show more
Yafutsufa

mrdumpling64 wrote:

god please no

IMO both are just equally filled with weeaboob fanboys/fan girls who make a giant fuss about every minor detail of the show
the best reason to make me hating 1 show after another... dem weeaboo :x :x :x

hm? choice? then... *proceed to jump from 11th floor*
Revion
Prefer Sword Art Online than Attack On Titan.
~
Because the plot of SAO seems more interesting, like the gear, triangle love (maybe or multiple?), the battle (but seems unreal, because it is the game and I like it), etc.
Attack On Titan though I think has more logic plot and setting than SAO, I don't like the storyline.
Dante8975
I prefered Sword Art Online. :)
Taadashi
Haven't watched Attack on Titan. As for Sword Art Online. I watched 5 episodes and then couldn't take it anymore because I really disliked that anime.
kouzuki_karen

Yafutsufa wrote:

mrdumpling64 wrote:

god please no

IMO both are just equally filled with weeaboob fanboys/fan girls who make a giant fuss about every minor detail of the show
the best reason to make me hating 1 show after another... dem weeaboo :x :x :x

hm? choice? then... *proceed to jump from 11th floor*
neonat
SAO because

[ Stellar ]
Neither.
They're both over hyped.
BoredPotato
Both had their ups and downs, but tbh, they're overrated. They could have been made (A LOT) better, but they just ended up pretty bad. I prefer SAO over AoT though.
limee_old
Attack on titan although I'm not really a big fan of either.
Akari Ehime
Shingeki no Kyojin <3
Seikunai
Both overrated as fuck. But I prefer AoT over SAO.
Nukedboom
I'd choose SAO, I liked it more.
They're both pretty overrated though.
ivan
x
ixsq

Sethlied wrote:

both are shit
SharinganGirl
Sword Art Online.
P r o m i s e s

SharinganGirl wrote:

Sword Art Online.
RatedNC17
Attack on titan. I just couldn't bring myself to watch SAO i just dislike it :/
DestinySonata
I honestly like Sword Art Online. When I watched it during its air-time it made me so happy.
Plus_old_1
both are pretty shit, but snk is way less shit
seasonS

Adicchi wrote:

Sethlied wrote:

both are shit

ampzz wrote:

Both are overrated garbage so do yourself a favour and watch older (read that as superior) anime titles.
SAO was good, I enjoyed it but I do think that many people overrated it. It didn't live up to the hype I heard about it. Still it was enjoyable
Navizel
Natame-

Plus wrote:

both are pretty shit, but snk is way less shit
^
Pizzicato
they're both good but way too overrated thus making them both shit
aBunny_old
overrated doesnt mean bad
SAO light novel is the best
Sapphiire_old_1
oh God why so manny hate *sigh* yes they are overrated , but not bad !
Kin
I don't know about the light novel, but TOO MANY people says it's SO GOOD or the best anime ever, they are not this bad, but I don't think they are this good. Also I tried to watch both, but I were kinda disapointed when I saw it was just a blockbuster, and nothing more (for me + I couldn't finish both). I would say, too much overrated Hi ADS everywhere

Also I think I'll say SnK
Tari
None, too mainstream for me
Sapphiire_old_1
why is to mainstream a reason to not liking it ? its a dumb reason honestly if you like it well thats fine , iif you dont like it thats fine to but not liking a anime just because its to overrated and mainstream wel thats just dumb
Navizel
because hipster.
Umi
i personally like both, if i had to choose, Snk because there was intensity in almost every episode.
[ Stellar ]

Plus wrote:

both are pretty shit, but snk is way less shit
I 100% agree with this.
People go way nuts about these over hyped animes.
Kyonko Hizara
SnK because it was actually interesting. It's pretty good if you look aside from how much people like to overrate it.

I could never get into SAO.
XYZ3370
I dropped SnK, couldn't stand that protagonist anymore (Ep 14 or so). I didn't really enjoy that story line, it was somehow cruel but not that interesting imo.
In SAO at least the idea was awesome. I enjoyed the whole setting and I actually liked those extremely over-dramatised scenes, way more tense than in SnK imo although Kirito was often so op.... The first arc was awesome imo, however nothing really to say about the second...
tyrael6192
if you use "overrated" as a primary argument for discarding something, it's pretty clear you don't really have anything valuable to say. all it means is literally "other people like this more than me", unless you haven't actually watched it, in which case it's a non-statement and your opinion is not valid anyway

just watch it and see if you like it lmao is it that hard
Sapphiire_old_1

tyrael6192 wrote:

if you use "overrated" as a primary argument for discarding something, it's pretty clear you don't really have anything valuable to say. all it means is literally "other people like this more than me", unless you haven't actually watched it, in which case it's a non-statement and your opinion is not valid anyway

just watch it and see if you like it lmao is it that hard

Oh God finaly somwone else that understands why its so retarded for not liking a anime just because it is 'overrated'
Nub1
The reason it is overrated is because lot of people like it.
Tekklorn
SAO because DAT ASS....una
Navizel

Adicchi wrote:

The reason it is overrated is because lot of people like it.
You just defined the meaning of the word overrated.
Nub1

Navizel wrote:

Adicchi wrote:

The reason it is overrated is because lot of people like it.
You just defined the meaning of the word overrated.
seeing tyrael6192 post make me wanna explain what is overrated, lol.

I already choose anyway, its on the first page
ruminine
like them both, but I'll choose SAO
tyrael6192

Adicchi wrote:

The reason it is overrated is because lot of people like it.
which is essentially what i said? a lot of people like it and rate it highly and then someone watches it and doesnt like it. to that person it is overrated, but that's not a statement about the nature of the show at all and therefore not relevant
Piine
Uhhh I wouldn't call it bad for being "overated" (Even though I usually say that...) Though I rather you say SAO or SnK have certain flaws and people ignore them thinking it the best anime ever, then classifying them as just overated. SAO is mainly a typical princess story with just good graphical details and SnK is a pretty normal action packed anime but I wouldn't just say it just it overated just because. a lot of people watch it...
Haxdelete
meiikyuu
titan
mimaylin
SAO for sure.
TsunLemon
Neither moved me much, but thought SAO was slightly better. Only problem it had was that everything was ruined on the ALO arc.
Meanwhile thought SNK only had the great animation and sometimes great OST going for it, everything else was below average.
ALTKID
SNK
Xiaolin
Both are really good~ >.<
But I prefer SAO ofc~ ;3
Cause awsome friend is Kirito. xD
- Yuuto -
SnK.
Since snk is the real combat not in based game
Raiken-
For the Fighting Scenes, I prefer SnK.
For the Lovely Scenes, I prefer SAO.
Sheepsticks
I really prefer SAO's theme. Can't wait for the 2nd season. :D
ALTKID
SNK

SNK have a better image than sao
and better plot ofc
PeeweeKagamine
In terms of Otaku's ranking, of course AOT/SNK would win. its like, in the 34th rank right now
but personally, i did not enjoy either snk or sao. i prefer stuff like oreimo or railgun
Quest
SAO.
Enough said.
Although, I quite like HEICHOU and his cleaning motives.
Sorageru
Both of them are good~
MrBakpao
for romance story i choose SAO
but in SNK you can feel some fear and sad in the story, combined with war between monster and human make SNK look better~
[Yue]
Sword Art Online!
I find it much more interesting :3
Taengz
Sword Art Online, I didn't like SnK that much, but it was still pretty good.
Elicchi_old
SAO. but SnK's pretty good.
Apex_old
I don't see the objective of this thread except by gaining thread posts. This thread is like comparing a chicken egg to a rock album.
Yukii
SAO!! :D
kirueggy
SAO

No offense to SnK, I mean both are pretty boss animes, just that the fandom for SnK is just... out of hand
Pawsu
SAO all the way

I mean AOT is good too, but I'm in love with the concept of SAO.
Lemozade
SAO. I've never been as immersed to a story line and character plot, most people didn't enjoy that function of it and only liked the action, but I thought it had such an immersive story, and fell in love with it instantly.
Kingdom_old_1

Sethlied wrote:

both are shit
randomizer89

Lucia-Hime wrote:

Sethlied wrote:

both are shit
DeletedUser_4041880
Probably AoT but I kinda like the idea of SAO.
Kisetsunotori
SAO because i like more of the futuristic fantasy
Taadashi
AoT definitely. Probably one of the better animes out there in current time. :)
Nyanstars
I like SAO more, online game animes rule!
deadbeat
btw guys, while everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and obviously not everyone likes SAO or AoT, if you don't like them, don't post here. simple.
we don't need negativity in threads like this >_>
AutoMedic

deadbeat wrote:

btw guys, while everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and obviously not everyone likes SAO or AoT, if you don't like them, don't post here. simple.
we don't need negativity in threads like this >_>
True

My opinion about Three two anime's that everyone's talking about this thread

AoT : Too much hype. Ruined the thing. Probably it's the replacement for Bleach without high school
SaO : The anime killed itself on ALO. God, everyone agreed that ALO arc is soo boring
EasyMillions
As much as I hate both of them I'd say...... :roll: AoT by far
Revy-
3 words. SAO
Greyusb
SAO, mainly because I love the light novel... Personally I don't fancy Attack on Titan's story and theme as much as other people do...
Celizavia
Attack on Online.

Geez it sounds so weird
- Kensley -
I prefer Sword Art Online because it has to do with technology. I don't like anime who plays in the past like Attack on Titan
Demon
I prefer Sword Art Online ;3
Green_Blue_old
SAO have a really awsome animation and graphic. . .

But i prefer AoT fot awsome story line and character development ;3
kirueggy
Actually changed my opinion, both suck and are overrated just like League of Legends.

Fight me.

Although I'd rather watch AoT because SOME of it is worth watching + people at my school aren't dying over it unlike stupid SAO
Birdy

kirukashi wrote:

both suck and are overrated just like League of Legends.
AutoMedic

kirukashi wrote:

Actually changed my opinion, both suck and are overrated just like League of Legends.

Fight me.

Although I'd rather watch AoT because SOME of it is worth watching + people at my school aren't dying over it unlike stupid SAO
+1

AOT is slightly better for the good arcs they've pulled off
41236
.
tanteiRE
Attack on Titan. It's not even like if I had to pick between the two, I choose AoT. I really like it >:D
The haters are just wannabee hipsters. Or are actually hipsters..
I'm meh with SAO. I have yet to read the light novel, but the anime really pisses me off.. At least the second half of season 1 did.
Yes, both are completely overrated. But AoT has decent reason to be, SAO does not.
FluffyTeddy
SAO
Drowned Crow
I Pref Sword art online

I realy wish ppl coud Stop calling it Attack on Titans.The Name is Shingeki no kyojin

tanteiRE

FuturistigSan wrote:

I Pref Sword art online

I realy wish ppl coud Stop calling it Attack on Titans.The Name is Shingeki no kyojin
No one is calling it Attack on Titans.. lol
Although it isn't the exact translation of Shingeki no Kyojin, it's the accepted English name. Same way Kyoukai no Kanata is Beyond the Boundary despite that not being the exact translation. Also, for people who buy/read the volumes in English, it is printed as Attack on Titan. Not saying all manga volumes in English are good.. Because one time, they went from Kamisama Hajimemashita to Kamisama Kiss..
Nothing wrong with calling it in its English name versus spelling it in romaji.
Nice picture though
Witch Mercy
Why would you even compare these two anime?
Anyways I choose AoT.
Foxtrot

FuturistigSan wrote:

I Pref Sword art online

I realy wish ppl coud Stop calling it Attack on Titans.The Name is Shingeki no kyojin
Stop being a weeaboo.
Geo
.
kagaminelenz
^Agree LoL XD
AoT and SnK is same, only in different language

Anyway, I prefer SnK because it have a heavier plot and it blood splatter so cool
[-Tsubomi-]
kfjlklka , shingeki no kyojin FTW ! < 3
lunarblue

Dulcet wrote:

FuturistigSan wrote:

I Pref Sword art online

I realy wish ppl coud Stop calling it Attack on Titans.The Name is Shingeki no kyojin
Stop being a weeaboo.
+1 hhhhhnnggg
Gumpy
Maybe I will watch them sometime in the future when people stop mentioning it to me constantly.
tanteiRE

Gumpyyy wrote:

Maybe I will watch them sometime in the future when people stop mentioning it to me constantly.
That'll be a while then.. The AoT manga is by no means close to finishing, and I doubt the SAO light novel is either. Unless their popularity drops out of the blue, which may happen if the SAO anime ends after Gun Gale, cause the anime is certainly more popular than the light novel.
But you're not missing out. :)
VoidnOwO
attack on titan definitely
kanasayu
im not obsessed with neither but sao was garbage so i'll choose attack on titan
41236
.
moonlight666
I'm kinda bored of romance, so i choose AoT for now
Hoppix

Sethlied wrote:

both are shit
This
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

/