forum

Chihara Minori - Kyoukai no Kanata (TV Size)

posted
Total Posts
77
show more
Rakuen
( =`・ω・´) AIRakuen 愛楽園 (Mod/GD/M4M)

[General]
Could be improved.

You can make an Easy diff with slower SV compared to normal
Longer sliders and more spinners if suitable

Try AI Mod and see if you have anything needed to be fixed, like audio lead-in, letterboxes etc

Hitsounds...they're strange
Take a closer look at them

[Timing]
Offset seems a little bit early, the hitsounds appear faster than the music
Try to follow the piano cover for the most accurated offset, instead of vocal

Remember offset is very important in mapping a song

[Normal]
Since it's the easiest difficulty of your map, I suggest to do a full and constant DS, for example use 1.2x for the whole diff
00:01:039 (1,2) - For this kind of notes can try making it more like symmetry with Tiny grid size when snapping
00:03:647 (2) - Like this one too, try to make it same DS instead of 1.09x before and only 0.77x after
^ also make it blanket with 00:02:995 (1) - if possible
00:04:299 (3,4,5) - ^ Applies for the mods too
00:06:256 - There's a piano sound here, but seems the offset is not correct it will be strange
^ I suggest to put a circle or something there
00:07:560 (1) - Remove NC, doesnt seems necessary cuz no vocal change or something
00:11:473 - Heavy beat, and there should be a finish hitsound, try something there
00:14:734 (1) - The spacing is strange as mentioned in the previous mods, which is too close to the previous note
00:19:299 - Since there's a heavy beat here, try to make it "hittable" (like slider start or a circle) or put NC at 00:19:625 (4) - , either of them can actually improve the gameplay
00:22:071 (1) - Make spinner stops here, Heavy beat, and then map something at 00:25:169 -
00:31:039 (3,4) - Strange spacing, try a constant and same DS, would be very helpful on reading them
00:34:299 (4,1,2) - Confusing pattern cuz 00:35:278 (2) - is pointed by 00:34:299 (4) - and they are arranged too closely

Nothing much, strongly suggested to use a full and same DS for whole diff.
If you found the notes are too far when you're spacing them, try to add some in the white ticks like 01:02:669 - seems it's a HP drain part

[Hard]
Take a look at the KIAI times, it's not applied
00:00:712 (1,2) - Just saying, in hard diff 2 stacked circles will actually stop the folow for a little
00:01:039 (3) - NC, seems it's a heavy beat and the actual start of the song beat
00:10:169 (3) - I see no point slowing down the note, I prefer smoother flow
^ Or else NC it to inform players that NC is changed or so
00:11:473 (1,2,3,4,5) - Can try sliders, they look awful to play imo
00:14:734 (3,4) - Bad spacing, it looks too close compared to notes before or after
00:16:039 (5,6,7,8,9,1,2) - They should have same spacing, the timing is same and close
00:57:125 (2) - Some slider whistle like this is not necessary, remove them

The arrangements are changing too fast from time to time
The notes are too close to each other making them less flow and just lots of hits
If possible decrease the circles stacks too for better flow ;)

Hope my mods help
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
thanks for the modding, but I notice that the first part before 00:11:147 is not match a bit with the singer voice.
So I would change the offset of that.

thx. I will fix it tmr. :)
_DG
Hello there, awakened by the title of this song :)

I apologize if I suck at this

NORMAL

00:13:430 (4) - Is it by intent it is at x=256, not x=240 ?
00:29:082 (1,2,3) - not much of a deal, but 1 and 2 being closer than 2 and 3 ?

HARD

Good enough. I approve of it :)
Kiai time that short but not much of a deal

INSANE

00:08:865 (1,2) - Make it look like one curve slider? Something like this


00:17:017 (1,2) - Put the starting of slider 2 properly under slider 1? :)

VINCENT'S INSANE

00:13:104 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I noticed this kind of "jumps" are common in other people's maps
00:34:952 (1,2) - It looks nicer if you make them parallel in one line, but that's what I think
00:51:908 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Makes me feel like the volume can start from like 50% and increase up to the slider
01:16:691 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - What an interesting bit. I like it

END
What can I say? Nothing else but really well made :)
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
ALL FIXED. PLZ MOD :) :) :) :)
IamKwaN

- Miichan - wrote:

ALL FIXED. PLZ MOD :) :) :) :)
Nya Nya Neko
from my q
not94's Easy
osu file format v12

[General]
AudioFilename: Kyoukai no Kanata.mp3
AudioLeadIn: 1000
PreviewTime: 53077
Countdown: 0
SampleSet: Soft
StackLeniency: 0.7
Mode: 0
LetterboxInBreaks: 0
WidescreenStoryboard: 1

[Editor]
DistanceSpacing: 1.2
BeatDivisor: 4
GridSize: 4

[Metadata]
Title:Kyokai no Kanata (TV Size)
TitleUnicode:境界の彼方 (TV Size)
Artist:Chihara Minori
ArtistUnicode:茅原実里
Creator:- Miichan -
Version:not94's Easy
Source:Kyokai no Kanata
Tags:beyond the boundary, opening, mirai kuriyama, kyoto animation, daisuki, Vincent, Miichan, HKGOLDEN
BeatmapID:0
BeatmapSetID:-1

[Difficulty]
HPDrainRate:1
CircleSize:3
OverallDifficulty:1
ApproachRate:3
SliderMultiplier:0.8
SliderTickRate:1

[Events]
//Background and Video events
0,0,"BG.jpg",0,0
//Break Periods
//Storyboard Layer 0 (Background)
//Storyboard Layer 1 (Fail)
//Storyboard Layer 2 (Pass)
//Storyboard Layer 3 (Foreground)
//Storyboard Sound Samples
//Background Colour Transformations
3,100,163,162,255

[TimingPoints]
1074,325.926956521739,4,2,0,70,1,0
1085,-100,4,2,0,60,0,0
37577,-74.0740740740741,4,2,0,60,0,0
38881,-100,4,2,0,60,0,0
42792,-74.0740740740741,4,2,0,60,0,0
44096,-100,4,2,0,60,0,0
53222,-100,4,2,0,60,0,1
61696,-74.0740740740741,4,2,0,60,0,1
63651,-100,4,2,0,60,0,1
68866,-66.6666666666667,4,2,0,60,0,1
70822,-100,4,2,0,60,0,1
75385,-100,4,2,0,60,0,0
81907,357.142857142857,4,2,0,45,1,0
82622,375,4,2,0,30,1,0
83465,588.235294117647,4,2,0,30,1,0
84641,-100,4,2,0,5,0,0


[Colours]
Combo1 : 0,255,0
Combo2 : 0,0,255
Combo3 : 128,128,0
Combo4 : 128,0,64

[HitObjects]
133,182,1074,2,0,P|202:233|285:238,2,160,2|0|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
273,149,3029,2,0,P|233:144|202:119,1,80
281,64,3681,2,0,P|359:98|405:167,2,160,2|0|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
169,156,5636,2,0,P|240:250|350:295,1,240
382,204,6940,2,0,P|303:169|257:100,1,160,0|2,0:0|0:0,2:0:0:0:
381,101,8244,2,0,P|454:130|501:193,2,160,0|2|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
354,242,10199,2,0,P|275:207|229:138,2,160,2|0|6,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
334,147,11829,5,0,0:0:0:0:
366,56,12155,2,0,P|405:73|428:108,2,80,0|0|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
269,52,13133,1,0,0:0:0:0:
237,142,13459,2,0,P|197:124|174:90,2,80,0|0|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
215,235,14762,2,0,P|136:200|90:131,3,160,0|0|0|6,0:0|0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
213,132,17370,5,0,0:0:0:0:
373,135,18022,1,2,0:0:0:0:
290,272,18674,1,0,0:0:0:0:
156,216,19325,6,0,B|186:216|186:216|204:176|260:156,1,120,6|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
348,160,20303,2,0,B|396:177|414:217|414:217|444:217,1,120,4|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
292,243,21281,2,0,B|255:230|242:200|242:200|219:200,1,80
256,192,21770,12,0,25844,0:0:0:0:
120,224,27148,6,0,B|144:248|144:248|200:192|200:192|256:192,2,160,2|0|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
32,108,29103,1,0,0:0:0:0:
204,192,29755,1,2,0:0:0:0:
348,192,30407,2,0,B|394:192|394:192|450:248|450:248|474:224,2,160,0|2|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
204,192,32688,5,0,0:0:0:0:
156,192,33014,2,0,B|112:192|112:192|84:220,2,80,0|0|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
252,192,33992,2,0,B|296:192|296:192|324:164,2,80
256,96,34970,2,0,B|212:96|212:96|184:124,3,80,2|0|0|0,0:0|0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
252,192,36274,2,0,B|292:192|292:192|324:216|324:216|356:192|356:192|396:192,1,160,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
396,112,37577,6,0,B|356:112|356:112|324:88|324:88|292:112|292:112|248:112,2,162.000000617981,6|0|4,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
324,292,39207,6,0,L|324:252,4,40
320,204,40185,1,6,0:0:0:0:
250,112,40674,1,0,0:0:0:0:
180,204,41163,1,4,0:0:0:0:
36,196,41814,6,0,B|80:128|80:128|168:104,1,160
252,108,42792,2,0,B|328:128|328:128|376:200,2,162.000000617981,6|0|4,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
224,200,44259,2,0,B|271:212|271:212|301:257,2,100,2|0|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
212,296,45400,1,2,0:0:0:0:
212,94,46051,1,0,0:0:0:0:
384,196,46703,1,2,0:0:0:0:
211,295,47355,2,0,L|211:199,2,80,0|0|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
277,339,48333,1,0,0:0:0:0:
349,309,48659,1,0,0:0:0:0:
380,235,48985,1,0,0:0:0:0:
349,161,49311,1,2,0:0:0:0:
292,103,49637,6,0,L|213:43,2,80
264,195,50614,6,0,L|106:75,1,160,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
48,136,51918,6,0,L|302:329,1,320,2|6,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
396,352,53548,6,0,P|389:295|310:259,1,80,0|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
259,192,54363,1,0,0:0:0:0:
297,163,54526,2,0,P|331:143|370:143,1,80,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
409,55,55177,2,0,P|443:74|462:109,1,80,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
372,144,55829,2,0,P|303:104|224:104,2,160,2|2|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
284,180,57459,5,0,0:0:0:0:
228,256,57785,2,0,P|262:275|301:275,1,80,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
284,84,58763,2,0,P|249:64|210:64,1,80,0|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
224,160,59414,2,0,P|189:179|170:213,1,80,0|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
260,244,60066,2,0,P|259:283|279:317,2,80,0|2|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
356,260,61044,1,2,0:0:0:0:
284,84,61696,6,0,P|318:103|360:104,2,81.0000003089905,2|0|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
256,192,62348,12,0,63326,0:0:0:0:
248,120,63651,2,0,P|246:198|288:268,2,160,2|2|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
340,144,65281,2,0,P|339:183|360:218,2,80,0|2|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
148,124,66585,2,0,P|145:221|198:309,2,200,0|0|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
268,204,68866,6,0,B|300:204|300:204|344:160|344:160|416:232,1,180.000006866455,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
276,284,69844,2,0,B|244:284|244:284|200:328|200:328|128:256,1,180.000006866455
256,192,70822,12,2,72777,0:0:0:0:
48,88,73429,6,0,P|257:33|477:88,1,440,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
256,192,75385,12,2,79296,0:0:0:0:
178,153,79948,6,0,P|256:132|338:153,1,160,0|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
252,268,81252,2,0,P|173:288|91:268,1,160,0|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
236,148,82622,2,0,P|314:127|416:164,1,180,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
256,192,84641,12,0,88170,0:0:0:0:
Bara-
Hi, from testplay queue,
Sorry for late reply :(
Easy
Hey Not94, short time no see ;)
Please, use less kick sliders (Fast reverses in anything below Hard, even though it is 1/2, don't use it. Don't use sliders with more than 1 reverse in anything lower than hard
Normal
Good, except the reverse thing as said in Easy
Hard
Perfect
Insane
I HATE high BPM streams, since I can't do above 140-150BPM >.<
Insane
Same as other Insane, but I SUGGEST rename to extra, extreme, since it is very very hard

Download the .osr files HERE
Good map, and good lcuk!
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
thanks for ur modding and testplays. ;) ;) ;)
10crystalmask01
Ello, mod from queue 8-)
[General]
*Inconsistent combo colours in your diffs.
*00:53:212 - Kai time starts here, not at 00:53:048.
[Vincent's Insane]
00:01:085 (3) - NC, since it's the first object appearing in the offset.
00:04:671 (3,6) - Move more apart.
00:24:353 (1) - Add finish on the tail, to follow the cymbal crash heard in the music.
00:27:125 (1) - Add finish on the head.
00:37:559 (1,2,3) - ^
00:40:168 (1,2,3) - ^
00:42:777 (1,2,3) - ^
00:45:385 (1) - ^
00:47:994 (1) - ^
00:53:212 (3) - NC instead of 00:53:049 (1) - , because it's the first object that appears in Kai time.
00:54:353 (1,3) - Why not create a blanket here with these notes?
01:00:385 (2,4) - Clearly, you could've made a blanket here, so it helps create a neater flow for you objects.
01:19:951 (2,4) - Move more apart, they shouldn't be attached to each other. Also, while you add it, you can also make a blanket here.
01:21:581 (6,7) - Make le blanket?

[Insane]
00:02:715 (7) - Inconsistent jump here.
00:16:201 (2,3,4) - Interesting. Try adding a drum clap on all these notes. After you've highlighted and added the finish on all of them, adjust the Additions (shown on the top oft of the screen) to this:

00:42:777 (8) - NC for slider speed change.
00:45:385 (1) - Add finish on the head.
00:52:478 (8) - NC, so it doesn't the way the notes becomes a stream doesn't look too random.
00:57:451 (2,3,4) - Should all be NC for the slider speed change.

[Hard]
00:38:049 (5) - Add finish
00:45:385 (1) - ^ NC the head.
01:02:179 (2) - Add finish on the head.
01:03:646 (1) - ^

[Normal]
AR +1
00:14:081 (6,1) - Fix the DS here.
00:16:038 (3) - Add finish on the tail.
00:27:125 (1) - Add finish on the head.
00:33:646 (3,4) - Fix the DS here.
00:37:559 (1) - Add finish on all parts of this slider.
00:45:059 (2,3) - Fix the DS here.
01:03:646 (1) - Add finish on the head.
01:08:864 (4,5) - ^
01:21:907 (2,1) - Fix the DS here. Stacking these objects may help.

Make sure you check the DS consistency in this diff. All your objects should be snapped accordingly, in Normal/Easy diffs.

[not94's Easy]
*Unherited timing points here.
*Check that all your objects distances are snapped accordingly.
00:03:681 (3) - NC
00:06:940 (5) - ^
00:10:199 (7) - ^
00:16:718 (6) - ^ instead of 00:17:370 (1) - .
00:36:274 (6) - ^
00:37:577 (1) - Add finish on all parts of this slider.
00:40:674 (3) - Add finish.
00:42:792 (2) - Add finish on all parts of this slider.
00:45:400 (4) - NC
00:50:614 (1,1) - Add finish on the head. Plus, that NC on 00:51:918 (1) - isn't necessary.
00:55:829 (5,1) - Fix the blanket here.
01:06:585 (3) - NC
01:08:866 (1,2) - dd finish on the head.
01:13:429 (1) - Should start on 01:14:081 instead, so it can emphasize the cymbal crash in the music with a finish on the head.

Good luck.
Nya Nya Neko

10crystalmask01 wrote:

[not94's Easy]
*Unherited timing points here. fixed but now there are many unsapped objects
*Check that all your objects distances are snapped accordingly.
00:03:681 (3) - NC fixed
00:06:940 (5) - ^ fixed
00:10:199 (7) - ^fixed
00:16:718 (6) - ^ instead of 00:17:370 (1) - .?
00:36:274 (6) - ^ ?
00:37:577 (1) - Add finish on all parts of this slider.that sounds a bit too overused
00:40:674 (3) - Add finish. ^
00:42:792 (2) - Add finish on all parts of this slider.^
00:45:400 (4) - NCfixed
00:50:614 (1,1) - Add finish on the head. Plus, that NC on 00:51:918 (1) - isn't necessary. fixed
00:55:829 (5,1) - Fix the blanket here.fixed
01:06:585 (3) - NCfixed
01:08:866 (1,2) - dd finish on the head.fixed
01:13:429 (1) - Should start on 01:14:081 instead, so it can emphasize the cymbal crash in the music with a finish on the head.fixed
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
all fixed
Jehyeon_old
[not94's Easy]

00:14:733 (5) - add new combo please To emphasize the vocal
00:16:690 (6) - add finish please Add to emphasize the instrument will look better because.
00:17:342 (1) - why add finish? awkward delete please
00:21:744 (1) - I think the spinner to 00:24:516 - It is good to end. Think it is better to add the finish
00:44:244 (3) - slider end 00:44:733 - here
00:47:994 - add finish
01:01:690 (1) - same suggestion

01:03:646 - add finish
01:19:951 (2) - slider end 01:20:603 - here
01:21:255 (3) - slider end 01:21:581 - here and 01:21:907 - add note

[Normal]

00:22:070 (1) - same easy diff
00:31:690 (6) - ctrl + g and 00:32:342 - add note
00:38:048 - delete finish
00:43:266 - ^
01:10:168 - clap add please

good luck

i can't Hard insane diff mod.. sorry :o
Unsfamiliar
Mii-chan~!

From my queue:

Insane
  1. 00:01:085 (3) - Add a new combo. This is where the measure actually starts!
  2. 00:29:081 (1) - I think that this slider is too close to the previous object. Since you use a similar spacing here 00:28:266 (5,6) but with 1/2 in the timeline. 00:28:429 (6,1) has a 1/1 gap in between them, so I suggest you move (1) further away, or make this anti-jump more obvious. Part of the issue here is with your use of slider velocity, which I'll touch on later.
  3. 00:30:875 (2) - The flow of this note coming from the previous slider is a bit unorthodox, since it is the below the end of the slider and at a different angle to which you want to end up. To fix this I suggest you smooth the slider out and move the note up a bit:
  4. 00:31:038 (3,4) - Here, I think you could make these sliders less 'scrunched up'. This will make it play and look much nicer. It aloso fits with my previous suggestion to improve flow here.
    This arrangement works pretty well for me as it flows nice into the next section. If you prefer the way you had it, just make the sliders less curved like in the screenshot.
  5. 00:31:690 (5) - New combo to signal the change in slider velocity?
  6. 00:32:994 (2,3,4,5) - Woah, this is a fairly large jump sequence for a calm part of this song. I would recommend you decrease the spacing between these objects a little. Another reason to decrease the spacing is because you start to use smaller spacing here 00:33:646 (6,7,8). Going from such large spacing to small spacing disrupts flow quite heavily here and might even cause people to misread 00:33:646 (6,7,8).
  7. 00:46:690 (7) - I don't see why you need to use 1.25x velocity here. 1.0x is fine in my opinion. If anything, it should be slower to represent the long vocal.
  8. 00:51:907 (1) - I like the idea of the gradual increase in volume, but I would not start it off at 5% :o It's kinda hard to hit the beginning of this stream when I can hardly hear any hitsounds. Increase the volume a bit please, 30% as a minimum.
  9. 01:08:212 - Add a note here please, I can can hear a drum in the song. Otherwise, there is an awkward 1/1 gap :/
  10. 01:08:864 (1,2,3,4) - This is solely my opinion, but I don't think I'm fond of this sudden directional change to 01:09:353 (4). I know you're trying to emphasise this note for the vocal, but I think if you place it along the same vector line (i.e the same direction) as the triple it would make more sense and play a lot better.
  11. 01:09:842 (1,2,3,4) - Same sort of thing as I mentioned above :)
  12. 01:27:561 - Make the end of this spinner 5% percent volume so the hitsound doesn't ring out.
  13. Ok, about the slider velocities. I feel you are trying to experiment with them too much, making the slider speed fluctuate unnecessarily. For example, you sometimes use 1.0 here, or 0.8 there, or even 1.25 randomly. I would highly recommend you try to structure your map with corresponding slider velocities better, by not overusing them. I would suggest about 3 different ones at most: a normal slider velocity (1.0 for most of the song), a slower slider velocity (for the start for example, and the earlier part of the verse), and a faster slider velocity (for the kiai time if you want). This is just my opinion on this, but too much variation could be a bit confusing and mess up you spacing. Well, just consider this and make your own judgment :)

Vincent's Insane
  1. Oh it's Vincent again, hi o/
  2. 00:04:998 (4,5) - I think you should just make this one slider that extends from 00:04:998 - 00:05:324. It would match the vocal much better and there honestly isn't anything audible on 00:05:161.
  3. 00:05:976 (1,2,3,4,5) - People's opinions differ when it comes to what over-mapping is, but I really think this is. 5 1/4 notes mapped to nothing in the song is how I see it. I feel it just adds unnecessary complexity to the map where the song does not warrant such. A 1/1 slider on the white ticks would work much nicer to catch those notes you can hear.
  4. 00:10:170 (3,4) - This rhythm could be improve to follow the vocal: a slider to start it off (with the end catching the guitar) and a note to follow the end of the vocal.
    This can be varied, but having the same effect. Just start it off with a slider, then it should be fine!
  5. 00:14:081 (7,8) - ctrl+g this on the timeline? To follow the 'ma' lyric or whatever it is.

Hard
  1. 00:05:976 - Any reason why you haven't mapped a note here? The guitar should me mapped here, since not much else is going on, otherwise there is an awkward gap imo.

Easy
  1. 01:01:690 (1) - If you slow down your play back rate, you will hear that the reverse does not actually land on the blue tick! I would recommend you remove the reverse and just make it a normal slider. You should probably avoid mapping on blue ticks in an easy difficulty anyway...

Ok, those are the main things I could find. Good luck!

Star for support :3
Nya Nya Neko

gpq123 wrote:

[not94's Easy]

00:14:733 (5) - add new combo please To emphasize the vocal fixed
00:16:690 (6) - add finish please Add to emphasize the instrument will look better because.fixed
00:17:342 (1) - why add finish? awkward delete pleasefixed
00:21:744 (1) - I think the spinner to 00:24:516 - It is good to end. Think it is better to add the finish no because the spinner is following the vocals
00:44:244 (3) - slider end 00:44:733 - here fixed
00:47:994 - add finishfixed
01:01:690 (1) - same suggestionfixed

01:03:646 - add finishfixed
01:19:951 (2) - slider end 01:20:603 - herefixed
01:21:255 (3) - slider end 01:21:581 - here and 01:21:907 - add noteyou're right, but I did something else

Unsfamiliar wrote:

Easy
  1. 01:01:690 (1) - If you slow down your play back rate, you will hear that the reverse does not actually land on the blue tick! I would recommend you remove the reverse and just make it a normal slider. You should probably avoid mapping on blue ticks in an easy difficulty anyway...
Fixed
LucyS
Hi Miichan
I like your song, take a mod =3

[not94's Eazy]
  1. 00:03:693 (1) - Move to 264, 68?
  2. 00:06:961 (1) - Use distance snap 1,0x, it's good not change the spacing
  3. 00:14:733 (1) - this may confuse, increase the distance, move to 184, 292
  4. 00:29:733 (3) - Move to 184, 100
  5. 00:42:777 (2) - should not increase the slider velocity here and in the others, is so hard for a eazy diff
  6. 00:40:168 (2,3,4) - Decrease distance
  7. 00:54:353 (2,3) - Simplify the rhythm here, http://puu.sh/7oTP0.jpg
  8. 01:03:646 (1) - Move to 252, 188
  9. 01:05:277 (2) - Move to 328, 208
  10. 01:06:581 - Try this rhythm http://puu.sh/7oUiQ.jpg


[Normal]
  1. 00:14:081 (6) - Decrease the distance
  2. 00:17:016 (1) - Suggestion:
  3. 00:33:646 (3) -
  4. 00:44:409 - Add a note?
  5. 01:19:299 (1) -
  6. 01:20:603 (3,1,2) -
[Hard]
  1. Decrease 1 AR plz, i think it better for this song
  2. 00:10:170 (1) - not cool increase the slider velocity here, it's better here 00:10:170 (1)
  3. 00:12:451 (4,5) - Move to 432, 320?
  4. 00:21:581 - Add a note here and 00:21:744 ?
  5. 00:23:538 (3) - Add a normal hit in the head
  6. 00:37:396 (3) - Move to 208, 112
  7. 00:56:309 (2,3) - Overlap these better
  8. 01:20:277 (4) - Move to 400, 232
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
wow

surprise,

thanks for your modding :) :) :) :)
DeletedUser_2243638
Hi~ Here are some of my mods

not94's Easy

00:21:255 Add finish, sounds epic~
01:01:038 ^
01:02:179 ^
01:08:864 + 01:09:842 I think the two sliders are too fast for an easy diff, try slow them down or use circles instead


Normal

00:27:125 remove finish because it doesn't really fit to that quiet point
00:40:657 remove finish
00:41:146 add finish
00:43:755 ^
01:01:038 ^
01:01:690 remove the last reverse at the end of the slider
01:18:646 remove clap because it gets quiet in this point
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old

Julini wrote:

Hi~ Here are some of my mods



Normal

00:27:125 remove finish because it doesn't really fit to that quiet point fixed
00:40:657 remove finishfixed
00:41:146 add finishfixed
00:43:755 ^ fixed
01:01:038 ^ fixed
01:01:690 remove the last reverse at the end of the slider NO?becoz there is a heavy beat
01:18:646 remove clap because it gets quiet in this point fixed
Love
Modding from my googlequeue.

[General]
The map is very monotone-sounding, which is against the guidelines. Try adding claps where you hear snares in the song itself to fix this problem.
Change the artist name to Minori Chihara.
The timing is wrong. The BPM should be 185 universal until the ending slow down. So change all of the 184 bpm timings to 185. Don't forget to click the box next to "Snap objects to new timing" and "Resnap slider lengths." Also snap 00:11:492's timing section and remove the timing section at 00:11:799.
Use this map for reference: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/120257 - Take the mp3, video and timing, just make sure you credit and link the map in the creator's notes.

[Vincent's Insane]
You should continue using hitsounds like you did at 00:47:994 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7). This was perfect.
00:00:921 (2) - Try stacking this on 00:00:758 (1), it looks a little bit better here.
00:04:998 (4) - Should keep whistling the 4/1's you have, like the slider end of 00:05:650 (5).
00:06:798 (2) - Stack this on 00:06:472 (1) as well
00:08:876 (1) - Whistle the beginning of this slider.
00:10:170 (3) - Another whistle at the beginning of this slider as well.
00:26:146 (2) - I'd highly suggest changing this, it breaks a lot of flow, maybe try something like this:
http://puu.sh/7sa5T.jpg
00:42:614 - Add a note here to continue the toms that you used earlier at 00:40:005 (7).
01:10:331 (6) - Why isn't this in a same spot as 01:09:353 (3) was after the slider before. Move 01:10:331 (6) to x:384 y:80 to make it consistant with that.
01:10:820 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This is overmapped and shouldn't be mapped like this at all. You can have a 1/2 notes on 01:10:820 - 01:10:983 -
01:11:146 -
01:11:309 -
and then a slider at 01:11:472.
01:11:635 (1,2,3,4) - These sliders ruin beat placement. Try using a 1/2 slider and then remapping these 4 into sliders and 1 note starting from 01:11:798. The end of 01:12:614 (4) - should be the note.

[Insane]
00:37:559 (1,1) - Why aren't these consistent with 00:42:777 (1)? You should change these to match what you have later on.
01:14:081 (4) - This shouldn't be a repeat slider. Try a spinner at 01:14:081 and then finish it at 01:15:059, removing the note placed there.
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old

Love wrote:

Modding from my googlequeue.

[General]
The map is very monotone-sounding, which is against the guidelines. Try adding claps where you hear snares in the song itself to fix this problem.
Change the artist name to Minori Chihara.
The timing is wrong. The BPM should be 185 universal until the ending slow down. So change all of the 184 bpm timings to 185. Don't forget to click the box next to "Snap objects to new timing" and "Resnap slider lengths." Also snap 00:11:492's timing section and remove the timing section at 00:11:799.
Use this map for reference: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/120257 - Take the mp3, video and timing, just make sure you credit and link the map in the creator's notes.fixed

[Insane]
00:37:559 (1,1) - Why aren't these consistent with 00:42:777 (1)? You should change these to match what you have later on. FIXED
01:14:081 (4) - This shouldn't be a repeat slider. Try a spinner at 01:14:081 and then finish it at 01:15:059, removing the note placed there. I hv tried to do that.. but I feel a bit not good enough :(
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
added hitsound
Ajo Joestar
Hi.
Mmm, there's so mani slider speed change on both insane diff . Remember that there shouldn't be more than 3 unless they are intuitive.
00:57:134 (1,1,1,1) - like here, on insane, you are using some slow sliders over the kiai, i personally don't feel it so natural while playing, specially with all these jumps and the spread stream before it.
And then, (on Vincent's insane 01:24:620 (1) - for example ), while the slow ending, it goes kinda fast, i say you should change the ending here.
And as i said before, try less sliders speed change, imo, longer spacing on kiai, than the intro (right now it's like the same), and less spacing on the ending of the song, wich is slower.
That's all. Good luck.
keeeeeeko
Hi.
from my queue.
Quick mod.
Be careful. Close means close.

[General]
  1. Missing Skin Files.
    hitcircleoverlay.png approachcircle.png reversearrow.png
  2. Song title is Kyoukai no Kanata (and source)
  3. Romanaised Artist is "Chihara Minori"
    Ranking Criteria wrote
    Eastern artists must be written in the proper 'surname firstname' format
  4. add tage "not94"
  5. Why you use different combo colours? I think you should unify all diffs.
  6. uncheck Widscreen Support.
  7. You should use more hitsounds. Please refer to Vincent's diff hitsounds.
  8. PreviewTime isn't snappend. 00:53:058 - or 00:53:221 - is better.
[not94's Easy]

  • You shouldn't change DS and SV.This is Easy diff.
    HP+1 OD+1
  1. 00:21:744 unsnapped inherited point.
  2. 00:05:625 (2) - slider end isn't snapped
  3. 00:08:254 (2) - Slider repeat and end isn't snapped.
  4. 01:22:627 (4) - ^
  5. 00:49:635 (1,1,1) - This NC is not needed.just ONE new Combo at 00:49:635 (1) -
[Normal]

  • 00:27:138 (1) - ~ 00:51:917 (3) - Where is hitsounds?:o
  1. 00:18:999 (3) - slider end isn't snapped
  2. 00:08:254 (5) - ^
  3. 01:22:622 (1,1) - remove sliderwhistle
[Hard]
  1. 00:33:658 (1,2) - remove sliderwhistle
  2. 00:34:963 (1) - ^
  3. 01:04:633 (5) - ^
  4. 01:06:589 (1,2,5) - ^
  5. 01:11:643 (2,4,6) - ^
  6. 00:09:848 (3) - slider end isn't snapped
  7. 00:17:350 (2) - ^
[Insane]
  1. 00:52:315 - unsnapped inherited point
Good luck.
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
okay lol

for now, I need to talk about the artist XD
Someone stated that the artist should be Chihara Minori and someone say it should be Minori Chihara, I dont really know because Im not Japanese,
What I know is there are 2 ranked version of Kyokai no Kanata, the artist of one of them is Chihara Minori , another one is Minori Chihara.
I got mad :o :o :o :o

anyway, I will set it as Chihara Minori :P :P :P
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old

keeeeeeko wrote:

Hi.
from my queue.
Quick mod.
Be careful. Close means close.

[General]
  1. Missing Skin Files.
    hitcircleoverlay.png approachcircle.png reversearrow.png
  2. Song title is Kyoukai no Kanata (and source)
  3. Romanaised Artist is "Chihara Minori"
    Ranking Criteria wrote
    Eastern artists must be written in the proper 'surname firstname' format
  4. add tage "not94"
  5. Why you use different combo colours? I think you should unify all diffs.
  6. uncheck Widscreen Support.
  7. You should use more hitsounds. Please refer to Vincent's diff hitsounds.
  8. PreviewTime isn't snappend. 00:53:058 - or 00:53:221 - is better.
FIXED


[Normal]

  • 00:27:138 (1) - ~ 00:51:917 (3) - Where is hitsounds?:o
  1. 00:18:999 (3) - slider end isn't snapped I think its fine
  2. 00:08:254 (5) - ^
  3. 01:22:622 (1,1) - remove sliderwhistle
[Hard]
  1. 00:33:658 (1,2) - remove sliderwhistle
  2. 00:34:963 (1) - ^
  3. 01:04:633 (5) - ^
  4. 01:06:589 (1,2,5) - ^
  5. 01:11:643 (2,4,6) - ^
  6. 00:09:848 (3) - slider end isn't snapped I think its fine
  7. 00:17:350 (2) - ^
[Insane]
  1. 00:52:315 - unsnapped inherited point


Good luck.
desudesud
P4M mod here

[General]
This is a TV Size song, so it should usually go with some sort of video, considering this version is made for TV for some sort of anime
Love the Skin! :D

[Easy]
General - I didn't list them, but you NEED to follow Distance Snap (DS), ESPECIALLY on an Easy difficulty like this. Go back in with AiMod and fix all 11 Distance Snap errors ASAP

00:48:330 (5,6,7,8) - Replace into one repeating slider of the same beat length
01:22:622 (4) - Unsnapped end

[Normal]
General - You need to follow DS

00:06:309 (1) - Add clap hitsound
00:12:302 - DS error, fix ASAP
00:13:437 - DS error, fix ASAP
00:13:924 - DS error, fix ASAP
00:18:999 (3) - Object's end not snapped
00:31:050 (6,7) - For both of the sliders, make it the same length, but with no repeat
00:47:515 - DS error, fix ASAP
01:01:698 (2) - Replace with a spinner from the beginning of this slider to 01:03:002

[Hard]
This is the best diff out of the 3 I modded.

General - Move HP Drain to 6

00:50:776 (2,3) - Unnecessary overmapping
00:51:428 (5,6) - Unnecessary overmapping
01:05:937 (10) - Stack this right on the end of the previous slider
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old

xVirtualNinjax wrote:

P4M mod here

[General]
This is a TV Size song, so it should usually go with some sort of video, considering this version is made for TV for some sort of anime
Love the Skin! :D done

[Normal]
General - You need to follow DS

00:06:309 (1) - Add clap hitsound fixed
00:12:302 - DS error, fix ASAPfixed
00:12:302 - DS error, fix ASAPfixed
00:13:437 - DS error, fix ASAPfixed
00:13:924 - DS error, fix ASAPfixed
00:18:999 (3) - Object's end not snapped I think its fine
00:31:050 (6,7) - For both of the sliders, make it the same length, but with no repeat fixed
00:47:515 - DS error, fix ASAP fixed
01:01:698 (2) - Replace with a spinner from the beginning of this slider to 01:03:002 good idea

[Hard]
This is the best diff out of the 3 I modded.

General - Move HP Drain to 6 fixed

00:50:776 (2,3) - Unnecessary overmapping fixed
00:51:428 (5,6) - Unnecessary overmapping fixed
01:05:937 (10) - Stack this right on the end of the previous slider why? :? :?
thanks for the modding :) :) :)
Hinsvar
Hello; modding as requested!

And the correct artist name according to the rules here is Chihara Minori, btw. You're already correct.

*Bolded = Unrankable or very, very strongly suggested; red = Highly suggested or questionable (still weaker than the bolded ones); black = Minor suggestions/rants; blue = Notes/advices to avoid/fix repeated problems. Also note that hitsound suggestions on a diff may apply on similar parts of the song and the other diffs of the mapset.

>General
  1. Remove all the commas on the tags. Tagging doesn't work that way here.
>not94's Easy
  1. 00:01:085 (1,2) - Any reason why the spacing is inconsistent here? I think you can just move (1) a little further from (2).
  2. 00:06:274 - Add a whistle? There's a clear piano sound here, so why not?
  3. 00:17:350 (1,3) - Hmm, add claps here? They fit pretty well with the instruments.
  4. 00:21:269 (3) - Move to (388,300) so the pattern here will be neater? Also, is the clap here an accident? It doesn't seem intentional, but if it is, remove the one on the head, at it doesn't fit with the song at all.
  5. 00:32:354 - You should really add a circle with a finish here since it feels too empty without one.
  6. 00:32:680 (1,2) - Uh, please use 1.0x distance spacing here, as a spacing change as drastic as this will definitely confuse typical Easy players.
  7. 00:38:060 - There should be a finish too, to follow the cymbal.
  8. 00:40:668 (3) - ^
  9. 00:43:277 - ^
  10. 00:45:396 (1) - ^
  11. 00:46:048 (2) - Having a whistle here would be wonderful to follow the instruments.
  12. 00:51:917 (2) - The NC isn't necessary, since this slider is still in the same stanza as 00:50:613 (1).
  13. 00:50:613 (1) - Remove the finish? It just doesn't fit.
  14. 00:54:199 (2) - Add a clap to make sure the hitsounding is consistent in this diff.
  15. 00:58:764 - ^
  16. 01:01:046 (6) - Add a finish to follow the cymbal too?
  17. 01:02:187 - ^
  18. 01:03:002 (2) - Remove the clap? It feels redundant and also conflicts with the one at 01:02:676.
  19. 01:05:285 - Add a clap? Same reason as 00:54:199 (2).
  20. 01:05:937 - ^
  21. 01:06:589 - ^
  22. 01:14:088 - Try to add a finish here?
  23. 01:15:066 - Oh, and add a clap here too?
>Normal
  1. 00:01:085 - 00:10:822 - Remove all claps here since they don't fit the instruments at this part, please. Then try to use another hitsounding pattern; for example, add a whistle every first and third white tick of every stanza? The whistles should go along pretty well with the song.
  2. 00:13:437 - Remove the clap here, then add a clap at 00:13:113 (4) and 00:13:762 so the hitsounding here will be more consistent?
  3. 00:17:350 - 00:18:999 - Add claps every two white ticks? Same reason as the whistles at 00:01:085 - 00:10:822.
  4. 00:19:639 (1,3) - The whistles aren't necessary, I think... I suppose you should just remove them.
  5. 00:21:595 - Add a clap?
  6. 00:27:790 (2) - Move this to (460,176)? It looks neater, IMO.
  7. 00:31:050 (6,7) - Don't you think these sliders are too close to each other? Try moving (7) to (224,108) maybe? (You'll have to fix the spacing error that results from this, though!)
  8. 00:38:060 - Add a finish since there's an audible cymbal sound? Feels empty to leave it unhitsounded.
  9. 00:40:668 - ^
  10. 00:43:277 - ^
  11. 00:45:396 - ^
  12. 00:48:004 - ^
  13. 00:54:525 (3) - Move the middle node to (48,296) and the one on the tail to (-4,272)? Looks tidier this way.
  14. 01:03:655 (1) - Make it look like this for a better flow, and again, to make it look tidier?
  15. 01:08:871 - Add a finish to be consistent with 01:09:849?
  16. 01:10:175 - Remove the clap here since it's empty here in the song?
  17. 01:14:088 (2) - Try to make this symmetrical by playing with the nodes? It doesn't look appealing the way it is currently...
  18. 01:21:587 (1) - Remove the whistle? It conflicts with the other whistles around it.
  19. 01:22:997 - Add a whistle to follow the piano?
>Hard
  1. The spacing looks pretty inconsistent... I'd say to only use up to three spacing values to be used consistently whenever you're not making a jump. It looks pretty messy as is. And the overall placement does look kinda unstructured. Try to make them look more appealing.
  2. 00:01:085 - 00:10:822 - Same as Normal, but using the default Soft sampleset.
  3. 00:37:571 (4) - NC this since the song's rhythm "resets" (I don't really have any better word for this, but I hope you get what I meant) here?
  4. 00:41:157 - Add a finish to be consistent with 00:38:549 (3)?
  5. 00:42:788 (6,1) - Swap NC? I think the combo pattern is more correct this way.
  6. 00:45:396 - Add a finish too, to follow that loud cymbal sound?
  7. 00:48:004 - ^
  8. 01:01:046 (4) - Add a finish? It should be obvious why after listening to the song here!
  9. 01:03:002 (1,2,3,4) - Make the spacing consistent so it won't be confusing?
  10. 01:03:655 - Add a finish?
  11. 01:05:611 (9,10) - I understand why are you making this kind of rhythm, but it's really not recommended since it's not accurately following the song at all. I suggest to simply use a 1/1 slider.
  12. 01:09:360 (4) - Move to (488,312) so 01:08:871 (1,2,3,4) will form a straight line? Looks neater like that, IMO.
  13. 01:09:849 (1,2,3,4) - Also make this a straight line too?
  14. 01:14:088 (6) - It's also not recommended to use a slider with multiple repeats since it can be really confusing to players because they don't know when will the slider ends. Just split this into a few sliders and/or circles.
  15. 01:20:283 - Add a whistle here to follow the piano?
  16. 01:21:261 (1) - There is nothing notable enough on the repeat for a whistle to be used on it, so remove it and add one at 01:21:261 and 01:21:913 instead?
  17. 01:22:997 - Again, add a whistle here to follow the piano?
>Insane
  1. 00:01:085 - 00:10:822 - Same as Normal and Hard. And I just noticed something... Why is the sample usage very different between difficulties?
  2. 00:05:949 (1) - Remove the NC? There is no need of an NC here, really.
  3. 00:07:606 (4) - Move this to (272,240) so it'll look neater here?
  4. 00:14:735 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - Uh, the music doesn't support these twelve consecutive claps, which makes them sound very, VERY annoying (objectively of course). The best start here would be to remove all of them.
  5. 00:22:573 (5,6) - Ctrl+G for a better flow?
  6. 00:26:485 (3,4) - ^
  7. 00:31:702 (5) - Use an NC to indicate that this slider is slower than the usual ones?
  8. 00:37:571 - Add a finish?
  9. 00:41:157 (2) - ^
  10. 00:42:788 (9,1) - Swap NC so the combo pattern will be consistent like the previous two combos before them?
  11. 00:51:917 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Uh, remove all the hitsounds here (except the finish on 00:51:917 (1)), then add a clap on 00:52:243 (5), a whistle on 00:52:651 (3), and another clap on 00:52:895 (6)? The current hitsounding is... kinda similar to 00:14:735 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1) in terms of quality, if I have to be blunt (sorry, couldn't find a better wording lol). A simpler hitsounding would do better.
  12. 01:09:686 (1) - You shouldn't map an empty part of the song like this one because it'd be confusing. And NOT silencing it, as it'll only lead to extreme awkwardness and confusion in the players' side. Just remove this, please.
  13. 01:14:088 - Add a finish? I think it fits with the song...
  14. 01:14:088 (4,1) - Swap NC? It follows the music's rhythm more correctly this way.
  15. 01:21:913 - Whistle to follow the piano?
  16. 01:22:622 - 01:23:444 - ^ (Everything in this range, I mean.)
>Vincent's Insane
  1. 00:01:085 - 00:10:822 - While adding a whistle only once every stanza is relatively correct, many piano notes here are stronger on the third white ticks. I suggest to add the whistles there too, not just the first white ticks (at 00:01:733 (2) and 00:03:030 (5), for example).
  2. 00:17:350 - I'd say to use the S:C2 clap here (or maybe just try to play with the S:C2 sample in the entire diff). It fits pretty well with the instrument.
  3. 00:17:021 (2,3) - These objects are too close to each other, making them feel weird to play. Consider giving more space?
  4. 00:21:921 (3) - Apply NC here since the music's rhythm "resets" (?) and starts to become stronger here?
  5. 00:29:094 (1,2,3) - What's with the inconsistency in spacing? Value-wise, they are consistent, but that's because the spacing calculation becomes different when you're changing the slider velocity. Try to make the spacing between them visually equal. This pattern will look neater that way.
  6. 00:30:398 (1,2,3) - ^
  7. 00:29:420 (3,4) - Make the spacing between them bigger (maybe 1.8x or something) so they'll be more comfortable to play?
  8. 00:45:396 - Add a finish here? I think it's obvious why.
  9. 00:50:613 (4,6) - Add NCs here since they're the start of entirely different patterns? Also, add a finish on (4)?
  10. 00:51:917 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Same case as 00:51:917 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) in Miichan's Insane diff.
  11. 01:01:046 - Add a finish? The music here really calls for it, IMO.
  12. 01:02:187 - ^
  13. 01:03:655 (1) - Drag this one grid down so the spacing at 01:03:002 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) will be consistent?
  14. 01:08:382 - Remove the finish since there's nothing that sounds like it in the song?
  15. 01:08:382 (1,2) - Swap NC because the music's rhythm only "resets" when (2) appears? I personally think that they shouldn't be like this on the first place, as the symmetry here implies that (1) is on the same stanza as (2), while it isn't really the case. Just try to only integrate (I hope you know what I'm talking about...) (1) into the 01:06:589 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) combo, and (2) only with 01:09:360 (3,4,5,6).
  16. 01:19:957 (2,4) - Try to make something like this? It looks tidier and it'll make this part look nicer.
  17. 01:20:283 (3) - Move this to (96,144) so the spacing will be more consistent and thus the pattern here will look neater? Also, add a whistle here and remove the one at 01:20:609 because the piano on the tick where this circle is... is stronger?
  18. 01:21:261 (5) - Add a whistle here too since the piano is pretty audible?
Hmm... This map really needs a lot of work. You should've expected it though, this being your first map.

You guys are pretty good in terms of rhythm, but the placement, hitsounding, flow, and slider shapes obviously need to be reworked. You'll need to get some very experienced (and patient!) modders here in order to guide you through everything. I'm not really patient in this kind of stuff, so sorry, I'm afraid I cannot give further support.

There will always be a way to get stuff done if you really want to do it, though!

Good luck on the way 8-)
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
just hv fixed what u suggested, thanks dear Hinsvar :D :D

I will keep working on it, thanks for such professional modding! :D :D
Swayzo_old
30 min free mod:
Your insane:
SPOILER
Overall: More sliders to match the singing
00:15:302 (9,1) - slider 1 on top of the drum roll
00:17:350 (2) - snapped about 1.5 further from 1
00:18:010 (1,2,3) - 1 and 3 curves
00:19:163 add note
00:37:571 (1) - make it 1 beat long, add a slider @ 00:38:060 that is also at 1 beat long, and same with 00:38:549
00:40:179 (1,2) - ^
00:42:788 (1,2) - ^

Hard:
SPOILER
00:01:085 (1,2) - slider 1 curving downwards, 2 is curving up wards
00:19:965 (3,4,5,6) - make them trail instead of going over eachother
00:21:269 (9) - 1/2 long slider
00:53:058 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - too many hitsounds
01:06:915 (2,5) - sliders going on top of eachother
Voxnola

Mod from queue~
4th time modding something. Sorry if I'm not helpful I'm new at modding >.>
[General]
Multiple red ticks for timing gets me weary for a really short map. You should get someone to check the timing for you
[not49's Easy]
There's some inconsistent spacing in this map. Be sure to properly DS things to 1.00x pls. This makes it hard for modders to mod. Please fix it.
Ctrl + Shift + A to check distance

00:27:138 (1,3) - these make a weird overlap. It shows while playing, consider moving the 1 downward (keeping DS) or maybe stack 1 with 3
00:30:398 (4,1,2) - these are pretty condensed and the DS isn't consistent here.
00:51:917 (1) - maybe it would be cool to shorten this slider to 00:52:895 - and then have a circle at 00:53:221 - I think it makes more sense to have something start at the kiai rather then a slider to end at the kiai
you could have something like this: 01:06:589 (1) - this breaks ds too. make sure everything is 1.00x
01:08:871 (1,2) - a bit close in my opinion
That's it for this diff::::Please fix the DS problems

[Normal]
00:16:032 (3,1) - maybe form a blanket? 00:29:746 (3,6,7,1) - that's a lot of straight sliders :p Maybe consider having some curvy flow?
00:47:678 (7) - maybe stack with the head of 00:48:004 (1) ? 7 also breaks DS
That's it for this diff:::: o3o

[Hard]
Maybe AR+1? There's some hard to read things in here
Like this 00:19:965 (3,4,5,6) - That's pretty hard to read for this AR
00:30:398 (1,2) - weird overlap. It's noticeable in game
00:31:376 (4) - awkward antijump, It looks like it's the same distance from 3 as it is with 2 and 3. Since the ar is 7 it's pretty hard to read and I'm not sure that it goes well with the song either.
00:36:267 (5) - maybe finish on the slider end and have normal sample set on this : 00:37:082 (1) -
00:49:309 (1,2,3,4) - idea? something like this?: 01:03:002 (1,2,3,4,1) - whew things like this are pretty hard to read
That's it for this diff:::: o3o Overall I think you should use more ds in this diff. Especially if you're going to keep it ar7

[Insane]
00:18:669 (3) - Ctrl + G for better flow?
01:00:231 (2,3,4,5,6) - maybe make them so that they look a bit more symmetrical: 01:21:913 (2) - Ctrl + G for better flow?
That's it for this diff::: dayummm I couldn't play it because I'm too newb at playing

