Sulker wrote:

Senritsu wrote:

Twin got his first rank gratzz /o/ tumpeng
rank moar map plx

Stop about the title guys. Just let QAT handle things from here, and once it's decided, then that's what's going to be.

Had to take a double take thinking I thought you was the mapper lol...
Name are too similarly spelt...

Zero__wind wrote:

Sorry if I seem nosy but I have to say I find 00:20:271 (1,2,3,4) - in Liar diff pretty unfitting
1/2 snap for this point like matches the song much better

Zero__wind wrote:

Sorry if I seem nosy but I have to say I find 00:20:271 (1,2,3,4) - in Liar diff pretty unfitting
1/2 snap for this point like matches the song much better

some other questionable points exist, such as overmapping at 00:30:937 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) -
and inconsistency between 00:23:437 (2,3) - (following drum) and 00:33:604 (1,1) - (following vocal)
but not so important as the wrong snap at 00:20:382 (2,3) -

What do you think

Oyatsu wrote:

If you did change, the QAT will unrank this, and you fix it. Then you need to find another BAT or is also BAT who bubbled your map to rebb or straightly rerank if it is allowed, depend on BAT

Zero__wind wrote:

irc rechecked
Rebubbled.

log

19:58 Setsurei: hi Zero__wind owo/
19:58 Setsurei: do you have time to check back?
20:00 Zero__wind: oh ok
20:00 Zero__wind: let me redownload
20:00 Setsurei: alright :3
20:19 Zero__wind: checked through, a few more to say
20:19 *Zero__wind is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/520660 Mayama Rika - Liar Mask anime size [Hard]]
20:19 *Setsurei is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/520660 Mayama Rika - Liar Mask anime size [Hard]]
20:19 Zero__wind: 00:12:862 (1) -
20:19 Zero__wind: the recovery time after this is a bit shorter than required
20:20 Setsurei: Natsu said it's ok with Hard
20:20 Zero__wind: spinners in Hard diffs should have a recovery time of a whole beat
20:20 Setsurei: it was before at 00:12:862 (1) -
20:20 Setsurei: 00:14:262 -
20:20 Setsurei: should I move it back there?
20:20 Zero__wind: yes I suggest you get it back to 00:14:462 - or 00:14:262 -
20:21 Setsurei: 00:14:462 - I'll move here then
20:21 Zero__wind: I personally pfefer 462
20:22 Setsurei: no need for hitsound at end?
20:22 Zero__wind: no
20:22 Setsurei: ok
20:22 Zero__wind: it's just actually thse end of the sound which started from 00:12:662 -
20:23 Zero__wind: and that's all for Hard
20:23 *Zero__wind is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/520475 Mayama Rika - Liar Mask anime size [Liar]]
20:23 *Setsurei is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/520475 Mayama Rika - Liar Mask anime size [Liar]]
20:23 Zero__wind: 00:33:604 (1) - I suggest that you end this at 00:34:049 - instead
20:24 Zero__wind: to be consistent with 00:23:437 (2) -
20:24 Zero__wind: so they both follow the drum
20:24 Setsurei: 00:34:104 - empty?
20:24 Zero__wind: yes
20:24 Setsurei: ok
20:25 Zero__wind: it actually plays pretty similar
20:25 Setsurei: should I move the green line too?
20:25 Setsurei: 00:34:104 - this green
20:25 Setsurei: 00:34:049 - to here
20:25 Zero__wind: ah yes
20:25 Setsurei: ok
20:26 Zero__wind: doesn't really matter though
20:26 Setsurei: well yea there's no object there
20:26 Zero__wind: one last thing about 01:24:436 (5,1) -
20:26 Zero__wind: spacing being too small
20:27 Zero__wind: it's really easily misread as 1/2 jump
20:27 Setsurei: prefer 1.5 or 2.0?
20:27 Zero__wind: no need to that much
20:27 Setsurei: 1.2?
20:27 Zero__wind: but at least bigger than 1.0
20:28 Zero__wind: yeah, that may be good
20:28 Setsurei: ok
20:28 Zero__wind: 1.2 should do
20:29 Setsurei: http://puu.sh/cEajB.jpg ?
20:29 Setsurei: that's 1.25 between 01:24:436 (5,1) -
20:30 Zero__wind: moved 01:24:269 (4,5) - ?
20:30 Setsurei: yeah, I rotate them with 3 too
20:31 Setsurei: because that's a triangle
20:31 Zero__wind: good
20:31 Zero__wind: ok I think that's all
20:31 Zero__wind: update then
20:32 Setsurei: alright
20:39 Setsurei: updated
20:39 Zero__wind: k

1. Think about dropping OD by 1 since the rhythm has some 3/2 gaps and the timing is changeable.
2. 00:22:937 (3) - I'd say that you've missed a new combo here. Rest of combos are shorter than this one.
3. 00:53:603 (3,1) - this is too tricky for the easiest diff. Consider avoiding this stack and doing something more understandable here. Example
4. 01:13:936 (4) - have you missed a new combo here? Feels like you did.
5. 01:25:603 (3) - and maybe one more NC here. The reason why should be pretty obvious.

1. 00:12:662 (5) - The spinner is too short for a Normal diff, as it is. remove the circle and start spinner at 00:12:662.
2. 00:40:937 (3) - the downbeat remains unstressed, which feels sorta tricky to play. I suggest to use rhythm like this. Basically, the main problem is that the strong beat isn't clickable.
   Note: 00:42:770 (2,3,4) - same. One more example. and 00:45:937 (4,1,2) - here. Example

1. 01:03:769 (1,2,3) - this is the only triplet in the whole diff. Consider replacing it with repeated 1/4 slider to keep the diff more playable and consistent.

1. 01:09:102 (5) - this one gets overlapped with scores/accuracy example. Not a big deal, but, uhhh.. a little fix like [http://puu.sh/cEcmx.jpg this] wouldn't hurt.

-Bakari- wrote:

Okay, so, everything looks fine to me. The main issues are gone, so, I think we are ready to go.

Re-qualified!

Sakura wrote:

Re-congratz Setsurei

Sakura wrote:

Re-congratz Setsurei

Sakura wrote:

Re-congratz Setsurei

buny wrote:

is anime size actually part of the song name, or is it just formatted badly?