forum

Noriko Matsueda,Takahito Eguchi - Eternity ~Memory of lightw

posted
Total Posts
40
show more
BishoujoAlice
The long note on the way left in the beginning is way to long in my opinion, may only be my opinion as i forgot to continue holding it along the way.
Seiryuu
Mod from irc.

15:33 Candice: yea,btw the mod
15:33 [-Seiryuu-]: yeah i almost forgot lel
15:35 [-Seiryuu-]: well okay first things first
15:35 [-Seiryuu-]: 00:06:579 (6579|1) - what does this ln represent?
15:36 Candice: increasing pitch every 4 cycle
15:36 Candice: a pattern
15:36 [-Seiryuu-]: hm okay
15:37 [-Seiryuu-]: 00:37:829 (37829|3) - this isn't needed imo
15:37 [-Seiryuu-]: doing irc mod because of browser issues lol
15:38 [-Seiryuu-]: 00:37:829 (37829|3,54579|2,55079|3,56079|2,56579|1,57329|2) - this isn't needed too, unless you want to change all the LNs to doubles
15:39 Candice: wait ah
15:39 [-Seiryuu-]: kk
15:42 Candice: but that LN represents something
15:42 Candice: that sound in the BG
15:42 [-Seiryuu-]: piano?
15:43 Candice: theres that sound in the bg starting from that point
15:43 Candice: u go listen
15:44 [-Seiryuu-]: only one sound
15:44 Candice: ya
15:44 Candice: 1 long sound
15:45 [-Seiryuu-]: souldnt you just put one LN
15:45 [-Seiryuu-]: because the last section has the same thing
15:46 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:28:579 (88579|3) - extend this
15:47 Candice: done
15:48 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:30:329 im sure there are more sounds here
15:48 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:30:329
15:48 [-Seiryuu-]: dammit
15:48 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:30:329 (90329|5,90329|3,90329|6) -
15:48 Candice: LOL
15:48 Candice: u rage ah?
15:48 [-Seiryuu-]: wut
15:48 [-Seiryuu-]: i copy pasted wrong xD
15:48 Candice: ohh
15:48 Candice: wait
15:49 Candice: got more sound meh?
15:49 [-Seiryuu-]: you should use LN for the piano
15:49 [-Seiryuu-]: and single notes for the short sounds
15:49 [-Seiryuu-]: or you could remove the LN at that part (i don't hear anything that lasts for that period of time)
15:51 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:29:829 - 01:48:579
15:51 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:48:579-
15:51 [-Seiryuu-]: wtf
15:51 Candice: ?
15:51 [-Seiryuu-]: the hl doesnt work like last time
15:51 [-Seiryuu-]: nvm
15:51 [-Seiryuu-]: from those 2 parts
15:51 [-Seiryuu-]: i think the LN could be reworked
15:52 Candice: wait i updates
15:52 Candice: d
15:52 Candice: u try agn
15:52 [-Seiryuu-]: kk
15:56 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:04:828 (64828|0,64829|2,64829|1) - make this a double
15:57 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:04:329 (64329|0) - delete this
15:57 [-Seiryuu-]: make the grace notes on one hand instead of both
15:58 [-Seiryuu-]: i think i'll just state the general problem
15:58 [-Seiryuu-]: notes that have the same volume use the same amount of notes
15:59 [-Seiryuu-]: notes that have the exact same sound use the same pattern
15:59 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:15:329 (75329|5,75360|6) - this grace note isnt needed
15:59 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:29:047 (89047|4,89079|5) - this too
16:00 Candice: wait firstly
16:00 Candice: the doubles
16:01 [-Seiryuu-]: double = 2 notes
16:01 Candice: u sure?? the pianist is like playing the piano
16:01 [-Seiryuu-]: triple = 3 notes
16:01 Candice: quite hard leh
16:01 [-Seiryuu-]: no i mean
16:01 [-Seiryuu-]: 2 notes on the same line
16:01 [-Seiryuu-]: not column
16:01 Candice: i know
16:01 Candice: but i think the second prob i say
16:01 Candice: shld be 3 note sia
16:01 Candice: u*
16:02 [-Seiryuu-]: ?
16:02 [-Seiryuu-]: it has the same volume .-.
16:02 Candice: wait ah
16:03 [-Seiryuu-]: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2377792
16:03 [-Seiryuu-]: first one is double, second is triple
16:03 [-Seiryuu-]: lol
16:04 Candice: updated
16:04 Candice: as long as got piano triple
16:04 [-Seiryuu-]: kk brb
16:04 Candice: double is for beat
16:04 Candice: 4 notes is when piano being played hard
16:05 [-Seiryuu-]: hmm okay
16:05 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:05:078 (65078|2,65079|3,65079|1) - wait wut this
16:07 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:05:078 (65078|2,65079|1,65079|3,89829|2,89829|4,93579|5,93579|1) - some of these LNs feel unneeded but it's fie if you want to continue putting it there
16:07 [-Seiryuu-]: fine*
16:09 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:51:704 - you should make the speed go back to normal here
16:10 [-Seiryuu-]: it flows way better
16:11 [-Seiryuu-]: 02:09:495 (129495|6) - delete this
16:11 Candice: shit how add timming ah??
16:11 Candice: i forgot
16:11 [-Seiryuu-]: and make the grace notes here 02:09:547 (129547|4,129578|3,129579|2) -
16:11 [-Seiryuu-]: r6
16:11 [-Seiryuu-]: f6*
16:12 Candice: i know but
16:12 Candice: how add inherent poimnt
16:12 [-Seiryuu-]: the + sign
16:12 Candice: like specify where to start the speed
16:12 [-Seiryuu-]: oh
16:13 [-Seiryuu-]: go to the place where the speed change is
16:13 [-Seiryuu-]: there should be a (use current time)
16:13 [-Seiryuu-]: under the offset
16:14 Candice: ok done
16:14 [-Seiryuu-]: 02:15:329 - LN here
16:15 Candice: done
16:15 [-Seiryuu-]: just one last thing
16:15 [-Seiryuu-]: trying to find the part brb
16:16 [-Seiryuu-]: 01:00:485 (60485|4,60516|5,60579|6) - this grace note looks weird :/
16:16 [-Seiryuu-]: but nvm
16:19 [-Seiryuu-]: well nevermind i can't find it
16:19 [-Seiryuu-]: just try to make the grace notes play out at smoothly as possible
16:19 [-Seiryuu-]: i'll just savelog this and post in on the thread