[Vincent's Insane]
00:26:648 (4,5) - these should have some sort of hitsounding. It feels a bit empty here (the 4)
00:31:213 (4,5,6,7) - awkward flow, consider switching 6 and 5? I don't see any reason for there to be a jump. you can always increase the spacing but it's better to have good flow. I doesn't feel too bad when playing it so this isn't really important
01:21:913 (7) - Ctrl + G?
01:22:622 (8) - ^
01:23:444 (1) - ^
That's it for this diff:::: o3o



wejiofwaekladsm, Sorry for my bad modding skills though
Good luck for ranked! ^^
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
mates , thanks for modding, I will fix it ASAP

:D :D :D :D :D
hoshisorakiseki
你好,
from pm,最近有点事,晚了一点

difficulty:not94's easy
00:11:816 (1,2,3,4) - clap is a little loudly...prefer to change to a quteter one.
00:21:758 (1) - the end is nearly silence ... i don't know it's unrank or not, but i prefer to make it a little loudly.
01:22:622 (4) - unsnap (aimod)

difficulty:normal
00:10:822 (3) - 这里前面所有note的音效有点单调...在其中加入一些whistle会好很多
00:14:735 (1,2,3) - 这些感觉都可以加finish,音比较重
00:18:999 (3) - unsnap (aimod)

difficulty:hard
replay-->http://puu.sh/7yQRm.osr
00:09:848 (3) - unsanp (aimod)

difficulty:insane
00:14:735 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - 不打算拉一条线出来?
00:51:917 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - 好长的连打
01:19:305 (3,4,5,6,7) - 3和4最好上移一点,整个五边形不太规则

difficulty:Vincent's insane
i think it's ok

加油
[ Joey ]
Hello Miichan!
From my modding queue


[not94's Easy]

00:03:679 (1,2) - I think it would look better if these two sliders mirror'd each other.
00:05:625 (2,1) – I don't think these sliders look good next to each other. Do something that looks like this maybe?
00:39:201 (1,2,3) – You can make this more of a straight line. I will show you in picture:
00:42:788 (2,3) – I could be wrong, but I don't think these are perfectly blanketed.
00:45:396 (1,2,3,4) – 1, 2, 3, and the head of 4 should make a more symmetrical shape.
01:19:305 – I suggest you lower the slider velocity here
00:53:547 (1) – I don't think a finish belongs here.
01:02:187 – Add finish here

[Normal]

00:04:328 (5,6) – Blanket these?
00:20:291 (2) – What do you think of this rhythm? I think it sounds better
Finish here 00:19:313 - and here 00:20:291 -
00:46:700 (6) – I think this slider should be straight and parallel to this slider 00:46:048 (5) -
01:08:871 (4) – New combo
01:09:849 (5) – Ctrl + g?


[Hard]

00:19:313 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) – There was something about this combo that didn't feel right to me when I was playing it. I think it is because I wasn't expecting any notes right here 00:20:128 -
What do you think of this? Remove these hit circles 00:19:965 (3,4) - and make this slider a reverse slider 00:19:639 (2) - So it ends here 00:19:965 -
00:30:398 (1,2) – I personally don't like how these overlap, but its not a big deal
Another suggestion: Remove these 00:55:177 (9,10) - and add a 1/1 slider here? 00:55:177 -
01:15:229 – Spinner should start here

[Insane]

00:17:021 (1) – I think this slider would look better flipped horizontally
00:20:128 (1,2,3,4,5,6) – Sounds cool if these are drum hitsounds
00:37:571 (1,2) - Feels better if these are 1/1 sliders.
00:40:179 (1,2) - ^
Suggestion: Hit circle here 00:44:092 - . Reverse ½ slider here 00:44:255 - .
00:58:112 (4) – Flows better if you lower this slider just a little bit
Finishes here 01:09:360 (4) - and here 01:10:338 (8) - ?
Very fun difficulty
Here is my replay and score (lol I'm bad)

[Vincent's Insane]

00:42:788 (1,2,3) - I like these but I think you should make them look a little different than the previous ones, or else it gets repetitive.
00:19:313 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) – This section doesn't go well with music imo.
01:24:620 – Spinner should start here?
Another really fun difficulty!
I couldn't find much I didn't like.
Here is my replay and score (Really sloppy but I still thought you might wanna see it :P )

Really really good mapset
Hopefully I was a little helpful!
Shot a star, good luck!
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
thanks everyone !

I will work hard on it :D :D :D :D
Nya Nya Neko
I'M terrible at hitounding '[]'
Vita-VVA
[Tips]
mod with light blue just is a suggestion or silly mod which made me uncomfortable personally
mod with purple is what I strongly suggest to do
mod with red is advise that I think should be changed
meanwhile, I was not a pro modder, so all of above is basing on my individual opinion :) Ignore them if you think they are helpless :)

没有hard吗?
[Normal]
最后一根红线是necessary的吗?以及,是否可以不通过红线改变滑条速度呢。。。个人建议尽量不要这样做,用绿线更好(虽然BPM的确是更改了)

00:06:273 (1) - not necessary 如果你是跟vocal(我个人喜欢跟节奏或者vocal选一个……仅供参考
00:06:273 (1) - 如果是跟vocal加一个note
00:11:800 (2) - NC
00:32:343 (8) - 和第一个一样
01:08:865 (1) - 可以使用

以及我normal作图很差的,都是仅供参考

[Insane]
00:08:868 (1) - 没有跟着任何节奏……不适合
00:14:735 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) -请再斟酌……
00:17:833 (1) - 有点死……
00:23:050 (1,2) - 这个三连……要是我我不会放,一是无东西可以跟,二是破坏我跳图的节奏……(我是鶸
相反的,00:26:800 (1) - 这个连就很perfect
00:44:083 (4,5) - 做个四方跳!强烈建议!
01:05:604 (6) - 节奏很活跃的图这里太僵硬格式化……建议换换排列
00:39:028 (4) - 和00:41:474 (4) - 感觉节奏应该是相同的……还请斟酌

跳的我很爽!

[V's Insane]
有很多我不喜欢的……但是不能称之为不合适的,于是我默默的跳过了……只有几点
00:33:658 (4,5,6,7) - 觉得不适合。。。不过说不上来哪里不适合
00:36:267 (3) - 连打略突兀
00:39:038 (1) - 和后面对不上……后面都没放连打……我觉得是我没好好听的原因……
01:00:068 (1) - 这个跳没有美感……

也是打的比较爽

That's all, Good luck and remember to make reply to me :)
Topic Starter
dlwlrma_old
不錯不錯, 你這種MOD 我還蠻喜歡的, 謝謝囉 :D :D :D
YoshinoSakura
妈呀都会中文,我该用什么语言mod
poddo
Hello there!! just a random person here trying to help -

not94's easy -
your tags are different on easy- remove the commas from the tags(they are "beyond the boundary, opening, mirai kuriyama, kyoto animation, Vincent, Not94", change them to: beyond the boundary opening mirai kuriyama kyoto animation Vincent Not94 to match with the other diffs)
01:06:583 (1) - the slider's repeat circle is sort of off-beat and feels weird? it ends in the red tick. not exactly an error but somewhat an opinion.
01:15:387 (1) - spinner spam? if possible reduce to only 2 spinners, beginners go crazy with spinners and spin ALL around the screen and lose the positioning of their mouse which makes the difficulty seem a lot harder for them.

good luck! the map seems really fun. the normal diff is very good for your first map.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply