forum

V's osu! Modding Que

posted
Total Posts
51
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]
ONLY 5 MAPS AT A TIME. I LEARNED MY LESSON.

A couple minutes before I thought to post this thread, someone in #modhelp lamented that their queue lacked anything "worth modding". Personally, I believe every beatmap has potential, and I wish to mod any Standard maps people may have. I ask for nothing in exchange: I merely wish to help people improve their beatmaps. However, there will be laid a few ground rules first:

1. No Taiko/CtB/Mania difficulties will be modded: I have nothing against these modes. But, due to the complexities of mania and the lack of support for Taiko and CtB in the editor, I am not adept at these modes, and it is not fair to anyone to give them uneducated advice.
2. No maps that are intentionally designed to beat unbeatable: These maps are not fair to osu players, and have no potential. If they are remapped in a playable fashion, I will mod them.
3. You aren't required to take my advice: I can't force you to change your maps. But if you aren't willing to make the changes, any more asking for advice will result in me repeating my original advice.
4. You can ask for GDs: I am not inflexible on this, but you must bear in mind I tend to be rather... um, unique.
5. TAG maps and 490 style maps can be presented: These I have no problem with. Executed well, these can be enjoyable to play and challenging. However, expect to see heavy modding to make them more polished.
6. CS6, CS7, and AR10 maps are allowed: I have always been a proponent of these stats. However, please try to be conservative if you use them. Especially with CS7. I will try my best to find a way to make these maps do justice these stats.
7. Nothing IOSYS or Nico Nico Douga (Touhou excluded): I object to these for very specific reasons. These songs are all over the place, and their mapping is a nightmare to make both complementary and sane.
8. I do not mod GDs: This is a personal belief of mine. I just feel that a GD is the ground of its creator, and me modding it is questioning their judgment as a mapper.
9. No maps above 4 mins: I made the mistake of originally okaying longer maps. Problem is, they can take many hours, hours which could have been better used on shorter maps. Sorry.
10. Asking for GDs is allowed: I know how hard garnering GDs can be, so I'm glad to be of help.

With that said, fire away.
Nerova Riuz GX
Nice, I want to support these kinda things but I don't know how to join #modhelp WTF

btw with a request
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/205107
thanks
Nekomata
a mod would be appreciated :)
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/308519
_handholding
HI, Mod request pls

My map - t/320484

not everyday you see someone nice enough to do NM selflessy without anything in return :)
Heanday
Uhh, sounds good !

Mod request please ! :D

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/235120

You don't have to mod all of them, choice some dif ! Thanks~
Bara-
Hi
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/302898
Thanks! Just mod which diffs oyu'd like
Kihhou
I'll throw in a map then?

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/235008

Thanks!
Kbuns
Thank you for this queue! I hope you'll throw me a mod :D
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/304301
Thanks again <3
Zarthbenn
Hey! Good to see you again, just here looking for a nm please.

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/304740

Thank you~
Pho
TV size's a bit generic, but oh well

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/304606

Thanks if you accept ~
Nuolong
Aw, I was getting Cirno ready and then saw that last rule.
Anyways, here's another
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/222621
Vocaloid. Thank you, I'm a new mapper, bit be as harsh as you want! (But please don't say stuff like, "this will never be ranked.")
Thank you very much, you're so kind :3
Aerous
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]

Nerova Riuz GX wrote:

Nice, I want to support these kinda things but I don't know how to join #modhelp WTF

btw with a request
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/205107
thanks
Don't EVER join #modhelp. They are condescending slime.

Easy:

