forum

12 Girls Band - Horse Race [Osu|Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
66
show more
Kawayi Rika
Hi ~ cmn_891127 ~ :)

Mod time for my Queue ~

Red : Must be fixed
Pink : Should be fixed
Purple : Just suggestions

[General]


  1. Change AudioLeadIn: 1500 or 2000 pls(1000 is too fast).

[Luka's Insane]


  1. 00:07:328 (1,2,3,4) - Try move to here like this.
  2. 00:11:572 (4) - Add new combo.
  3. 00:15:816 (2) - ^
  4. 00:23:597 (1) - ^
  5. 00:29:963 (3) - ^
  6. 00:44:109 (1) - Extend to here 00:44:552,sound much better.
  7. 01:15:763 (1) - Move 1 grid down.

[Hard]


  1. Too low setting for this diff.
    AR+1 or 2,OD+2,HP+1 much better play with me.

That's all ~

Good luck ~
Topic Starter
cmn_891127

Kawayi Rika wrote:

Hi ~ cmn_891127 ~ :)

Mod time for my Queue ~

Red : Must be fixed
Pink : Should be fixed
Purple : Just suggestions

[General]


  1. Change AudioLeadIn: 1500 or 2000 pls(1000 is too fast). fixed

[Luka's Insane]


  1. 00:07:328 (1,2,3,4) - Try move to here like this. fixed
  2. 00:11:572 (4) - Add new combo. fixed
  3. 00:15:816 (2) - ^
  4. 00:23:597 (1) - ^
  5. 00:29:963 (3) - ^ fixed
  6. 00:44:109 (1) - Extend to here 00:44:552,sound much better.
  7. 01:15:763 (1) - Move 1 grid down. fixed

[Hard]


  1. Too low setting for this diff.
    AR+1 or 2,OD+2,HP+1 much better play with me. fixed

That's all ~

Good luck ~
thank you, Rika~
Kenezz
I see the BPM good =o
winber1
Luka's

00:35:470 - maybe it's just me, but i like it better if you added a note here and at 00:35:558 - . Musically this also makes sense because this way the pattern repeats four times in a 4/4 time signature.
00:49:794 (1,1) - i feel one spinner fits better. nothing really calls for two spinners.

Hard

--the silent notes i don't like very much to be honest. I'm almost about to say that the way you used the silent notes is unrankable, but i'm also hesitant to say that as well.

00:03:107 (1,2,3) - really awkward to play. End 00:03:107 (1) - at 00:03:461 - and do something like http://puu.sh/m411 the pattern i used may look kinda weird, but it feels a lot less awkward.
00:14:425 (1) - remove combo
00:40:244 (2) - i'd add a new combo just to make the spacing and to emphasize the music.

Aoi's

--I have just realized that the beat is not 169.64 in the beginning. The is is every 3/2 ticks, which is about 115ish. However, you don't really need to change any timing since it works out, but you need to realize that the beat is actually at 00:02:930, 00:03:461, 00:03:991, and 00:04:522. From there on the BPM is 169.64

With that in mind. You should map the beginning of the song like this http://puu.sh/m49V

00:04:875 (1,2,3,4) - stacks are kinda hard for beginners to read :/
00:56:514 (1) - remove combo and add new combo on next note
01:31:883 (6) - you should unstack

Really, it's a nice mapset. I don't really have any complaints.

good luck~~

(sorry for taking so long >_>)
jossieP
uhhhh eeehhh >:
I must leave my apologize, I dont like the way that this is mapped T.T sorry again this is a nice song, you have nice maps here but I dont agree with the way that you guys are mapping this, especially on the taiko diff >_< is an awesome work is hard and challenging a bit overmapped but again, I in my personal opinion dont like the way is mapped.
In my opinion taking that instrument (dont know how its name, sorry for my ignorance) as main and unique sound is just so superficial, I will love if you take some sounds of the background and map some of them, but you are just aiming on follow that instrument.
Sorry again dont mind me this is just my personal opinion, Im sure that you are on your way of ranking this
One more time sorry
obviously dont kudos this

[Aoi's Leg]

I really like this diff is supposed to be a [Normal] diff right? well it really feels like a [Normal] diff, but is moar variated and follows almost all the sounds on the song
  1. 01:09:601 (1) - burai slider is unrankable, the end of slider is getting back on itself
  2. 01:11:016 (2) - same for ctrl+r
  3. 01:12:430 - no increase the distance snap?
  4. 01:35:774 (1) - covered by previous spinner hitburst
also having a custom hitsound silenced like this is unrankabledont get mad with me, is just my opinion Im nothing for tell you how to map, sorry again
Also the difference between [Normal] and [Hard] is too big, maybe must add a second and easier [Hard] diff? again is just my opinion


