forum

Kasabian - Fire

posted
Total Posts
63
show more
Andrea
~General~
  1. There's too many kiai fountains through this short song, it's highly not suggested to do it this way, remove some of them if you can.
~Normal~
  1. I suggest you to reduce OD by 1 tick to make a better difficulty spread for this kind of difficulty.
  1. 00:27:482 (1) - I don't think this new combo here is necessary, just remove it.
  2. 00:31:585 (1) - Same for this one, you don't need it.
  3. 00:35:687 (1) - Yeah I'm being nitpicky, I think you've added too many new combos here.
  4. 00:39:790 (1) - And this one as well.
~Hard~
  1. I suggest you to increase HP Drain by 1 tick to make a better difficulty spread for this kind of difficulty.
  1. 00:19:277 (1) - This slider is almost off-screen, I suggest you to move it up a bit to avoid this problem.
~Insane~
  1. I suggest you to increase HP Drain by 1 tick and reduce OD by 1 tick to make a better difficulty spread for this kind of difficulty.
  1. 00:28:508 (1) - Remove this new combo from here, it's not necessary.
  2. 00:36:713 (1) - Same goes for this one for the same reason stated above.
  3. 00:37:739 (1) - This slider is touching the HP Bar, move it down a bit to fix this problem.
Topic Starter
Sonnyc

Andrea wrote:

~General~
  1. There's too many kiai fountains through this short song, it's highly not suggested to do it this way, remove some of them if you can. // Well, but I think they fits the song though.
~Normal~
  1. I suggest you to reduce OD by 1 tick to make a better difficulty spread for this kind of difficulty. // ok (actually though 4/6/8 would be better,, but nvm~~)
  1. 00:27:482 (1) - I don't think this new combo here is necessary, just remove it. // Fix
  2. 00:31:585 (1) - Same for this one, you don't need it. // k
  3. 00:35:687 (1) - Yeah I'm being nitpicky, I think you've added too many new combos here. // :3 Agree
  4. 00:39:790 (1) - And this one as well.
~Hard~
  1. I suggest you to increase HP Drain by 1 tick to make a better difficulty spread for this kind of difficulty. // k
  1. 00:19:277 (1) - This slider is almost off-screen, I suggest you to move it up a bit to avoid this problem. // idk~ this is in anyways,,
~Insane~
  1. I suggest you to increase HP Drain by 1 tick and reduce OD by 1 tick to make a better difficulty spread for this kind of difficulty. // fix
  1. 00:28:508 (1) - Remove this new combo from here, it's not necessary. // k
  2. 00:36:713 (1) - Same goes for this one for the same reason stated above.
  3. 00:37:739 (1) - This slider is touching the HP Bar, move it down a bit to fix this problem. // I don't want to consider this as an important issue,,
Thanks ^^
Pokie
Alright then!

Bubbled!

Garven
[Normal]
00:09:021 (1) - Why are these combos so much shorter compared to 00:25:431 (1) - ? I'd keep them all longer.

[Hard]
00:16:200 (1) - Remove new combo
I guess they're -all- the shorter combos in this map though.

[Insane]
00:28:508 (1) - The end of this is snapped incorrectly. Should be at 00:29:277 -
00:36:713 (1) - Same here. Should be ending at 00:37:482 - instead of this phantom-like ending with no real rhythm.
Combos are a mess. Make them consistent please.
Topic Starter
Sonnyc

Garven wrote:

[Normal]
00:09:021 (1) - Why are these combos so much shorter compared to 00:25:431 (1) - ? I'd keep them all longer. // Fix

[Hard]
00:16:200 (1) - Remove new combo // This was to emphasize the lyric "i'm on fire"
I guess they're -all- the shorter combos in this map though.

[Insane]
00:28:508 (1) - The end of this is snapped incorrectly. Should be at 00:29:277 - // Reduced size to fit,, maybe
00:36:713 (1) - Same here. Should be ending at 00:37:482 - instead of this phantom-like ending with no real rhythm.
Combos are a mess. Make them consistent please.
Fixed combo inconsistencies. Thanks~
Garven
FOOTBAAAAAAAALLLLLFWEOI:USDFO:AISJDFLAK
Stefan
Congrats

So many Koreans. o.o

Also, this is Rock? Wat
Cloudchaser
wow o3o

congratz
Alarido
Yeeeah! \:D/

2/25 to 3/21 -- less than a month from ground to glory :D
Backfire

So this map is both completely awful and the best map of all time.

No middle ground.
S h i o n
omg this song!!! loving premier league!!
Shohei Ohtani
oops
Stefan

Backfire wrote:


So this map is both completely awful and the best map of all time.

No middle ground.

weeeeelp
Mismagius
Why do people downvote this >: it's not even a bad map/song
theowest
they seem to hate football. :(
Nessuka
BARCLAYS LOL
Darksonic


User Rating 5.00

LOL, why so much hate.
Topic Starter
Sonnyc

Stefan wrote:

Congrats

So many Koreans. o.o

Also, this is Rock? Wat
The original song is Rock~

D: rating
Moway
Here's a 10 from me, trying to help orz.

I don't watch football but I love Kasabian. Grats on the rank, hopefully people will ease up on their ratings >_<
bmin11
랭크 축하드려요!
Coro
Oh my, the ratings ._.

Just 'cause it's short doesn't make it a bad map orz
MineC24
평점테러가...
Birdy
3 Sonnyc maps gg
Mashley
Source should not be listed as Barclays Premier League, this song is Kasabian's and though it was used for that it was not created for it and therefore that source is incorrect. The mp3 is clearly not of satisfactory quality and this should have been pointed out ages ago. Also you should be mapping the full song anyway, no reason to just map a short version other than laziness really.
It's quite well mapped, I won't dispute that, but things like this should be fixed before a map get ranked at that they haven't been shows a significant problem with the standards of whoever bubbled or ranked this.
S h i o n
pretty nice 10-rating map
Flanster
I remember another one of these but in the past when I was a kid, it was really awesome to hear.
Jarby

Mashley wrote:

Source should not be listed as Barclays Premier League, this song is Kasabian's and though it was used for that it was not created for it and therefore that source is incorrect. The mp3 is clearly not of satisfactory quality and this should have been pointed out ages ago. Also you should be mapping the full song anyway, no reason to just map a short version other than laziness really.
It's quite well mapped, I won't dispute that, but things like this should be fixed before a map get ranked at that they haven't been shows a significant problem with the standards of whoever bubbled or ranked this.
Yeah, the audio peaks at ~15KHz despite being 192kbps. On top of that, the video file included with the map still contains audio thus bloating the osz further. It's really not acceptable.
Kodora
lol ppl r u rtrdd vt 1 jst fr leight?
BCI

Kodora wrote:

lol ppl r u rtrdd vt 1 jst fr leight?
h br ur uprt /rns
Doomsday

Mashley wrote:

Source should not be listed as Barclays Premier League, this song is Kasabian's and though it was used for that it was not created for it and therefore that source is incorrect. The mp3 is clearly not of satisfactory quality and this should have been pointed out ages ago. Also you should be mapping the full song anyway, no reason to just map a short version other than laziness really.
It's quite well mapped, I won't dispute that, but things like this should be fixed before a map get ranked at that they haven't been shows a significant problem with the standards of whoever bubbled or ranked this.
Quoting for truth

The map is good, yes, but this kind of thing shouldn't be slipping through the net
Stefan

Mashley wrote:

Also you should be mapping the full song anyway, no reason to just map a short version other than laziness really.
It's the Mappers decision if he wants to map a Part of the Song or the whole Song. The one thing which bothers me is the Title. You wrote that it is the Opening of Barclays Premier League. So.. actually something like Opening would be required in the Title since there is a Full Version of the Song iirc.
Mismagius

Stefan wrote:

Mashley wrote:

Also you should be mapping the full song anyway, no reason to just map a short version other than laziness really.
It's the Mappers decision if he wants to map a Part of the Song or the whole Song. The one thing which bothers me is the Title. You wrote that it is the Opening of Barclays Premier League. So.. actually something like Opening would be required in the Title since there is a Full Version of the Song iirc.
(TV Size)?


Also, yeah, now that I notice, this mp3 shouldn't be of rankable quality. :<
Stefan

Blue Dragon wrote:

(TV Size)?
Welp, yeah that.
BrokenArrow
Something is really bothering me..
Why do this kind of discussions always appear after the song was ranked?

This is happening way too often recently. @any XAT: Get your shit done before you rank a song next time.
Topic Starter
Sonnyc
Sorry for the quality of mp3, maybe that's the result of cutting from youtube directly.
There used to be Edit Ver. at the title, but deleted by guideline.

Source should be bpl for sure, because this version of the song belongs there.
If I was mapping the full song, that is when I should get rid the source.
Shohei Ohtani

BrokenArrow wrote:

Something is really bothering me..
Why do this kind of discussions always appear after the song was ranked?
Welcome to osu!
RinMiku14

BrokenArrow wrote:

Something is really bothering me..
Why do this kind of discussions always appear after the song was ranked?

This is happening way too often recently. @any XAT: Get your shit done before you rank a song next time.
This is not any recent at all. If memory serves me right, this is mostly always happening.
Mashley

BrokenArrow wrote:

Something is really bothering me..
Why do this kind of discussions always appear after the song was ranked?

This is happening way too often recently. @any XAT: Get your shit done before you rank a song next time.
Because there are some incompetent BATs who don't know basic standards for ranking...

Stefan wrote:

Mashley wrote:

Also you should be mapping the full song anyway, no reason to just map a short version other than laziness really.
It's the Mappers decision if he wants to map a Part of the Song or the whole Song. The one thing which bothers me is the Title. You wrote that it is the Opening of Barclays Premier League. So.. actually something like Opening would be required in the Title since there is a Full Version of the Song iirc.
Not saying you musn't but really it is just a waste not to map the whole thing especially with a great song like this... I think players, when they see that someone mapped a song they like, will be disappointed if they see it's just a short version, I know I was. Also it's just pretty lazy tbh (I know, I shouldn't complain about laziness, but still).
D33d
I downloaded this to expect disgust, but it's not that bad. The patterns in [Insane] feel pretty good and it's effective as a "TV Size" sort of deal.

Still, it would've been worth mapping the full thing for sure, because forty seconds doesn't allow for much of a build at all. It could've also benefited from a more interesting normal difficulty, with a more relaxed easy diff to fit the low-tier nature of this map. Nothing much to do from this point, because the mapset's technically sound.

DEEDIT: Oh yeah, the set isn't technically sound, because of the gash audio and needless bloat. Uuuuurgh. Come on, lads; sort it out.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply