Unknown Artist - Onna no ko no Skirt ga Totsuzen Mekuretari · forum

Stefan

Global Moderator

Joined January 2011

Stefan 2014-11-03T18:29:47+00:00

So "acane_madder" has been mentioned as composer of the lyrics and the music:

that actually makes it acceptable enough as Artist.

Megurine Luka wrote:
Acane_madder is the composer of the original song. And the singer of this version named it as "Anonymous", I think it would be fine if we keep it. Diff name is basically due to the title. But I would change it.

We had a similar case on p/2571141

Mao

Elite Mapper II

2,963 posts

Joined December 2012

Mao 2014-11-03T18:37:00+00:00

Also is Unknown Artist really appropriate if you can at least find something that relates to the current version?
For "Alle meine Entchen" it was the case that there was literally nothing know about neither the composer nor the vocalist of that version.

Sey

1,406 posts

Joined October 2010

Sey 2014-11-03T19:03:31+00:00

At least an artist is given here from the original song. In "Alle meine Entchen" we had an utterly exception which normally should be avoided whenever it's possible. There was not even any evidence for the artist of the original song, but it's definitely given in this song.

Shohei Ohtani

Shohei Ohtani 2014-11-03T21:20:43+00:00

hahahah wow look at that, everyone who didn't touch this map for 2 months decided to come out and finally get mad about it once it got ranked

hahahah man wouldn't that have been cool the 2 months this sat bubbled with no posts

Sey

1,406 posts

Joined October 2010

Sey 2014-11-03T21:43:24+00:00

CDFA wrote:
hahahah wow look at that, everyone who didn't touch this map for 2 months decided to come out and finally get mad about it once it got ranked

hahahah man wouldn't that have been cool the 2 months this sat bubbled with no posts

We're a team. Instead of blaming others you better should see that as some constructive feedback to improve the mapset and doing it better next time. Be that as it may, let us just wait for some BATm's or QAT's response and see what they are thinking instead of starting any pointless quarrel here.

Shohei Ohtani

Shohei Ohtani 2014-11-03T21:58:36+00:00

I'm. . . I'm not blaming anyone for anything?

I'm saying that this map sat in pending for 2 months without any input, and once it was ranked, input started coming in, so now what's probably going to happen is that this map will get unranked and there will be a lot of pointless arguing over the rule and stuff which could have been done beforehand with a lot less drama.

I know that the BAT is a team, so I consulted QATs about this issue and they said it was fine, but to use "Unknown Artist".

Instead of viewing my post as an attack, you "better should see" that as a reminder to put in some initiative to actually get issues like this done DURING the ranking process if you see any sort of oddity rather than doing it afterward.

Megurine Luka

2,579 posts

Joined November 2010

Topic Starter

Megurine Luka 2014-11-04T06:14:58+00:00

Dear all, unknown artist does not have any problem in this case. Due to the singer himself choose to hide his name, I would be appreciate if you guys follow his idea.
The person who post this video said "代投本家：sm20136093。原作者匿名" which means "Post this video for the singer. Original song: smxxxxxxx. The singer is anonymity."
Therefore I don't really think unknown artist is a problem.

Thanks CDFA, for all these things.

Stefan

Global Moderator

10,393 posts

Joined January 2011

Stefan 2014-11-04T09:19:15+00:00

CDFA: I think you're getting the initiative wrong. There is no fault by anyone but to clarify if that even looks legit as option should be done. Qualified section in a nutshell.

Can we just consult some chinese/japanese speaking BAT/QAT member(s)?

wcx19911123

3,862 posts

Joined June 2010

wcx19911123 2014-11-04T09:41:55+00:00

I'm here to explain sth

the song is not the original version, it's sang by an anonymous singer. the song was released the first time in here, a website like niconico.jp

for cover songs, actually we should write the name of the singer as artist, not the original composer or anything else. in this special case, I think it's better for us to keep the anonymous artist, it's the only homage we can do for the singer

Zero__wind

osu! Alumni

3,314 posts

Joined August 2012

Zero__wind 2014-11-04T10:01:55+00:00

So here comes a chinese speaking member
I'm fine with "Unknown Artist" in this case as long as it's better than "Anonymous"
and CDFA claimed that this is already decided after discussion with QAT members
while the video(song) uploader on bilibili stated clearly "原作者匿名" which means the original artist is anonymous
I don't think you guys need to be so concerned

Sey

1,406 posts

Joined October 2010

Sey 2014-11-04T10:15:08+00:00

Zero__wind wrote:
I don't think you guys need to be so concerned

I was going to ask a BATm about this but nvm then. Anyways, being concerned is absolutely okay here and it's good seeing people willed to clarify things up before it's too late for that. Doesn't really matter if they can be proven wrong or not. And EVEN IF CDFA clarified it with QATs they also can do mistakes, so good that we talked about it.

Stefan

Global Moderator

10,393 posts

Joined January 2011

Stefan 2014-11-04T11:28:58+00:00

Well, thinking that the creator can also work as artist but I guess we stay in wcx and Zero__Wind's posts. Hopefully this doesn't become to a trend.

Congrats

Rakuen

1,654 posts

Joined March 2013

Rakuen 2014-11-04T11:57:07+00:00