i agree - who do we target next night? nyquill?GuyInFreezer wrote:
It depends on Nyquill's claim. But I think it's possible that this game can be solved today.
forum
5-P Dethy Mafia (N2) - The Endgame
posted
Total Posts
339
Somehow I read that as target the same person at N0.Sephibro wrote:
it is obvious that if we all target the same person it will be easier to guess everyone's sanity (adding the information we already got from n0)Lincolm wrote:
If we target the same person, then the result will be same isn't it? I kinda agitated with this kind of logic, seriously...
Correct, depends on Nyquill.Sephibro wrote:
or one is skSakura wrote:
So 1 of Seph/Lincolm is Naive and the other Sane.
Which means im either Insane or Paranoid, if GiF is Paranoid then I'm Insane, which means Sephibro would be town too. If GiF is Insane then I'm Paranoid.
Of course we still need Nyquill's results to form any further decissions.
Of course we still need Nyquill's results to form any further decissions.
It really depends on Nyquil's result. As I said, it is possible that this game can be solved today.Sephibro wrote:
i agree - who do we target next night? nyquill?GuyInFreezer wrote:
It depends on Nyquill's claim. But I think it's possible that this game can be solved today.
Technically, Sakura, you can be sane as well. (If that's the case, Sephi is SK lol)
Yeah normally you dont get clears D1 because eveyrone targets someone different.
And if scum kills whoever we agree to target then it's easier because their actual alignment is known.
And if scum kills whoever we agree to target then it's easier because their actual alignment is known.
Sephibro wrote:
you shouldn't have said that sakura
Also, apart from the result, I think scum is in Lincom/Nyquill.
Shouldn't be a problem because if anything im most likely to die tonightSephibro wrote:
you shouldn't have said that sakura
i meant today - 28/11, not today - d1.GuyInFreezer wrote:
It really depends on Nyquil's result. As I said, it is possible that this game can be solved today.Sephibro wrote:
i agree - who do we target next night? nyquill?
We lack on information to be sure who's sk d1
Got innocent on Lincolm.
Just woke up, and I have a test right now. Will post in afternoon
Just woke up, and I have a test right now. Will post in afternoon
I'm clear.
I was really hoping that Nyquill would claim guilty on someone though.
the only one who may already know our sanities is the sk - that's why i suggested not to share information d1
Nah, sharing info today was worthy. We already have two confirmed towns.
but in that case we would have lost the n0 result of whoever gets killed n1, so it's almost the same
Topic Starter
The girl known as Furudo Erika shortly returns, carrying a sawed-off shotgun and says, "Oh I nearly forgot to clarify. Of course, you cannot investigate yourselves. That would be silly. You yourself already know whether or not you're the killer."Sephibro wrote:
@mod: can a cop target self?
The girl leaves the parlor after that, saying she needs to get some objects from the gardening shed.
I feel like lynching Nyquill today while Sephi/Lincolm crosschecks and Me/Sakura checks Lincolm.
At least we have confirmed town, regard mafia game is about paranoia.Sephibro wrote:
but in that case we would have lost the n0 result of whoever gets killed n1, so it's almost the same
kNoHitter wrote:
whether or not you're the killer or not.
what nh said, why would you ever need to target yourself?
Okay i'm off for real now.
Okay i'm off for real now.
Why Nyquill? Why not me or Sephi?GuyInFreezer wrote:
I feel like lynching Nyquill today while Sephi/Lincolm crosschecks and Me/Sakura checks Lincolm.
Do you object?
We need to lynch today, and that's for sure.
We need to lynch today, and that's for sure.
Would be better since targeting someone can be the SK if we're insane or sane, even though it is lesser chance.Nyquill wrote:
what nh said, why would you ever need to target yourself?
Okay i'm off for real now.
And I feel like lynching Nyquill because he didn't had a report on Sakura
.... But I'm confirmed town.
No, if there is better result when we lynch Sephi or Me, it would be better, isn't it?GuyInFreezer wrote:
Do you object?
We need to lynch today, and that's for sure.
Can you clarify how this confirms you GiF?Sakura wrote:
Sephibro > Sakura (Innocent)
Sakura > Sephibro (Guilty)
GiF > Sakura (Guilty)
Lincolm > Sakura (Innocent)
Nyquill > Lincolm (Innocent)
Sephibro Not Paranoid
Sakura Not Naive (Also not SK)
GiF Not Naive
Lincolm Not Paranoid
Nyquill Not Paranoid
Hold on. I'm writing down a reason right now.
oh wait facepalm.
if someone's lying is among the non-paranoids.
Interestingly enough, if Nyquill's SK he HAD to clear GiF because then it would become 1v1 between him and GiF
Sephi: Sakura Inno
Sakura: Sephi Guilty (Town)
GIF: Sakura Guilty
Lincolm: Sakura Inno
Nyquill: Lincolm Inno
If Nyquill claims guilty on someone: Nyquill is scum.
If Nyquill claims innocent: GIF clear.
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Sane/Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive/Insane
If Nyquill is insane: Lincolm scum. Sakura Sane. Sephi Scum. GIF Paranoid. (Doesn't work)
So we're left with:
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Sane/Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Because Sephi/Lincolm/Nyquill has a chance to be sane, Sakura can't be sane.
That leaves with:
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Sakura/GIF confirmed.
Sakura: Sephi Guilty (Town)
GIF: Sakura Guilty
Lincolm: Sakura Inno
Nyquill: Lincolm Inno
If Nyquill claims guilty on someone: Nyquill is scum.
If Nyquill claims innocent: GIF clear.
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Sane/Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive/Insane
If Nyquill is insane: Lincolm scum. Sakura Sane. Sephi Scum. GIF Paranoid. (Doesn't work)
So we're left with:
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Sane/Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Because Sephi/Lincolm/Nyquill has a chance to be sane, Sakura can't be sane.
That leaves with:
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Sakura/GIF confirmed.
Also, based on this report, Sephibro has the highest chance of being town among three Sane/Naive group.
All the assumptions are taken care of.
If Nyquill claims guilty on someone: Nyquill is scum.If you're talking about this line, you're thinking to hard because at this point, we already won.
If that happened, we already won at that point*
Sephi: Sakura Inno
Sakura: Sephi Guilty (Town)
GIF: Sakura Guilty
Lincolm: Sakura Inno
Nyquill: Lincolm Inno
If Nyquill claims guilty on someone: Nyquill is scum.
If Nyquill claims innocent: GIF clear.
Sephi: Sane/Naive/Insane
Sakura: Sane/Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane/Sane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive/Insane
Nyquill: Sane/Naive/Insane
If Sakura's scum then Lincolm and me are Insane or Naive, you're Paranoid and Nyquill is Sane
If Nyquill is insane: Lincolm scum. Sakura Sane. Sephi Scum. GIF Paranoid. (Doesn't work)
So we're left with:
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Sane/Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Because Sephi/Lincolm/Nyquill has a chance to be sane, Sakura can't be sane.
That leaves with:
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Sakura/GIF confirmed. Sakura is not confirmed.
Sakura: Sephi Guilty (Town)
GIF: Sakura Guilty
Lincolm: Sakura Inno
Nyquill: Lincolm Inno
If Nyquill claims guilty on someone: Nyquill is scum.
If Nyquill claims innocent: GIF clear.
Sephi: Sane/Naive/Insane
Sakura: Sane/Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane/Sane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive/Insane
Nyquill: Sane/Naive/Insane
If Sakura's scum then Lincolm and me are Insane or Naive, you're Paranoid and Nyquill is Sane
If Nyquill is insane: Lincolm scum. Sakura Sane. Sephi Scum. GIF Paranoid. (Doesn't work)
So we're left with:
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Sane/Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Because Sephi/Lincolm/Nyquill has a chance to be sane, Sakura can't be sane.
That leaves with:
Sephi: Sane/Naive
Sakura: Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Sakura/GIF confirmed. Sakura is not confirmed.
Also why Nyquill should be lynched today:
1. Sephibro got guilty'd by Sakura, who is confirmed town and confirmed not sane. There's 50% chance that Sakura is insane, therefore he has a chance to be town.
2. Lincolm got inno'd by Nyquill, whose role is unknown. If Nyquill is SK, it basically clears Lincolm. Therefore, he has a chance to be town, albeit lower than Sephi's.