00:12:185 (1) - This should be a new combo right here. Though 6 note combos are okay in Easy, this calls for a new combo. 00:12:185 (1) - should remain a new combo, though.
00:20:320 - The note at 00:12:185 starts with that magnificent whistle, right after a crescendo. This spinner ends a second such crescendo, and should have the whistle hitsound as well.
00:32:863 (2,3,4) - Put claps on these. It emphasizes the building crescendo very well.
00:44:727 - This doesn't need a timing change. It really needs the whistle effect from the beginning spinner, which compliments and accentuates the crescendo. A finish might be in order as well.
01:01:507 (1,2) - Claps would go well here.
01:02:185 (3) - In the middle (not on the ends) apply a finish. It really does wonders for the buildup.
01:07:778 (2,4) - It's a little awkward having these pretty much identical. Perhaps rotate the top one slightly and move the note after it?
01:09:134 (4) - This needs to be new combo.
01:11:846 (1,2,3) - You need to find a way to make this ONE slider. You want something with the length of 01:11:846 (1) - in the timeline, with two repeats, as that fits the music better.
01:15:575 (6) - Needs to be new combo as well.
01:17:270 (1,2,3,4) - Similar problem. Make it one slider.
01:19:982 (1,2,3) - As above. The thing is, these parts are ramping up the difficulty. A lot.
01:23:710 (2,3,4,5) - This makes more sense musically as a slider with three repeats with a length of 01:24:049 (3) - in the timeline.
01:45:405 (2,3,4) - Take out the notes, not the slider, and move 01:45:744 (3) - to the white tick before it, and add two repeats. Fix the spacing to compensate.
02:28:287 (5,6) - These don't fit the music, remove them.
02:28:965 (1) - Move this to 02:28:456 (1) - and lengthen it to reach to 02:30:490 - . Add a clap to the end.
02:36:931 (1) - Make this a new combo.
03:16:592 (1) - Make this hitsound section C1, not C2, and add a whistle. Ends on a nice note.

Note: Your Easy shows mapping skill, but I think it is a safe thing to say that this is a little too hard for Easy. It might be worth it to cut down on the notes and make more of it sliders, as well as reduce the Distance Snap a bit. I will update the post tomorrow or the day after concerning the Hard and Vision. The rest are GDs, and I don't want to upset their apple carts. Keep watch of this post.

Nekomata wrote:

a mod would be appreciated :)
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/308519
This was a tricky one to mod, because you did this really well. I couldn't even find anything in Normal.

Hard: 01:10:844 (1,1,1) - Um, these don't need to be all new combo. Just have the first note as NC.
01:14:373 (2) - This looks better if you get it to x: 400 y: 132. It looks better and the snapping makes a little more sense.
01:29:667 (1,1,1) - Again, don't need these all to be NC.
02:04:667 (4) - This makes more sense for flow if you rotate it 90 degrees clockwise with selection as center.

Hi Im Nathan wrote:

HI, Mod request pls

My map - t/320484

not everyday you see someone nice enough to do NM selflessy without anything in return :)
I simply thought it was a tragedy that those pictures weren't resized, so I went ahead and did that. Unfortunately, I couldn't make them 1024x768 without significant loss of quality in them, so I used black bars on the side and I resized it to the common 800x600 used in osu. The links are here:

Pic 1: http://puu.sh/hJMzI/5a1a7182d6.jpg
Pic 2: http://puu.sh/hJMAv/53d334d18b.jpg
Pic 3: http://puu.sh/hJMB4/b1768fc34a.jpg
Pic 4: http://puu.sh/hJMBO/e2ca865c27.jpg

All you would need to do is resize the background to 800x600.

Normal:

01:02:282 (3) - This should look like... this?
01:52:282 (2,3,1) - These three should be one slider, and new combo for 01:53:820 (2) - .
01:57:666 (1) - Delete this, and move 01:57:762 (1) - to its place, extending the end of the spinner to where it was before, at 02:01:320 - .

Note: I would recommend knocking the AR to 3.5, the HP to 3.5, and the OD to 4.

Very Hard:

This doesn't really need to be here. If you slightly up the CS on the hard, the gap is lessened.

Insane:

00:13:820 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - These aren't needed. Take those out, bring 00:14:589 (1) - to where (5) was, and make it a long swooping slider.
00:45:743 (1,2,3,4) - This reads a little awkward. If you made 00:45:935 (2,3) - like 00:45:743 (1,4) - , and rotated 2 and 3 45 or 90 degrees counter clockwise, it would look much better.
00:56:128 (1) - In lieu of this note, just add a repeat to 00:55:551 (3) - .
01:16:704 (4,1) - The jump here is way too big. Take 01:16:128 (1,2,3,4) - and replace the notes with it, and use CTRL+H.

Note: This changes will dramatically lessen the gap between Hard and Insane. However, an Easy is needed.

