NoHitter wrote:

Frostings wrote:

I wanted to PL Sona D1 because his usual town behavior hurts town later in the game

This is a big ping. You would choose to lynch a townie even after knowing he's a townie? Hurts town "later in the game" is irrelevant if you lynch scum in the first place.

Gumica wrote:

Also I've been rereading ISO's for the past hour (except Setsuen's, cause fuck that) and I really have to say that between all of the lurking and other accusations here, Frostings has just pulled the most scum-like post for my taste.
@Frostings; One shouldn't Policy Lynch out of that kind of idea. That's like saying we always have to PL Setsuen on D1 for retarded walling. Nobody likes it, but it's not an argument for a lynch. Thus your lynch on Sonatora is without any legitimacy. Using Self-vote for the excuse to retain your vote on him till, isn't really acceptable. Do you have any other valid reasons for your vote, or is it plainly Policy Lynch based?

Gumica wrote:

Same as with Frostings, Navizel. You've got no superhuman abilities to the future.

Raging Bull wrote:

Im surprised you want to lynch town than push for one of your null scum read.

Raging Bull wrote:

Navizel wrote:

Just a question, would you guys want BRBP to be alive and screw town later or kill him before he lays his eggs?

Idk hows that related. Does that mean you want to PL Sonatora? Cause it seems that way. FOS Navizel

DakeDekaane wrote:

Thinking it better, I can also ride the Frostings bandwagon /o/

Raging Bull wrote:

Frostings wrote:

I have no good reason to unvote him yet

I wanted to PL Sona D1 because his usual town behavior hurts town later in the game

Going back on this, it seems like you know hes town already

Gumica wrote:

Your past games aren't basis for your vote. I won't accept the reason for vote a past game.
As for the Sonatora, he stopped that behaviour. People stopped suspecting Sephibro/Drezi, when he stopped lurking, so...

Setsuen wrote:

Gumica wrote:

Your past games aren't basis for your vote. I won't accept the reason for vote a past game.
As for the Sonatora, he stopped that behaviour. People stopped suspecting Sephibro/Drezi, when he stopped lurking, so...

I hope some town remember that newbie mafia where Nav+Cts won as scum bc Cth avoided the lynch D1............
Stopping behaviour =/= not scum in fact, I would suspect them more until they prove that they can hold that behaviour for a VERY LONG TIME.

Raging Bull wrote:

Im not PLing someone who already improved their behavior.

Sonatora wrote:

I'm not trolling there.

I really wanted to get lynched off but I have to fix this clusterfuck first

Frostings wrote:

Please congratulate me

Setsuen wrote:

tn5421 wrote:

Or people that are posting even less than me.

You post less. Push attention to people who post lesser than you. Diversion much. For info posting less and pushing attention to other people who post less is scummy while posting a lot and pushing attention who post less is neutral.

Frostings wrote:

NoHitter wrote:

This is a big ping. You would choose to lynch a townie even after knowing he's a townie? Hurts town "later in the game" is irrelevant if you lynch scum in the first place.

Yes, actually I would PL a town. It's only D1, about three or four people scumread Sona and he already started talking about giving up. He basically refused to give his reads until RB pretty much forced him to. Even AFTER people townread him because of his terrible play, he STILL wanted to lynch himself. Sure we could try scum hunting, which I'm not suggesting we shouldn't do, but if we don't get anywhere then I'm suggesting Sona as an option. We could try letting Sona live for D2~D3 but obviously he isn't going to contribute and be pretty much useless.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not tunneling on Sona, I've been trying to find potential scum as well, but Sona isn't in my town read.

Posting more in a sec...

Static Noise Bird wrote:

We still have quite a lot time for analyzing, but... wait. There's a train already going on? Don't leave me out, guys!
Vote: Frostings

tn5421 wrote:

Frostings wrote:

Yes, actually I would PL a town. It's only D1, about three or four people scumread Sona and he already started talking about giving up. He basically refused to give his reads until RB pretty much forced him to. Even AFTER people townread him because of his terrible play, he STILL wanted to lynch himself. Sure we could try scum hunting, which I'm not suggesting we shouldn't do, but if we don't get anywhere then I'm suggesting Sona as an option. We could try letting Sona live for D2~D3 but obviously he isn't going to contribute and be pretty much useless.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not tunneling on Sona, I've been trying to find potential scum as well, but Sona isn't in my town read.

