nold_1702 wrote:

GO TO HELL!!

Maybe i should go to hell

-Asagi wrote:

nold_1702 wrote:

GO TO HELL!!

Maybe i should go to hell

this mapvis fun as hell
so go to hell

go to rank

good luck!

as your request

[General]
fine

[Easy]
建议AR+1，有些节奏好读点点
01:52:235 (2) - 我建议你用个比较特殊的形状来突出下这个3/2 slider，因为其他slider全都是2/1，这个如果shape不突出

[Normal]
也是建议AR+1
01:06:181 (2) - 试试用特殊shape来合曲？比如毛毛虫之类的

[623's Hard]
00:42:991 - shouldn't you end the slider here? the current rhythm is a bit odd imo
00:58:072 (2,3) - this spacing is really confusing to read the rhythm, I suggest you make this spacing much larger, or the slider is easily read as it start at 00:58:397 -
02:07:478 - the slider should end at here, as the same rhythm you used before and after this slider, for example like 02:12:586 (2) -
02:15:262 (4,5,1,2,3) - this pattern is a bit harder than the average of the diff, I suggest to make this pattern a bit easier to play, for example like 02:17:856 (3,1,2,3) -
02:23:856 - how about add a note here, or it's a bit empty imo

[Insane]
01:51:910 (1,1) - 可以叠好点
01:58:072 (1) - 这个我建议不要叠在01:58:397 - 上面，可以把这个slider移开，节奏好读些
02:11:208 (4) - 建议调整下这个note的位置，前后spacing差的有点多，或者调整下02:11:451 (1) - 也行
02:15:667 - 这里加个note好点，空1/1出来感觉有点长，如果加了的话记得调整下02:15:424 (1) - 的位置保持spacing
02:24:991 - 我觉得这一段的节奏稍微简单过头了，比如可以让slider停在这里，然后02:25:153 - 放个note在4上面

[Ends' Insane]
01:44:370 (1) - change this to 2 circles, plays better imo. circle fit the heavy beat(01:44:451 - ) better than slider end, also please make the stream 01:44:370 (1,2,3,4) - looks more smooth
02:17:045 (2,3) - hope you can try to move 2 left a bit and 3 right a bit , the current spacing of the 1/4 silders are not regular(short sliders only need to click and hold but without moving the mouse, so the center of a short slider is the slider head, not the hole slider body)

[EXTRA]
01:06:748 (1,2) - 这spacing可以大一点，比如01:07:316 (1,2) - 这样，不然有点看不出是两个circle还是一个slider
01:09:910 (3,1) - 这spacing有点大，建议至少改改slider方向，让spacing小点，像01:10:559 (1,1) - 这样
01:18:505 (1,2) - 这个spacing有点大，建议把01:18:667 (2,3,4) - 移到x:420 y:224之类的地方
01:21:018 (1,2) - 同01:06:748 (1,2) - ，至少摆的看得出是circles好点
01:23:370 (1,2) - 这个可以移到x:264 y:168左右的地方，然后方向对着下一个note好点，现在这个有点简单，然后突然接大跳01:23:694 (1,2,3) - 有点吓人
01:56:937 (2,1) - 这个spacing也有点吓人，这个可以移到x:92 y:284左右的地方，因为短slider的中心是slider头，现在这个spacing不太平衡
02:01:964 - 建议把NC移到02:02:126 - ，不然这个stack有点难读
02:03:586 (1) - 没叠好么
02:23:045 (2,3) - 这个不ctrl+g一下？
其实这diff，打起来感觉两个kia比其他地方简单得多。。虽然看上去其实kiai更难

在叫我好了

LapFox Trax isn't a viable source, just push it to the tags.

Priti wrote:

LapFox Trax isn't a viable source, just push it to the tags.

How'd that get in there :O

Also worth noting for any BATs checking the EXTRA, it's a good idea to get some playtests for the audience the difficulty is made for.
It's hard for someone like me to evaluate it because I can't play it, so I recommend getting some opinions.
I did get one pro player and they weren't fond of the jerky movements, it's worth getting some more testers.

Here are my test plays ^_^/

https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1218341
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1218351
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1218358

very hard

Reply to wcx:

Despite of the points I mention below,all fixed!

Easy:
-AR+1 略快

Insane:

-01:58:072 (1) - 这个我建议不要叠在01:58:397 - 上面，可以把这个slider移开，节奏好读些
個人認為,現在這個放法讀圖沒問題,反而如果不放這裡,放其他地方顯得怪怪的

Extra:

01:23:694 (1,2,3) - 有点吓人 這個打起上來感覺很好,看起來下人,但是玩上來都沒問題

02:23:045 (2,3) - 这个不ctrl+g一下？ 玩在的pattern打上來比較順手

01:18:505 (1,2) - 这个spacing有点大，建议把01:18:667 (2,3,4) - 移到x:420 y:224之类的地方 這個同01:23:694 (1,2,3) -

UPDATED!!

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

reply to priti: okay and done

reply to charles: there must be players who don't like this map but,surely somebody does.Have a look on the favourit list of this map,rrtyui,Kert and many more expert added it as fav proving that those patterns are good for them.Besides,hv a look on Maddy's test play result on page 2 and his feedback on this map.

reply to frost: wow you're pro !!

Here is my one play on the extra. Was not fond of the movements at all, feels like it is mapped too much to be "hard" instead of actually being a map. I would reconsider the extra at least. The insane was kind of meh in my opinion as well. The low AR made it feel like a hard and the patterns and rhythm just made it feel bleh to play, maybe with higher AR it would play better but as of now it just feels like a hard. The others played just fine to me.

I like your skin for an X "Fuck" so much JAKACHAN
and that was really nice record orz

Kert wrote:

This is the most epic map in osu! Have a taste of my stars~

Maddy wrote:

fun

Remember,there must be players to love and players to hate/dislike.
Jakachan,thanks for advance though.


Moreover,Jakachan,I am here clear-cut to indicate that I DO NOT map for difficulty but map for the song as you can listen the song is fast enough for me to map like this.Therefore,pointing out that the mapper (me) is mapping for hard instead of mapping just a map wittout any evidence is an unfair blame for me.

nold, to be honest, you follow the rhythm pretty well, but I think the cursor movement is extremely jerky and awkward at points, try having atleast a tiny bit of flow instead of having the sliders placed randomally over the whole map.
Also, you forgot to remove LapFox Trax from the source, you only added it to tags.

Priti wrote:

You forgot to remove LapFox Trax from the source, you only added it to tags.

my bad,done

Priti, instead of just going around and say maps are bad in whatever point, you could also give suggestions. If you don't have any, then just don't post.

Irreversible wrote:

Priti, instead of just going around and say maps are bad in whatever point, you could also give suggestions. If you don't have any, then just don't post.

Funny that you are saying this, because I just talked to him in IRC about the issues with some jerky movements and odd slider leniency.
And Irre, something you don't seem to understand: People are not obligated to give suggestions if they want to show their opinion, aslong as they don't just yell "LOL THIS IS SHIT" or something pointless like that, its fine to not fully commit to it.

please stop the war,Priti.
Thank you for your opinion in IRC.

The rhythm is just fine the flow is not. Every movement feels very jerky which does not work well with the type of sliders that are used which could use some serious work. Believe me nold I love your mapping but this one does not fit well in my opinion.

it's in fact verrrrrry weird


but I like weird stuff so I found it actually fun to play, it's not unplayable at all

im just bad http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1219161

JAKACHAN wrote:

The rhythm is just fine the flow is not. Every movement feels very jerky which does not work well with the type of sliders that are used which could use some serious work. Believe me nold I love your mapping but this one does not fit well in my opinion.

I think the flow is okay and the movement is not so weird and jerky at all. Some other mappers' style on movement like Amamiya Yuko's sound much more bizarre and nold's is acceptable. Few play counts can actually make me use to that movement. So, the movement may not be as bad as you think. Btw, the map is very challenging >w<. Support you nold.

p.s. I love Amamiya Yuko (Skystar)'s beatmaps so much >~<.

Result

JAKACHAN wrote:

The rhythm is just fine the flow is not. Every movement feels very jerky which does not work well with the type of sliders that are used which could use some serious work. Believe me nold I love your mapping but this one does not fit well in my opinion.

I was excited becuz this map can challenge our space moving when high bpm 1/2
addition , we can enjoy the map reading when ar10 in this map
nold's map is good

Kert wrote:

This is the most epic map in osu! Have a taste of my stars~

I have nothing to complain about, except my not good enough 2key skill~

after fixed many tiny things via irc
ranked

YAY RANK
Gratz !

!

fanzhen0019 wrote:

!

gratz

!

YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

直接瞎了
这已经超越有生之年系列了
估计这辈子是pass不了了

恭喜Rank~

incoming

Congratz!!

恭賀陛下成就千秋功業！

pls [EXTRA] AR9

Is it just me or does the offset feel terrible?

The EXTRA is epic and the Taikos are still cool~
Congratulations!!

gratz
尿