Kawayi Rika wrote:

Good luck ~
I dont apologize for that quote xD
lovhin456
Hello, sorry for the delay

General:
- Disable letterboxing during breaks for all difficulties
- I have to agree with ikari_kyon, the difficulty gap between Aoi's leg and Hard is kinda big, it may be better to make Aoi's leg a complete easy diff not a easy/normal and after that make another diff that would make the mapset have a better spread

Aoi's Leg:
- 00:02:930 >> This may be hard for new players because it's a short slider and also it has 2 repeats these two things combined can result into something confusing for a player so try to change it into something else
- 00:04:875 (1,2) >> Stacks may be hard for new players, consider unstacking
- 00:06:290 (3,4) >> ^
- 01:13:845 >> New combo
- 01:30:822 >> ^
- 01:31:530 >> Stacks may be hard for new players, consider unstacking

Hard:
- 01:32:237 >> It may be a good idea to split this combo into 2 sets of combos

Luka's Insane:
- 00:14:337 >> I think that it actually feels better if you start the repeating slider here
- 00:15:044 >> ^
- 00:22:914 >> It would be nice to split the combo into 2 sets of combos
- 00:39:891 >> New combo
- 01:15:879 >> Same as 00:14:337
- 01:17:294 >> ^

Tama's Taiko Oni:
- Center the difficulty settings

* That's all
Topic Starter
cmn_891127

lovhin456 wrote:

Hello, sorry for the delay

General:
- Disable letterboxing during breaks for all difficulties
- I have to agree with ikari_kyon, the difficulty gap between Aoi's leg and Hard is kinda big, it may be better to make Aoi's leg a complete easy diff not a easy/normal and after that make another diff that would make the mapset have a better spread

Aoi's Leg:
- 00:02:930 >> This may be hard for new players because it's a short slider and also it has 2 repeats these two things combined can result into something confusing for a player so try to change it into something else
- 00:04:875 (1,2) >> Stacks may be hard for new players, consider unstacking
- 00:06:290 (3,4) >> ^
- 01:13:845 >> New combo
- 01:30:822 >> ^
- 01:31:530 >> Stacks may be hard for new players, consider unstacking

Hard:
- 01:32:237 >> It may be a good idea to split this combo into 2 sets of combos

Luka's Insane:
- 00:14:337 >> I think that it actually feels better if you start the repeating slider here
- 00:15:044 >> ^
- 00:22:914 >> It would be nice to split the combo into 2 sets of combos
- 00:39:891 >> New combo
- 01:15:879 >> Same as 00:14:337
- 01:17:294 >> ^

Tama's Taiko Oni:
- Center the difficulty settings

* That's all
All fixed, except the Luka's Insane
  • - 00:14:337 >> I think that it actually feels better if you start the repeating slider here
    - 00:15:044 >> ^
    - 01:15:879 >> Same as 00:14:337
    - 01:17:294 >> ^
I asked Luka, she said she would not like to change them. I see these combos feels like it starts later than the music. If I change the pattern, it is more difficult to hit.

Thank you very much~
lovhin456
Hello, sorry for the huge delay ...

[General]
- The timing seems a bit off to me, I'm not really good at this so I recommend you get someone to check it

[Aoi's Leg]
- Fine

[KS's Normal]
- Fine

[Hard]
- 01:32:237 >> I'm not sure if it is a good idea to do a new combo spam here. It does look good but others might think it's unnecessary, for me it's fine

[Luka's Insane]
- 00:02:930 (1,2) >> Delete these notes ? They don't make sense because the music starts on 00:03:107 so these two notes are not following anything
- 00:11:596 >> New combo ?
- 00:41:306 >> I think that the new combo should start here rather than in the previous note
- 00:44:842 (2,3,4) >> Not sure about these, they don't sound that well
- 01:08:717 (2) >> End the slider here ?

The mapset looks good, no real problems
Megurine Luka
不想给你带来麻烦所以还是改掉了:<

Timing的话找下Faust吧:)

Download: 12 Girls Band - Horse Race (Short Ver.) (cmn_891127) [Luka's Insane].osu
Faust
Here's your timing.

BPM: 169.64 Offset: 278
BPM: 171.00 Offset: 92,237
BPM: 201.00 Offset: 94,166
BPM: 85.20 Offset: 95,061
Topic Starter
cmn_891127

lovhin456 wrote:

Hello, sorry for the huge delay ...

[General]
- The timing seems a bit off to me, I'm not really good at this so I recommend you get someone to check it
Faust have checked it. I am not sure it is the best timing, and I just can say I play it fine in Easy, Normal & Hard (Insane is difficult for me).

[Luka's Insane]
- 00:02:930 (1,2) >> Delete these notes ? They don't make sense because the music starts on 00:03:107 so these two notes are not following anything
- 00:11:596 >> New combo ?
- 00:41:306 >> I think that the new combo should start here rather than in the previous note
- 00:44:842 (2,3,4) >> Not sure about these, they don't sound that well
- 01:08:717 (2) >> End the slider here ?
All fixed

Faust wrote:

Here's your timing.

BPM: 169.64 Offset: 278
BPM: 171.00 Offset: 92,237
BPM: 201.00 Offset: 94,166
BPM: 85.20 Offset: 95,061
Thanks for your help~
Faust
How do you feel about the timing?

Are you confident about it now?
Topic Starter
cmn_891127

Faust wrote:

How do you feel about the timing?Are you confident about it now?
the timing in the end is really good, but
00:14:248 (1,2,3) - off
01:15:083 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - ahead

ONLY these 2 parts have problems
Faust
I need you in-game so I can be specific.
lovhin456
Bubbled
LKs
-
[Random Timing Check]

00:58:968 (1) -
01:01:087 (1) -

偶然路过看见的 感觉有些地方还是有点快 比如上述note(我用的是luka难度)



看你 如果改了我可以rebubble
Topic Starter
cmn_891127

LKs wrote:

-
[Random Timing Check]

00:58:968 (1) -
01:01:087 (1) -

偶然路过看见的 感觉有些地方还是有点快 比如上述note(我用的是luka难度)



看你 如果改了我可以rebubble
最开始那条红线还是没有加,不过把开始和第一个kiai的红线都+6ms
LKs


其实你把luka难度这么放就会发现note从准确压音变成越来越慢(offest278) 171BPM作用到00:01:875 (2) - 是让这个note比之前快了6ms但减去offest加上的6ms其实是一模一样的(我是以大哥diff为例) normal的话因为offest一开始放早了6ms所以到00:01:339 (3) - 反而跟得很准

anyway, rebubble. GL on rank
Topic Starter
cmn_891127
谢谢LKs~~~~~
Megurine Luka
It should be me saying "I love you"

;_;
Shohei Ohtani
bubble modding

Insane:
00:10:541 (3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - Not kawaii overlap!
00:15:670 (1,2,3,4,5) - Center this on the y-axis
00:45:205 (3) - Not kawaii overlap!
01:14:541 (3) - Not moe slider

Hard:
00:07:812 - Not snapped green section
00:51:126 - Not snapped green section
01:08:528 (2) - Not moe overlap
01:32:391 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - You don't need this many new combos

Normal:
00:34:947 (4) - Make this paralell with (3)?

Easy:
00:06:650 (2) - Probably make this look more like this http://puu.sh/AyPI
00:17:615 (4) - Touches HP bar a little bit
01:09:589 (1) - No. Just make this regular
01:11:004 (2) - ^

Whee.
Topic Starter
cmn_891127

CDFA wrote:

bubble modding

Insane:
00:10:541 (3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - Not kawaii overlap! x
00:15:670 (1,2,3,4,5) - Center this on the y-axis x, since it is an adjustment for stack leniency
00:45:205 (3) - Not kawaii overlap! x
01:14:541 (3) - Not moe slider x

Hard:
00:07:812 - Not snapped green section fixed
00:51:126 - Not snapped green section fixed
01:08:528 (2) - Not moe overlap x
01:32:391 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - You don't need this many new combos x
01:32:237 >> It may be a good idea to split this combo into 2 sets of combos
01:32:208 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13) - 这个这个。。。如果坚决要这么摆的话中间至少加个NC吧。。insane下这种梗都很容易坑到人的……
Normal:
00:34:947 (4) - Make this paralell with (3)? x

Easy:
00:06:650 (2) - Probably make this look more like this http://puu.sh/AyPI x
00:17:615 (4) - Touches HP bar a little bit fixed
01:09:589 (1) - No. Just make this regular x
01:11:004 (2) - ^ x

Whee.
Thank you~~ :(
LKs
hmm, since all the changes the mapper made are trivial (a couple of uninherited sections(resnap) and a note)

reb
Shohei Ohtani
Wow I generally don't mod bubbles without pointing out unrankable stuff.

I'm not sure what kind of drugs I'm on.

But thanks for taking the suggestions anyway :D
HakuNoKaemi
Megurine Luka
^ But this is truly a Short ver cutted by me :o

This rule sounds ... well nothing.. 呵呵。
Topic Starter
cmn_891127
:(
lovhin456
Rebubble
Kurai
[Aoi's Leg]
  1. Can you explain me why the difficulty is called "Aoi's Leg" please. It doesn't make sense to me.
  2. 01:09:589 (1,2) - The end point of (1) and the start point of (2) are really ugly and.. weird. D:
    Please try to change them into something more natural ?
[Hard]
  1. 01:32:215 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - New combo shouldn't be used for design issue. So please don't spam it.
That's all~
Topic Starter
cmn_891127

Kurai wrote:

[Aoi's Leg]
  1. Can you explain me why the difficulty is called "Aoi's Leg" please. It doesn't make sense to me.
    ...It is named by the guest mapper, while I know the reason, it is a custom to commemorate a certain Big Brother...
    If necessary, I will change it to Easy~

  2. 01:09:589 (1,2) - The end point of (1) and the start point of (2) are really ugly and.. weird. D:
    Please try to change them into something more natural ? fixed
[Hard]
  1. 01:32:215 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - New combo shouldn't be used for design issue. So please don't spam it. fixed
That's all~
Thanks for your modding~
Kurai
Okay, Ranked ~!
Aurele
No one have replied after the ranking. Never saw that before.

Anyways, Congratulation! :D
Mercurial
Is not rare at all.

Congratz.
Darksonic
Anime or Japanese songs = Lot and fast replies

Gratz ^^
[CSGA]Ar3sgice
Lot and fast
ts8zs
Conz……有的Diff不去滑条背景音略不爽
tutuhaha
崩溃
同时接收的亲儿子!
你的搞掂了我的还泡着Orz!!!!
这....这就是....这就是app的悲催之处么T口T!!
不管怎样~恭喜鸟~
Topic Starter
cmn_891127
Thank you, all guys~
Traditional Chinese music is very rare.

tutuhaha wrote:

崩溃
同时接收的亲儿子!
你的搞掂了我的还泡着Orz!!!!
这....这就是....这就是app的悲催之处么T口T!!
不管怎样~恭喜鸟~
亲~你家儿子也快了~兄弟年上神马的最有爱了~哦呵呵呵呵呵呵呵~
ts8zs

cmn_891127 wrote:

Thank you, all guys~
Traditional Chinese music is very rare.

tutuhaha wrote:

崩溃
同时接收的亲儿子!
你的搞掂了我的还泡着Orz!!!!
这....这就是....这就是app的悲催之处么T口T!!
不管怎样~恭喜鸟~
亲~你家儿子也快了~兄弟年上神马的最有爱了~哦呵呵呵呵呵呵呵~
那是什么Q Q?
Topic Starter
cmn_891127

ts8zs wrote:

那是什么Q Q?
你懂得……
YTYuyu
wow another Chinese song ranked from you. you know that you're the reason why i listen to Chinese music. at 1st i didn't like it at all, but after seeing your ranks and modding them for some time, i'm starting to listen to them and they sound pretty nice. congratz on the rank ;)
ts8zs

Byakugan249 wrote:

wow another Chinese song ranked from you. you know that you're the reason why i listen to Chinese music. at 1st i didn't like it at all, but after seeing your ranks and modding them for some time, i'm starting to listen to them and they sound pretty nice. congratz on the rank ;)
This song is china's most famous erhu song.
Anyone who studied erhu can play this song
_Kiva
大哥窝来献上双腿了
Megurine Luka
擦居然rank了……当年对这图可真没什么指望……不管怎么说………真的太感谢
Banana
Scorpiour
总算rank了,好长时间啊……

现在在期待百鬼夜行了呢
Foreverends
恭喜rank!!! :)
Beren
恭喜
Breeze
I love MeiGuoDaGe Luka ;_;
AoiX
咦 rank了液
MaxiMilliaN_old
Gratz :)
Please sign in to reply.

New reply