forum

GhostFinal - Gan Xie

posted
Total Posts
44
show more
Topic Starter
buhei
thx all
rezoons
Hi :),

M4M:

[Flask's Normal]
  1. OD+1 because there are a lot of slider in this diff
  2. 00:24:643 (2,3) - Maybe you could do a better overlapping:
  3. 00:27:012 (4,1) - ^
  4. 01:04:906 (1,2,3,4,1) - Maybe you could do something like this:
  5. 01:15:959 (1) - Too high it touches the score when you play it.
  6. 01:15:170 (4,1) - Well if you want to keep the overlapping suggestion there are a ton of others like this in your map but i will stop pointing them out.
  7. 01:23:854 (4) - Very weird slider. It stops on a blue tick and seems a little off following the music. Maybe you could do this instead:
  8. 01:36:485 (3) - ^
  9. 01:49:117 (5) - ^ Ok, apparently it's done on purpose so i will stop pointing them out but when i heard the music it really seems weird (except for some of them where it fits well)
  10. 02:06:485 (4) - Remove the red tick. It doesn't really modify it's shape. (Or make the change od shape more obvious like this:

    or like 03:07:867 (3).
  11. 02:47:538 (1) - Move it to x=164 y=260. The blanket will be better.
  12. 03:11:222 (3) - Move the second point to x=164 y=144 and the end point to x=96 y=92 for a better blanket.
  13. 03:39:246 (2) - Not properly centered. Move it two or three grid up.
  14. 04:15:959 (1,3) - Try making them at the same high.
  15. 04:22:275 - Since the singer hold the note i think you can add a spinner at the end.
[Hard]
  1. 00:22:275 (1) - I think a whistle is more suiet and fits better.
  2. 00:32:538 (3) - Whistle at the start (because of the drum)
  3. 00:35:696 (3) - ^
  4. 00:38:854 (3) - ^ etc.....
  5. 00:59:380 (7,8,1) - They are really close and looks like 1/8. Compare to 01:05:499 (5,6,7)
  6. 01:09:249 (5,1) - You can avoid this overlapping.
  7. 01:18:722 (5,6,1) - Same as before.
  8. 01:42:012 (3) - Try avoiding to touch the end of 01:41:22 (1) with this slider.
  9. 01:54:643 (3) - ^
  10. 02:02:341 (1,2,3) - The three notes seems useless and don't follow anything. You can remove 1 and 2.
  11. 02:15:380 (5) - The red tick seems pretty useless.
  12. 02:15:170 (7,8,1) - Try making them less stuck together.
  13. 02:19:906 (2,3,4) - Spacing different from 2 to 3 than from 3 to 4.
  14. 02:21:485 (6,7,1) - Same as before.
  15. 02:40:827 (5,6,1) - ^
  16. 02:47:538 (1) - I found this slider a little bit weird. Why not making a perfectly round one?
  17. 02:56:420 (8,1) - The red point is pretty much useless.
  18. 03:16:749 (3) - ^
  19. 04:08:656 (1,2,3) - Same as before.
Very good map. I havn't really found anything. And since i find the song pleasant i give you a ~star~ ;)
~ Good Luck ~ :)
Banana
[General]
BPM感觉得加倍 现在3白线上的音效音量略轻 就是被吞了一个重拍下去,然后bpm改了sv变成1.5也正常,1/8变成1/4也不容易被挑

[Hard]
看到开着grid snap的排列我十分想拿把刀开捅nazi..关于(个人理解的)细节我就概况一下中心思想
00:27:801 (7) - 三角形不正
00:33:130 (4) - 临近的能看出来的间距不等
00:54:643 (2) - 已经不符合ds了滑条头就尽量不要overlap 这里是和00:53:656 (8),间距和(8,1)的相同最好

图的整体感觉是大跳用的很少 对于慢速歌来说靠基本节奏是做不出有意思的图 所以排列..
00:58:591 (4) - 这个半跳不跳的滑条个人觉得象00:55:433 (4)那样用一个anti-jump比较适合,不行可以试试stack+anti
00:59:972 (8) - 额 槽不知道从何吐起就不吐了反正我读成1/8...(想了想还是吐一下好了..慢速歌用慢速梗效果不好 而且这边还有00:57:012 (1)之类的各种慢速梗 扎堆的效果更不好

01:07:003 - 这附近开始0.75倍速 个人的感觉是做图做到这里的时候觉得sv高了就绿线减个速 要怪只怪sv设高了... 这边相对前面并没有明显的理由来用减速 不过既然减速做完了我就不吐槽说remap plz之类的东西了..以下几条针对变速吐槽..

01:07:275 (2) - 尽量间距稍微大点 比如1.3 不喜欢overlap
01:08:064 (3,4) - 改为两个stack的圈 后面节奏相同的部分也是同样的建议
01:25:433 (1) - 变回原速的时候看着就像跳了一下 这边个人觉得不需要跳所以建议是0.9间距

01:30:959 - 这个finish建议加两条绿线单独降低这里的音量
01:39:643 (5) - 这边再跳一个吧 和01:52:275 (5) - 对应
02:06:091 (6) - 这边stack两个好奇怪 因为整体上看圈用的就不多 这样一stack显得更少了 不过没问题倒是 要是我来处理可能会0.5间距随便找个位置放起来 嘛 随口一说
02:20:696 (4) - 包住(3)?还是之前吐槽过的小间距跳
02:23:854 (4) - 这边考虑向vocal靠一靠 之前感觉就是跟着vocal来的这边完全(也许)就对不上 可能的解决办法是使vocal的02:24:446处开始滑条
03:00:959 - 感觉如果不是都加finish的话 加这会好一点
03:36:091 - finish (同时建议减小finish音量或者改原版的soft finish或者问原作者要这个地方的finish)
03:40:038 - ^
03:43:985 - ^
03:48:722 - ^
03:52:670 - ^
04:20:301 - ^

[Flask姥爷‘s Normal]
03:18:327 (2) - 头改whistle?
04:12:012 (5) - 直滑条
两条已经尽力了 nm能有什么问题

good luck
eveless
[Hard]
00:56:025 (6,7) - 感觉flow略不对,个人偏好于这种
01:09:643 (1) - slider挤在一起略丑,建议无视DS这里拉开来,比如这样02:20:499 (3,4,5,6) - 虽然按照我之前在群里说的这里应该算是非常有特色的……间距,不过在大环境下来看我只能说我看着像是你是不是搞错了间距。
02:29:380 (2) - 建议间距拉开一点点,虽然我明白你是因为减速减少了间距但是这样挨着实在是不太好看
02:31:749 (1) - ^同上,02:32:538 (2) - 也一样
02:47:143 (6) - spacing
04:22:324 (1,1) - 感觉略莫名,拉到线上比较好吧……

自己再检查一下spacing错误吧再来找我
Selisi
排名好高> < 咱提一些建议 参考用
[general]
视屏好大。。。没问题么?
[Hard]
  1. 00:59:380 (7,8,1) - 这个节点感觉怪怪的没有蓝线很少用这种节点的
  1. 03:55:433 (5,6,7) - 怎么说呢这个虽然有些突然但是也可以接受 可以吧 不知道> <。。。??
  1. 做的不错 但是combo的摆放美感没有到达极致的感觉这个是很柔美的歌曲 用那么多直滑条真心不好
[Flask's normal]
  1. 00:36:485 - 这怎么有两条时间线
  1. 不错的说 好评
早日rank哦QvQ~~
eveless
bubbled
Topic Starter
buhei

eveless wrote:

