1. Except the timing issue mentioned above, nothing else.

1. 00:30:914 (2,3) - Blanket. Otherwise it's fine.

1. 00:00:504 (1) - Delete whistle on reversearrow. Puts way better emphasis on the piano than setting whistles there.
2. 00:02:147 (2) - Delete whistle on sliderend for same reason.
3. 00:06:462 (5) - Instead of whistles, go with a drumclap-addition on sliderstart and drumfinish-addition on sliderend.
4. 00:14:476 (2) - Missed whistle on sliderstart.
5. 00:31:531 (3) - Delete the whistle on sliderend. It should be at 00:32:147 (4) -

1. 00:02:147 (1) - Delete NC
2. 00:04:613 (4,5) - You can improve the flow here: http://puu.sh/eoi4X/10f1d39602.jpg
3. 00:21:462 (3) - I feel like the whistle is unnecessary here, might consider to put it off.
4. 00:24:339 (4) - Same as above, whistle on sliderstart can be deleted.
5. 00:32:558 (3) - Delete whistle on sliderend, four whistles in a row sound overhitsounded.
6. 00:44:887 (1) - Drumclap on sliderstart instead.
7. 00:45:709 (2,1) - Might as well put some effort and blanket this.
8. 00:48:586 (2,3,4) - Spacing looks ugly here, space all 1.50xDS?
9. 00:51:873 (1) - Unnecessary NC, you don't increase SV here.
10. 00:51:873 (1,1,1) - Flow is pretty much broken here, it's better to 00:52:284 (1) - Ctrl+g this slider for smoother flow.
11. 01:04:613 (1,2,3) - Not trying to blanket here? I find this pattern some ugly with this overlap >.>
12. 01:19:408 (1) - Ctrl+g?
13. Not a fan of so much broken flow in Hard's but k.

1. I feel you're a bit too forgiving with the OD/HP here, I mean it's an Insane after all. Consider to increase both by 0.5/1.
2. 00:21:462 (3) - Maybe delete whistle here.
3. 00:23:517 (6,1) - NC at 6 already.
4. 01:23:078 (1) - NC is unnecessary, delete.

Pho wrote:

[Hard]

1. 00:02:147 (1) - Delete NC it's needed imo
2. 00:24:339 (4) - Same as above, whistle on sliderstart can be deleted. I think it fits
3. 00:48:586 (2,3,4) - Spacing looks ugly here, space all 1.50xDS? no, I want the jump to the triple and the next slider
4. 00:51:873 (1) - Unnecessary NC, you don't increase SV here. true, but it's the starting slider of the pattern
5. 01:19:408 (1) - Ctrl+g? I think current flow is better

1. timing isn't set up for taiko conversion (the ranked one isn't either so uh lol). you'll just need to omit bar lines for the red points at 01:21:546 - 01:22:112 - 01:22:730 - , then add another red point at 01:23:404 - with 89bpm. could look at this map starting at 01:36:623 (1) - for reference cuz it's like the exact same thing done right

1. 00:42:832 (5) - confirmed with 400 people that this is 1/6
2. 01:22:730 - would be nice to raise the volume here to like 15% or 20% cuz 10% is super quiet

1. 00:42:832 (4) - snapping ya know. 1/6 reverse probably wouldn't work in a hard too well so gl
2. 01:22:730 - volume ya know
3. 01:23:067 (2) - forgot a whistle

1. 00:41:599 (1) - i am sad

pishifat wrote:

popping cuz bold stuff

[general]

1. timing isn't set up for taiko conversion (the ranked one isn't either so uh lol). you'll just need to omit bar lines for the red points at 01:21:546 - 01:22:112 - 01:22:730 - , then add another red point at 01:23:404 - with 89bpm. could look at this map starting at 01:36:623 (1) - for reference cuz it's like the exact same thing done right
   I have no clue what you're saying, so I believe you and am changing it. didn't add taiko whatever thing to the last red line you told me to add though, since you didn't tell me to add

[easy]

1. 00:41:599 (1) - i am sad it's fine

thats it yay

Setz wrote:

based ringating's magic is OP.

1. Why not AR8? If you are adding that 0.1 for jumps, I would rather prefer 8.3 then >.>
2. 00:28:654 (2,3,4,5,6) - 25% claps on these sound nice.
3. 00:32:456 - I wonder why there isn't a circle here like other triplets did.
4. 00:36:051 (4) - Finish doesn't fit here.
5. 00:39:134 (4,5,6,7,8) - I don't understand the rhythm here even if you use hitsounds to conceal overmapping, if you are mapping to music and vocal, my comprehension is something like this: http://puu.sh/eGAS9.jpg
6. 01:17:661 (8,1) - The stack here can be fixed easily.
7. 01:21:051 - I can't hear whistles starting from here, please increase the volumes as the music isn't really descending.

1. 00:46:325 - Redundant green line.
2. 00:36:051 - Finish doesn't fit here.
3. 00:39:545 (3) - Same issue as Insane, the new stanza starts at 00:39:956 - , so you don't need to overmap here to assort with those at the back. I prefer you place kick sliders 00:42:832 (4,5) - .
4. 01:21:051 - I have mentioned this in Insane.

1. 00:39:750 (1) - Clap?
2. 00:52:284 (2) - Drum finishes for both head and tails.
3. 01:12:832 - Whistle missing.

1. 00:09:339 - Whistle doesn't fit here.

IamKwaN wrote:

modding this tonight, have a nap first lol
I love maps with no GDs. yay
[Insane]

1. Why not AR8? If you are adding that 0.1 for jumps, I would rather prefer 8.3 then >.> lol changed to 8
2. 00:28:654 (2,3,4,5,6) - 25% claps on these sound nice.i did 45%. 25% sounds will sound too quiet compared to notes with 50% volume around these
3. 00:32:456 - I wonder why there isn't a circle here like other triplets did. mainly following the piano sound here

[Hard]

1. 00:39:545 (3) - Same issue as Insane, the new stanza starts at 00:39:956 - , so you don't need to overmap here to assort with those at the back. I prefer you place kick sliders 00:42:832 (4,5) - . did something like what i did on insane

No Dap wrote:

Genocide's mapset moved to ranked!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!@#@#!@#!@#!@#!@#!@#!@$!%!#$@#^%$#%@#%$#!^&%$&