Why hope I can randomly kill CTh when I can just lynch him
forum
osu! Medical Mafia [Game Over!, Mafia Win]
posted
Total Posts
499
If we mislynch and take 3 deaths it's game over, it's up to everyone in the end.
I do want everyone to make clear who they are targetting regardless so if they die we know who they were targetting.
everyone claimed targets so weak doctor is potentially already dead
We also learn if it was a mislynch during the d so we can replan to avoid having 3x deaths
This is false, butbeeboy123 wrote:
We can't take 3 deaths though it is 2 at max
Scenario where we get 3 deaths as shows. I killed off doctor for the purpose of this scenario.
2 of the deaths we had (Both the Lynch and Mislynch) are on the 3/6 non lethal roles which is already very low
After that we all need to target perfectly without any of the lethal doctors or scum being jailed (which is 4/5 roles) which we can also predict. On top of the fact we can change our plans in the twilight phase.
Killing of doctor also assumes that non of the lethal roles have no been lynched.
god I really should have read these posts over before posting them ;-;
2 doctors are dead, Nurse inherited the first one's, the other one targeted CBot so they have a killing ability, so weak doctor is still alive.
Nurse got the power of a mod killed doctor so it is more likely to be a safe doctor than a lethal one
Why?beeboy123 wrote:
Nurse got the power of a mod killed doctor so it is more likely to be a safe doctor than a lethal one
Wait this makes no sensebeeboy123 wrote:
Nurse got the power of a mod killed doctor so it is more likely to be a safe doctor than a lethal one
My logic was 2 scum, 7 doctors, 3 scum roles 3/7 chance.
In either case that would make you easily conf town since there's only 1 nurse in the game unless the last scum or the real nurse wants to counter claim that.
I feel like we get no-where doing nothing. Higher chance of 3 doctor kills + scum kill 2v1 me and sona are the ones that live and we are both to shit and get tricked by scum.
did you read my post where i show all possible night kills?
Weak
CPR
Quak
Mafia
We know one of the CPR or Quak is dead.
Weak
CPR/Quak
Mafia
Those are all 3 possible kills tonight on a worst case scenario.
Weak
CPR
Quak
Mafia
We know one of the CPR or Quak is dead.
Weak
CPR/Quak
Mafia
Those are all 3 possible kills tonight on a worst case scenario.
As much as I want to lynch someone I agree with your logic
Vote: No Lynch
Vote: No Lynch
I still prefer to hear from everyone else, if the rest don't like this plan then i'll just hammer CTh. If they agree then i'll vote No Lynch.
I'll just sit on no Lynch as I trust your decision and have no need to not vote at all and waste everyones tiem
No rush, according to the title we still have about 3-4 days anyway.
Can I trust you on this one, Sakura? I don't want to target a scum.
I'm not scum, but if you prefer to target someone else we can arrange that.
Topic Starter
Sakura wrote:
No rush, according to the title we still have about 3-4 days anyway.
The title is a lie. This was actually a bastard game and the day ends now.
...
Of course I'm kidding. What a bad joke anyways.
Wait wat forget this votecount. Fixing it.
Topic Starter
Votecount 2.05
Players needed to lynch: 4
Chamelo_Th - 3 - Navizel, Sonatora, Drezi - (L-1)
No Lynch - 1 - beeboy123 - (L-2)
Players not voting: Chamelo_Th, Sakura
Players needed to lynch: 4
Chamelo_Th - 3 - Navizel, Sonatora, Drezi - (L-1)
No Lynch - 1 - beeboy123 - (L-2)
Players not voting: Chamelo_Th, Sakura
Please tell me if you see any mistakes.
just letting Sakura choose what to do for today
Can i trust that at least everyone that is town will follow the list and no lynch? or do you want CTh dead and see what he flips AND risk getting 3 deaths as well during the night if he's town.
what will the plan be if you hammer Cth?
Whoever targets CTh targets whoever CTh was supposed to be targetting, which means they target each other. Other than that, same thing.
If CTh is hammered and flips townSakura wrote:
Looking over Medical Mafia on MS it seems the original plan was to target whoever was below then it got somehow changedDrezi > Navizel
beeboy > CTh
CTh > Sonatora
Navizel > Sakura
Sakura > Drezi
Sonatora > beeboy
This will break it up into 2 circles, since beeboy's scumreading CTh he shouldnt have any issues having the chance of getting him killed.
Drezi > Navizel
beeboy > Sonatora
Sonatora > beeboy
Navizel > Sakura
Sakura > Drezi
beeboy > Sonatora
Sonatora > beeboy
Navizel > Sakura
Sakura > Drezi
>nolynchbeeboy123 wrote:
Hammer is more fun
>hammer more fun
u srs
I decided that I should contain my cancer and let someone who thinks things through like Sakura decide what the best option is
I am a leader not a monarch, I offer options, let the town decide what they prefer to do and ultimately follow what we all agree upon.
vote: CTh
Gave a chance to pull votes this is what I believe is the best choice
Gave a chance to pull votes this is what I believe is the best choice
And that's a hammer.
I swear if Cth flipped town
It was bound to happen as I have been hinting at wanting to do it for awhile
So you rather end the day than wait at least 24 hours for ppl to give input on my new plan?
Okay, so:
And have fun with it.
Drezi > Navizel
beeboy > Sonatora
Sonatora > beeboy
Navizel > Sakura
Sakura > Drezi
beeboy > Sonatora
Sonatora > beeboy
Navizel > Sakura
Sakura > Drezi
And have fun with it.
I can't believe people voted me off because I replied to CB in D1 and didn't read one post from Drezi.
One more thing, I and Sakura purposed the same method; to let everyone share their target last night so we can resolve.
But there's only me who was told that it's not gonna work, by Navizel and voted me.
Weird.
Anyway, I'll wait and see... it's a good thing to let everyone know my playstyle from their first(second?) play.
One more thing, I and Sakura purposed the same method; to let everyone share their target last night so we can resolve.
But there's only me who was told that it's not gonna work, by Navizel and voted me.
Weird.
Anyway, I'll wait and see... it's a good thing to let everyone know my playstyle from their first(second?) play.
I actually only looked at CBot's ISO to look for association tells, but that's about it.
Topic Starter
Final Votecount for D2:
Players needed to lynch: 4
Chamelo_Th - 4 - Navizel, Sonatora, Drezi, beeboy123 - (LYNCH)
Players not voting: Chamelo_Th, Sakura
Players needed to lynch: 4
Chamelo_Th - 4 - Navizel, Sonatora, Drezi, beeboy123 - (LYNCH)
Players not voting: Chamelo_Th, Sakura
The doctors argued all day. Some of them talked about a Quack doctor, wait, was actually one of those fake hospitasl? Just when I was thinking too much about that the dicussion became real violent. I heard many noises, broken glass, punching, a bit of everything, probably signaling that a fight had started. "Get him! He's the other killer!", "No wait, I'm innocent"!... after a while of that, I heard all fighting stoped an a huge scream of agony.
It was kinda obvious: one of them had probably died. "There's... nothing here! Nothing that says he was one of the killers!"... after that, just silence. "Were we... wrong?, we took down an in-". Just as a doctor was saying that, the speakers around the hospital said they needed all doctors for the night shift right away. "We'll continue tomorrow, this won't end here".I heard every doctor leaving after that.
I was extremely nervous. This hospital was crazy, and even my own life was in risk."
It was kinda obvious: one of them had probably died. "There's... nothing here! Nothing that says he was one of the killers!"... after that, just silence. "Were we... wrong?, we took down an in-". Just as a doctor was saying that, the speakers around the hospital said they needed all doctors for the night shift right away. "We'll continue tomorrow, this won't end here".I heard every doctor leaving after that.
I was extremely nervous. This hospital was crazy, and even my own life was in risk."
Chamelo_Th, Town Doctor, was lynched Day 2.
It is now Night 2.
All actions are to go to my inbox within ~36 hours. That means Friday, 15th August 2:00AM UTC.
Topic Starter
Ending night ~20 minutes earlier. Resolving night actions.
Topic Starter
I don't really know what's happening anymore. I heard another big scream this night, but nobody else seemed to notice it. Was I becoming insane? The sooner I could get out of here, the better.
Today I heard the usual discussion next door, saying that an innocent died, since no evidence could be found to incriminate it. This was becoming really intense, could they find the other killer before its too late? I'm not feeling really good because of the accident, but I may need to escape as soon as possible.
Today I heard the usual discussion next door, saying that an innocent died, since no evidence could be found to incriminate it. This was becoming really intense, could they find the other killer before its too late? I'm not feeling really good because of the accident, but I may need to escape as soon as possible.
Sakura, Town Doctor, was found hanged Night 3.
It is now Day 3.
Deadline is in ~5 days, that means Wednesday, August 20th, 02:00 AM.
Also from now on Nights will be only 24 hours long.
Votecount 3.00
Players needed to lynch: 3
(No one is voting)
Players not voting: beeboy123, Drezi, Navizel, Sonatora
Players needed to lynch: 3
(No one is voting)
Players not voting: beeboy123, Drezi, Navizel, Sonatora
what
@mod - kindly fix the shift's over tab, it's confusing me
Topic Starter
Oh god. Seems I messed up pretty badly. Fixed.
Thanks.
Thank you based Paranoid Doctor/Quack Doctor/Goon for killing Sakura
goddamnit
Thank you based Paranoid Doctor/Quack Doctor/Goon for killing Sakura
goddamnit
If people really followed the circle thing, the other goon is either Sonatora or beeboy.
Ok, thats it
Vote: Drezi
Vote: Drezi
I can't suffer this bullshit either
brb playing league
brb playing league
you serious did you even try to analyze the situation
exactly
beeboy, did you follow what Sakura planned?
Welp I guess it is Sonatora but I want to follow the circle myself and I am too lazy to do it until the morning
I'm assuming everyone followed
Drezi>Navizel>Sakura>Drezi
Drezi is probably the Paranoid Doctor who jailed me so I can't protect Sakura last night. The only remaining were you and Sonatora.
Drezi>Navizel>Sakura>Drezi
Drezi is probably the Paranoid Doctor who jailed me so I can't protect Sakura last night. The only remaining were you and Sonatora.
I protected beeboy last night.
this is confusing
going to post a long one
going to post a long one
I want to look things over before I lynch sons too tired to think properly
who the hell is the Naive Doctor
If the Naive Doctor is still alive, please confirm
idk. fuck this shit. not going to post a long one anymore
it really is between you and sona
Drezi - Paranoid Doctor. I guess he really followed Sakura's plan and jailed me that's why I couldn't protect Sakura.Drezi wrote:
But if it IS beeboy I can still possibly Jail his kill and then we don't win even if it's CTh..
it really is between you and sona
reread the thread
Also, here is Sonatora D1
These are the people who Sonatora voted:
beeboy
Navizel
SNB/Sakura
Cth
Drezi
He didn't vote:
CB (scum)
Frostings (town)
Gumica (town)
Vote: Sonatora
^omgus vote. SNB voted him and he voted SNBSonatora wrote:
VOTE: SNB
Talk
CTs and Gumica are confirmed town. Sonatora isn't. CB didn't like the Sonatora wagon on D1CalignoBot wrote:
CTs gets a town pass for now. Not all that convinced on it for too long as it is currently.
Gumica is pretty much dead null.
Sonatora gets a free null read until day 2 because I can't get any kind of read from anything he's saying at all.
Also, here is Sonatora D1
Meet Sonatora D2Sonatora wrote:
Second of al, I voted navziel before since he acted suspicious on his first post.
Sonatora wrote:
Navizel : Town, for now
Sonatora ignored CB on D1.Sonatora wrote:
I only targeted Navizel last night since he felt vulnerable. He's also an obvious town so why not.
These are the people who Sonatora voted:
beeboy
Navizel
SNB/Sakura
Cth
Drezi
He didn't vote:
CB (scum)
Frostings (town)
Gumica (town)
Vote: Sonatora
don't jump on the bandwagon yet please.
god, i hate playing as town
beeboy, did you target Sonatora last night? Everything will make sense if you didn't.
I targeted beeboy last night. That's the only thing you need to know
Also, I think that scum targeted Sakura since scum can't do anything to Sakura. The only ones can be involved are the ones who targeted Sakura last night. Drezi's probably a paranoid.
That's what I said. Drezi is a paranoid doctor and he jailed me that's why I couldn't protect Sakura.
Guys you're jumping to conclusions too fast.
I did target you and if I'm jailer that would mean you couldn't protect Sakura, couldn't CPR/Quack kill her, and then you couldn't have NK-d her either, that's for sure. But it's very much possible that I'm NOT the jailer, and it was CTh or Sakura, or it's Beeboy/Sona, in which case, the other one could have been CPR/Quack too. You could also just be the Naive Doctor, which is a VT without any protection and it's still possible that you're in fact the Quack/CPR doctor, if CTh was or Sona is the Jailer since they targeted you last night.
I did target you and if I'm jailer that would mean you couldn't protect Sakura, couldn't CPR/Quack kill her, and then you couldn't have NK-d her either, that's for sure. But it's very much possible that I'm NOT the jailer, and it was CTh or Sakura, or it's Beeboy/Sona, in which case, the other one could have been CPR/Quack too. You could also just be the Naive Doctor, which is a VT without any protection and it's still possible that you're in fact the Quack/CPR doctor, if CTh was or Sona is the Jailer since they targeted you last night.
What's sure is that I CAN'T be Quack/CPR, since last day we established that I can only be Quack/CPR if Navi is the Jailer, and obviously Navi is not Jailer.
All I can say I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people
All I can say is I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people*
I hope this clears up something
Oh and by the way, we aren't sure yet what beeboy targeted last night.
Oh and by the way, we aren't sure yet what beeboy targeted last night.
And how exactly do you know that?Navizel wrote:
All I can say is I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people*
And BOOM hits the bulletDrezi wrote:
And how exactly do you know that?Navizel wrote:
All I can say is I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people*
So I have been working on a list of who is what but I need this to be clarified before I can continue
@mod can another doctor save a CPR?
@mod can another doctor save a CPR?
Topic Starter
What do you mean? CPR Doctors can be protected like any other player.beeboy123 wrote:
So I have been working on a list of who is what but I need this to be clarified before I can continue
@mod can another doctor save a CPR?
@mod I meant a weak doctor ;-; woops, can a weak doctor be saved if they target scum but are targeted by a doctor?
Topic Starter
Yes, if a weak doctor targeted a scum player but at the same time a normal doctor protected the weak doctor, then it lives.beeboy123 wrote:
@mod I meant a weak doctor ;-; woops, can a weak doctor be saved if they target scum but are targeted by a doctor?
Day 1 Targets
Drezi > beeboy
Navizel > Drezi
CTh > Navizel
Sonatora > Navizel
beeboy > No Target
Day 2 Targets
Bee>Sona>Bee
Drezi>Navi>Sakura>Drezi
And cannot be
Bee -Scum
Sona -
Navi -Doctor, CPR, Jailer
Drezi - Quack, CPR
Sakura - CPR, Quack
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Here is what I got using the current info.
Therefore I cannot be a kill role or else Sona would be dead unless one of us is a jailer and the other is CPR (as Navi, Drezi and Sakura cannot be CPR) but it is safe to assume CPR is dead.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Drezi > beeboy
Navizel > Drezi
CTh > Navizel
Sonatora > Navizel
beeboy > No Target
Day 2 Targets
Bee>Sona>Bee
Drezi>Navi>Sakura>Drezi
And cannot be
Bee -Scum
Sona -
Navi -Doctor, CPR, Jailer
Drezi - Quack, CPR
Sakura - CPR, Quack
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Here is what I got using the current info.
Therefore I cannot be a kill role or else Sona would be dead unless one of us is a jailer and the other is CPR (as Navi, Drezi and Sakura cannot be CPR) but it is safe to assume CPR is dead.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
owo that was a work in progress hence all the missing parts I meant to save that as a draft I will to to make conclusions later
Except Navi can be CPR, who killed Sakura, if the NK was jailed.
Navi can be Doctor too, with me Jailing his protection.
The rest of your conclusions, I've said already. And why the hell would it be safe to assume the CPR/Quack is dead, when any of us could be it except me.
Navi can be Doctor too, with me Jailing his protection.
The rest of your conclusions, I've said already. And why the hell would it be safe to assume the CPR/Quack is dead, when any of us could be it except me.
Because you are analyzing something that wasn't done.Drezi wrote:
Except Navi can be CPR, who killed Sakura, if the NK was jailed.
Navi can be Doctor too, with me Jailing his protection.
The rest of your conclusions, I've said already. And why the hell would it be safe to assume the CPR/Quack is dead, when any of us could be it except me.
I would have deleted that post if it was allowed
I was following this, btw I was going to ask why he thought this especially this partNavizel wrote:
All I can say I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people
Also of course I would add what you said yesterday about what could happen as that is what you do when you work as a team.
Anyway I won't be on for awhile which is why I wanted to save my post as a draft so I didn't lose it. I will lurk on my phone though if you have anymore questions you want to ask me.
Topic Starter
Votecount 3.01
Players needed to lynch: 3
Drezi - 1 - Sonatora - (L-2)
Sonatora - 1 - Navizel - (L-2)
Players not voting: beeboy123, Drezi
Players needed to lynch: 3
Drezi - 1 - Sonatora - (L-2)
Sonatora - 1 - Navizel - (L-2)
Players not voting: beeboy123, Drezi
Please tell me if you see any mistakes.