 01:34:258 (4,5) - Fixed!
23. 01:50:902 (6,1) - would avoid overlap since you don't do it i n the who le rest of the section Fixed!
24. 01:55:628 (3) - more space to prev because that would look better in combination with 01:55:833 (4,1) - Fixed!
25. 02:14:121 (10,11,1) - moving this one like this may end up looking nicer True, but flow is more important
26. 02:21:929 (5,6,1) - this jump emphasizes 6 while the song emphasizes 5 and 1 :/ Fixed!
27. 02:23:778 (6,7) - space decrease is kinda random Fixed!
28. 02:24:189 (1) - could then use a bit more spacee Fixed!
29. 02:33:025 (7,1) - nc swap for logical reasons Fixed!
30. 02:33:847 (9,1,2,3) - space seems random and out of control just because NC *which shouldn't even be there rererr rdklafsj* Fixed!
31. 02:35:696 (4,5,1) - jump should be from 5 to 1 and not 4 to 5 Fixed!
32. 02:39:600 (7,1) - nc swap because new phrase in vocals Fixed!
33. 02:41:244 (5) - nc because of same reason (alternatively at least nc 02:41:449 (6) - if you don't want to follow vocals with combos) Fixed!
34. 02:39:600 (7,1) - distance should be a jump because of previous reasoning Fixed!
35. 02:40:422 (3,4) - less to emphasize Fixed!
36. 02:41:244 (5) - more Fixed!
37. 02:46:176 (6,1) - nc swap for reasons also space higher would not hurt here Fixed!
38. 02:50:491 (1,2) - swap nc for reasons Fixed!
39. 03:00:354 (1,2,3) - if at all jump should be from 2 to 3 Fixed!
40. 03:03:436 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - spacing in this pattern is a tad higher than in most standard patterns in this section so it'd fit in better if nerfed

as you can see most of these are repeating things and i might even have forgotten some so it'd be best to go over that again on your own and make sure that the spacing in this diff is not just random jumps in some places but emphasizes either instruments or vocals in means of spacing Fixed!
Hitsounds
prolly applies to all diffs
your whistlepattern is kind of poor in the beginning
it would make sense to whistle on the most dominant piano sounds like 00:01:176 - 00:01:792 - 00:03:641 - and then follow main piano with whistles, doing that will result in the following

1. 00:04:463 - add whistle Fixed!
2. 00:05:080 - -finish +whistle Fixed!
3. 00:07:134 (6) - -whistle and tail of 7 -whistle Fixed!
4. 00:07:751 - +whistle Fixed!
5. ... and so on, basically you can use a lot of whistles in this section which you currently dont do but i won't mention them for at least this section anymore since it's just the same shit over and over ok
6. 00:11:039 - kinda sad that you don't use soft hitclap 2 and soft hitclap 3 together in one sampleset without the finish to hitsound both tracks in the music accordingly and in one part just miss out on the claps or in the other on the finishes dunno :/ dunno ://
7. 00:27:477 - just saying that for this part it can sound kind of nice if you follow 1) the vocal with whistles 2) the main piano as well just as i told you for the last section I followed the main piano
8. 00:27:477 - things like this should have clapfinishes btw Fixed!
9. 00:34:052 (1) - a hi
10. 00:42:271 (1) - you finish pattern is kind of inconsistent with this one (see 00:40:628 (1) - ) Fixed!
11. 00:43:915 (1) - adsf Fixed!
12. 01:04:463 - should have same hitsound as 01:02:819 - Fixed!
13. 01:19:874 (1) - misses finish Fixed!
14. btw why do you not mute the sliderslides of the normal sampleset but only of the soft one ?? Because most people play with skins that doesn't have a sliderslider for soft sampleset, that isn't muted, lol.
15. 02:33:025 (7) - 01:14:943 (1) - has a finsih Fixed!
16. 02:59:121 - silencing this spinner end makes not much sense lol True.

rest seems to make more or less sense kinda sad again in 02:59:532 - because you can't use both hits and claps in the same sampleset ?
i wished you used whistles for the piano hits and the most dominant vocals in the kiai and out of them wherever it makes sense, this hitsounding would profit a lot from that ok.


[Hard]
ar 7 cuz spread after looking at normal this is irrelevant
i won't have to break this one down into categories for easier understanding because it's pretty much k

1. 00:14:121 - not mapping this is kind of weird :/ Fixed!
2. 00:21:723 (3,4) - this is literally just randomly extended, not even the insane does that here and you should prolly stick to the 1/2 rhythm you had Fixed!
3. 00:29:121 (5) - nc because you don't 2 bar combos in this section actually idk just 1 measure combos pls Fixed!
4. 00:20:285 (4,5,6) - this is a bit weird to play because you have to read the stack under the sliderend and the next stack and then move, movement could be smoother if you stacked 6 on 1 instead of under 5 Fixed!
5. 00:57:066 (1,3) - overlapping these doesn't look that nice :I
6. DECIDE IF YOU WANT 2 OR ONE MEASURE COMBOS IN KI AI REALLY ok
7. 01:26:039 (4) - stacking this on 5 would give a similar feeling to 01:12:888 (3,4) - Fixed!
8. 01:32:306 (4) - would avoid this one, or add more triplets here and there right now it's the first and only triplet in the section which is kind of inconsistent and gives off a random feeling Fixed!
9. 01:56:860 (3) - would look a bit better like this imo Fixed!
10. 02:06:312 (1,2) - could be better off as a slider since the rhythm is already quite complicated in this part so no need to make it even harder with additional circle patterns Fixed!
11. 02:33:949 (8) - 02:50:388 (4) - same comment as the last seemingly random triplet Fixed!
12. 02:55:833 (5) - take away one repeat to do a rhythm like http://puu.sh/if13d/97050049d6.jpg the reason is that hte current rhythm is unexpected and this one would be more obvious Fixed!

not sure about the stream in regards to spread ok

[Normal]
referencing this dq p/4138147
ok i was kinda confused why the normal would need AR 5.5 but uhh ar fits
i'll cut this one short a bit because
as it stands the normal does not successfully function as the easiest diff of the set
A normal is kind of allowed as the lowest diff if it is beginner friendly enough and fulfills the average requirements of an easy
currently your normal does uhh just pretty standard normal things, the chains of 1/2 things don't get that long but some parts are more dense than others and rhythms like 00:57:066 (1,2,3,4) - Fixed! can be kind of confusing for a beginner, at least so i think
overall this is not the kind of diff that you would pass when you play osu for the first time and this is kind of the problem
my advice would be to make this diff more dense so that it ends up at something like 2.1ish stars and then make an easy which avoids rhythms like
00:02:203 (2,3) - 00:30:765 (1,2,3,4,5) - 03:11:860 (1,2,3,4,5,6) -
it's rhythms like thes that make the diff hard to comprehend for a complete beginner but at the same time they are also kinda appropriate for the song so this is really a bit tricky
spread to hard would be better if this diff was a bit more dense as well
so making this more dense in some section and mapping another diff would be the best choice for this set imo
02:27:477 (1) - 2.71x distance lol Fixed!
00:14:121 (6) - lool you even mapped it in normal and didn't in hard ahdlfkhas;k btw why is it a jump you don't have that many jumpsi n hard and this is a 2.1x one in normal Fixed!
00:16:792 (5,6,1) - if you decide to implement this using this rhytm more often may be an idea Fixed!
00:50:080 (7,1) - this one may be used more often as well Fixed!
basically i would use these 2 kind of rhythms to make this diff a bit more dense overall and especially in the beginning few sections
and get rid of all jumps lollllll


Leaving a star here for now because in it's core this is quite nice, you should focus on getting some sense into the jumps in insane and tell me what you think about my thoughts on your lowest diff
also yes i'm kinda nazi with spacing ever since i saw it as one of the most frequent dq reasons so please keep that in mind as well and i don't think the adjustments i'm suggesting will make it any less fun to play

ok bye

edit: forgot star xd
edit2: me starring this means like nothing i think a few more mods for this and - if you should make another diff, necessary - would be cool

1. 02:28:710 - why there is red timing here in insane diff but not on other diffs
2. why not use same combo colour for every diff ?
3. why insane has more tags than other diffs ?
4. why insane doesn't has letterbox during break checked but other diffs have ?

1. 00:31:176 (2,3) - I think spacing here should be a bit bigger than 00:30:765 (1,2) - since 00:31:381 - sound kinda more emphasized than 00:31:176 - so make spacing here 00:31:176 (2,3) - will kinda make sense with the song , try move 00:31:176 (2) - to around x260 y224
2. 00:33:025 (2) - rhythm here play a bit weird somehow since you map the emphasized beat 00:33:230 - as sliderend , I would use this rhythm instead
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:55:628 (1) - finish?
4. 00:58:504 - ^ ( hitsound suggestion can apply to other diffs too )
5. 01:08:573 (1) - ^
6. 01:28:299 (2) - nc here instead of 01:28:093 (1) - ? your nc follow cymbal in previous rhythm but why suddenly change to vocal , that a bit inconsistent imo
7. 01:35:491 (1,2) - spacing looks kinda similiar to what you used for 1/2 thing here 01:34:874 (1,2) - , you can increase spacing here 01:35:491 (1,2) - and here 01:36:312 (1,2) - a bit so it make the spacing here a bit easier to read
8. 02:46:381 (2) - nc should be here instead of 02:46:175 (1) - since your nc here seems to follow the cymbal sound
9. 02:46:381 (2,4) - overlap here looks not that really good imo , you can curve (2) more a bit imo it wouldn't ruin the flow here that much
   SPOILER

   
10. 02:53:573 (1,2) - similiar to 01:35:491 (1,2) -

• hitsound on some part is pretty inconsistent somehow like 00:29:121 - you have whistle in insane but in this diff it don't and this one too 00:31:381 - , better recheck hitsound consistency here

1. AIBat v3.1 wrote:

   Snapping
   
   Unsnapped inherited (green) sections at:
   02:20:315 - snap to 02:20:285

2. 02:10:628 (3,4,5,6,1) - I think stream like this is kinda hard for hard player , you can convert these circles 02:10:628 (3,4,5,6) - to 1/4 reverse slider
3. 02:55:422 (1,2,3,4) - ^ similiar
4. 03:22:134 (3,4,5,6,7) - ^ similiar
5. 03:15:765 (2,3) - try this rhythm instead ? it play better imo
   SPOILER

   

• same as hard about hitsound some part hitsound is a bit inconsistent with insane diff , idk if this intentionally tho

1. 00:18:436 (2,3) - spacing is a bit inconsistent here
2. 00:47:203 (1,2,3) - inconsistent spacing
3. 01:00:354 (1,3) - not that necessary but stack these ? so it would make pattern here a bit cleaner
4. 01:03:641 (1,2) - inconsistent spacing
5. 01:08:367 (4,1) - ^ again lol better make spacing same on every notes so it a bit easier for new player to read
6. 01:11:655 (1,2) - ^ hmm better recheck spacing a bit here I see it inconsistent by like 0.1 or something a lots here in this diff
7. 02:08:984 (1,2) - I think this rhythm play better for new player
   SPOILER

   

CelsiusLK wrote:

m4m as requested

[general]

1. 02:28:710 - why there is red timing here in insane diff but not on other diffs hehe, Okoratu told me that too after i replied to the mod lol
2. why not use same combo colour for every diff ? Ooops
3. why insane has more tags than other diffs ? Fixed fixed
4. why insane doesn't has letterbox during break checked but other diffs have ? rip my memory =.=

[insane]

1. 00:31:176 (2,3) - I think spacing here should be a bit bigger than 00:30:765 (1,2) - since 00:31:381 - sound kinda more emphasized than 00:31:176 - so make spacing here 00:31:176 (2,3) - will kinda make sense with the song , try move 00:31:176 (2) - to around x260 y224 Fixed!
2. 00:33:025 (2) - rhythm here play a bit weird somehow since you map the emphasized beat 00:33:230 - as sliderend , I would use this rhythm instead Fixed!
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:55:628 (1) - finish? Fixed!
4. 00:58:504 - ^ ( hitsound suggestion can apply to other diffs too ) Fixed!
5. 01:08:573 (1) - ^ Fixed!
6. 01:28:299 (2) - nc here instead of 01:28:093 (1) - ? your nc follow cymbal in previous rhythm but why suddenly change to vocal , that a bit inconsistent imo Fixed!
7. 01:35:491 (1,2) - spacing looks kinda similiar to what you used for 1/2 thing here 01:34:874 (1,2) - , you can increase spacing here 01:35:491 (1,2) - and here 01:36:312 (1,2) - a bit so it make the spacing here a bit easier to read Fixed!
8. 02:46:381 (2) - nc should be here instead of 02:46:175 (1) - since your nc here seems to follow the cymbal sound Fixed!
9. 02:46:381 (2,4) - overlap here looks not that really good imo , you can curve (2) more a bit imo it wouldn't ruin the flow here that much Fixed!
   SPOILER

   
10. 02:53:573 (1,2) - similiar to 01:35:491 (1,2) - ? I think i fixed it in the before u pointed it out, lol.

[hard]

• hitsound on some part is pretty inconsistent somehow like 00:29:121 - you have whistle in insane but in this diff it don't and this one too 00:31:381 - , better recheck hitsound consistency here Fixed!

1. AIBat v3.1 wrote:

   Snapping
   
   Unsnapped inherited (green) sections at:
   02:20:315 - snap to 02:20:285 Fixed!

2. 02:10:628 (3,4,5,6,1) - I think stream like this is kinda hard for hard player , you can convert these circles 02:10:628 (3,4,5,6) - to 1/4 reverse slider Fixed!
3. 02:55:422 (1,2,3,4) - ^ similiar Fixed!
4. 03:22:134 (3,4,5,6,7) - ^ similiar Fixed!
5. 03:15:765 (2,3) - try this rhythm instead ? it play better imo I will change if some other else say it again.
   SPOILER

   

[normal]

• same as hard about hitsound some part hitsound is a bit inconsistent with insane diff , idk if this intentionally tho I already new that here, since there's no many hit objects it will be hard to compare Insane/Hard with Normal.

1. 00:18:436 (2,3) - spacing is a bit inconsistent here Fixed!
2. 00:47:203 (1,2,3) - inconsistent spacing Fixed!
3. 01:00:354 (1,3) - not that necessary but stack these ? so it would make pattern here a bit cleaner Fixed!
4. 01:03:641 (1,2) - inconsistent spacing Fixed!
5. 01:08:367 (4,1) - ^ again lol better make spacing same on every notes so it a bit easier for new player to read Fixed!
6. 01:11:655 (1,2) - ^ hmm better recheck spacing a bit here I see it inconsistent by like 0.1 or something a lots here in this diff Fixed!
7. 02:08:984 (1,2) - I think this rhythm play better for new player I like mine better :>
   SPOILER

   

good luck on ranking

here my map for m4m https://osu.ppy.sh/s/317236 ( easy still wip but I guess you can just mod normal hard and insane since I mod your map 3 diffs so yea q: )

Mentional wrote:

hi, for m4m

• 
  

  Normal

1. 01:03:641 (1) - How about changing this one like this: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3262443 And of course fixing 01:04:669 (2) - after that so DS stays correct Looks nicer imo. Too curvy.
2. 01:11:039 (5) - hmm why is this one curved a bit? I don't think it needs to be. didn't change the above.
3. 01:24:189 (5) - Not stacked perfectly with 01:22:545 (2) - Umm.... ok
4. 01:34:874 (1) - Does this also need to be curved? Imo yes, but ok!
5. 01:38:162 (1,2) - A question, why did you start using DS 1.25 here? Or is it something I'm missing..? It's obviously a slower part, lol.
6. 02:02:819 (1) - This one looks better without the curvepoint at x:196 y:272 imo. Fixed!
7. 03:22:545 (1) - Move this one to x:348 y:256? No need to.

• 
  

  Hard

1. 00:19:258 (1,2,3,4) - This one looks really weird and awkward to play, I suggest changing it I don't see the problem here. I've used this kinda part many times in other Hards & Insane lol
2. 00:22:545 (1) - Could remove curve from this one It looks better with it curved imo.
3. 00:43:093 (3) - ^ ^
4. 00:52:956 (4,5) - This part feels a lot better to play with both sliders having one more reverse added to them. And also fits the song more I know, i did that at first too... But i would keep the little break between them.
5. 01:05:902 (3,4) - I don't think these two sliders fit here starting from red ticks, how about this? http://puu.sh/iqYEJ/1bbd578876.jpg (Picture is from 01:05:696 - to 01:06:723 - ) I follow the vocal here.
6. 01:10:011 (4) - Could remove curve from this slider Naah, looks kinda weird imo.
7. 01:14:943 (1) - Don't think this reverse slider fits here.. try this?: http://puu.sh/iqYKH/bad44bf0b3.jpg (Picture is from 01:14:943 - to 01:15:354 - ) Fixed!
8. 02:15:765 (1,2,3) - Don't think these fit here starting from the red tick, how about this?: http://puu.sh/iqYXR/2f46362b02.jpg (Picture is from 02:15:765 - to 02:16:586 - ) Pattern could be like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3262540 And if you decide to change of course move the stream after this one closer ^^ Same as before, i follow vocal.
9. 02:22:956 (2,3,4,5) - ^ Same fix should work on these. Same.
10. 02:24:806 (2,3,4) - ^ Same thing here. Same.
11. 02:29:121 (2) - This one isn't snapped Fixed!
12. 02:37:340 (4) - Looks better to me without a curve Not me.
    
    SPOILER

    Unsnapped objects
    02:38:983 (4) - Fixed!
    02:39:394 (5) - Fixed!
    02:39:805 (1) - Fixed!
    02:41:038 (3) - Fixed!
    02:44:120 (4) - Fixed!
    02:44:531 (1) - Fixed!
    02:45:353 (3) - Fixed!
    02:46:175 (5) - Fixed!
    02:48:846 (7) - Fixed!
    02:50:079 (2) - Fixed!
    02:50:490 (1) - Fixed!
    02:53:983 (3) - Fixed!
    02:54:394 (4) - Fixed!
    02:54:805 (5) - Fixed!
    02:56:757 (1) - Fixed!
    03:08:983 (2) - Fixed!
    03:09:394 (1) - Fixed!
    03:10:216 (3) - Fixed!
    03:10:627 (4) - Fixed!
    03:11:757 (2) - Fixed!
    03:14:120 (5) - Fixed!
    03:14:531 (6) - Fixed!
    03:15:764 (2) - Fixed!
    03:18:846 (2) - Fixed!
    03:19:257 (3) - Fixed!
    03:20:079 (5) - Fixed!
    03:20:490 (6) -

• 
  

  Insane

1. 00:07:340 (7) - Could remove curve? Naah, no need to.
2. 00:09:189 (1) - Could remove the white curve point, looks better to me that way I don't think so.
3. 00:12:888 (3) - Move to x:399 y:266 What. No need to imo.
4. 00:29:121 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Flow seems kinda weird here. I know. But it's okay to play.
5. 00:42:682 (2) - Place it like this for better flow: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3262622 The cursor movement goes the way the slider is curved in my way, lol.
6. 00:53:162 (6,7,8,9,10,11,1) - This stream should start here: 00:52:956 (5) - Yes, But it feels better to play it this way. I will change if someone says it too.
7. 02:13:504 (7) - NC? Fixed!

And that's all I could find, hope you found this mod helpful

Okoratu wrote:

tochi the metronome still resets on 02:29:942 - instead of 02:28:710 - rofl

Kotonoha wrote:

Shouldn't it be

Artist: lily-an

http://liz-tora.com/liz-tora/reunion/ From other metadata checks by qats i know they check the official website and use whats listed "Vocal".
Besides, I can't remember any maps getting ranked for some time now with only Circle listed in artist when there is vocalist too.
Also this http://osu.ppy.sh/b/388170

• Fine

1. 00:17:203 - make some note here?
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:31:997 (5,6,1) - bad flow imo, recommend move 00:32:203 (6) - to x205 y245
3. 01:20:902 (4,5) - place some jump here can make more fit and fun
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 01:38:161 (1) - finish
5. 02:03:847 (2,3) - better don't stack, will make player confuse imo

1. 00:19:669 (2) - stack on 00:19:874 (3) - head? more clear to read
2. 00:20:285 (4) - same stack with 00:20:696 (6) -
3. 00:43:915 (1) - wrong whistle on the slide?
4. 02:29:121 (2) - wrong snapping at the tail
5. 03:15:764 (2,3) - i think you can make better rhythm here
   
   SPOILER

   

Kawaiwkyik wrote:

[General]

• Fine

[Insane]

1. 00:17:203 - make some note here? Fixed!
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:31:997 (5,6,1) - bad flow imo, recommend move 00:32:203 (6) - to x205 y245 I like my current flow better.
3. 01:20:902 (4,5) - place some jump here can make more fit and fun True, hmm... i don't think it needs to be changed tho.
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 01:38:161 (1) - finish Fixed!
5. 02:03:847 (2,3) - better don't stack, will make player confuse imo Fixed!

[Hard]

• Fixed!

1. 00:19:669 (2) - stack on 00:19:874 (3) - head? more clear to read I think it would be confusing if there's a slider stacking on the head, and tail.
2. 00:20:285 (4) - same stack with 00:20:696 (6) - Same as above, almost..
3. 00:43:915 (1) - wrong whistle on the slide? Fixed!
4. 02:29:121 (2) - wrong snapping at the tail Fixed!
5. 03:15:764 (2,3) - i think you can make better rhythm here I like mince better.
   
   SPOILER

   

good luck

appleeaterx wrote:

Hi -Tochi!

:idea: General

* Shouldn't be that big of an issue, but if you could please resize the BG to 1366x768. LOL, only 1px. Fixed.
* Fix this in Hard/Insane diffs. Fixed!
* Preview point unsnapped? oops.

Normal

* 01:03:230 (4,1,2) - Why is this spaced 1.2x? Suddenly switching from spacing is definitely not something you should do in this difficulty. If you intended a sort of slow-down effect here, it wouldn't really work since it's only for like 3 objects, which would make it very confusing to suddenly slow down. Fixed!
* 01:30:765 (5,1) - Spacing error. Fixed!
* 03:21:312 (4,5,6,1) - Creating diamond shape here looks much better here imo. Fixed!

As far as patterns go, it looks okay, but really be consistent with DS. The first half of the song uses 1.4x mainly, but the other half 1.2x and I personally don't really see a good reason for that ..... you should really keep things consistent, especially for the lowest diff. I fixed all the spacing issues! (i hope lol)

Hard

* 00:17:203 (5,2) - Hmm.. I don't think it'll be an issue but spreading these out seems better to me, to avoid confusion with the reverse arrow. uuuh, i think i will keep it lol.
* 02:07:751 (1,2,3) - I highly recommend you to keep spacing here. Currently, it's quite hard to read the difference between snaps due to weird polarity issue going on at (2,3). Fixed!
* Actually, to me it'd sound better if you added a note on 02:08:778 (3) - to fix that polarity issue lol.

Sometimes due to weird rhythm choices (bit similar to the comment of the Insane diff) polarity is a bit messed up at some parts. Hope you can avoid that. I like this diff tho, neat :3 Thanks ^^

Insane

* 00:47:819 (3,4) - Please don't use extended sliders like this, the sound on the white tick is definitely not something to skip to make this 3/4. I'll consider this, it sounds very weird too because of the hitsound on the slider-end, but when i removed it, it sounded good
* 01:34:874 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - While I like the idea, the change in snaps is very confusing to me. I don't really see the confusing, u ar ethe first one mentioning it, but i might change when someone other else do too.
Using DS here would be better imo. It might just be me xd wat
* 02:15:765 (1) - Add finish? Sounds like a cymbal to me o-o? Naah, sound random to me lol.
* 02:18:436 (2,3) - Hmm.. these claps are really loud but there's nothing in the song to support that. Fixed!
* 02:22:340 (1) - Add clap to slider tail. Fixed!
* 02:23:984 (7) - Definitely missing some hitsounds here. Fixed!
* 02:46:380 (1,2,3) - While I love the pattern / flow here, I find that the vocal at 02:47:099 - could be mapped. Fixed!
* 02:48:845 (5) - I can assume that this whistle on the slider body was a mistake? Nope.
* 02:59:530 (1) - Quite sure this 5/8 slider is not needed, probably a mistake. OOOOOOOOPPPSS


I found this diff a bit weirdly mapped in terms of rhythm. A lot of sliders showed me that you tend to prioritize the synth/piano over everything else. However, because of that a lot of noticeable vocal/drum/clap notes are skipped. Maybe it's just me who thinks this orz

I don't think I'm going to push the map forward in it's current state, needs more improvement imo. ;w;
Wishing you good luck and have fun \o/ Thanks ;w;

Okoratu wrote:

oi can you undead this