forum

osu! Medical Mafia [Game Over!, Mafia Win]

posted
Total Posts
499
show more
beeboy123
frostyling whoever got mod killed
beeboy123
and I forgot bold

@mod Did nurse have powers last night?
Sakura
Le facepalm.
beeboy123

Sakura wrote:

Why did you think predicting who scum would target was a priority during the night phase?
As a town doctor I could protect them or not die as the weak doctor.

Sakura wrote:

Why did you think it would be akin to commiting suicide?
Quack doctor fell under the category of commuting suicide as it is an accidental town death (bad word choice)

Weak doctor kills themselves.

A long with some other bad things that I didn't think about until now.
Topic Starter
Zexion

beeboy123 wrote:

and I forgot bold

@mod Did nurse have powers last night?
A doctor died (even if it was a modkill), so the nurse inherired a power.
beeboy123
So unless there are other overly paranoid doctors we should all have targets
beeboy123
by paranoid I mean careful
Sakura
So no one else?...
Topic Starter
Zexion
Votecount 2.03
Players needed to lynch: 4

Chamelo_Th - 1 - Navizel - (L-3)

Players not voting: beeboy123, Chamelo_Th, Drezi, Sakura, Sonatora

Sonatora has been prodded.
Please tell me if you see any mistakes.
Navizel
I like pringles

my vote still remains

Cth>Sontatora>Sakura>beeboy>Drezi
Sakura
Now I'm getting suspicious of Navizel, there's no reason to hold out their target...
Navizel
It's bad to not vote my scumread? what
Sakura
I've been asking who you targeted last night, that's all (Question also goes to Sonatora but he/she hasn't even been around so much he/she got prodded)
Navizel
drezi
Navizel
what good would that bring anyway
Sakura
Lots of good believe it or not, now i'm just waiting for Sonotora.

While you're around any particular reason why you went for Drezi?
Sakura
Now updated!
Sakura (SNB) > Sonatora
Drezi > beeboy
Navizel > Drezi
CTh > Navizel
Sonatora > ???
beeboy > No Target
Navizel
I don't get beeboy and Sonatora. they probably won't be killed by scums due to their playstyle
I feel CTh and CB are scum
Gumica SNB null
AutoMedic
I'm back from the dead


anyways, the current flow of the discussion led me to a bad hypothesis


Vote: Cth
Chamelo
You feel that I'm scum.
Okay, so your vote is based on your feeling, right.
Chamelo
And dat Sonatora sheep...
AutoMedic
It feels like you're the scum. Asking suspicious questions at the first minutes of day 1. Why wouldn't I suspect you?


But remember, It's just my intuition. Dont take it seriously. I need information
AutoMedic
On other news, I heard that there's another playstyle that involves mafia blending with twon and negating all thoughts


My intuition is saying something
AutoMedic
*town
Navizel

Chamelo_Th wrote:

You feel that I'm scum.
Okay, so your vote is based on your feeling, right.
I thought it was obvious but whatever. They are my thoughts last night, not today.
Chamelo
Did you mean: Day 2?

And gut feeling, yeah, gut feeling.
:|

Who did you protected last night?
Chamelo
And my previous post meant for Sonatora.
AutoMedic
Here's my list


Cth : Intuition-san is teing me that you're the scum.
Sakura :Still leeching me for info
Navizel : Town, for now
beeboy : Aggressive town, but there's no lead that this guys a mafia. Null town
Drezi

Sonatora wrote:

Sakura :Still leeching me for info
As is CTs, and I'd like you to answer too, since we're only missing your target, I see no reason not to cooperate with Sakura at this point.
AutoMedic
Oh, my target last night? It was Navizel. Anything else?
Chamelo
Now that's a hard resolving pattern. :v
Drezi
Ok so we have
Sakura (SNB) > Sonatora
Drezi > beeboy
Navizel > Drezi
CTh > Navizel
Sonatora > Navizel
beeboy > No Target

That means Gumica was CPR/Quack doctor and it was him who killed CBot since noone targeted him, and Gumica was killed by scum (not the other kill capable doc or being weak doc), since noone targeted Gumica and CBot wouldn't have died if he was weak doc.

So what people CAN'T be are:
Sakura: CPR/Quack (since noone else targeted Sonatora who could have saved him)
Drezi: none, but since there's only one killing role left it's not probable that I have it and Navi is the Jailer at the same time.
Navi: none, being a killing role is a bit more probable, since two people could have jailed him.
CTh: none, being protective or killing is a lot more probable, since Navi was targeted by two people so either 2 nonkilling or 1 killing 1 protective among them.
Sonatora: same as CTh.

So what we can figure of this for sure is that we should have Sakura protect a townread, that she feels would get NK-d.
Drezi
Sakura: CPR/Quack (since noone else targeted Sonatora who could have saved him, and noone targeted Sakura who could have jailed the kill*)
Drezi
So it's the line from the list of what she CAN'T be, to avoid confusion.
AutoMedic
I only targeted Navizel last night since he felt vulnerable. He's also an obvious town so why not.
Chamelo
Wait.
We forget that Frosting could be CPR doctor or Quack doctor.
You know, Frosting targeted CB and CB targeted Frosting.
Drezi
What?

Frosting was modkilled D1, and Nurse got his powers (or he was nurse), so we went into N1 with the 6 doctor roles.
Chamelo
Sorry, I missed.

Gumica
Drezi
No it said Town Doctor, so he wasn't Nurse, the Nurse got his powers, doesn't change the point either way.
Drezi

Chamelo_Th wrote:

Wait.
We forget that Frosting could be CPR doctor or Quack doctor.
You know, Frosting targeted CB and CB targeted Frosting.
So you mean Gumica instead of Frostings, ok but I had already concluded that Gumica HAD to be CPR/Quack, and he couldn't have died from being targeted by other docs or being a weak doctor so scum HAD to target Gumica.

Why are you presenting it as something new?

Vote: CTs
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply