Thanks for the mod.

Lizbeth wrote:

Easy
00:16:024 (1,2,3) - this sounds weird, move it, 2/6 later... im not sure

I wasn't sure what to do about that so I turned it into a couple of sliders.

Mod Info's:

Green: Suggestions.
Orange: I think you should fix this.
Red: You must fix this.

Starts Suggestions:

All seems ok.

[Easy]

zzz...zzz...

[Normal]

Slider Velocity: 1,30

[Hard]

It's ok

Starred~

68 BPM... challenging offset ._.

Offset: 352 (-13 from current)

...but hearing it from all the offsets I get, it's confusing. I agree with it being 68 BPM, it's just that... the offsets are dynamic at some points. For now this is the best I can get.

[Overall]

BPM: 68,00 - Offset: 290 (Remember to resnap all notes.)

Normal sections seems too loud. Lower volume.

[Easy]

Slider tick 3 sounds weird. Use 2 or 4.

Seems fine~

[Normal]

01:14:042 (5) - New combo.
01:17:095 (1) - I never suggest hitsounds, but here place a hitfinish.

[Hard]

00:33:081 (7) - New combo.

A very relaxing song~ Thanks for mapping it. ~ Star

[Easy]

Just because its a easy, don't devoid it of hit circles/sliders, map more parts please.

Click for picture >.> yes yes, I got lazy.


Also, Slider Tick Rate should be 2. 3 sounds off...

[Normal]

00:42:027 (3) - Extend this to the white tick, and fix spinner afterwords.
01:03:089 (2) - Place under (1) & (3) so it doesn't touch the slider.
01:07:042 (8) - one right, one up ( turn off grid snap )
01:15:036 (3) - isn't snapped. ( snap the rest then )
01:27:071 (1,2,3,4) - Place all in center. I thinks plays nicer.

[Hard]

Nice, I like this. Its pretty enough ^:)

This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.

Hello~

[Easy]
00:42:704 (5) New combo?

[Normal]
All note unsnapped! Resnap Please.

[Hard]
This difficulty is too! Resnap Please.
00:12:999 Remove Break.

Great song~! I like it~ Especially good hitsound.
Starred.

General:

Tags?

Timing:

In general, I'm not confident about the offset the offsets I'm getting vary too much, I see Zekira has posted one so I'd keep that for now

Easy:

Remove audio lead in time for this difficulty.

Well it's an easy, and there isn't much wrong with it.

00:30:035 (3) - Maybe move this directly beneath 2.
00:37:041 (3) - Directly above 2.
00:47:099 (3) - I'd move this horizontally so its on the same level as 1 and 2 is a square below.
01:03:088 (1,2,3) - Here it isn't evident exactly what beat you are following, I'd remap this bit.
01:09:017 (4) - Spacing? New combo.
01:12:070 (2) - New combo.
01:16:023 (1) - Spacing - too close to 4.

Normal:

Remove audio lead in.

01:03:058 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - No this part doesn't work, it doesn't play nicely either. Options -

1 - Delete and ignore this whole section by extending the break (and mapping earlier)
2 - I love this part! (Keep it)
3 - Try this (ignore the numbers this is where I had the beats):


4 - Edit what you have, then I'd suggest:

01:03:058 (1) - Delete
01:06:023 (6) - Delete
01:05:094 (5) - Make a slider till 01:06:528

Other than that seems fine.

Hard:

-- Why do the sliders have different sound effects just for this difficulty?
-- I'm not hitsound modding but I'd check for consistency between difficulties one example at 01:10:940 the hitsounds seem much louder than the other difficulties. Also this difficulty seems to have different cymbals etc.
-- You ignore the part I had issue with in the other difficulties (01:03:058)

00:00:005 (1) - I generally don't like beats before the timing section.
00:12:999 Remove break.
00:43:881 ^
01:02:041 - Start the spinner here and end it at 01:04:028

Good job with the map, I'm uncertain about the timing but I couldnt find a better alternative for now. Nice hitsound use as always, good map

~~ Starred

This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.

[Easy]

00:29:046 (2) - Nice Hitsound. <3

[Normal]
00:26:038 (6) - Move a little closer to (7)

[Hard]

Nothing wrong here.

I apologize for my late minor mod..Starred.

By AL2e10's Mod queue ~

[Hard]
00:29:469 (1) remove new combo
00:31:234 (1) ^
00:39:175 (1) ^
00:41:822 (1) ^
00:43:587 (1) ^
00:46:234 (1) ^
00:47:999 (1) ^
00:38:293 (4) new combo

[Easy, Normal]
That fine !!

[All]
Good map !!
Star !!

Just here to star this map

Fuuko's mod dekimashita~

Easy:

Nothing wrong found.

Normal:

0:22:557 (8); Consider adding a break here.

Hard:

Argh. Nothing wrong found. ;-;' That pisses me ( jk jk <3 )

General:

I strongly recommend you change the hitcircle size on the hard diff. Most people don't like small hitcircles. ( I am one of them, myself... )

The hitsounds are amazing, hence why I don't see a single reason to not star this. Keep up the good work. ;*

Love the map and the custom hitsounds.

If you need more combo bursts, just call me.





Diff will come at you soon. Along with modding.

I think three is the max for each post so...

SOFT mod is gogo

nice map but first off, the timing goes out from 01:15, i think it needs another timing section around here for it to perfectly be in time, as it is it feels very wierd.

srry i cant find the the offset for this section, im no good at timing >_>

[Hard]
00:50:064 (2,3) - spacing is too close, with distance snap on move (3) a lil bit and you will see what i mean


very nice song and peacefull beatmaps, good job, i just hope somebody comes along who can time this properly for you

star because i <3 it XD

Hard's sooo easy. If an Insane wouldn't feel overmapped, I'd say one would be nice.

Like I said, I won't be modding, just general comments. I didn't find anything that stood out through a play through each diff, and the technical stuff seems to check out. I thought the offset might be off at some point, but that could've just been me hitting a new song out of time. I don't have the time to test this right now in editor. I can SS it pretty easy, but the OD's low so offset could be off a little.

Anyways, nothing that blew me away, but it seems like a nice easy map. Star, good job.

This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.

Dusty wrote:

Yeah, that offset is annoying to find... I changed the BPM though.

The BPM Analyzer gave me a BPM about 1.875x larger than the one I had, so I thought that was just it being stupid. It gave me 127.43, while I had 68. I changed the BPM to 68 - (68/127.5)*(127.5-127.43) = 67.963.

There are probably multiple offsets/BPMs. (Or MM is just being extremely retarded.) No promises, but maybe I'll take a look when I wake up. Or you could ask a local resident timer, like Ephemeral, adam, yoshi, strawberry-kun, etc.

Song is a bit soft, so that's sometimes difficult. I'll take some plays in editor to figure it out if I do later on.

I believe I have that Insane difficulty that you are looking for, Shinde.

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty) [Insane].osu

And something else to go with it, everyone loves white, right?

Oh yeah, and I need you to replace the .osb file with this one.

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty).osb

[Easy]
Nothing particularly odd as far as I noticed.

[Normal]
01:16:118[4,5,6] These all are slightly late. Move them one tick backwards, and it should mesh with her singing.

[Hard]
Nothing bad I noted here, either, although it is quite tricky. =)

[Insane]
Since it's incomplete, so you might change it, but a 37 second wait is a bit long, especially for one spinner, lol. Also, not sure if there's any purpose to having Kiai time during the break...

All in all though, I definitely dig the orchestral/renaissance faire tone of the song, and the vid's pretty neat too. A star for you!

HowlingBlue wrote:

[Normal]
01:16:118[4,5,6] These all are slightly late. Move them one tick backwards, and it should mesh with her singing.

Oh, wow. You're right.

(insert whining about the timing being annoying)

Updated diff coming through.

Ain't finished yet but, since you want to do SB changes and I haven't downloaded the new one.

EDIT: New and improved, squeaky clean diff. Now with more KB! 0_o

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty) [MarioBros777's Heroic].osu

OSU! Timing Help!

BPM 68
Offset 320 340

Starred~!

Edit: Still Testing... ...Done

[Easy]


[Normal]
00:26:081 (7) - Pretty low down
00:42:025 (3) - ^

[Hard]
00:24:045 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I suggest you move this whole section up a bit.

[Heroic]
Please lower the HP drain a bit....
01:28:057 (1) - Loooooong slider......

Great map (This map would fit the easy series )
*star*

Lower HP Drain and I'm not changing that slider.

Plus hitsound additions. ^_^ You got to love them.

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty) [MarioBros777's Heroic].osu

Now if you excuse me, I'll help myself to some cake.

The timing and 1/6 beat snap divisor scares me... ;_;. Sorry, but I won't touch on timing then. However, I thought there should not be any notes before the initial offset ?

This song reminds me of Final Fantasy Tactics. =O

A star for yea, since I really have no idea how to mod a 1/6 map, but I have test play all of them, seems fine to me if the timing is correct.

alvisto wrote:

This song reminds me of Final Fantasy Tactics. =O

Hitoshi Sakimoto composed both this song and the songs in FFT, so that's why they're similar.

Dusty wrote:

alvisto wrote:

This song reminds me of Final Fantasy Tactics. =O

Hitoshi Sakimoto composed both this song and the songs in FFT, so that's why they're similar.

:O No wonder ! xD

[General]

Turn MB's diff's lead-in down to 1985 to be consistent with Hard.
I'd recommend adding a black layer in the storyboard so that the video fades in from black instead of from the current background; looks better in my opinion.

[Normal]

00:27:692 - Excess timing section.

[Hard]

Has a lot of random uninherited timing sections, please fix.

01:21:810 (2) - A little non-symmetrical.

[MB777]

00:05:634 (3,4,5) - Inconsistent spacing.

Geez, that's a lot of spinners... With only 1:19 of draining time, you have a spinner every 6 seconds. Might want to tone that down a bit.

Still a cool map though.

Kytoxid wrote:

I'd recommend adding a black layer in the storyboard so that the video fades in from black instead of from the current background; looks better in my opinion.

Done. (that's actually really cool)

Kytoxid wrote:

[Hard]
Has a lot of random uninherited timing sections, please fix.

aah, how did that happen?...

Kytoxid wrote:

01:21:810 (2) - A little non-symmetrical.

It's better now.

Have to bug MB777 about his diff.

I love this game even though I haven't beaten the first story yet. I modding without even being asked for this reason.

[Normal]
00:56:810 (3) - Pushed into the lifebar looks wrong and on hard rock it's slightly offscreen.

[Hard]
The speed up seems really uncalled for and yet it seemed really good.

Great maps, and wonderful hitsounds, you get a star.

rust45 wrote:

[Normal]
00:56:810 (3) - Pushed into the lifebar looks wrong and on hard rock it's slightly offscreen.

Oops, that shouldn't happen. Fixed.

rust45 wrote:

[Hard]
The speed up seems really uncalled for and yet it seemed really good.

If it seemed good, then I guess it was called for?

Also, thanks for modding

Since I've modded this already, I'll mod the one last thing I didn't before. (and I'll pubble once this mod and MB777's diff are fixed).

[Easy]

01:26:810 - Unused timing section.

[Normal]

01:20:781 - Unused timing section.
01:21:369 - ^

[Hard]

01:31:369 - Unused timing section.

[MB777's Heroic]

(remember to make sure you change the lead-in time, currently the black background flashes in late because there's too much lead-in)

01:36:389 - Unused timing section.

This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.

LOVE !_!

yeahyeahyeahhh wrote:

Easy
>> 01:09:163 (1,1,1) - Don't really see the need for new combos like this on an easy, but your call.

Fixed, thanks.

DeathxShinigami wrote:

LOVE !_!

Thanks!

This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.

Thanks for modding!

Gens wrote:

[Normal]

1. OD feels a tad too high.

OK, lowered by 1.

Gens wrote:

[Hard]

1. Shouldn't a 2x warning be there somewhere?

I guess...

Gens wrote:

01:28:134 - Kiai fountain? unfitting :[

whoops, forgot to add Kiai to the timing section before it, fixed

Gens wrote:

EDIT: Oh yes, check the Audio lead in in Mario's diff, the background is not black when it starts

MB hasn't sent me an updated version, but fixed just so people stop pointing this one out

oh crud, I didn't submit anything yet? I swear I did.

Let's get this ranked!

Oh...and I can do those jumps, Gens. And I suck at osu!

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty) [MB's Heroic].osu