forum

osu! idol (Final Round - Complete!)

posted
Total Posts
1,032
show more
Flanster

LuCy200131 wrote:

when the osu Idol! begning and what is the orize for top3
It has already begun, please read the opening post first, as for the prizes, I have no idea really, personally im planning to give a 3 month supporter tag to the winner.
Hard

ziin wrote:

Very disappointing all around :(.

ar·bi·trar·y
adjective
based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system.

If there are no visible comments, it really seems arbitrary (and there are no visible comments in the first post).
you barely didn't make it because you fluked many notes. Some of your tones are really good but then again you often sing like one halftone to high. And when you get in the highs it's really off. It seems that this song wasn't really in your range. Maybe next time you shold use some song that compliments you and isn't as difficult as kiss from a rose. I've seen the comments of the judges and it's just that you're a bit too late to look at them.
They've propably been deleted or something before you've been able to take a look or something like this.
But I still think it's mean of you to say that the judges decided arbitary. It's not like this and you should be a good sportsman, wish good luck to the others and practise your singing. Then you can try again next time.
CoolshadowFNG

Hard wrote:

ziin wrote:

Very disappointing all around :(.

ar·bi·trar·y
adjective
based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system.

If there are no visible comments, it really seems arbitrary (and there are no visible comments in the first post).
you barely didn't make it because you fluked many notes. Some of your tones are really good but then again you often sing like one halftone to high. And when you get in the highs it's really off. It seems that this song wasn't really in your range. Maybe next time you shold use some song that compliments you and isn't as difficult as kiss from a rose. I've seen the comments of the judges and it's just that you're a bit too late to look at them.
They've propably been deleted or something before you've been able to take a look or something like this.
But I still think it's mean of you to say that the judges decided arbitary. It's not like this and you should be a good sportsman, wish good luck to the others and practise your singing. Then you can try again next time.
Very well put, Hard. Remember that constructive criticism is the key to allow us to become better vocalists. I very much doubt the judges would just something arbitrarily, as I listened to almost every entry in that first round, and credit was given where it was due. If I were in the same situation, I would just wish everyone else good luck and try my best to improve for next time, which I'm still doing regardless of getting through.

There ain't no rest for the wicked.
ziin

Hard wrote:

it's just that you're a bit too late to look at them.
This is what I'm complaining about.
CoolshadowFNG

ziin wrote:

Hard wrote:

it's just that you're a bit too late to look at them.
This is what I'm complaining about.
Actually, you're not too late, but if you really want the comments, here they are:

shARPii - "Not really accurate at the beginning but the end is really better! You've the voice, be careful and train your voice a little before recording the real entry ^^"

Kitokofox - "You started out a little off, but you fixed it a little getting closer to the later parts of the song. Try practicing a bit more to strengthen your tone accuracy. Your voice sounds able to handle heavy notes, so don't go lightly on that fact. :)"
CoolshadowFNG
OMG YEALINA BROUGHT HER A-GAME TO THIS ROUND. BEAUTIFUL COVER.
Nepeta Leijon
Welp looks like I'm gonna fail this round
Marcin

ziin wrote:

Very disappointing all around :(.

ar·bi·trar·y
adjective
based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system.

If there are no visible comments, it really seems arbitrary (and there are no visible comments in the first post).
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... 1519288254
check here
Aleks719

ziin wrote:

If it will make you feel better i like your singing, but i'm not a judge, so...
Topic Starter
ztrot
supporter is the prizes for the top 3 I could of sworn it was announced, also we might map the winners cover :U
Flanster

ztrot wrote:

supporter is the prizes for the top 3 I could of sworn it was announced, also we might map the winners cover :U
That'll be fun lmao.
LightDreamer
I really need to know if pop ballads are allowed.... Are they?
Thanks
Flanster

LightDreamer wrote:

I really need to know if pop ballads are allowed.... Are they?
Thanks
Should be fine, go for it.
LightDreamer

LoliFlan wrote:

LightDreamer wrote:

I really need to know if pop ballads are allowed.... Are they?
Thanks
Should be fine, go for it.
Thanks again, Nya~
VirusZeke
i am sick this week--.. got a really high fever and.... my cover was...... uhh XD dunno how to tell----

http://puu.sh/bNw2K/6971b2aa42.mp3

*flails*

i'm scared---- that i will failzz
*eat a lot of pills , cough , flip self to bed*
VirusZeke

LoliFlan wrote:

ztrot wrote:

supporter is the prizes for the top 3 I could of sworn it was announced, also we might map the winners cover :U
That'll be fun lmao.

i really need a tabby or cash as prize pft :v
well--
map the winners cover ?

*HYPER MODE ON*
MissTitannia
If I am not sure if a song fits in pop category, can I PM the judges or post it here so one of judges can tell me? :)
Flanster

MissTitannia wrote:

If I am not sure if a song fits in pop category, can I PM the judges or post it here so one of judges can tell me? :)
You can go ahead and post here.
MissTitannia
Flanster

MissTitannia wrote:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eXrR9yvBM4s ? :)
Don't really know what I can categorise this as but it is not pop.
MissTitannia
Ohh okayy T.T I didn't know to categorize it either xD
Coro
I guess I might as well check too, just to be safe

Is this pop?
http://youtu.be/4NShEKYoPXw
CoolshadowFNG
Just putting a point across here.

J-techno should be counted. Only My Railgun is J-techno by ear, but is officially classed as J-pop, so please make a clear judgement on whether or not stuff such as J-techno counts.
Nepeta Leijon

CoroQuetz wrote:

I guess I might as well check too, just to be safe

Is this pop?
http://youtu.be/4NShEKYoPXw
That's one of my favourite songs! And yeah, I think this should be classed as pop.
Garven
Most deco27 stuff is more rock than pop. Save it for the next round!
jazzy9875x
Only 37 out of 79 made the second round? so 42 people got kicked, that's allot e.e
CoolshadowFNG

jazzy9875x wrote:

Only 37 out of 79 made the second round? :o
Yeah, which kind of worries me for this round. Each time, we'll have to impress the judges even more than the last time.

In case you couldn't tell, I'm positively terrified of falling at the hurdle here.

Hence why I'm planning an entry to really impress people.
LightDreamer
Maybe I'm crazy.... I will sing Glowstone Love!

It's a soft pop song with piano almost all the time, but it ends with true pop style. I think it fits my voice really well.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WXaPv0oIBLw

Edit: Dammit, I hate to change the pitch
ziin

Marcin wrote:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XEL-Zb_ldV0l4jpv7IAWzER-LV-uoo9pE2nIb7PI23Y/edit#gid=1519288254
check here
This should either be in the first post, or you should put the comments in a cell so it doesn't cause issues.
yealina

CoolshadowFNG wrote:

OMG YEALINA BROUGHT HER A-GAME TO THIS ROUND. BEAUTIFUL COVER.
ttttttttttttttthx >w<

ziin wrote:

This should either be in the first post, or you should put the comments in a cell so it doesn't cause issues.
atcully you can delect the words from "/pubhtml" to the last in the first post URL for details
Coro
Umm how about this then

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_4BLiOP1aaY
Is this pop? (Actually quite a bit of soft rock can be considered pop right?)
If this isn't considered pop, what sort of song am I looking for?
LightDreamer
I did it.... Now I'm so nervous that I won't sleep...

I sound like a little girl
shARPII

LightDreamer wrote:

I did it.... Now I'm so nervous that I won't sleep...

I sound like a little girl
You cute litt *slapped*

CoolshadowFNG wrote:

Yeah, which kind of worries me for this round. Each time, we'll have to impress the judges even more than the last time.

In case you couldn't tell, I'm positively terrified of falling at the hurdle here.

Hence why I'm planning an entry to really impress people.
dem song.
Hard
is this pop?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=25-lY12SyJY

This really fits my voice. I am a girl and can't sing girl songs, which is a bit sad.
CoolshadowFNG

shARPII wrote:

CoolshadowFNG wrote:

Yeah, which kind of worries me for this round. Each time, we'll have to impress the judges even more than the last time.

In case you couldn't tell, I'm positively terrified of falling at the hurdle here.

Hence why I'm planning an entry to really impress people.
dem song.
Exactly. It's a very audacious entry, but one I can't really avoid doing.
CoolshadowFNG

LightDreamer wrote:

I did it.... Now I'm so nervous that I won't sleep...

I sound like a little girl
Interesting choice. I looked at a lot of their songs as reference for this round, too.
Flanster
Keep em coming, the sooner all entries are submitted, the sooner we can judge them!
LightDreamer

shARPII wrote:

LightDreamer wrote:

I did it.... Now I'm so nervous that I won't sleep...

I sound like a little girl
You cute litt *slapped*.
Thank you for the good comments!

*gros câlin*
Topic Starter
ztrot
if you are worried about what is pop or not send a pm to any of the judges or myself we will clear that up asap.
LuCy200131

ztrot wrote:

supporter is the prizes for the top 3 I could of sworn it was announced, also we might map the winners cover :U
Nice
but i am have propleom
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply