Okoratu wrote:

yo rakuen could you wait, I'm getting one additional opinion on hitsounds

/summon Raika


@OblivioN I like that slider and it's not part of my hitsound commentary

Destiny

1. hi it's mod time
2. Stack leniency to 5 so that notes like 00:22:517 (1,2,3) - stack ingame? hmm i'd like SL4 better
3. 00:17:155 (1,2) - would increase overall spacing in 00:17:155 (1,2,3) - to avoid this tiny overlap (using 1.8x snap looks better to me) ok
4. 00:36:687 (1) - would shorten this spinner to 00:38:602 - and do 3 circles like 00:22:517 (1,2,3) - because same thing nice
5. 01:06:176 (1) - this edge creates for pretty awkward flow from 01:05:921 (4) - ok
   
   something like this would be MUCH more pleasant to play

   
   rotated 01:05:921 (4) - slightly downwards and slidershape of 01:06:176 (1) - should really not have the ball move backwards
6. 01:24:942 (2,3) - moving this one closer to 01:24:559 (1) - a bit (like 2.1 spacing) would be less jumpy and awkward and yes hmm.i think it's fine maybe..
7. If you nerfed spacing in 01:25:453 (4,5) - you should nerf this spacing a tiny bit as well ^
8. 01:32:602 (7,1) - & 01:33:368 (3,4) - could use more space because you did more space all the time in patterns like 01:31:836 (4,5) - 01:30:049 (6,7) - 01:22:900 (2,3) - so yea increasing spacing here a bit wouild actually be sense 1.3ds now :D
9. 02:24:559 (3,4,5) - would use more space, would feel more comfortable imo ok
10. 02:40:517 (2,4) - would take these 2 and move them to 260|350 is hfor more even spacing and less awkward flow hmm, no i prefer now
11. 02:41:921 (8,9) - doing small spacing after a 3.0xish jump just feels weird: either reduce spacing from 02:41:666 (7) - to 02:41:921 (8) - or something like this is an option as well i made the 7 close with 8
12. 02:48:176 (7) - moving this so that it has even spacing like dis or something will flow better okkk
13. 02:53:921 (7) - why not one more repeat like 01:22:261 (8) - ? actually, i use 1/12 repeat silder after garven dq my map
14. 03:00:432 (6,1) - going from giant into baby spacing might not be the best idea :/ as a buffer
15. 03:01:963 (6,7) - spacing 2 giant imo ^
16. 03:02:091 (7,8) - ye, basic problem is going from giant into totally small spacing ^
17. 03:05:666 (5) - moving this slightly down an to the left like wow awesome
    
    this would be cool

    
18. 03:07:708 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - doing a more jumpy slider reliant pattern like 01:34:772 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - could be more fun here hmmmm hard to change..
19. 02:50:091 (7,2) - could avoid tiny overlap yea
20. 03:18:942 (1) - one additional anchor for ok
    
    better curve?

    
21. 03:23:666 (2) - disregard the stack and move it to 335|246 for better spacing like 03:24:687 (2) - has :> 348,254 now
22. 03:51:368 (5) - this is the only slightly not aesthetic slider in this whole map, i would go for a slidershape which avoids ending like this hmm,do some adjustment

Box with stack which are off in the editor and can cause weird stacking behaviour ingame

• 
  qwq i hate stack leniency

1. 00:59:027 (4,6) - fixed
2. 01:01:580 (5,6) - this one is even behaving weirdly fixed
3. 01:08:091 (8,1) - weird behaviour ingame hmm,just so so
4. 01:26:474 (8,1) - fixed
5. 01:34:134 (7,8) - yes this looks super weird changed
6. 02:10:261 (6,1,2,3) - if you do increase stack leniency this is getting broken, moving 02:10:261 (6) - to 191|232 completely solves your problem
7. 02:14:346 (3,4) - looks weird w fixed
8. 02:52:134 (9,10) - these don't stack properly with 02:52:389 (1) - and look weird fine
9. 03:55:708 (1,2,3,4) - would custom stack this because http://puu.sh/e9xJZ/46b1af924c.jpg doesn't look so nice :/ ok

hitsound stuff

1. 00:18:687 - forgot clap added
2. 00:30:176 (2) - is there a whistle on this sliderbody only for me o: i haven't see whistle on silderbody :/
3. 01:01:580 (5) - missing drum set added
4. 01:47:155 (1) - should use same hitsounding as 01:43:070 (1) - imo (i think i made it inconsistent with last mod) ok
5. 03:14:474 (7) - forgot to remove whistle on sliderbody :> fixed
6. 02:01:325 (1) - forgot whistle + soft additions added
7. 02:23:793 (1) - forgot whistle + soft additions added
8. 02:15:623 (1) - forgot whistle + soft additions added
9. 02:16:389 (3) - forgot whistle added
10. 02:25:836 (1) - sampleset should be drum fixed
11. 03:59:921 (2,3,4,6,7,8) - remove the drum sampleset as it follows the strong beats for the whole rest of the song ok
12. 04:00:814 - add drum sampleset added
13. 04:01:325 - add drum sampleset added
14. 02:27:878 (1) - you forgot to add the soft sampleset and the volume change like 00:55:963 (1) - has! added
15. 03:20:985 - would increase volume to 40% so that you actually hear finsish ok

combos

• 
  all fixed

1. 00:41:155 (1,2) - swap NC because downbeat
2. 00:27:368 (3) - NC because 00:25:325 (1) - , 00:23:283 (1) - make more sense then
3. 00:31:453 (4) - NC
4. 00:35:538 (6) - ^
5. 01:06:687 (1) - removing this NC would make much more sense with 01:22:517 (1,2,3,4,5,6) -
6. 01:09:240 (1) - ^
7. 01:12:559 (5,1) - swapping thse NCs for same reasons
8. 02:50:346 (1,2,3,4,5) - see 01:18:432 (1,2,3,4,1) - for comboing
9. 04:14:602 (5,1) - would swap nc for same combo reason ^

Rakuen wrote:

As requested!

Legend

Default = Normal mods
Blue = Strongly recommended
Red = Unrankable issue
Pink = Will be discussed if not changed

General

• 我对hitsound没什么意见，看一遍你觉得可以就行

Easy

1. 00:23:793 (2) - DS (closer to 1.0x) 好的
2. 00:24:814 (3) - 感觉这里00:24:559 - 和00:25:070 - 的音比较重 改了一下.easy空拍就是蛋疼 怎么都弄不自然
3. 00:29:410 (1) - Remove NC ok
4. 00:31:453 (3) - NC (combo too long) ok
5. 01:29:666 (1) - DS (1.0x) fixed
6. 01:55:708 (2) - DS fixed
7. 01:59:283 (2,3) - ^ fixed
8. 02:47:283 (1) - ^ fixed

Normal

1. 00:26:602 (6) - DS (1.2x) fixed
2. 02:15:623 (4) - ^ fixed
3. 02:38:091 (1) - 空白部分加DS会增加难度，建议1.2 这里感觉还行...
4. 04:10:261 - Remove hitsounds? 好

Hard

1. 01:04:644 (5) - Remove? 这里没音 考虑了一下还是留下来和后面衔接好点...
2. 03:27:112 (1) - 稍微离03:26:602 (5) - 开点 好

Destiny

1. 圈圈大小放4？现在这个比Hard还大 .原本是3的..改成3.5了 4的话太小了 就3.5了

Call me back!

Rakuen wrote:

Narcissu's Insane

1. 01:05:666 - 听起来觉得声量是在加大 （也看看其他两个KIAI）……弄成一樣了……之前是想圈少聽上去會輕一點
2. 01:38:346 (1,2,3,4) - Over? 好像是1/8 （同上）……好，雖然我和CB都認為是1/12但是我本來就是1/8 LOL
3. 03:22:857 - 这里几多个03:22:687 (2) - ……好
4. 03:39:368 - Spinner?……翻抄了Pururut的滑條√
5. 04:18:176 - 有点刺耳，用回建议88%声量……好

Okoratu wrote:

yo rakuen could you wait, I'm getting one additional opinion on hitsounds

/summon Raika

LordRaika wrote:

Okoratu wrote:

yo rakuen could you wait, I'm getting one additional opinion on hitsounds

/summon Raika

>_</ hi there, umm so i got summoned here... to crazily detailed on hitsound check... :
I warn u, this is going to be crazy orz, check this when u have the right mood ^^

Hitsound Mod

[Destiny]

First, after take some time listening to the music without hitsound then check your whole hitsound...
i got some conclusion here :

1. first, there is nothing wrong with your hitsound for all ^^
   but after analyzing everything on what u hitsound, i can suggest smthg to improve them.
2. i feel... this part 00:06:942 - , 00:11:027 - whistle can sounds better and different than ANY other whistle around here.
   umm the reason is all of that part above has the "kick sound"
   .
   next,
   I LIKE how u can 00:40:134 - make this sampleset drum (start slider) 00:40:644 - , 00:41:155 - and so on...
   for most people, they wont even notice the differences between default "drum-hitnormal and soft-hitnormal" xD ahaha
   but.... even u set it like that.... for me... iT DOES nothing sounds impressive yet ... YET
   .
   and...
   if im not mistaken, i can't see you ever use S:C1 clap... ( the soft-hitclap.wav ) , here goes my suggestion for 2 of the above that i mention... CHOOSE one of this two kick sound :
   NICE but if you don't want something blend or fitting the song too much, DONT use this....
   Use this one instead.... This one is much louder and still ^^b ( so i recommend this for STD ) I chose this one
   after choosing one of them, we will make 4 copy of it, rename it into drum-hitnormal.wav
   COPY it into soft-hitclap.wav replacing your soft-hitclap....
   Copy it again and rename into soft-hitfinish2 replacing yours ( we can revert this LATER if u dont like it )
   and finally copy it for soft-slidertick.wav
   put inside song folder... refresh editor by reenter it....
   .
   drum-hitnormal.wav take immediate effect here : 00:39:623 - fixing all of them automatically ^^ . hmm i had tried it,but i like the default "drum-hitnormal" more so i'm decide to use default drum-hitnormal so sorry
   soft-hitclap.wav is for this 00:06:942 - add clap here , keep the whistle if you want...
   same goes to 00:11:027 - ^ 00:15:112 - ^ nice and i keep whistle
   soft-hitfinish2 this one also works automatically here 01:06:176 - and of of S:C2 section... i love normal-hitnormal dont slap me /run
   soft-slidertick.wav too, works automatically for something like this 01:56:219 - missing but it does the job here. hmm,nice
   but such as 01:55:453- 01:59:538- 02:03:623- ·····e.t.c will overused
3. Yep that's it... i really hope that works awesome for your preferences on hitsounding.... ( some people love the sound of normal-hitnormal more than anything , so feel free to restore your soft-hitfinish2 )
4. for WHAT you hitsound... 01:20:219 - u overused clap here orz... simply remove it.... in Editor > VIew > Volume > MUsic 100% and sample 0% , and all other clap looks on the right time except this,
   01:21:495 - overused clap too.... , 01:21:751 - remove finish.... yeah... assuming you add clap for each drum snare sound, then it SHOULD only appear on most 2/1 beat, same goes to finish , each 2/1 beat ^^ its best that u check it again for all >_< fixed >_<
5. and 1 more crazy hitsound that will sounds !@#$%!!
   Download and rename this into drum-hitnormal2.wav
   Where you use this is simply add new timing as D:C2 with 100% volume here.... 01:37:836 - ( remove any other drum whistle here on repeat slider )
   can be used again here.... 02:53:921 - , 03:10:517 - and so on sounds not appropriate and too loud,sorry

That's , pretty much cover anything i guess... :3 while the normal-hitwhistle3 is used on Narcissu's Insane , so no problem.

^^
hope that helps...

... Ceui....
nice song!!!

LordRaika wrote:

nah, its okay ^^

another thing is you can add Finish on each of the default hitnormal sample set drum part, drum finish works the same with kick sound, adding finish on them, will give you the result of hitnormal+hitfinish, do this to all similar part.

also for last one hitsound, so basically you are saying no sound or default soft-hitnormal low volume works better than the custom hitsound i recommend

Pururut wrote:

akasha出来挡枪了