Thanks for the mod!Xinely wrote:
krfawy asked me
General
- both soft-sliderslide and soft-sliderslide2 has length even they are silent which mean unrankable, please change with blank sliderslide from RC Fixed
- both soft-hitwhistle soft-hitwhistle2 have 10ms delay, cut them off please Fixed
Cup
- 00:04:588 - no whistle when the music is clearly a drum? There's a guitar sound on the head (hitnormal) and a clap on the tail (hitclap) - no change
- 00:06:697 (3) - it would be nicer if you change to 1/2 so you can add whistle on tail to follow drum more i guess Sure
- 00:10:213 (2) - x:388 to get the spacing more consistent Moved to x-372 instead, I want a slightly larger spacing here to emphasise the clap on (3)
- 00:07:635 (1) - i would really suggest to reduce the spacing a bit, the current spacing is a little bit far which makes newbie could get confuse Fixed anyway when changing 00:06:697 (3) -
- 00:23:806 (3) - i'd say just use circle at 00:24:041 - in this time, you used much 1/2 lol Feels awkward to leave the prominent guitar sounds unmapped, I'll keep this
- 00:29:197 (2) - miss clap on head Fixed
- 00:38:806 (3) - same as 00:23:806 (3) - same as 00:23:806 (3) -
- 00:40:681 (4) - in here too, this is Cup so the rhythms should be easy and not complicated with much 1/2, i'd say just use circle at 00:40:916 - Did change this one, guitar is weaker here so it still sounds okay with just the circle
- 00:42:322 (2) - x:264 for consistent spacing? Emphasising the clap on (2) with a slightly larger spacing, no change
Salad
- 00:17:713 (2) - clap on redtick is just a mistake for me since the clap sounds at 00:17:947 - , replacing with whistle would be nice Intentional, since this is the pattern MB mapped and it was the best compromise I could come up with. I honestly think it sounds fine, and there's also a whistle here already anyway (unless you meant default soft whistle?)
- 00:32:947 - are you sure to skip map clap music? also clap at head 00:32:713 - again it doesnt fit with music. and also (wtf lol), i'd end the slider at 00:33:416 - to follow the melody more MB doesn't want to change this slider, so this is the best I can do. To me it sounds less awkward to include the clap than to skip it
- 00:34:588 (3) - literally same as above, it makes me cry ;_; ^ ;_;
- 00:36:463 (6) - ^ (i mean just clap on head doesnt fit, and the best one is default soft whistle ;_;) I guess we have differing opinions here >.< I think it fits for reasons stated previously, won't change
good luck
New .osz with updates to Cup, hitsound updates to Salad and updated AudioLeadIn is here.