forum

FOLiACETATE - Heterochromia Iridis

posted
Total Posts
61
show more
Mystyk
Hi there! Very late mod, sorry, but here it is:

General:
Check AiMod, because it seems like the tags are different.

Beginner:
01:06:981 (2,3) - maybe you could replace these with a long slider, just like 01:05:635 (1) - the beats in the background are basically the same at these places
01:13:169 (3,1) - I love this :3
01:27:160 (1,2) - these feel out of place, it is not comfortable to play, maybe try something like this? http://puu.sh/4Hz4I.jpg
01:25:008 (1) - I think the repeat should start 1/2 earlier
01:33:348 (2,1) - well this is a little bit confusing, because you focused on the melody and not the big beat, so it feels a bit strange to hit the circle after the slider, so in my opinion something like this would fit better:
http://puu.sh/4Hy1d.jpg
01:38:864 (2,3) - the distance actually confused me, even though it is fine, I would rather use a slider instead of a hit circle (2) - http://puu.sh/4HylX.jpg - it also fits the melody better
01:44:380 (3,4) - it feels like (3) doesn't fit the melody or the beats perfectly, so I think this would be more comfortable to play - http://puu.sh/4Hyxe.jpg - it fits the melody and the piano too (but you have to rearrange the spinner)

Standard:
00:08:595 (2) - it might flow better, if you rotated (2), e.g. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1018251
00:29:582 (2,3) - this antijump is kind of confusing, so I would suggest you to put (3) further (just an example http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019300)
01:11:017 (1,2) - please change the color here, at this point the background video is "disturbing" and it is hard to see the notes, and maybe don't stack them (?) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1018246 (the screenshot might not show it well that it is hard to see the notes)
01:20:703 (1) - very small thing, but I think this would look nicer: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019313
01:26:353 (3,1,2) - I think the short reverse sliders are a bit hard (and kind of unnecessasry too), so you should try to make it a bit easier, for example like this: http://puu.sh/4I3fW.jpg
01:31:465 (1,2) - you might want to use a slider instead of 2 hit circles, since (2) is on a red tick (and there is a fast piano sound in the background too, so the slider ticks would fit too)
01:36:846 (2,3) - this was confusing, because between these notes, there was another melody, and you didn't place anything there, so it would be nice if you replaced (2) and (3) with a slider
01:38:192 (1) - remove maybe? there is only a soft beat there, and you might make it easier if you remove it, and (2) will be emphasized better, since it's a bit beat, and the new combo will start there too
01:50:299 (1,1) - it might flow better if you replaced these --> http://puu.sh/4I3GP.jpg (but of course make it nicer if you decide to do it)

Hyper:
00:28:909 (3,1) - I don't like the sudden spacing change, and I don't think there is anything THAT loud in the music, so what about something like this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019532
01:12:496 (2,3) - stacking is confusing here (or the antijump), I woulld rather do it in a different way: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019510
01:19:627 (1) - this place feels a bit empty - 01:20:030 (2) - so why don't you try using 2 1/2 sliders? http://puu.sh/4I5vI.jpg
01:26:622 (5,2) - this overlap is ugly imo, try playing those 4 reverse sliders a bit to the right: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019521

Another:
00:05:905 (4) - why don't you put this a bit left? to make the distance around 1,50, because you used high spacing here too 00:05:366 (1,2,3) -
00:11:824 - add hit circle? since you left out a bigger beat in the music
00:12:093 (2,3,4) - I think it would fit better to the melody if you removed (2) and put (3) and (4) 1/2 earlier then add a hit circle here 00:12:900 (4) - it would fit a lot better imo, it is weird that you put those long sliders right AFTER the melody starts
00:20:299 (5) - remove hit circle, because you follow a pattern before, kind of hard to explain but "tu-tu-tu-tu tu tu-tu" and here you put one more object, and i think (4) is unnecessary, because the sounds are not so loud
00:22:452 (7) - same here ^
00:47:609 (1,2) - I think you could make these nicer: http://puu.sh/4I6tl.jpg
01:07:788 (1,2) - replace these with hit circles? i think circles here fit better, they empshasize the individual beats better than sliders
01:34:021 (2) - put a hit sound on the reverse maybe(?), it sounds a bit empty
01:37:250 (5) - same here, but you even put a hitsound to the beginning, but no hitsound on the reverse, while you can hear the same sound at both places
01:39:537 (3) - something like this for better flow? http://puu.sh/4I6LK.jpg - (3) will lead into (1) nicely like this

Extra:
01:24:739 (7,1) - ugly overmap imo, we can hardly see the end of the slider, it would be better to replace (1), e.g. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019646
01:55:411 (2) - this should end 1/2 earlier and you should add a hit circle - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019654

That's it for this difficulty, there is not much to say, I can't play it, and it looks decent already.

I'm sorry if my mod is not useful, the mapset is already very nice, so you get a star from me. I also got to like the song, good job, and good luck!

PS. Find a better BG :>
Topic Starter
ktgster
Mystyk

Mystyk wrote:

Hi there! Very late mod, sorry, but here it is:

General:
Check AiMod, because it seems like the tags are different. - I forgot

Beginner:
01:06:981 (2,3) - maybe you could replace these with a long slider, just like 01:05:635 (1) - the beats in the background are basically the same at these places - a slider feels wrong to use here personally
01:13:169 (3,1) - I love this :3
01:27:160 (1,2) - these feel out of place, it is not comfortable to play, maybe try something like this? http://puu.sh/4Hz4I.jpg - as soon as I saw this, i thought of the same thing BUT, theres no room for the slider and removing the 2nd note feels weird to hear
01:25:008 (1) - I think the repeat should start 1/2 earlier - oh wow, fixed
01:33:348 (2,1) - well this is a little bit confusing, because you focused on the melody and not the big beat, so it feels a bit strange to hit the circle after the slider, so in my opinion something like this would fit better: - done
http://puu.sh/4Hy1d.jpg
01:38:864 (2,3) - the distance actually confused me, even though it is fine, I would rather use a slider instead of a hit circle (2) - http://puu.sh/4HylX.jpg - it also fits the melody better - I kinda followed this since this raises a overlap issue and made the last slider a circle instead
01:44:380 (3,4) - it feels like (3) doesn't fit the melody or the beats perfectly, so I think this would be more comfortable to play - http://puu.sh/4Hyxe.jpg - it fits the melody and the piano too (but you have to rearrange the spinner) - done, rearranged spinner to when piano starts

Standard:
00:08:595 (2) - it might flow better, if you rotated (2), e.g. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1018251 - yay for changing parts that made this obsolete, changed to something that works decently I think
00:29:582 (2,3) - this antijump is kind of confusing, so I would suggest you to put (3) further (just an example http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019300) - also done because its just too good
01:11:017 (1,2) - please change the color here, at this point the background video is "disturbing" and it is hard to see the notes, and maybe don't stack them (?) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1018246 (the screenshot might not show it well that it is hard to see the notes) - unstacking would look weird but changed NC color
01:20:703 (1) - very small thing, but I think this would look nicer: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019313 - done
01:26:353 (3,1,2) - I think the short reverse sliders are a bit hard (and kind of unnecessasry too), so you should try to make it a bit easier, for example like this: http://puu.sh/4I3fW.jpg - ehh I don't like the use of 1/2's in such a fast map, done something different instead
01:31:465 (1,2) - you might want to use a slider instead of 2 hit circles, since (2) is on a red tick (and there is a fast piano sound in the background too, so the slider ticks would fit too) - I just went with a 1/1 repeated slider. It can't be that hard
01:36:846 (2,3) - this was confusing, because between these notes, there was another melody, and you didn't place anything there, so it would be nice if you replaced (2) and (3) with a slider - replaced with a slider, now I gotta rearrange more notes
01:38:192 (1) - remove maybe? there is only a soft beat there, and you might make it easier if you remove it, and (2) will be emphasized better, since it's a bit beat, and the new combo will start there too - despite the difficulty, I actually think this slider emphasizes quite well and fits the song
01:50:299 (1,1) - it might flow better if you replaced these --> http://puu.sh/4I3GP.jpg (but of course make it nicer if you decide to do it) - done

Hyper:
00:28:909 (3,1) - I don't like the sudden spacing change, and I don't think there is anything THAT loud in the music, so what about something like this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019532 - okay, done
01:12:496 (2,3) - stacking is confusing here (or the antijump), I woulld rather do it in a different way: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019510 - also done
01:19:627 (1) - this place feels a bit empty - 01:20:030 (2) - so why don't you try using 2 1/2 sliders? http://puu.sh/4I5vI.jpg - I prefer the current one as (1) is the note that goes well with the melody
01:26:622 (5,2) - this overlap is ugly imo, try playing those 4 reverse sliders a bit to the right: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019521 - fixed

Another:
00:05:905 (4) - why don't you put this a bit left? to make the distance around 1,50, because you used high spacing here too 00:05:366 (1,2,3) - ehh, this is fine as it is
00:11:824 - add hit circle? since you left out a bigger beat in the music - woah, forgot
00:12:093 (2,3,4) - I think it would fit better to the melody if you removed (2) and put (3) and (4) 1/2 earlier then add a hit circle here 00:12:900 (4) - it would fit a lot better imo, it is weird that you put those long sliders right AFTER the melody starts - this part was changed due to suggestions from someone
00:20:299 (5) - remove hit circle, because you follow a pattern before, kind of hard to explain but "tu-tu-tu-tu tu tu-tu" and here you put one more object, and i think (4) is unnecessary, because the sounds are not so loud
00:22:452 (7) - same here ^ - done for both
00:47:609 (1,2) - I think you could make these nicer: http://puu.sh/4I6tl.jpg - fixed
01:07:788 (1,2) - replace these with hit circles? i think circles here fit better, they empshasize the individual beats better than sliders - this destroyed so much, thank god for an alternative
01:34:021 (2) - put a hit sound on the reverse maybe(?), it sounds a bit empty - okay
01:37:250 (5) - same here, but you even put a hitsound to the beginning, but no hitsound on the reverse, while you can hear the same sound at both places - I just spammed white ticks for hitsounds, done regardless
01:39:537 (3) - something like this for better flow? http://puu.sh/4I6LK.jpg - (3) will lead into (1) nicely like this - also done

Extra:
01:24:739 (7,1) - ugly overmap imo, we can hardly see the end of the slider, it would be better to replace (1), e.g. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019646 - tried something else since that ruins the flow quite a bit
01:55:411 (2) - this should end 1/2 earlier and you should add a hit circle - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1019654 - done

That's it for this difficulty, there is not much to say, I can't play it, and it looks decent already.

I'm sorry if my mod is not useful, the mapset is already very nice, so you get a star from me. I also got to like the song, good job, and good luck! - It's fine, and also thanks

PS. Find a better BG :> - BG's are impossible to find
val0108
go to rank
[CSGA]Ar3sgice
i feel 00:18:281 - 00:27:833 and 01:12:093 - 01:25:008 can add in more 1/4s or short sliders, the music feels more than the constant 1/2+triple 1/4s 0,0

and good map

val0108 wrote:

go to rank
Midnaait
I want to make taiko diffs :<

val0108 wrote:

go to rank
Mystyk
I want this ranked :< *gave stars*
Zare

val0108 wrote:

go to rank
grumd
okay gotta mod it soon
remind me sometime pls
grumd
Hallo.

— General

  • In the end of the video you can see: http://puu.sh/5qLIi.jpg
    So change the tags to "LeaF sak Coalenscent Breakcore t+mugen CHOiX To7"
    And maybe also add some tags like beatmania etc?
— Terror

  • 00:05:635 (3) - imo this stack ruins the jumpy speed that was set up by 00:05:366 (1,2,3) - . place the slider at 00:05:635 - and the circle at 00:05:905 -
    for example you can stack the circle on (5) if placed at 00:05:905 -
    00:17:743 (1,2,3,4) - It's not really possible to recognize the 1/4 music under that 1/4 stream, so you should better make the repeating slider longer and remove the 1/4 notes: http://puu.sh/5qKxm.jpg
    01:13:169 (1) - End point 1 grid up? :)
    01:27:564 (1,2) - It's a bit harsh to start a stream from a red tick, and there's no real loud sound that needs that emphasizement on this note. you should replace these two by a 1/4 slider to make this pattern a bit more readable
    01:30:523 (2) - This should be 1/6
    01:33:618 (1) - This should be 1/6 too
    02:01:062 (2) - You forgot one repeat
— Another

  • 00:36:846 (2) - For the sake of readability, it's better not to stack them. Try this: http://puu.sh/5qL3R.jpg
    00:52:183 - Better place a circle there, it's the beginning of the 00:52:317 (6,7,8,1) - pattern
    01:06:712 (1) - This jump feels a bit unnatural since the distance until the next object is smaller than to the previous, but the rhythm until previous is smaller. (hope you got it xD) Well, place it closer to the previous one: http://puu.sh/5qLaD.jpg
    01:18:281 (4) - 1 grid down?
    01:20:703 (1,2,3) - Make this triple neater please, it looks odd. http://puu.sh/5qLdA.jpg
— Hyper

  • 00:10:344 (3) - Even for Hyper, this feels like a jump. Maybe place it a bit farther? http://puu.sh/5qLj5.jpg
    01:02:138 - Add a note here. 01:02:272 (2) - this one alone feels out of place
    01:30:927 (3) - Two repeats was really unexpected, better remove one repeat and add a circle afterwards
    01:31:465 (1,2,3) - This pattern will be better if you make all these sliders not triples but 5-ples :D Like that: http://puu.sh/5qLqr.jpg
    If you're afraid that people might misread last slider as 5-ple too, replace it by triple with circles: http://puu.sh/5qLsK.jpg
— Standard

  • 01:52:183 (2,3,4,5,1,2) - This is a bit too hard for this diff. Replace 01:52:183 (2) - with a single slider from 01:52:183 to 01:52:452 - and make a slider from 01:53:259 to 01:53:662 -
— Beginner

  • 01:24:470 (2,3,1) - The spacing is a bit inconsistent here, fix it.
Call me back after fixes.
Topic Starter
ktgster

[CSGA]Ar3sgice wrote:

i feel 00:18:281 - 00:27:833 and 01:12:093 - 01:25:008 can add in more 1/4s or short sliders, the music feels more than the constant 1/2+triple 1/4s 0,0 - I don't like adding random triples if the song doesn't really support it and would just be overmapping which I don't like

and good map

grumd wrote:

Hallo.

— General

  • In the end of the video you can see: http://puu.sh/5qLIi.jpg
    So change the tags to "LeaF sak Coalenscent Breakcore t+mugen CHOiX To7"
    And maybe also add some tags like beatmania etc? - done
— Terror

  • 00:05:635 (3) - imo this stack ruins the jumpy speed that was set up by 00:05:366 (1,2,3) - . place the slider at 00:05:635 - and the circle at 00:05:905 -
    for example you can stack the circle on (5) if placed at 00:05:905 - done
    00:17:743 (1,2,3,4) - It's not really possible to recognize the 1/4 music under that 1/4 stream, so you should better make the repeating slider longer and remove the 1/4 notes: http://puu.sh/5qKxm.jpg - also done
    01:13:169 (1) - End point 1 grid up? :) - dat nazi, done
    01:27:564 (1,2) - It's a bit harsh to start a stream from a red tick, and there's no real loud sound that needs that emphasizement on this note. you should replace these two by a 1/4 slider to make this pattern a bit more readable - no change here since its not really hard to read and the 1/4 slider before that makes it easier to play. Although I changed the 1/4 slider to a circle so I hope that makes it more easier to play
    01:30:523 (2) - This should be 1/6 - done
    01:33:618 (1) - This should be 1/6 too - ^
    02:01:062 (2) - You forgot one repeat - ouch, how did I miss that
— Another

  • 00:36:846 (2) - For the sake of readability, it's better not to stack them. Try this: http://puu.sh/5qL3R.jpg - done
    00:52:183 - Better place a circle there, it's the beginning of the 00:52:317 (6,7,8,1) - pattern - done
    01:06:712 (1) - This jump feels a bit unnatural since the distance until the next object is smaller than to the previous, but the rhythm until previous is smaller. (hope you got it xD) Well, place it closer to the previous one: http://puu.sh/5qLaD.jpg - was just thinking of the same thing, done
    01:18:281 (4) - 1 grid down? - why not
    01:20:703 (1,2,3) - Make this triple neater please, it looks odd. http://puu.sh/5qLdA.jpg - fixed
— Hyper

  • 00:10:344 (3) - Even for Hyper, this feels like a jump. Maybe place it a bit farther? http://puu.sh/5qLj5.jpg - increased the spacing, should be more readable
    01:02:138 - Add a note here. 01:02:272 (2) - this one alone feels out of place - done
    01:30:927 (3) - Two repeats was really unexpected, better remove one repeat and add a circle afterwards - done, I wonder if this will be too hard?
    01:31:465 (1,2,3) - This pattern will be better if you make all these sliders not triples but 5-ples :D Like that: http://puu.sh/5qLqr.jpg
    If you're afraid that people might misread last slider as 5-ple too, replace it by triple with circles: http://puu.sh/5qLsK.jpg - well I had to change this whole part and shift around things a bit, this should be fine now
— Standard

  • 01:52:183 (2,3,4,5,1,2) - This is a bit too hard for this diff. Replace 01:52:183 (2) - with a single slider from 01:52:183 to 01:52:452 - and make a slider from 01:53:259 to 01:53:662 - done although I moved some objects around
— Beginner

  • 01:24:470 (2,3,1) - The spacing is a bit inconsistent here, fix it. - fixed
Call me back after fixes.

val0108 wrote:

go to rank
I hope...
grumd
Cool, bubble!
Zare
Fuk Yesh
Irreversible
Alright, checked everything IRC and I guess it's ready to go.

Ranked!

congratz for your first ranked map :)
Lanturn
Hurray for more Canadian made maps!

Grats on your first ranked mapset
Dainesl
Thanks Irre. Congrats Ktgster!
Irreversible

Lanturn wrote:

Hurray for more Canadian made maps!

Grats on your first ranked mapset
2 maps from canada ranked in one day, this was planned for sure! *gets paranoid*
grumd
Congratulationzzz :>
Dolphin
Hey more LeaF on osu is a good thing!
Leader
This is so pleasant to play despite high BPM, great job.
Wishy
Excellent map.
Kyouren
Gratzz!! Kyx and ktgster!!^^ for first Ranked Maps!!^^
silmarilen
RIP hands
Pettanko
congrats!
vape
Jesus christ
pw384
gj!

@Flower
Iain
hands to the grave.
MeraMiPoP_old
gj!

@Flower
Aqo
wooow it happened

grats ktg!
Alumetorz
niceee
congrats :D
Ulysses
Fuck my ass please,
you are genius!
Mystyk
congrats! I love this mapset! :3
Giralda
woah grats ktg!
Kanye West

nold_1702 wrote:

Fuck my ass please
:shock: :shock: :shock: :shock: :shock:


is that ktgster

getting a map ranked :shock:

congrats man!
Hard
ktgster got one ranked. i'm happy.

i made cookies and ate them to celebrate. Now I'll play this. And i'll fail. But that's okay cause failure makes us stronger.

Wait I know that map. I threw a star on it. Well... Don't judge me...
Diptags
Great map! sounds good :D
blooming tea
Please sign in to reply.

New reply