Good luck.
Candy-Sama
SV's way too sudden, try to make the impact less sudden by putting 0.8x, 0.6x then 0.5x.
OMEGAffection
ingame MOD
but, closed chat TAB :?

--my modding--
slip notes
strong sound point
Change biased placement
change to 1/12 stairs...etc

sorry 1diff easy modding
good luck ;)
Aeven
Good map :)

I think you should change Overall Difficulty (Piano Concerto No.8 OD8→OD7 or 6)

Because your map is using mostly holds

https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Osu!mania_Ranking_Criteria
Guidelines :Overall Difficulty should be:
9-10 when using mainly notes and just a few amount of holds
7-8 when using a mix a balanced notes and holds
5-6 when using mostly holds

I'm sorry I can't give you very good advice.

Good luck ;)
- Veritica -
Hi ~ :)

General
go to Aimod and check = Ctrl + Shift + A

Song Setup > Design > Uncheck :
Widescreen Support ( This is for storyboard only ) , Letterbox during breaks, Enable Countdown ( not allowed in mania mode )

Volume 2 % ? ( min 5 % )

For all diffs 01:51:579 - Go to Timing > Set current position as preview point

Beat Snap Divisor 1/16 ? :o 1/4 it's enough :D

Kiai's end unsnapped, how about 02:14:829 - End of kiai ? ( timing > Timing Setup Panel > Add Timing Section + go to Style > Uncheck kiai mode | for end of kiai | ) and go to timing 02:15:590 - Delete

Tags conflict with another diffs ( must be the same as another diffs )

Good Luck~ 8-)
Evening
hi some general stuff that i will point out since you asked me to

Suggested Stuff

Tags:

Remove final fantasy x-2 this is already in the source, don't need to repeat it twice
( the purpose is to help players find maps, repeating is not really necessary anyways )

Piano Grade No.1

HP : At least 7.0
OD : Seems fine for EZ

Piano Grade No.2

HP : At least 7.0
OD : Seems fine also

Piano Concerto No.8

HP : At least 7.0 but recommend this to be slightly higher like 7.5 or something
OD : Seems fine at 7.0

Really think you should check out AiMod also
CTRL + SHIFT + A in editor if you don't know

if anything doesn't really make sense in the AiMod just PM or something, i'll explain w
Nanatsu
offset 537 would be fine, 579 is a bit awkward.


to be honest, i can't catch what's meaning of your difficultys.

something like EZ,NM,HD would be better to other players to notice grade of your dificulty level. but it's up to you.


if you want to make ranked map, you need to make 3 diffs of "each key"

for example, if you make 4k, you should make 3 diffs of 4 key. no wonder, it's apply to 7 key setting.

so i can say that it's not completed map yet. but if you don't aiming ranked, there is no problem.

but if you don't aiming ranked map, moding request is kinda strange


for ranked map, i should say about one more thing. maps are must be hitsounded.

your map is not included hitsounded, so i suggest that you make hitsound.


don't use 02:15:590 kiai time, i suggest to use 02:15:579


Tags are different with other diffs, Audio Preview time is different with other diffs,

Countdown is different with other diffs, Letterbox in breakes are different with other diffs.


i'm not going to pattern mod, because the pattern of difficulty is almost same.. it would be too hard to mod.

column 1234567
[Piano Concentro No.8][/box]
00:03:037 (3037|5) - move to 7, i followed something 1/2 stair stream

00:09:579 (9579|4,9579|2) - move to 1,6

00:26:829 (26829|6) - move to 5

00:32:329 (32329|2,32579|3,32829|4) - move to left side, i mean. 2,3,4

00:36:797 (36797|0) - using 1/2 or 1/4 snap for here. then you can notice why i pointed out here.

00:47:329 (47329|2) - move to 1 or 2

00:53:829 (53829|2) - move to 2

00:58:079 - 00:58:829 - maybe you intended something impact on these parts. but, in other words, it seems like empty which left/right each side.

01:02:079 - 01:05:079 - i suggest you to use LN timing like here 00:48:579 - 00:52:329 -

because it feels more better to play. or you intended it because of 2 LN pattern? never mind if so.

01:06:079 - add LN 2 which is stop 01:06:579 - here

01:06:485 (66485|4,66516|5) - use 1/12 snap for here ( i even can't notice that this is reasonable snap for it. maybe overmapped )

01:08:047 (68047|5) - ^

01:11:579 (71579|5) - awkward. 1/12 could be better.

01:29:047 (89047|4) - up note to 01:29:079 -

02:03:516 (123516|5,123547|3) - ^^
MapleSyrup-
Hi~ Mod Queue :3

Please check the AIMod... :(
Please fix everything...

Columns
1|2|3|4

Piano Grade No.1
00:00:579 (579|2) - Move to 1
00:00:829 - add note to 2
00:01:579 (1579|1) - move to 4
00:03:579 (3579|2) - move to 1
00:04:579 (4579|1,4829|2) - Ctrl+H
00:07:579 (7579|1,7829|2) - ^
00:10:079 (10079|3,10329|0,10579|1) - ^
00:10:829 (10829|2) - Move to 1
00:12:329 (12329|1) - ^
00:13:579 (13579|1,13829|2) - Ctrl+H
00:16:829 (16829|2) - Move to 4
00:18:329 (18329|1) - Move to 1
00:48:579 (48579|2) - Delete?
00:50:079 (50079|1) - ^
00:51:579 - add note to 1
00:54:579 (54579|2) - Delete
00:56:079 (56079|1) - ^
01:10:079 - add note
01:10:829 - ^
01:11:579 - ^
01:25:829 (85829|0,85829|3) - delete one
01:25:829 (85829|3,85829|0) - add note
01:39:579 (99579|2) - delete?
01:42:329 (102329|3,102329|0) - delete one
01:51:579 (111579|1) - delete
01:53:079 (113079|2) - ^
01:57:579 (117579|2) - ^
01:59:079 (119079|2) - ^
01:59:079 (119079|2) - add note
02:24:579 (144579|0) - start from 02:24:829
the last 4 LN's should finish to 02:30:579

Piano Grade No.2
00:00:829 - add note to 3
00:49:079 (49079|0) - delete
00:49:329 (49329|3) - move to 1
00:50:579 (50579|3) - delete
00:51:829 (51829|2) - move to 00:51:579
00:55:079 (55079|3) - delete
00:56:579 (56579|0) - ^
01:01:079 (61079|3) - ^
01:02:579 (62579|0) - ^
01:03:329 (63329|1,63829|1,64079|2) - delete
01:04:829 (64829|2) - move to 01:05:079
from 01:09:579 to 01:11:329 - change to this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2378484
01:35:829 (95829|1,96079|2) - Ctrl+H then add note to 01:36:079
01:53:579 (113579|3) - ^^^^^
02:24:579 (144579|0) - Move to 02:24:829
the last 4 LN's should finish to 02:30:579

Piano Concerto No.8
Saw a few problems
Seems fine for me
(Also I can't mod 7K mod well :/ )
Enmi_old_1
Actually I love this song ;w;


Fix problems above.
And for "This mapset needs at least 1 easy/normal diff." I'm not sure this should be fixed cuz even though you make an easy/notmal diff, that warning will still appear. Just ignore this one.

P.S : Can I make a GD for this beatmap? :3
Vvn
i cant mod this map.. but, nice map.. i can learn LN pattern easier ( i still learn some LN pattern :D )
lapprand
I feel like there's a lack of changing in the ln's style, they're always the same long lasting notes. If your intention is to practice that kind of mapping then it's good. However it may get boring for people to play over and over. I also felt a bit of work on my left hand, that is good for practice, though I wouldn't do it over and over of course, I'm too lazy to practice. Also watch for that sv. Apart from that it's a good mapping, I wish it'd be more dificult but the song isn't that much of a help.
Bedrake
01:28:579 to 02:24:329 the long notes can be cut short
- Lacaille -
nice map~!! :) :)
BeAyWayYou
nice map :) feels like a real piano playing 8-)
gpdl
I think it's a little boring
SeikoNya
Passara
I feel like the mapping fits the song well, but I think that the SV changes happen to quickly. The SV changes do work well with the song once they have transitioned into the change, but the transitions feel way too rapid and are very difficult to predict and read. I also feel that the 4k versions are kind of boring, especially compared to the 7k ones, but I don't really see a way to fix that because of the speed of the song.
Soup
Piano Concerto No.8: Some of the denser chords during the end from 02:15:287 - 02:24:412 for me feels a bit awkward. It's completely my opinion though, I might just be bad :V. I also think the SV changes at 01:24:579 and 01:36:579 seem out of place with the music.

Also, I'm not sure if it's a bug or just me, but at 01:24:579 I noticed that it goes back to 4/4 on the timeline. :?
HOST_old
hi mod from pm req

u can ignore my mod if u think this is not pertinent.


column 1 / 2 / 3 / 4



all diffs end at 02:30:579

[(4K) Piano Grade No.1 - 4Key]

00:00:579 (579|2) - move 1
00:00:829 - add LN at 2, end 00:01:079

00:51:579 - add 1
00:57:579 - add 3
01:09:579 - add 3

01:53:079 (113079|2) - move 1
01:59:079 (119079|2) - move 2
02:11:079 (131079|2,131079|3) - move 1, 3
02:12:329 (132329|0) - move 4
02:12:579 (132579|2) - move 2

02:24:579 (144579|0,144579|3,145079|1,145329|2) - these LNs end 02:30:579



[]

column 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 / 5 / 6 / 7



[(7K) Piano Concerto No.5 - 7Key]


01:26:047 (86047|4) - move to 01:26:110

01:51:047 (111047|6) - remove

02:07:985 (127985|4) - move to 02:08:141
02:08:047 (128047|5) - move to 02:08:110



[(7K) Piano Concerto No.8 - 7Key]

00:09:579 (9579|6) - this LN end 00:13:579
00:13:829 (13829|5) - move 1

01:08:829 - add 7

02:07:297 (127297|6) - remove
02:07:360 - add 7
02:08:047 (128047|4) - remove
02:08:079 (128079|3) - remove
02:08:110 - add 4
02:08:141 - add 5
02:09:495 (129495|6) - move to 02:09:516


[]

good luck :3
RuberusuScarlet
please reed !
https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Kudosu



hi ~

from my queue

|1|2|3|4|

mod
[(4K) Piano Grade No.1]
HD6

00:24:579 - add 1 or 3
00:24:829 - ^2
00:26:079 - ^1 or 2
00:26:329 - ^3
00:27:579 - ^3
00:27:829 - ^1 or2
00:29:079 - ^1 or2
00:29:329 - ^3
00:30:829 - ^2
00:32:079 - ^2
00:32:329 - ^1
00:33:829 - ^1
00:35:079 - ^1
00:35:329 - ^4
00:36:829 - ^4
00:38:079 - ^4
00:38:329 - ^1
00:39:579 - ^1
00:39:829 - ^4
00:41:079 - ^4
00:41:329 - ^2
00:42:829 - ^4
00:44:079 - ^4
00:44:329 - ^3
00:45:829 - ^3
00:47:079 - ^3
00:47:329 - ^4

02:03:454 (123454|0,123516|1,123579|2) - I think it will be difficult to play for beginners
so…
02:03:454 (123454|0) - delete
02:03:516 (123516|1) - move to 02:03:579 -

02:09:454 (129454|0,129516|1,129579|2) - ^
good luck
Aste-
HI HI ~

MOD Ready ^.^

uhh.. please don't give kudosu to NON-Modder (Read the rules please T0T)

OK, for mod

Colum
1-2-3-4

General
WARNING!!!!
Open your AI MOD PLease

There's some inherited point that isn't snaped well ( 1ms unsnaped)

Sample Vol = 30 - 40 %
Grade 1
HP & OD = 7

00:00:860 add note on 1
00:01:079 (1079|3) - Move to 2
00:01:329 (1329|0,1579|1) - Move 2 column to right
00:02:079 (2079|1,2329|2) - Move to 1
00:02:579 (2579|0) - ^ 3
00:03:579 (3579|2) - ^ 1

01:29:079 (89079|1) - Add column 1
01:35:079 (95079|0) - ^ 4
02:03:579 (123579|2) - ^ 4
02:09:579 (129579|2) - ^ 4

02:24:579 (144579|3,144579|0,145079|1,145329|2) - End here => 02:31:079

Piano Grade 2
OD = 7

the chart seems Fine ~

Remember. Only give Kudosu to a modder , Not to GD or Comment

GL ^.^
AJIekceu
Hi
Minimod from message request

Crade 2
01:10:079 - add note
01:10:829 - ^
01:31:079 - ^
01:34:079 - ^ and so on at every loud sound

Great mapset. Wonderful song. I love it *o*

Sorry for bad mod, I lost modding skill .___.
Good luck
Topic Starter
Anole VX
All mods so far has been taken into consideration and maps of all diff has been greatly refined and updated.Thanks for the mods.

New mods are welcome :)

And ofcourse i will be more aware of giving kudosus from now on :)
- Yuuto -
Hi! Here are my mods as requested in my queue...

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

[General]
  1. Timing : Kiai needs end time point
  2. Background :Ok
  3. Metadata : delete Final Fantasy X-2 in (7K) Piano Concerto No.8 , since it has written on the source.
  4. Aimod : Too many conflicts, please balance the preview time and the source also the tags, you can check it by yourself (ctrl+shift+a)
[(7K) Piano Concerto No.8]
00:24:360 (24360|3) - wrong snaps. should be on 00:24:329
00:35:329 (35329|5) - move to 1
01:25:829 - I'd suggest you to add a note here. since the sound is same like 01:26:079 (86079|4,86079|3) -

  • 01:27:579 (87579|1) - delete
    or
    01:27:830 - 01:28:079 - 01:28:329 - add a long notes as well
01:26:079 (86079|0) - ends here 01:28:579 -
01:45:579 - add a note to 1 since the piano is pretty loud just like you did on 01:46:079 (106079|3,106079|5,106079|6)
02:25:079 (145079|4,145329|2) - I highly suggest you to lift down these to 02:26:329 - AND..
02:26:579 - since I heard a sound there add a long notes to 3 and 5 end at 02:30:579 -
02:24:829 (144829|6,145579|0,145829|5,146079|1) - end at 02:30:579 -

[(7K) Piano Concerto No.5]
00:14:079 (14079|2) - move to 2
00:24:829 (24829|1) - move to 6 so the right hand isn't that empty.
00:32:079 (32079|2) - move to 6
00:43:579 (43579|4) - move to 4
00:53:079 (53079|5,53079|2,53329|1,53329|4,53579|3,53579|5,53829|2,53829|4,54079|0,54079|3,54329|5,54329|2) - I don't think these should be 2 noted since you did add a notes with 1 notes in the previous and the next part one. Also I think the sounds maybe arn't that loud compared to 00:54:579 (54579|6,54579|3) - I'd suggest you to make those become one keypress note.
01:29:079 - I think you have to add a note to 1 since the sound is louder than 01:28:829 (88829|1,88829|6)
02:12:579 (132579|4) - move to 3 for the flows.
02:12:579 (132579|4) - I heard a piano, so I'd suggest you to add a note

[(4K) Piano Grade No.2]
00:30:329 - add to 3
00:52:079 - add note to 2
01:26:079 - I think one more note is fine, since the sound is quite similar to the previous one
01:33:579 - add note to 4 , loud piano
01:36:579 - add note, loud piano
02:00:829 (120829|0,121079|1) - I'd suggest you to ctrl + G this part since the sounds of 02:01:079 and - 02:01:329 - are same. It's totally fit to be jack'd
02:02:079 (122079|0) - move to 4, same reason as above
02:08:079 - add note to 4, pretty loud piano

[(4K) Piano Grade No.1]
00:17:079 (17079|2) - move to 4.
00:58:329 (58329|2) - move to 4, the sound or the pitch is same with the previous note
00:59:079 (59079|2) - move to 4, same reason
00:59:579 (59579|1) - move to 4, the pitch.
01:00:579 (60579|0) - move to 3
well the elses was balanced....

[Overall]
Very peaceful musics. I enjoyed the musics very much. Good luck

Oh for additionals :

Don't give kudosu to people who're shouldn't get it. You can only give the kudosu to the modders who have helping your maps. Just don't abuse them. https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Kudosu
Kurisu Makise
Hi! Just overall mod

(4K) Piano Grade No.2 - OD 7 (OD 6 is too low for normal difficulty)
(7K) Piano Concerto No.5 - OD 7, HP 7
(7K) Piano Concerto No.8 - OD 7, HP 8 (or OD 8, HP 8)

No kudosu, too little mod for that :D
MEGAtive
Hi
Mod requested from my queue

Note: Check AIMod to see is there any error in your map or not.

4K Piano Grade No.1
02:21:079 - Make the slider starts at 02:21:579 , and add notes At 02:21:079 instead
4K Piano Grade No.2
01:20:079 - Delete one of the slider, since it would make the chart inconsistent
7K Piano Grade No.5
No error found.
7K Piano Grade No.8
No error found.

Overall it's a good beatmap+good piano music. Good luck. :)
Topic Starter
Anole VX
thanks for the mod,i will change it tmr :)
edisk
7k Piano Concerto No.8

01:49:245 - 01:51:088
I think they should either be all long notes or normal ones. (The middle long note is fine to me though.)

02:19:370
The note placing seems weird to me.


EDIT: changed 01:50:745 to 01:51:088 . (forgot to edit it when I posted)
ArcherLove
hi collumn 1~7
02:27:579 - End of kiai please.

7K Piano 5

00:03:829 (3829|3,4079|2) - Ctrl G ?
00:04:829 (4829|3) - move to 2
00:05:579 (5579|1,5829|2) - move to 5-6 ?
00:06:829 (6829|3,7079|2,7329|1) - Ctrl G then 00:07:579 (7579|3) - move to 2 ?

7K Piano 8

nothing

good job
good luck!~
Blizs
Hi~~~
From Modding Queue :3
Column 4K : 1|2|3|4
Column 7K : 1|2|3|4|5|6|7


[(4K) Piano Grade No.1]
  1. 00:59:579 (59579|1) - maybe put at 4.
  2. 01:02:829 (62829|1) - put at 3.
  3. 01:03:579 (63579|3) - put at 1.
  4. 01:10:079 (70079|3,70329|2) - must be change the position :3
  5. 01:10:829 (70829|0) - put at 4.
  6. 01:11:829 (71829|3) - put at 1.
  7. 01:35:829 (95829|0,96079|1,96329|2) - I prefer not to using 1/2 repeated long notes in Easy. change it to single notes.
  8. 02:00:329 (120329|0) - put at 2.
  9. 02:00:579 (120579|3) - put at 1.
  10. 02:07:829 (127829|3) - ^^
  11. 02:12:329 (132329|0) - put at 3.
  12. 02:13:079 (133079|3) - ^^
  13. 02:13:829 (133829|1,134079|2) - must be change the position :3
  14. 02:14:579 (134579|0) - put at 3.
  15. 02:14:829 (134829|3) - put at 1.
[(7K) Piano Concerto No.5]
  1. 01:00:454 (60454|5,60516|3,60579|6,60579|1,60579|0) - I'm a bit confused here as a normal diff. Try to move 01:00:454 (60454|5) to 3 and 01:00:579 (60579|0,60579|1) - to 5 & 6
  2. 01:05:016 (65016|3,65047|4) - I prefer to remove this two
  3. 02:05:047 (125047|4) - I prefer to remove this
  4. 02:07:995 (127995|4,128037|5) - ^^
  5. 02:11:047 (131047|1) - ^^
[(4K) Piano Grade No.2]
  1. 01:49:891 (109891|1,110391|3,110891|2,111047|1) - uh oh.... you miss the 1/3 there
  2. 02:03:485 (123485|1) - oops.. you missed again...
  3. 02:09:485 (129485|1,129547|0) - again...
[(7K) Piano Concerto No.8]
  1. 01:06:454 (66454|3,66495|4,66537|5,66579|6) - I prefer to use 1/8 here not 1/12
  2. 01:26:079 (86079|0) - make the long note end at 01:28:579
  3. 01:28:579 (88579|3) - This long note must be start at 01:29:079
  4. ^ If OK add 1/2 long note at 01:28:579 and 01:28:829
  5. 01:49:079 (109079|0,109735|1,110735|4,110922|5) - I prefer not to use long notes here. Enough with 1 long note in the middle.
OK That's all I can mod :3
and thanks for use my new queue XD
Takane6
Hi from queue :D

Column
1 2 3 4
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

(4K) Piano Grade No.1
Check AI mod :3
00:00:829 (829|0) - delete note
01:14:079 - 01:24:579 - try to not make the notes in same place :3 even it has a same sound
01:42:329 - delete one note
02:24:329 (144329|0) - move to 3
02:24:579 (144579|2) - delete

(7K) Piano Concerto No.5
00:53:329 (53329|4,53829|2) - delete?
01:02:016 (62016|0) - delete
02:17:829 (137829|2) - move to 02:18:329
02:22:829 - add note for consistency
02:24:579 (144579|6,144579|3,144579|0) - maybe the LN end at 02:28:579

(4K) Piano Grade No.2
00:23:079 (23079|3) - change to normal note
00:51:829 (51829|2) - delete
01:11:329 (71329|0) - move to 3
01:11:579 (71579|2) - move to 1
01:15:579 - add note for consistency
01:17:079 - ^
01:36:579 - ^
02:03:485 (123485|1,123516|2,123579|3) - use 1/12 maybe?
02:11:360 (131360|0) - 1/4?

(7K) Piano Concerto No.8
01:24:579 - too strong for 6 note ( delete 2 note )
01:01:079 - too strong for 5 note ( delete 1 note )
I think its good for me :D

I almost fall asleep when mod this mapset xD
im thinking that this map will be more better if you add piano sound inside :D
Arzenvald
dont kudos
quick review
hmm weird diff spread

4K | Easy > Normal // rankable
7K | Normal > Hard // where is easy? this possibly unrankable because you need to make a 7K easy.. and the 7K normal is over 2.00 stars
i aware about the diff spread, consult to BAT / QAT about this... ==a
Kruzon
Hi, sorry for late mod ;w;

My 7k Column Format: 1 l 2 l 3 l 4 l 5 l 6 l 7
I will only mod 7K Piano Concerto Lv.8

Piano Concerto Level 8
SPOILER
Umm.. This is hard right? if this is Hard then apply my mods, however if otherwise ignore them
This is more like an Insane or Hard++ difficulty due to overchord+ noodles = et = eradicate non-et

00:06:579 (6579|4) - the sound not suppose to be that loud, delete this
00:07:079 (7079|3,7329|2) - move them to column 4 and 5
00:12:579 (12579|4) - delete (you can put this as pressure note on insane)
00:21:079 (21079|0,21079|5,21329|1,21329|6) - Ctrl + J
00:21:579 (21579|0,21829|1) - Ctrl + J as well
00:49:079 (49079|5,49079|2) - delete.. too stronk for hard lol
00:50:829 (50829|4) - delete
00:51:329 (51329|6) - move to 6
00:51:579 (51579|4) - move to 6 (now this fit with jacks)
00:51:579 (51579|1) - move to 1 yeah same reason
00:51:829 (51829|2) - move to 2
00:51:829 (51829|6) - move to 5
00:52:079 (52079|5) - move to 7
00:52:329 (52329|3) - delete
00:56:579 (56579|6) - delete @_@
00:56:829 (56829|2) - kinda awkward to press, i suggest move to 5
00:58:079 (58079|2,58329|2) - seriously, delete them
00:58:329 (58329|6) - add a note on 7
00:58:329 (58329|0) - hmm delete as well, it lose its meaning lol
00:59:079 (59079|6,59079|4) - delete them, and add a note on 1
00:59:579 (59579|6) - what is this for?
01:00:495 (60495|4,60537|5,60579|6) - splendid c:
01:00:579 (60579|1) - hmm delete
01:01:079 (61079|4,61079|1) - delete them
01:02:079 (62079|3) - delete
01:02:579 (62579|6,62829|6,63079|6) - this jacks are unnecessary, perhaps delete 01:02:829 (62829|6) -
01:03:829 (63829|1) - delete so this empty gap between 01:02:579 (62579|6,63079|6) - has meaning, considering a pattern
01:08:329 (68329|4) - move to 7
01:08:579 (68579|1,68579|6,68829|1,69079|4) - walao, delete them haha
01:15:829 (75829|1,76579|1,76579|3,76579|4,76579|6) - do you have any idea how hard this to press especially holding 2 notes
01:46:829 (106829|5,106829|1) - move them to 1 and 7 respectively to emphasizes same sound played atm
01:46:579 (106579|6,107329|1) - delete i suppose, they don't have meaning yet you can put 1 note but not here
01:47:829 (107829|5) - i dont understand this long note exist for what
01:49:735 (109735|1) - you might want to break this long notes into half and spread em apart (or rather, place them in ascending order), coz unless you do so, it aint got meaning OR just make them a single note instead, this is waaaayy better
01:50:735 (110735|4,110922|5) - this also, single note is better
umm it's tough road ahead the remaining map but i guess you get the picture already why i asked you to delete some note, I'll leave the rest in your hands
This is quite good, only if you changed the tag to insane. The pattern is well placed as well, fitting along the piano pieces. But since this is hard(?) you gotta nerf them m8

- Good luck with your map c:
Deep Sea
Hello Candice
mod ready

[General]
Check AiMod
Unrakable mapset

[(4K) Piano Grade No.1]

00:00:829 (829|1) - delete
00:00:829 (829|0) - move to 2
00:17:079 (17079|2) - move to 4
00:18:579 (18579|1) - move to 1
01:24:079 - add note to 3
01:43:579 (103579|1) - move to 4
02:24:579 (144579|0,144579|3,145079|1,145329|2) - end this LNs here

Good luck and Merry Christmas !!! :oops:
Fuuyu
Oss~ From modding queue, wrapping up things now

So, I'll just be modding No. 1, 5 and 2

Before I start you would want to change your diff name or just erase the " (4K) and (7K) " cause it's already written at the side of the diff name.

Garou Mod
Column : |0|1|2|3|4|5|6|


Piano Concerto No. 1


01:13:329 (73329|3) - Move to 2

01:13:579 (73579|2) - Move to 3

01:13:829 (73829|1) - Move to 2

01:24:579 (84579|2) - Move to 0

01:34:829 (94829|3) - Move to 2

02:12:579 (132579|1) - Move to 3

02:13:329 (133329|2) - Move to 0

02:13:829 (133829|1) - Move to 3

02:14:579 (134579|0) - Move to 1

02:14:829 (134829|3) - Move to 0

What I was doing here was acutally follow it's pitch that why i suggested to move some notes

Piano Conerto No. 5


I'm gonna try to make some patterns.

00:31:579 (31579|4) - Move to 5

01:18:079 (78079|1) - Move to 0

01:18:079 - Then add another note at 2

01:19:579 (79579|1) - Move to 0

01:19:829 (79829|2) - Move to 1

01:54:329 (114329|4) - Move to 6

01:54:329 (114329|1) - Move to 0

01:54:579 (114579|6) - Move to 5

01:54:579 (114579|0) - Move to 1

02:02:329 (122329|0) - Move to 1

02:19:579 (139579|2) - Move to 4

02:19:829 (139829|4) - Move to 3

Piano Concerto No. 2


00:03:329 (3329|3) - Move to 2

00:14:079 (14079|1) - Move to 0

00:14:579 (14579|3) - Move to 1

00:14:829 (14829|0) - Move to 3

00:15:079 (15079|3,15079|2,15329|0,15329|1) - Ctrl +J

00:25:329 (25329|2) - Move to 1

00:25:579 (25579|1) - Move to 2

00:25:829 (25829|2) - Move to 1

00:28:579 (28579|1) - Move to 0

00:28:829 (28829|0) - Move to 1

00:35:047 (35047|3) - ? > Move to 00:35:079

00:38:579 (38579|2) - Move to 3

00:38:829 (38829|3) - Move to 2

00:39:079 (39079|2) - Move to 3

00:39:329 (39329|3) - Move to 2

00:40:579 (40579|2) - Move to 1

00:40:829 (40829|1) - Move to 2

00:49:329 (49329|0) - Move to 3

00:52:579 - Add a LN here that ends here 00:52:829 - Then add a note at 1

01:12:082 - Add a note at 0 ( Yo can still hear the piano here )

01:12:329 - Add a note at 3 ( Here too )

01:37:579 (97579|2,97829|0) - Ctrl + J

01:38:079 (98079|2) - Move to 3

01:38:329 (98329|3,98579|2,98829|0) - Ctrl + J

01:39:079 (99079|2) - Move to 0

01:42:829 - Add a note at 3

02:09:454 (129454|2) - Move to 02:09:516

02:09:485 (129485|1) - Move to 02:09:547

02:09:547 (129547|0) - Move to 02:09:579

02:15:079 - Add a LN here that ends here 02:15:579 - at Column 2

02:15:329 (135329|0) - Instead of starting the LN here why not start it here? -> 02:15:579 - same end

Naturally the LN follows another beat like a hum or the singer maybe but it's up to the mapper in the end. That's all, Good Luck!
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply