ErufenRito wrote:

Easy:

01:25:263 (1) - It appears way too soon after a spinner for an easy, id suggest to delete this whole combo and extend the spinner to 01:26:808
X
Overall, this difficulty its pretty good

Someone:

AHHH please, increase overall difficulty D:
V
00:45:864 (2) - This slider just sounds bad. And i blame to the ending point of the slider. If it were me, i would make it end 00:46:379, and add one repeat, so it will end at 00:46:894. Deleting the circle in thatnplace of course.
hmm... I'll think about it
00:51:143 - This was a good place to put a note in the 1/4. Im saying this cause i can notice that you kinda want them Lol. If you are going to do this, you will have to delete 00:51:014 (8,9)
V
01:13:418 (3) - Make this end at 01:13:675, and add a circle with a clap at 01:13:804.
X
Umm i can say more about these little 1/4 things... but this is very biased to what i think its better, and its your map, so i guess i would just stop here.

Sakura301 wrote:

[General]

[Easy Sallad]
00:00:285 (1,2,3) - Move theese notes 2 grids down to center (1) and (3)?
V
01:25:263 (1,2,3) - Umm center them?
V

[Some]
Fine

[Somone]
Fine

[Natteke's WAN WAN]
I'll start with my favorite quote: (at the bottom of my siggy)
X
00:53:846 (1) - I'd use Linear slider if your going to make a slider look like this, it's pretty ugly imo, try to make a rainbow kind of slider like: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8918
V
00:55:906 (1) - ^
V
01:21:786 (1) - Awkward Spinner (doesnt seem to be following the music, i hear many lyrics in the background that could very well be notes instead)
Netteke will look at this
Also i think it's kind of overmapped
I dont think so

Nice map nevertheless +Star

Sakura301 wrote:

[Natteke's WAN WAN]
I'll start with my favorite quote: (at the bottom of my siggy) - not everyone has to be a bad player
01:21:786 (1) - Awkward Spinner (doesnt seem to be following the music, i hear many lyrics in the background that could very well be notes instead) - It's fine to me
Also i think it's kind of overmapped - lol

• • Disable countdown

• • 01:26:035 (1) - End this spinner here 01:27:837 (white tick)

• • 01:26:807 (6) - End this slider here 01:27:837 (white tick)

Vicho-kun wrote:

These are just suggestions, you don't have to change them if you don't agree with me

[General]
Change the artist to Asumi Kana
Add tags: Fujita Saki Kitamura Eri
why? no
Source: WORKING!!
orz, does it matter at all?

[Easy Sallad]
Fine

[Some]
Fine

[Someone]
00:45:870 (2) - make this slider more longer (1/4 of beat) but mantain the number of repetion, like this:

:( This slider makes me happy... ;'(
01:01:556 (4) - remove the clap at the end of the slider
ye
01:02:884 (2,3,4,5) - add claps
ye
01:26:066 - add kiai?
???????

[Nateke's WAN WAN]
Great! Good Job

Star!

SOMEWAN WAN WAN! SOMEWAN WAN WAN! :3

arken1015 wrote:

[Easy Sallad]< Is that 'Salad'???
no he is Sallad4ever
00:03:374 (4) - [Suggestion] How about move 1 grid right?
00:23:974 (3) - How about move 1 grid left?
00:37:365 (1) - [Suggestion] How about move 1 grid right?
01:18:567 (1) - How about move 1 grid left?
nazi mod is so nazi
[Some]
01:17:279 (3,4,5) - Little spacing problem ;_;
;_; grid lvl3 sux
01:26:035 (1) - [Suggestion] Slience?
mb
[Someone]
01:03:631 (4) - [Suggestion] How about move 1 grid up?
xD
[lepidon! - Taiko Oni]
I believe lepidon :3
good
[Natteke's WAN WAN!!]
[Suggestion] Tag 'Natteke Desu' -> 'Natteke_Desu' ???
no



Good song :3
Anyway... Good luck orz
THX

strager wrote:

Easy Sallad
Isn't it spelled Salad? Or is it a character name or somthing?

strager wrote:

General
Natteke Desu should only be in his diff's tags, not in the tags of other maps.
lepidopodus should only be in his diff's tags, not in the tags of other maps.

Lybydose wrote:

If you don't put guest names in all the difficulties, the song will not show up if you search for the guest mapper's name.

blissfulyoshi wrote:

strager wrote:

General
Natteke Desu should only be in his diff's tags, not in the tags of other maps.
lepidopodus should only be in his diff's tags, not in the tags of other maps.

Just to make sure everyone is properly informed about tags, here is the issue about having guest mapper tags only in the corresponding guest diff:

Lybydose wrote:

If you don't put guest names in all the difficulties, the song will not show up if you search for the guest mapper's name.

Note: This is copy and pasted from the MAT board after our discussion on tags.

KIA wrote:

And what should I do? Leave guest mapper tag on every diff or diff specific?

blissfulyoshi wrote:

KIA wrote:

And what should I do? Leave guest mapper tag on every diff or diff specific?

Keep the guest mappers name tag in everydiff please.
Sorry for not explaining this earlier.

Xgor wrote:

[Background]
Crop the background to 977 x 735 :/
I'll resize to 1024x768 better
[Tags]
I doubt anime is needed in tags
no, it's already in source
[Preview point]
I think you should place the Preview point at 00:49:726 (But you probably won't so whatever~)
no
[Easy]
Great Easy, a bit tricky rhythms but not that bad.

[NormalHard]
Can't find much to complain here either

[HardInsane]
Please raise the slider velocity <.<
D: no, I wont respace all notes again
[InsaneWAN WAN]
Oh look, 00:17:022 to 00:31:957 is not hitsounded at all.
It's there for reason
Well couldn't find much, but it has gotten allot of mods~
*star*