Heanday wrote:

Uhh, sounds good !

Mod request please ! :D

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/235120

You don't have to mod all of them, choice some dif ! Thanks~
Ooh, Garven's Hard and Easy. I'll enjoy dissecting Garven's diff... MUAHAHA!

Might have to do it tomorrow, though. Keep posted.

baraatje123 wrote:

Hi
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/302898
Thanks! Just mod which diffs oyu'd like
Might wanna shrink the background first. And I really like your slider art.

Easy:

00:25:667 (2) - Shorten this so it ends on 00:26:153 - . It just makes more sense with the music.
00:35:559 (1) - The whistle here sounds... strange. It doesn't make sense to have it here.
01:11:883 (5) - This doesn't need to be here. Nothing suggests it should be there.
01:27:937 (1) - Same problem as 00:25:667 (2) - .
01:39:613 (1) - The music is silent from 01:43:667 - on, so you should have the spinner end there.

Note: The Easy needs very slight nerfing to get into rankable territory, below 1.5 stars.

Hard:

00:16:748 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - I love the idea you have here, but it gets really high DS for a Hard in the end. I recommend selecting them all, and using CTRL+SHIFT+S and scale the whole thing to 0.850 scale.
01:39:532 (1) - Same thing as the other diffs.

Insane:

00:56:153 (4,5,6,7) - This could be tidied up a bit. The overlaps are somewhat unsightly.
01:01:505 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - I would just make this a regular stream, instead of a stream with sliders.

Note: Your difficulty is also a bit too high here. Aim for below 4.75 stars.

Extra:

00:31:342 (5,6) - These are a little awkward. Just continue the note pattern from (4) and hook it to the next slider.
01:39:532 (1) - Dock the slider to here 01:43:667 - .

Kihhou wrote:

I'll throw in a map then?

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/235008

Thanks!
Oh, I remember this map! I always loved it too. Unfortunately, I have not much time left in the day, so I'll do this one tomorrow. Keep posted.

Kbuns wrote:

Thank you for this queue! I hope you'll throw me a mod :D
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/304301
Thanks again <3
Always welcome here.

Easy:

00:04:384 (1) - This should be fixed to... this?
01:26:884 (1,2) - Make this be only one slider.

Note: Maybe lower AR?

Normal:

00:02:006 (2) - Move to x:336 y:160

Hard:

00:40:421 (5) - This kinda suggests a clap.

Note: Your Hard heavily is relying on straight sliders. Try adding curves to them whenever possible, as that reflects the whimsy and fantasy of the piece. Even slight curves do wonders.

Insane:

01:26:884 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - Try travelling in an arc around the playing field. Not only is it easier to read, it's more fun to play.

Perhaps your biggest problem is your colours for your combos. Look at the background, listen to the song. They portray fantasy and bold adventure. Study the background to see what colours are good. Perhaps a navy colour, as suggested by the blimp's underside? Maybe a sand tan colour, like the blimp? Perhaps a crimson colour to reflect the maiden's garb? Perhaps the most elusive, the adobe brown of the boots or the dark gold of the blade the lass holds? Look for things to complement the background and the feel of the song, not clash with them as the generic colours given do.
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]

NolanM wrote:

Aw, I was getting Cirno ready and then saw that last rule.
Anyways, here's another
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/222621
Vocaloid. Thank you, I'm a new mapper, bit be as harsh as you want! (But please don't say stuff like, "this will never be ranked.")
Thank you very much, you're so kind :3
I do accept Touhou songs. But not stuff like those mash up songs where they take random Japanese things and fit it to a melody. And I would NEVER say anything insulting.

The song is a bit big for me to do today, though.
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]

Aerous wrote:

TV size NM :) !!

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/302343
Easy:

01:12:898 (1) - Move back a white tick, keed the end at the same place.
01:17:477 (1,2) - This seems like it should be one slider.

I would recommend sprucing up the colours, though. Generic isn't great.

Pho wrote:

TV size's a bit generic, but oh well

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/304606

Thanks if you accept ~
I make it a rule of thumb not to mod GDs, because I feel like I'm overstepping my boundaries.

Revolution:

00:04:101 (1,2,3,4) - try connecting these together, making an arc from the stream to the next combo.
00:14:053 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Make these work their way toward the next set of notes. As is, it feels strange.