3. Nyquill, on other hand, have no chance of being town based on today's report. There IS a chance of Nyquill being town, but it's lower than Sephi's and Lincolm's, therefore highest chance of being scum.
1. Sephibro got guilty'd by Sakura, who is confirmed town and confirmed not sane. There's 50% chance that Sakura is insane, therefore he has a chance to be town.
2. Lincolm got inno'd by Nyquill, whose role is unknown. If Nyquill is SK, it basically clears Lincolm. Therefore, he has a chance to be town, albeit lower than Sephi's.
3. Nyquill, on other hand, have no chance of being town based on today's report. There IS a chance of Nyquill being town, but it's lower than Sephi's and Lincolm's, therefore highest chance of being scum.
Anyway, among Sephi, Lincolm and Nyquill we have 1 sane, 1 naive and 1 sk.
That's the thing. Otherwise
If Sephi is Insane, it doesnt work since im conf town.
If Lincolm is Insane, it doesnt work since im conf town.
Now what happens if Nyquill is Insane?
GiF would NEED to be Paranoid (since he cant be sane).
From that assumption then Sephibro is SK and Lincolm Naive.
But if Lincolm is town then how the heck is Nyquill Insane?
So yeah GiF's clear.
God my head X_X
That's the thing. Otherwise
If Sephi is Insane, it doesnt work since im conf town.
If Lincolm is Insane, it doesnt work since im conf town.
Now what happens if Nyquill is Insane?
GiF would NEED to be Paranoid (since he cant be sane).
From that assumption then Sephibro is SK and Lincolm Naive.
But if Lincolm is town then how the heck is Nyquill Insane?
So yeah GiF's clear.
God my head X_X
If I was sane and Sakura is scum, that means that Sephi is insane/naive, lincolm is insane/naive, and Nyquill is confirmed naive.
That means that Sephi's and Lincolm's role will conflict.
That means that Sephi's and Lincolm's role will conflict.
you see, the thing is, there's 2 innocents and 1 guilty on me.
If im scum
One Inno has to be Naive, Another Inno has to be Insane, And the guilty has to be Sane/Paranoid.
those 3 would be seph, gif, lincolm.
Then that means that Nyquill would be paranoid or Sane... but oh wait Nyquill got an inno!
If im scum
One Inno has to be Naive, Another Inno has to be Insane, And the guilty has to be Sane/Paranoid.
those 3 would be seph, gif, lincolm.
Then that means that Nyquill would be paranoid or Sane... but oh wait Nyquill got an inno!
Therefore, I can't be sane.
As I said, all the assumptions are taken care of.
oh wait, that's... awkward... argh my head
I'm working on a recap of what happened so far.
Sephi: Sakura Inno
Sakura: Sephi Guilty
GIF: Sakura Guilty
Lincolm: Sakura Inno
Nyquill: Lincolm Inno
If Sephi's SK
Sakura: Paranoid
GIF: Insane
Lincolm: Naive/Sane
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
If Sakura's SK
Sephi: Naive/Insane
GIF: Paranoid
Lincolm: Naive/Insane
Nyquill: Sane
If GIF's SK
Sephi: Naive/Sane
Sakura: Paranoid and Insane
Lincolm: Naive/Sane
Nyquill: -
thus GIF is confirmed
If Lincolm is SK
Sephi: Sane
Sakura: Paranoid/Insane
GiF: Paranoid/Insane
Nyquill: Naive
If Nyquill is SK
Sephi: Naive/Sane
Sakura: Paranoid/Insane
GiF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Naive/Sane
This is how you analyze properly - tell me if i made any mistake
Sakura: Sephi Guilty
GIF: Sakura Guilty
Lincolm: Sakura Inno
Nyquill: Lincolm Inno
If Sephi's SK
Sakura: Paranoid
GIF: Insane
Lincolm: Naive/Sane
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
If Sakura's SK
Sephi: Naive/Insane
GIF: Paranoid
Lincolm: Naive/Insane
Nyquill: Sane
If GIF's SK
Sephi: Naive/Sane
Sakura: Paranoid and Insane
Lincolm: Naive/Sane
Nyquill: -
thus GIF is confirmed
If Lincolm is SK
Sephi: Sane
Sakura: Paranoid/Insane
GiF: Paranoid/Insane
Nyquill: Naive
If Nyquill is SK
Sephi: Naive/Sane
Sakura: Paranoid/Insane
GiF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Naive/Sane
This is how you analyze properly - tell me if i made any mistake
Yeah I just realized. Hold on a sec.
But I still want Nyquill though. He still has the highest chance of flipping scum.
Order of possiblity of flipping town based on report : Sakura/Sephi > Lincolm > Nyquill
Outside of the logic/report stuff, my current scumpool is {Lincolm/Nyquill} so I still want Nyquill dead today.
Best case scenario for us now is that Nyquill is SK
Otherwise SK will 100% kill the Sane/Insane tonight :\
I was probably right that it wasn't good to share n0 info
Otherwise SK will 100% kill the Sane/Insane tonight :\
I was probably right that it wasn't good to share n0 info
I'm more familiar with dethy with n0 kill, so meh.
tbf I want to lynch today just because we have a mislynch.Sephibro wrote:
No. we NL today
ftr the SK isnt supposed to know the sanities, just alignments.
don't hammer NL yet - I'm making some more analysis and tell everybody what to do next night
If we're lynching based on probability of flipping scum, we're lynching Nyquill.
If we're lynching based on whose sanity is going to be most useless, we're lynching Lincolm.
If we're not lynching today, we still have to figure who to target.
If we're lynching based on whose sanity is going to be most useless, we're lynching Lincolm.
If we're not lynching today, we still have to figure who to target.
Then unvoteSephibro wrote:
don't hammer NL yet - I'm making some more analysis and tell everybody what to do next night
BTW, can I scumhunt in this setup?
you can do what you want, you're confirmed, just don't make me angry plsGuyInFreezer wrote:
BTW, can I scumhunt in this setup?
lol this sucks
If we're lynching based on probability of flipping scum, we're lynching Nyquill.
If we're lynching based on whose sanity is going to be most useless, we're lynching Lincolm.
If we're lynching based on dethy walkthrough, we're lynching Sakura, who got lone guilty.
And since we have one confirmed town, lynching today and not lynching today has a equal chance of us winning.
If we're lynching based on probability of flipping scum, we're lynching Nyquill.
If we're lynching based on whose sanity is going to be most useless, we're lynching Lincolm.
If we're lynching based on dethy walkthrough, we're lynching Sakura, who got lone guilty.
And since we have one confirmed town, lynching today and not lynching today has a equal chance of us winning.
lone guilty excluding the report of confirmed town*
Posting overall possibility for reference.
Sephi: Sane/Naive/insane
Sakura: Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive/insane
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Sephi: Sane/Naive/insane
Sakura: Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive/insane
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
We're not voting until we fill this table:
If we NL today
- Nyquill -> Sakura
- Sephi ->
- Lincolm ->
- Me ->
-Sakura ->
If we lynch Sakura today:
- Sephi ->
- Nyquill ->
- Me ->
- Lincolm ->
If we lynch Sephi today (Insert Trollface here):
- Nyquill -> Sakura
- Me ->
- Lincolm ->
- Sakura ->
If we lynch Nyquill today
- Me ->
- Lincolm ->
- Sakura ->
- Sephi ->
If we lynch me today, y'all are dumb.
If we NL today
- Nyquill -> Sakura
- Sephi ->
- Lincolm ->
- Me ->
-Sakura ->
If we lynch Sakura today:
- Sephi ->
- Nyquill ->
- Me ->
- Lincolm ->
If we lynch Sephi today (Insert Trollface here):
- Nyquill -> Sakura
- Me ->
- Lincolm ->
- Sakura ->
If we lynch Nyquill today
- Me ->
- Lincolm ->
- Sakura ->
- Sephi ->
If we lynch me today, y'all are dumb.
Why's lynching lincolm not an option?
If any of y'all townread sephi, raise your hand.
Simply I forgot to put him.Sakura wrote:
Why's lynching lincolm not an option?
Anyways i think i should scan GiF who's alignment is confirmed if i get innocent then most likely seph is SK, if I get guilty then idk.
Sephi: Sane/Naive/insane
Sakura: Insane/Paranoid
GIF: Paranoid/Insane
Lincolm: Sane/Naive/insane
Nyquill: Sane/Naive
Sephi: Sakura Inno
Sakura: Sephi Guilty
GIF: Sakura Guilty
Lincolm: Sakura Inno
Nyquill: Lincolm Inno
If we NL today
- Nyquill -> Sakura
- Sephi ->
- Lincolm ->
- Me ->
- Sakura ->
If we lynch Sakura today:
- Sephi ->
- Nyquill ->
- Me ->
- Lincolm ->
If we lynch Sephi today (Insert Trollface here):
- Nyquill -> Sakura
- Me ->
- Lincolm ->
- Sakura ->
If we lynch Nyquill today
- Me ->
- Lincolm ->
- Sakura ->
- Sephi ->
If we lynch Lincolm today
- Nyquill -> Sakura
- Me ->
- Sakura ->
- Sephi ->
If we lynch me today, y'all are dumb.
Also why cant i be sane? :<
I want Sakura/Sephi/someone-else in LyLo tomorrow.
Because too many sane possibilities.Sakura wrote:
Also why cant i be sane? :<
Like, I'm the only one who can't be sane, which means that 4 ppl can be sane. Among those 4 ppl, you're least likely (if no chance) to be sane because you have the possibility of being paranoid and insane, which is in the other group of sanity. (Usually ppl are either sane/naive or insane/para)
Wait. Shit. Hold on a second.
nvm.
inb4 I scan GiF and get Inno...
Anyways guess i'll scan Nyquill, if we lynch Nyquill I'll scan Lincolm.
Why i'm not scanning conf town GiF? if im guaranteed not to be sane, then that means whether im paranoid or insane i'll get a guilty on him, which gives me no info.
Anyways guess i'll scan Nyquill, if we lynch Nyquill I'll scan Lincolm.
Why i'm not scanning conf town GiF? if im guaranteed not to be sane, then that means whether im paranoid or insane i'll get a guilty on him, which gives me no info.
We're lynching either Lincolm/Nyquill today, and you're gonna scan whoever didn't get lynched today.
That will confirmed your sanity tomorrow.
That will confirmed your sanity tomorrow.
confirm*
Sephi's checking me tonight.
Lincolm is checking Sephi if we lynch Nyquill today.
Nyquill -> Sakura
Sephi -> Nyquill
Lincolm -> Nyquill
Sakura -> Lincolm
GIF -> Lincolm
objections?
Sephi -> Nyquill
Lincolm -> Nyquill
Sakura -> Lincolm
GIF -> Lincolm
objections?
this if we NL. now let me consider scenarios with lynch
Hold on a sec. I'm trying to create a scenario where someone is confirmed town no matter what happens tomorrow.
F.
I made a typo on my testing place and now I need to run the scenarios all over again D:
I made a typo on my testing place and now I need to run the scenarios all over again D:
Screw this. I'm taking a break from this a bit.
Topic Starter
The moderator (still carrying the shotgun) heads back to the parlor once again and upon arrival, shows her disappointment. "You've talked for ages, and you still haven't concretely decided on an action yet? Wow you guys are more incompetent than Battler!"
She tilts her head upwards and clicks her tongue. "No one is voting for anyone yet."
Mod Note: If you find these posts annoying and want me to do a more "regular" format then please inform me.
She tilts her head upwards and clicks her tongue. "No one is voting for anyone yet."
Mod Note: If you find these posts annoying and want me to do a more "regular" format then please inform me.
Ok, just got to a certain conclusion.
Today, we MUST vote NL because there's no way to be 100% sure we are gathering enough information tomorrow to mathematically know who's the SK.
In we NL today, we can NL tomorrow too. If we Lynch today, tomorrow is LyLo
vote: No Lynch
Today, we MUST vote NL because there's no way to be 100% sure we are gathering enough information tomorrow to mathematically know who's the SK.
In we NL today, we can NL tomorrow too. If we Lynch today, tomorrow is LyLo
vote: No Lynch