Posting more in a sec...

wat
are you serious?

DakeDekaane wrote:

And tbh I find a bit weird SNB jumping on Frostings' wagon, what made you join the wagon after looking a lot of people on it?

Raging Bull wrote:

I never thought i see this day.
prod Setsuen

DakeDekaane wrote:

I'm not sheeping anyone, I could like vote immediately and only go for what certain person says, I'm doing my own conclusions based on what I read, that and a bit of OMGUS.

Sonatora may be a good candidate for PL, but I think we should go for who is scummier.

Setsuen wrote:

also @Frosting

"I'm still not removing my vote yet" is literally one of the stunts I would pull as mafia in EpicMafia. Although my forum mafia playstyle is different from my EM playstyle, I have found strange similarity between my scum play in EM and the scum play by mafia in forum mafia which is also why I FOSed Nyquil in ChaosInDummyville soooo easily.

Frostings wrote:

Drezi - went from null to town because this post. If he was scum, there is no advantage of posting this

Setsuen wrote:

Now state every single possible scum team you four. Or Else.

Raging Bull wrote:

Frosting

Gumica wrote:

- I have a distaste for Frostings PL idea.

beeboy123 wrote:

@snb what did navi do to go from null-scum to null?

Static Noise Bird wrote:

Scum
Drezi OR Gumica. I can't tell which one, but they both probably are not. I'll expect tn or Frostings to be either one's partner.

Static Noise Bird wrote:

I'm suspicious about Drezi and Gumica; they are posting good posts, so I'll assume either one of them is playing their scum role very well (watch me get lynched next night because of this post, gg).

Raging Bull wrote:

Welp everyone prod dodge-ing. Well i still prefer Frosting lynch than tn.

Raging Bull wrote:

Lol at setsuen. If its boring, do something. Kinda obvious since you tell us that.

beeboy123 wrote:

All of your scum reads are due to people not posting content. did anything posted so far feel odd to you?

Frostings wrote:

beeboy123 wrote:

@snb what did navi do to go from null-scum to null?

Pretty random question, what was the reason for this?

Frostings wrote:

1. RB pushing a lynch on me
2. SNB's scumreads
3. Your question to SNB about Navi

Navizel wrote:

If scum could kill Setsuen N1, that would be great :>

Frostings wrote:

Static Noise Bird wrote:

I'm suspicious about Drezi and Gumica; they are posting good posts, so I'll assume either one of them is playing their scum role very well (watch me get lynched next night because of this post, gg).

So you want to lynch those that look town because they are probably scum, over the ones that look scum..?

Raging Bull wrote:

you are essentially PLing him and you said we gain nothing by PLing.

DakeDekaane wrote:

This game is like a rollercoaster, but without the ups and downs.

Raging Bull wrote:

And it may be easy for scum to start a wagon but if they lead it, they would be read as town easier so there is an incentive to start a wagon.

beeboy123 wrote:

-6 hours of discussion time in exchange for 2 days of being inactive is not worth the effort for a scum.

Sonatora wrote:

SCUM-
Frostings- I dont need any arguments in this one. Besides, it's already painfully obvious at this point of the game that Frosting's a scum

tn5421 wrote:

I can do you one better than that, setsuen.

Vote: SephiBRO

Post and I'll consider removing this.

Sonatora wrote:

Vote: Sephibro

Lemme help ya there tn-senpai

tn5421 wrote:

Sonatora what are you even doing?

Raging Bull wrote:

Man vote frosting. He hates you.

Sonatora wrote:

Nah, I'm fine with him

tn5421 wrote:

Unvote

Not comfortable putting someone at L-1 without getting some kind of response first.

Navizel wrote:

Also, you didn't post anything for 27 hours too and you probably saw me browsing the forum which means you're lurking too so screw you

Static Noise Bird wrote:

Well I don't know about the 4th reason, but the other ones sound rather obvious now that I think about them.

Good reason for tn to get replaced - can't take the pressure and accusations of lurking am I right ladies?

Navizel wrote:

Also, you didn't post anything for 27 hours too and you probably saw me browsing the forum which means you're lurking too so screw you

Setsuen wrote:

Are u srs.

Drezi wrote:

And scum has nothing to gain by trying to push a PL, it's not even like a scum partner needed saving or anything, scum can just join any wagon and lynch off a scummy townie, why would they pull shit like this.