nooodl is voting for me, and I know I'm not mafia, so I'm going to go ahead and vote for him. 
VOTE: nooodl
VOTE: nooodl
forum
Ongoing Mafia 1 (Abandoned and Old)
posted
Total Posts
223
I'm going with strager's logic. Vote Wojj.
Topic Starter
2 Wojjan
2 nooodl
1 Powerdrone
Gotta convince three people to vote someone.
2 nooodl
1 Powerdrone
Gotta convince three people to vote someone.
Here's my interpretations of the votes. If you have anything to add (e.g. I misunderstand someone's argument), feel free to do so.
Argument against Wojjan
Wojjan made a Freudian slip by not knowing about the Doctor role (which would only occur if he wasn't a Doctor, and the only other role is a Mafia member).
Argument against nooodl
nooodl is, accoring to Wojjan, "very caught up in this game". To me, though, he just seems interested in keeping the game moving (as I am).
Argument against Powerdrone
nooodl says Powerdrone is acting out of place. I couldn't say because I don't know Powerdrone. Voting solely due to a metagame reason is kinda out there IMO, too.
Argument against Wojjan
Wojjan made a Freudian slip by not knowing about the Doctor role (which would only occur if he wasn't a Doctor, and the only other role is a Mafia member).
Argument against nooodl
nooodl is, accoring to Wojjan, "very caught up in this game". To me, though, he just seems interested in keeping the game moving (as I am).
Argument against Powerdrone
nooodl says Powerdrone is acting out of place. I couldn't say because I don't know Powerdrone. Voting solely due to a metagame reason is kinda out there IMO, too.
Defense/Explanation: This is no Freudian slip. I am a Doctor, but tried to press nooodl into a reaction. Were he to act odd when confronted with an accusation, I could point this out, and we have our scum.strager wrote:
Argument against Wojjan
Wojjan made a Freudian slip by not knowing about the Doctor role (which would only occur if he wasn't a Doctor, and the only other role is a Mafia member).
Defense/Explanation: I'm luring nooodl out here. You too would do well to know that nooodl hasn't played any Mafia game with me, and I would not know his playing behaviour. I would, for instance, not attack SFG or Rolled for being active, I know they are.strager wrote:
Argument against nooodl
nooodl is, accoring to Wojjan, "very caught up in this game". To me, though, he just seems interested in keeping the game moving (as I am).
Hope this helps clearing up your troubles.
That's a pretty weak defense, IMO. It's not illogical but I'm having difficulty believing you.Wojjan wrote:
Defense/Explanation: This is no Freudian slip. I am a Doctor, but tried to press nooodl into a reaction. Were he to act odd when confronted with an accusation, I could point this out, and we have our scum.strager wrote:
Argument against Wojjan
Wojjan made a Freudian slip by not knowing about the Doctor role (which would only occur if he wasn't a Doctor, and the only other role is a Mafia member).
I'll buy that.Wojjan wrote:
Defense/Explanation: I'm luring nooodl out here. You too would do well to know that nooodl hasn't played any Mafia game with me, and I would not know his playing behaviour. I would, for instance, not attack SFG or Rolled for being active, I know they are.strager wrote:
Argument against nooodl
nooodl is, accoring to Wojjan, "very caught up in this game". To me, though, he just seems interested in keeping the game moving (as I am).
What reaction? I don't see how...Wojjan wrote:
Defense/Explanation: This is no Freudian slip. I am a Doctor, but tried to press nooodl into a reaction. Were he to act odd when confronted with an accusation, I could point this out, and we have our scum..
...could evoke any reaction, other than "Lol no". More so, why say that, instead of...Wojjan wrote:
vote: nooodl. You're being very caught up in this game, and you wouldn't if you had a boring role. I think you're a mafia.
So, a direct question to Wojjan: Why say "a boring role" rather than "doctor"? Considering, in my opinion, the latter would have proked a similar, if not greater response?Wojjan wrote:
vote: nooodl. You're being very caught up in this game, and you wouldn't if you were a doctor.
The trouble lies in focus. The reaction I was hoping for should spring off of
instead of the boring role bit.Wojjan wrote:
vote: nooodl. You're being very caught up in this game, and you wouldn't if you had a boring role. I think you're a mafia.
Topic Starter
<------- Vacation. Deadline extended till I'm back.
oh before I forget, that would be a lie and then strager would point that out and be all omg u scum just the same.DiamondCrash wrote:
More so, why say that, instead of...Wojjan wrote:
vote: nooodl. You're being very caught up in this game, and you wouldn't if you were a doctor.
Hey Powerdrone, results?Powerdrone311 wrote:
SORRY! I've been really busy, and haven't been able to be here! I'm here now though.
I'm going to read over the thread again and see who's suspiciousical.
I voted for noooodl. I'm in another mafia round though and I'm rather busy.
Topic Starter
I'm back but not ready to do anything yet. Day will end tomorrow or the day after.
Topic Starter
Last extention due to the "bleh's", if no lynch by tomorrow, all live players are replaced by all dead players.
What.LadySuburu wrote:
Last extention due to the "bleh's", if no lynch by tomorrow, all live players are replaced by all dead players.
I was waiting for the day to end...
I don't want the game turning into crap, so I'll do this:
Unvote
If someone wants to vote for Wojjie I'll re-place my vote. Now, at least, we get a lynch and we aren't gay'd.
On a logic-related note:
Last night I conceived a method for increasing the chance of the Town winning and therefore likely decreasing the length of the game. I'll need to be alive tomorrow to lay out the plans, of course, so we can execute them. If I say them now I'm not sure we'll have enough time to do it and the Mafia will try to ruin the whole operation (there are several ways to help the Mafia if it isn't done properly) so we'll have to wait until tomorrow.
Topic Starter
Extra extention due to me apperently not posting that rule somewhere.
So, let's do this again.
It's 3 to lynch. If there is no official lynch by deadline, ALL LIVING PLAYERS ARE REPLACED BY THE DEAD PLAYERS.
That being stated (again), I now give a week expansion for the last time.
So, let's do this again.
It's 3 to lynch. If there is no official lynch by deadline, ALL LIVING PLAYERS ARE REPLACED BY THE DEAD PLAYERS.
That being stated (again), I now give a week expansion for the last time.
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Topic Starter
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Confirm
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Topic Starter
Night ends.
3 to lynch.
Have fun!
3 to lynch.
Have fun!
Okay, the plan:
Everyone pledges they will protect another person. Each person has only one person protecting them, forming a ring.
If we can make a no-lynch (without penalty), we can do that.
If not, or if we want the game to not dwindle to an elimination fest, we need to remove one person from the ring, and they will be lynched.
Living players, in order from the OP:
Now, we see who is killed during the night, if anyone. If someone is killed, we lynch the person who was supposed to have protected them because either they aren't playing the game right or they aren't a Doctor (and thus are a Mafia Good). If no one is killed, oh well; continue with the next day.
Today, I am going to Protect: Powerdrone.
Everyone pledges they will protect another person. Each person has only one person protecting them, forming a ring.
If we can make a no-lynch (without penalty), we can do that.
If not, or if we want the game to not dwindle to an elimination fest, we need to remove one person from the ring, and they will be lynched.
Living players, in order from the OP:
- Wojjan
- DeathxShinigami
- strager
- DiamondCrash
- Powerdrone311
Now, we see who is killed during the night, if anyone. If someone is killed, we lynch the person who was supposed to have protected them because either they aren't playing the game right or they aren't a Doctor (and thus are a Mafia Good). If no one is killed, oh well; continue with the next day.
Today, I am going to Protect: Powerdrone.
So then I want to Protect: strager Am I doing it right?
Ahem. If I'm not mistaken, I protect Powerdrone?strager wrote:
Today, I am going to Protect: Powerdrone.
- Wojjan
- DeathxShinigami
- strager
- DiamondCrash
- Powerdrone311
Protect: Wojjan
There we go.
Then Powerdrone protects me.
There we go.
Then Powerdrone protects me.
Topic Starter
There is no "No Lynch".
That is all.
That is all.
Hold on, wait, what?
How's this going to work now?
How's this going to work now?
It sort of only gives us a night guarantee, provided the mafia is BOTCHED ASS STUPID.
"Botched ass stupid"? Kind of a childish, rather reckess outburst from a relatively tame player, don't you think?Wojjan wrote:
It sort of only gives us a night guarantee, provided the mafia is BOTCHED ASS STUPID.
The ring in that post was purely an example. I provided how protections would occur after that list if that ring were chosen.DiamondCrash wrote:
Ahem. If I'm not mistaken, I protect Powerdrone?strager wrote:
Today, I am going to Protect: Powerdrone.
- Wojjan
- DeathxShinigami
- strager
- DiamondCrash
- Powerdrone311
I guess pairs could work, but rings work for any size, and if two Mafia are "protecting" each other they wouldn't vote for the person they are "protecting" so there's a less chance of a Mafia hit (but also less chance of a Townie hit).
Current ring:
DiamondCrash: strager
strager: Powerdrone
Powerdrone: Wojjie
Wojjie: DxS
DxS has to vote to protect DiamondCrash to complete the ring. However, we cannot have a five player ring if we cannot vote to not lynch anyone. Therefore, someone has to be killed.
I am prodding DxS. If he doesn't come soon I'm going to vote him off because I dislike inactive players.
Are you saying my plan has a hole? I'd like to hear it. As far as I can see, the Mafia cast their votes to LS and LS determines who is killed, or something. (OP says Mafia do not know who each other are, so I assume they cannot discuss?)Wojjan wrote:
It sort of only gives us a night guarantee, provided the mafia is BOTCHED ASS STUPID.
EDIT: Fixed a hanging [/color] tag.
Oi oi its before 4 pm -8 GMT give me a break I got back from school
Protecting DiamondCrash
There there I'm here.
Protecting DiamondCrash
There there I'm here.
I'm confused, don't we choose to protect someone by PM to the GM? Is it night right now? I thought it was day, in which case we'd be voting to kill someone...
We are saying who we would protect if we were all Doctors.Powerdrone311 wrote:
I'm confused, don't we choose to protect someone by PM to the GM? Is it night right now? I thought it was day, in which case we'd be voting to kill someone...
If someone dies, the person who should have been protecting the person who died is Mafia.
Sorry I seemed rushing DxS; just wanted you in the game.
And I just realized I don't think I chose someone to protect last night... Wups? =X
It's funny, cause I protected Wojjan every night since I've been alive... which is two. =P
Oh, right, I forgot...
Vote: Wojjie
Vote: Wojjie
I wonder why Wojjan protected me...I don't talk to you so much and it seemed upon instinct you would act to protect me still. Very suspicious.
Not really. You were next on the list. The only thing I find strange is strager, who was the only person not to go by the list, even though he was the one who produced it. He seemed to act on his instinctal need to either skip protecting me, or his need to protect Powerdrone. As I can't see any reason for the first, it must be the second. Why protect Powerdrone? He's done it before, too.DeathxShinigami wrote:
I wonder why Wojjan protected me...I don't talk to you so much and it seemed upon instinct you would act to protect me still. Very suspicious.
Perhaps he knows something about Powerdrone we don't? I dunno, I'm probably being overanalytical.strager wrote:
Argument against Powerdrone
nooodl says Powerdrone is acting out of place. I couldn't say because I don't know Powerdrone. Voting solely due to a metagame reason is kinda out there IMO, too.
WIFOM WIFOM WIFOM
you do know the mafia isn't as stupid as to kill the target they are going to "protect"
END OF WIFOM
you do know the mafia isn't as stupid as to kill the target they are going to "protect"
END OF WIFOM
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
What do you mean collectively target? It doesn't make a difference, does it?strager wrote:
Yes.
But the Mafia don't know who each other are and don't know who to collectively target.
I'm not sure exactly how the Mafia choose a Night Kill because I'm not a Mafia member.DiamondCrash wrote:
What do you mean collectively target? It doesn't make a difference, does it?strager wrote:
Yes.
But the Mafia don't know who each other are and don't know who to collectively target.
Mod: If you could clarify how Night Kills are decided that would be helpful.
I guess I just assumed Mafia members sent their vote to LS and she determined who would die.
Topic Starter
As I know I've stated before...
Each mafia gets their own night kill, just as each doctor gets their own protection.
Each mafia gets their own night kill, just as each doctor gets their own protection.
Oh.LadySuburu wrote:
As I know I've stated before...
Each mafia gets their own night kill, just as each doctor gets their own protection.
o_o
So their more like... serial killers?
Topic Starter
Pretty much. Serial Killers are just like mafia, only they win by themselves.Powerdrone311 wrote:
So their more like... serial killers?
I called them mafia because all the living players have to be mafia or Doctors to win. You can't win alone.
I just noticed I used the wrong "there". :/
Can I self-vote? Just so A new player would come into the game, that is.
If so: Vote: Wojjie
Yeah I'd rather we move on.
Whoever should protect me, protect the one I'm getting.
If so: Vote: Wojjie
Yeah I'd rather we move on.
Whoever should protect me, protect the one I'm getting.
Topic Starter
Mod note: If anyone saw my post before I deleted it, then forget what I posted, mod was being stupid.
Aanyway, checking current vote tally.
Wojjan (2) - strager, Wojjan
Aanyway, checking current vote tally.
Wojjan (2) - strager, Wojjan
herp derp
Vote: Wojjan
If you're sure.
If you're sure.
Topic Starter
Being dead of the one, Wojjan.
Time of Night.
Time of Night.
Topic Starter
Classes, will update soon with new players.
On that note, I will allow the start of discussion among the currently living players.
strager and DxS die.
There are to be no lynch votes until I send the roles to the two incoming players, but discussion is fine. (I won't count any votes before then.)
On that note, I will allow the start of discussion among the currently living players.
strager and DxS die.
There are to be no lynch votes until I send the roles to the two incoming players, but discussion is fine. (I won't count any votes before then.)
mod: If a mafia kills a doctor, does the doctor's protection still work?
Topic Starter
Yes. On that note, I want to clarify a few things.0_o wrote:
mod: If a mafia kills a doctor, does the doctor's protection still work?
Let's say Joe is protecting Bob.
Jane and Fred both target Bob with a kill.
Bob will die.
Now, if Joe and Fran are protecting Bob, and Jane and Fred are targeting Bob, Bob won't die.
Topic Starter
adam NoHitter in
confirm
confirmed
It looks like strager's ring approach has a hole in it now.
So if two mafia target one person, and there's only one doctor protecting him, he will still die.
Any ideas?
So if two mafia target one person, and there's only one doctor protecting him, he will still die.
Any ideas?
Ring having a hole in it? I never.NoHItter wrote:
It looks like strager's ring approach has a hole in it now.
So if two mafia target one person, and there's only one doctor protecting him, he will still die.
Any ideas?
No, not really. But the mafia don't know each other, so it would be pot luck if they both/two of them were to pick the same one, wouldn't it?
Okay, since strager and DxS died...
We can assume both mafia killed different people.
since strager died, and DxS was protected him, DxS was mafia.
But DxS died...
We can assume both mafia killed different people.
since strager died, and DxS was protected him, DxS was mafia.
But DxS died...
Powerdrone had the forsight to kill the person that couldn't be protected by Wojjan, because Wojjie was dead, I suppose.NoHItter wrote:
Okay, since strager and DxS died...
We can assume both mafia killed different people.
since strager died, and DxS was protected him, DxS was mafia.
But DxS died...
Vote: Powerdrone
Damn, I forgot that there could be more than 2 mafia as of now...
Also prodding the other players
Also prodding the other players
I just feel that Diamond is mafia.
DiamondCrash wrote:
No, not really. But the mafia don't know each other, so it would be pot luck if they both/two of them were to pick the same one, wouldn't it?
I still say we go with it though.NoHItter wrote:
Damn, I forgot that there could be more than 2 mafia as of now...
Also prodding the other players
protect: adam2046
/me pokes thread.
Almost the five-month anniversary!
Almost the five-month anniversary!
Hey.
Vote: DiamonCrash
Vote: DiamonCrash
Topic Starter
If I don't see some activity, I'm just going to close the game (like all the others that died out.).
I might make one more attempt after that (at normal mafia), and if that fails I'll either post a restricted-join mafia, or be done hosting mafia here for a while. A long while.
So... yeah, deadline is currently suspended, and if there's a serious lack of activity when I finally get sick of waiting, then I'm ending this game.
I might make one more attempt after that (at normal mafia), and if that fails I'll either post a restricted-join mafia, or be done hosting mafia here for a while. A long while.
So... yeah, deadline is currently suspended, and if there's a serious lack of activity when I finally get sick of waiting, then I'm ending this game.
This is why you don't kill me, guys.
D=
D=
lol
I think I feel pressured to vote now to get some activity going
Vote: Powerdrone
He's inactive atm and not posting is a way of evading
I think I feel pressured to vote now to get some activity going
Vote: Powerdrone
He's inactive atm and not posting is a way of evading
Topic Starter
Bleh. Day started when there were 5 players.Wojjan wrote:
SPOILERIt's "day-ish". Votes don't count anyway. You're to blame for inactivity, Suburu.
someone else post
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
How so?
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
vote Powerdrone
that's what you get when youlet your heart win don't post
that's what you get when you
If you guys wouldn't mind, I'd like to drop out of this actually. Probably should have asked a long time ago.
Topic Starter
What? A lynch? Is that even possible?
Powerdrone was killed in a 1 in 1,000,000 (5) chance.
Night time, and sending new role to whomever's next in line.
Powerdrone was killed in a 1 in 1,000,000 (5) chance.
Night time, and sending new role to whomever's next in line.
Topic Starter
Noted, There's now a free spot open, but the game will continue on as normal.Powerdrone311 wrote:
If you guys wouldn't mind, I'd like to drop out of this actually. Probably should have asked a long time ago.
Thanks. Sorry I was so inactive and such. :/
The prosecution is ready to rock.
In other words, confirmed and ready.
In other words, confirmed and ready.
Topic Starter
I dost forgot to lable the thread night.
Night gets a little longer.
Night gets a little longer.
Topic Starter
Night will end by the end of this weekend.
Topic Starter
0_o and NoHItter die.
The game begins again.
3 to lynch.
The game begins again.
3 to lynch.
Vote: Diamond
This game really is a massive RVS, isn't it?adam2046 wrote:
Vote: Diamond
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
vote: DiamondCrash
Vote: nooodl
You bandwagoner.
You bandwagoner.
Topic Starter
I'll kill off Diamond once school isn't bogging me down. (Hosting a game during school, yeah, bad idea. I know.)
Topic Starter
Officially abandoned due to many things.
Mainly due to not only too much time passing, but also due to apperent lack of actual interest in the game.
Mainly due to not only too much time passing, but also due to apperent lack of actual interest in the game.