The skin... you might want to edit the numbers, so they are high visibility. Black is better than white in this case.
Monstrata
Uhhhh I think you might want to post in the beatmap thread itself lol... So people can actually click the time stamps
Rukaru
hey veronica. o/

is that your mod above? you should have posted it in the map thread, not in the queue. you didn't get any kudosu for posting here and the mapper won't gained star priority too.

anyway, is this still open? can I request for a mod?
here's my map : https://osu.ppy.sh/s/278135
thanks. ignore if this queue were closed. xD
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]

monstrata wrote:

Uhhhh I think you might want to post in the beatmap thread itself lol... So people can actually click the time stamps
Done.

Rukaru wrote:

hey veronica. o/

is that your mod above? you should have posted it in the map thread, not in the queue. you didn't get any kudosu for posting here and the mapper won't gained star priority too.

anyway, is this still open? can I request for a mod?
here's my map : https://osu.ppy.sh/s/278135
thanks. ignore if this queue were closed. xD
The queue is open, but it's pretty late in the day for me, so larger ones I'm saving for another day.
Pittigbaasje
Heyy! I would love to have a mod for my map: LeBask - Hardcoriste
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/266567
Thanks in advance!
-Pittigbaasje
pishifat
weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeww

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/297909#
AsakuraNe
Heloo~ :3 awesome queue here~

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/300360

Thanks in Advance :)
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]
For the rest of today, queue closed. I have a lot piled up, and I can't finish it all today.
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]
Queue re-opened.
CerealeKiller
Hi there !

Mod request for this map : Visionary

It would be very much appreciated :)
Strategas
Greetings,

Mod request for this great song! : https://osu.ppy.sh/s/306307

Thank you!
Mio_chan
hello~
my map: Last Note. - Route Sphere
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/78682

since the song is long, you may mod whatever no. of diffs you like,
thanks :)
Lucyii
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/67565
This is long but only one diff, thanks :3
Alheak
Hey V

Please take a look: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/298724

Thank you!
Liiraye
henryx
Hello.

I'd like a mod for this map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/311609

Thank you! :)
nanoK
Generic map.
47th map, tv size.

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/300148

Please post the mod in my thread, not your's. that way you can get kudosu as well as me
Monstrata
Kotayo
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/129314

would appreciate a mod :D
Peachtrees
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/312278

relaxing song, not sure if you like those owo
Skyhmer
A queue with no limits on the # of maps could be hell...
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/282217
Please and Thank you
VINXIS
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/288974 mod whatev u want
clayton
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/307468
joke map
if you even bother with this one, thanks
Xinying
Hello~
My map for NM : https://osu.ppy.sh/s/308302
Thanks in advance.
mion_6GKM
hello!

Nm please

SawanoHiroyuki[nZk]:Gemie - X.U.

thanks!
GiantZarz
Hello~!


NM please~
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/304885

jumps are beatable for pros (and some 9k+)
Ciyus Miapah
hi there

im requesting some normal mod here
but if you want do m4m feel free to ask it

here's the link
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/275655

thanks.
XiMerx
Hi V
GD request here
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/312426

Thank you~
xChorse
Ilk Ender47
Ummmmmmmmmm.....
Mod please..
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/301412
Thanks in advance! :3
Hpoe you like it..! :D
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]
Queue closed. 20 mods... this shall be good. This might take a few days for me to properly do these all.
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]
Mod queue is re-opened. This time, I actually set a limit, like a sane person.
Nekomata
Charraz
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/306793

Like I wrote in the song description insane diff isn't finished yet but if you want you can mod it anyway.
Thanks in advance!
Koto Hono
First time beatmapping, not sure whether this is the right place to post.
If it is, would like some help on https://osu.ppy.sh/s/314018
Thank you!
Rizen
would be appreciated if you can mod this map please:

link: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/301830
title: Still into You
artist: Paramore
length: ~3:30
difficulties: 2 (excluding 1 GD)

thanks--
Topic Starter
[ Eon Fox ]
Unfortunately, I'm going to have to bench this for a while. When I made this queue, I forgot about MANY things I already had on my plate.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply