1. 01:25:762 (2,3,4,5,6,1) - Only this part bugs me. I didn't find any problem in the diff except this. 2 and 3 don't make a good blanket compared to 00:41:429 (4,5) or every other blanket in the map, 01:26:428 (3,4,5) this back and forth feels weird because the whole map there is a really smooth flow so it feel weird seeing you using a pattern like this at the end of the map and finally 01:27:763 (6,1) here too it's not wrong but feels at this opposite of the way you mapped the diff with this non-smooth flow. (I'm not sure if i explain it well). Anyway, i suggest to remap these 6 objects.
2. 01:37:429 (1,2) - Why stacking? You always use a x0.1 spacing instead of stack throughout your whole diff. Is it because it's a 2/1 gap instead of 1/1 for the other gap? It still feels weird for me this change of pattern. But if you don't want to maybe you could still add a note at 01:37:762 at the middle and do your x0.1 spacing on 3 notes like 01:30:762 (1,2,3).

1. 00:14:429 (4) - I find all the pattern really good but this slider killed everything imo. Look at 00:10:762 (1,2,3,4) and 00:12:095 (1,2,3,4). Each time the 1/4 slider goes in the same "general direction" as the 3 previous sliders. Here it don't do it. Why? It kills the pattern and it gives also a weird flow. You could have donne something like this:
   
   SPOILER

   
   But on the contrary 00:15:762 (4) don't bother me because it ends the pattern so you don't expect some thing like 00:11:762 (4,1,4,1) and the flow from 3 to 4 is normal.
2. 00:36:429 (2,3) - The flow from 2 to 3 bother me. I find it weird too. Maybe change it like this:
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:42:761 (1) - Why the spacing here is only x0.8 when it's x1.3 througout the map? If it's an anti-jump you usally do them like 00:16:595 (2,3) si idk.
4. 00:48:428 (1) - ^ It doesn't bother me when there is a 2/1 gap like at 00:45:929 (2,1) but when it's 1/1 i find them disturbing. If it was a mapping style i would understand but sometimes there aren't there like 00:51:262 (2,3) or 00:56:595 (2,3) so i don't understand this choice.
5. 00:51:761 (3,1) - etc.....
6. 01:00:762 (4,1,2) - You put jump at 00:58:762 (1,2,3) so why not here too?
7. 01:14:429 (4,1) - Stacked and not spacing x0.1 like 01:20:429 (1,2) and.... everywhere else in the map?

1. 00:39:095 (2) - Maybe rotate it 90° like this:
   
   SPOILER

   
   Like this i think it feels more natural to go to 3 instead of when the slider is pointing at.... I'm not sure if i use the right words but i hope you understand what i mean.

rezoons wrote:

Hi ,
Hello :3

Mod from my queue.

I'm sorry if i'm late but a lot of mutuals asked me for mod and they are priority. Also i know a good modder is supposed to understand the way a mapper map but i'm sorry i didn't understand yours so i apologise for all the time i will go against it in my mod without noticing it.
that's fine (:

[Normal]
Placement/Aesthetic

1. 01:25:762 (2,3,4,5,6,1) - Only this part bugs me. I didn't find any problem in the diff except this. 2 and 3 don't make a good blanket compared to 00:41:429 (4,5) or every other blanket in the map, 01:26:428 (3,4,5) this back and forth feels weird because the whole map there is a really smooth flow so it feel weird seeing you using a pattern like this at the end of the map and finally 01:27:763 (6,1) here too it's not wrong but feels at this opposite of the way you mapped the diff with this non-smooth flow. (I'm not sure if i explain it well). Anyway, i suggest to remap these 6 objects.
   changed, yep
   
2. 01:37:429 (1,2) - Why stacking? You always use a x0.1 spacing instead of stack throughout your whole diff. Is it because it's a 2/1 gap instead of 1/1 for the other gap? It still feels weird for me this change of pattern. But if you don't want to maybe you could still add a note at 01:37:762 at the middle and do your x0.1 spacing on 3 notes like 01:30:762 (1,2,3).
   unstacked

[Hard]
Placement/Aesthetic

1. 00:14:429 (4) - I find all the pattern really good but this slider killed everything imo. Look at 00:10:762 (1,2,3,4) and 00:12:095 (1,2,3,4). Each time the 1/4 slider goes in the same "general direction" as the 3 previous sliders. Here it don't do it. Why? It kills the pattern and it gives also a weird flow. You could have donne something like this:
   
   SPOILER

   
   But on the contrary 00:15:762 (4) don't bother me because it ends the pattern so you don't expect some thing like 00:11:762 (4,1,4,1) and the flow from 3 to 4 is normal.
   great
   
2. 00:36:429 (2,3) - The flow from 2 to 3 bother me. I find it weird too. Maybe change it like this:
   
   SPOILER

   
   indeed
   
3. 00:42:761 (1) - Why the spacing here is only x0.8 when it's x1.3 througout the map? If it's an anti-jump you usally do them like 00:16:595 (2,3) si idk.
   don't feel any problem on play here
   
4. 00:48:428 (1) - ^ It doesn't bother me when there is a 2/1 gap like at 00:45:929 (2,1) but when it's 1/1 i find them disturbing. If it was a mapping style i would understand but sometimes there aren't there like 00:51:262 (2,3) or 00:56:595 (2,3) so i don't understand this choice.
5. 00:51:761 (3,1) - etc.....
   again, don't really see a problem with this on 1\1
   
6. 01:00:762 (4,1,2) - You put jump at 00:58:762 (1,2,3) so why not here too?
   changed
   
7. 01:14:429 (4,1) - Stacked and not spacing x0.1 like 01:20:429 (1,2) and.... everywhere else in the map?
   missed that
   

[Insane]
Placement/Aesthetic

1. 00:39:095 (2) - Maybe rotate it 90° like this:
   
   SPOILER

   
   Like this i think it feels more natural to go to 3 instead of when the slider is pointing at.... I'm not sure if i use the right words but i hope you understand what i mean.
   don't think so :\

Well, anyway, good luck ^^

- R u m i a - wrote:

from mod request for [Shi-Ra] , modding mania diffs only
Generals : where's the kiai time? xD It's so hard to add kiai sections to this song...added now anyway.
[Light March]
00:04:095 - Add 1 more - Done
00:04:762 - ^ - Done
00:11:262 (11262|0) - not needed i guess, for normal diff , better delete - why? it's easy to play and it fits well with the music
00:18:762 (18762|3) - delete - Done
00:18:429 - add - why? there's no need in one more note
00:24:595 (24595|3) - better move here? 00:24:762 - Done
00:22:095 - add - This pattern will be harder after adding one more note
00:23:762 (23762|0,23762|2,24095|1) - should be same note amount , these 2 - I see, but there it's more comfortable to press and I want to make accent here
00:29:262 (29262|1) - move here? make the beat stronger - sorry, I don't want to make it stronger here
00:30:929 (30929|2) - delete - awww...why? it sounds good at this pattern
00:32:762 - add at 4 - Done
00:37:929 - add - Done
00:47:762 - add at 2 - Done
00:53:762 (53762|3,54095|5) - change to normal notes? have no reason to make holds plus here 00:54:095 have strong beat should put 2 notes - All done
01:09:762 - add - Added
01:37:095 (97095|6,97179|5,97262|4,97345|3,97429|2,97512|1,97595|0) - whoa stream for normal diff? u serious? lol why not? maybe it's equal to Normal lvl 15 or higher, anyway remodelled
01:39:762 (99762|0,99845|1,99929|2,100012|3,100095|4,100179|5,100262|6) - ^ - same^
[Hell March]
00:11:429 (11429|1) - moveto collumn 1 ( there's a repeating sound there ) - Done
00:11:929 (11929|2) - - ^ - Done
00:19:095 - add - Added
00:39:762 - add at 2 - Added
00:43:595 - add - Not sure for what but add it anyway
01:05:929 (65929|5) - turn this to hold? 1/1 hold instead of this 01:06:095 (66095|2) - remove this - Both done, remodel some parts in this way too
01:06:262 - change to hold as well ( 1/2 hold ) - Done after previous suggestion
01:06:429 (66429|3) - 1/1 hold - ^
01:07:429 (67429|1) - move here 01:07:262 - Moved
01:09:762 - add at 4 - Done
01:11:762 - add at 7 - Done
01:12:095 (72095|0) - move to 3 - Oh...it'll ruin my pattern here, but well, seems good
01:12:429 - add at 4 - Done

Spy wrote:

Hello,mod by request
I'll mod mania diffs.

NM & HD

[Shi-Ra's Hell March [NM]]
01:04:595 - Add a note - Done
01:04:929 - Add a note - Done
01:05:929 - Add a note - Done
01:06:262 - Add a note - Done
01:07:262 - Add a note - Done
01:07:595 - Add a note - Done
01:07:929 - Add a note - Done
01:08:595 - Add a note - Done
01:08:929 - Add a note - Done
01:09:262 - Add a note - Done
Start from 01:04:095 - 01:09:429 - You can remove some LNs~ - Remodelled
01:19:095 - Add a note - Done
01:24:595 (84595|4) - Remove - Sorry, I can't ruin alternation here
01:24:929 (84929|5) - Remove - ^
01:26:929 (86929|1) - Remove - ^
01:27:262 (87262|2) - Remove - ^
01:27:595 (87595|1) - Remove - ^

[Shi-Ra's Hell March [HD]]
00:11:929 (11929|0) - It is here,00:11:984,This is (1/6)
00:13:179 (13179|3) - Remove
00:15:845 (15845|3) - Remove
00:22:512 (22512|2) - Remove
00:23:845 (23845|5) - Remove
00:26:679 (26679|1) - Remove
00:27:845 (27845|3,28012|5) - Remove
00:33:512 (33512|5,33679|3) - Remove
00:36:179 (36179|1) - Remove
00:49:179 (49179|5) - Remove
00:49:512 (49512|2,49679|4,49845|6) - Remove
00:52:179 (52179|4) - Remove
00:52:345 (52345|0,52512|2,52679|4) - Remove
00:54:512 (54512|3) - Remove
00:54:845 (54845|4,55012|6,55179|4,55345|2) - Remove
00:57:179 (57179|2,57512|2,57679|0) - Remove
00:57:845 (57845|5,58012|3) - Remove
00:59:845 (59845|3,60179|4,60345|6,60512|4,60679|1,60679|6) - Remove
01:02:512 (62512|2,62845|6,63012|4,63179|1,63345|1) - Remove
01:06:845 (66845|1) - Remove
01:07:345 (67345|5,68179|5) - Remove
01:10:512 (70512|5) - Remove
01:13:179 (73179|2,73179|4) - Remove
01:15:845 (75845|4) - Remove
01:17:179 (77179|5) - Remove
01:18:512 (78512|5) - Remove
01:19:845 (79845|1) - Remove
01:21:179 (81179|2) - Remove
01:21:429 (81429|5,81429|3,81512|2,81595|1,81595|4,81679|0,81762|1,81845|2,81929|3,81929|6,82012|4,82095|5,82095|1) - Here seems a little strange
01:22:429 (82429|3,82429|1) - Move to 01:22:484,this is (1/6)
01:23:845 (83845|4) - Remove
01:23:845 (83845|4,84179|2,84345|4,84512|0,84679|2) - Remove
01:26:512 (86512|1) - Remove
01:26:512 (86512|1,86845|2,87012|4,87179|3,87345|5,87345|1) - Remove
01:29:179 (89179|4,89512|4,89679|1,89845|1,90012|6) - Remove
01:31:845 (91845|5,92179|1,92345|3,92512|3,92679|1) - Remove
01:34:512 (94512|1,94845|5,95012|3,95345|3) - Remove
01:37:512 (97512|2,97679|0,97845|1,98012|2) - Remove
01:39:845 (99845|1,100179|1,100345|2,100512|0,100679|1) - Remove
01:40:929 (100929|2) - Change to LN and End it
All fixed and rearranged

Good luck to rank ^_^
Thank you, Spy ^w^

silverboxer wrote:

from my modding queue

Normal

HP -1?
4 is fine

00:45:762 (1) - blanket slightly better: (x:420,y:192); (x:442,y:239); (x:453,y:287)
ok
00:46:762 (3) - too close to slider 1. Make a perfect triangle with endpoint of slider 1 and circle 2: http://puu.sh/586xY.jpg
alright
01:33:762 (3,4) - since these circle are centered: 01:37:429 (1,2), why not make the other ones?
01:36:429 (3,4) - ^
why not?