bubbled
thx
Nymph
SPOILER
20:41 *buhei zhens(?) nymph
20:41 Nymph: 00:58:393 (3,4) -
20:41 Nymph: spacing
20:41 Nymph: hard
20:41 buhei: okay
20:42 Nymph: 01:08:064 (3,4) -
20:42 Nymph: 这些节奏略莫名
20:42 Nymph: 我建议跟鼓
20:42 Nymph: 01:11:222 (3,4) - 同上
20:42 buhei: ..我觉得没什么啊
20:42 Nymph: 那就随便了
20:43 Nymph: 只是不知道跟的什么 略奇怪
20:43 Nymph: 01:23:854 (3,4,5,6) - spacing?
20:43 buhei: 因为后面加快了吧
20:44 buhei: SV
20:44 Nymph: 但是你前面用的1.3 1.4啊
20:44 Nymph: 为啥这里变成1.2了
20:44 buhei: 前面不太想贴着
20:45 buhei: 我看看
20:45 Nymph: 就是因为前面没贴着所以这里贴着我觉得很乱很挤 so
20:45 buhei: 改好了
20:45 buhei: 后面我也该下
20:45 buhei: 改*
20:46 buhei: done
20:47 Nymph: 02:45:959 (3,4,5,6) - 这里改完了?
20:47 buhei: 是的
20:51 buhei: ?
20:51 Nymph: =
20:55 Nymph: 没了
Topic Starter
buhei

Nymph wrote:

SPOILER
20:41 *buhei zhens(?) nymph
20:41 Nymph: 00:58:393 (3,4) -
20:41 Nymph: spacing
20:41 Nymph: hard
20:41 buhei: okay
20:42 Nymph: 01:08:064 (3,4) -
20:42 Nymph: 这些节奏略莫名
20:42 Nymph: 我建议跟鼓
20:42 Nymph: 01:11:222 (3,4) - 同上
20:42 buhei: ..我觉得没什么啊
20:42 Nymph: 那就随便了
20:43 Nymph: 只是不知道跟的什么 略奇怪
20:43 Nymph: 01:23:854 (3,4,5,6) - spacing?
20:43 buhei: 因为后面加快了吧
20:44 buhei: SV
20:44 Nymph: 但是你前面用的1.3 1.4啊
20:44 Nymph: 为啥这里变成1.2了
20:44 buhei: 前面不太想贴着
20:45 buhei: 我看看
20:45 Nymph: 就是因为前面没贴着所以这里贴着我觉得很乱很挤 so
20:45 buhei: 改好了
20:45 buhei: 后面我也该下
20:45 buhei: 改*
20:46 buhei: done
20:47 Nymph: 02:45:959 (3,4,5,6) - 这里改完了?
20:47 buhei: 是的
20:51 buhei: ?
20:51 Nymph: =
20:55 Nymph: 没了
updated
Topic Starter
buhei
OAO
Nymph
ranked.
Topic Starter
buhei

Nymph wrote:

ranked.
Thx XDDDD
Flower
congratz
Flask
什麼我都還沒看mod
Topic Starter
buhei

Flask wrote:

什麼我都還沒看mod
F酱啊饿姐和妮妮都压根没提起你的图
Satellite
Congratz~!
pw384
什么 不黑神麻婆又rank
Topic Starter
buhei

384059043 wrote:

什么 不黑神麻婆又rank
听说投十分天上会掉下来馅饼,快去看
Quilt
gratz
Melt

384059043 wrote:

什么 不黑神麻婆又rank
Fycho
恭喜不黑神麻婆又rank~ :)
Zero__wind

384059043 wrote:

什么 不黑神麻婆又rank
raririn

384059043 wrote:

什么 不黑神麻婆又rank
Topic Starter
buhei

raririn wrote:

384059043 wrote:

什么 不黑神麻婆又rank
什么 rrr神麻婆又复读
mintong89

384059043 wrote:

什么 不黑神麻婆又rank
Coro
Tianyi~

Gratz ranked~
a32

384059043 wrote:

什么 不黑神麻婆又rank
纯引
Please sign in to reply.

New reply