01:33:762 (3) - nc to be consistent with other difficulties
01:36:429 (3) - ^
not needed here

Hard

00:23:761 (4) - move to x:374,y:97
okay

00:31:429 (3) - too close to slider 1. move to x:96,y:280
00:55:095 (3) - too close to slider 1. move to x:368,y:180
i don't think so

Insane

00:22:984 (2) - move to x:124,y:248
01:16:345 (2) - move to x:120,y:244
you mean 24 and 20? anyway adjusted a bit

I really couldn't find much to fix here... amazing map! Sorry I couldn't mod it more

1. 00:06:929 - This beat sounds pretty high in the music, so I think a note is necessary. In my personal point of view, you should add a note in the column 5 (btw, and optional.. You can add a clap in this new note).
2. 00:11:762 (11762|6, 11873|5, 11984|4, 12095|3) - After to mod all the map, I notice this (and all the 1/3 sections unnecesary), because you only used this pattern few times, you didn't use it in other parts of the song where the 1/3 is emphasized, I recommend you to re-arrange all of this patterns and try to avoid the 1/4, as I'll say in my next suggestion I find them a bit difficult for the difficulty
3. 00:14:762 (14762|1) - I'd move this to the second column, actually the 1/3 could be a bit tricky for this difficulty, so I think this pattern in consecutive columns will be a bit easier for average players.
4. 00:16:095 (16095|0, 16095|6) - Something like above, the double note fits perfectly here, but I'd move both objects to the 3rd and 5th column respectively (well, in this case it can be convenient to move the objects to the 2nd and 6th column if you want, respectively).
5. 00:36:929 (36929|3) - I see your intention here, but I find it more consistent (and at the same time a bit easier to read due to this reason) if you move this to the 1st column and add a new object in 00:37:095 (37095|3) -
6. 00:37:762 - I think is necessary to emphasize this beat with something.. Hmm.. Add a note in the 5th or 6th column (?
7. 01:03:429 (63429|1, 63929|1) - I'd use a hold instead of these single notes. Definetly it'll fit better with the music.
8. 01:03:595 (63595|4) - What about removing this? there is not a concrete sound, so I think this object is not realy necessary here. And maybe a 1/2 rest is a good thing.
9. 01:12:762 - For consistency in this section, you should add a note in the 4th column
10. 01:37:095 (97095|6, 97179|5, 97262|4, 97345|3, 97429|2, 97512|1, 97595|0) - Wait.. why this 1/4? Is not justificated with the music, the only object justificated in the music is the one in 01:37:345 (97345|3) - but the rest are just useless (listen the music in 25% playback pls), so I suggest you to remove the other objects over 1/4 ticks.
11. 01:39:762 (99762|0, 99845|1, 99929|2, 100012|3, 100095|4, 100179|5, 100262|6) - Exactly the same as above, the only note justificated with the music is the one in 01:40:012 (100012|3) -, so remove the rest over the blue ticks please.

1. 00:18:512 (18512|1, 18512|5) - I find these notes unnecesary here, they are just overmapping because there is no sound here. If you remove this, the previous and next patterns will sound much better without this notes, believe me. You should remove them.
2. 00:22:512 - A note here sounds good, and it'll be consistent with your patterns. I'd add a note in the 3rd column.
3. 00:30:429 (30429|2, 30429|5, 30512|1, 30512|4, 30595|0, 30595|3, 30679|1) - This is simple, there is no need to overmap to make a difficulty enjoyable, actually your diff. is pretty good so I don't find any good reason to use all of these objects over blue ticks, as I said they are just overmapping. I highly suggest you to remove those objects over 1/4 ticks (listen in 25% playback always to be sure where 1/4 objects fit and where not). In addition, doing this unnecesary overmap, you're being inconsistent with similar sections, which it is a bad thing.
4. 00:34:762 (34762|4, 34762|6, 34929|0, 34929|2, 35095|1, 35095|6) - I don't like that much how this pattern sound, actually it sounds like a constant 1/2 pattern which is not following anything in concrete. So, you can maybe do something like this
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 00:51:845 (51845|4) - Remove this please, is just useless and make this pattern sound bad
6. 00:54:512 (54512|3) - (^)
7. 01:01:595 (61595|5, 61929|1) - Here, I think you're enforcing the 1/2 and it is not really necessary I have to say. In my opinion you should these objects and let act the hold alone.
8. 01:21:845 (81845|2, 82012|4) - Useless notes, they are just overmapping. Remove them please (well, check the rest by yourself, i think you'll get the point after those things mentioned).

mancuso_JM_ wrote:

Hi! Modding mania diffs. as per Sieg request!
I'll see the columns in the following order 1|2|3|4|5|6|7

[Light March:]

Fixed most of all except parts with double notes, I always try to avoid double notes in my NM patterns, they're uncomfortable, so I re-arrange them in another way.

[Hell March :]

Fixed all.

I hope this mod can helps you.. Really helpful, thank you so much ^w^
Good Luck! ^^

SPOILER

75,54,92429,2,0,B|117:54|169:91|141:165|131:187|131:187|121:210|93:284|146:321|205:323|236:298|248:258,1,390,8|12,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

SPOILER

75,54,92429,2,0,B|109:83|145:81|194:53|194:53|141:131|141:131|166:188|164:230|164:230|201:225|237:246,1,390,8|4,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

SPOILER

322,34,92429,2,0,B|320:66|294:98|251:93|216:103|221:65|208:38|141:49|110:86|111:132|128:162|156:176,1,300,8|12,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

PROGUY wrote:

Hi there. Here's my check as requested.

...I can't check either of your mania charts as they seem to crash my client on my attempt to enter the Editor. Can you guys please try to fix this?
P.S. Those charts are awesome btw

PROGUY wrote:

Alright then. Let's see...

Welp, I and the AiMod have reported that:


Piano'd.

1. Your current background is 1365x768 while it should be 1366x768, please fix this.
2. Disable the Widescreen Support on every difficulty since you're not using it.

1. 01:37:481 (4) - Add a new combo here due to the new stanza and music change, also because otherwise it's too long compared to the others.
2. 01:39:814 - Start the spinner here, it will follow the melody much better, the ending can remain the same.

1. Reduce OD and AR by 1 tick, they're too high for this kind of difficulty right now.
2. I noticed you've used lots of tricky stacks on this difficulty, please make them normal so they're not confusing for beginners to read.

1. 00:42:813 (1) - I kinda dislike this anti-jump here, I think it would be better if you can stack it with the next slider instead.
2. 01:41:481 - Unused green line, remove it from here.

1. 00:27:147 (1) - Remove this new combo from here, it's not necessary.

Andrea wrote:

~General~

1. Your current background is 1365x768 while it should be 1366x768, please fix this.
2. Disable the Widescreen Support on every difficulty since you're not using it.

~Bakari's Easy~

1. 01:37:481 (4) - Add a new combo here due to the new stanza and music change, also because otherwise it's too long compared to the others.
2. 01:39:814 - Start the spinner here, it will follow the melody much better, the ending can remain the same.

~Normal~

1. Reduce OD and AR by 1 tick, they're too high for this kind of difficulty right now.
2. I noticed you've used lots of tricky stacks on this difficulty, please make them normal so they're not confusing for beginners to read.

~Hard~

1. 00:42:813 (1) - I kinda dislike this anti-jump here, I think it would be better if you can stack it with the next slider instead.
2. 01:41:481 - Unused green line, remove it from here.

~Elvis' Insane~

1. 00:27:147 (1) - Remove this new combo from here, it's not necessary.