Chewin wrote:

[Pokie's Normal]

1. Remove the same unused green lines I wrote in the Easy diff ;3　I'm lazy
2. 00:47:066 (1) - Finish on the slider's head to emphasize the clash in the cymbals　I get your meaning. But, just saying. Everyone having their own hitsound sense. Nothing could be a must to enforce mapper following all of them. So I may reject parts of your suggestions here. Sorry.
3. 02:20:765 (2) - New combo?　Such like a baka which using only single notes for a combo. D: I mean easier diff for sure.
4. 02:27:751 (4) - This slider's reverse arrow is covered by the HP bar: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/450865 Consider to fix it　Fixed in last update.
5. 03:31:450 (1) - Same of Easy. Don't use SC:1 finish. Use the Normal one. Done.
6. 03:59:806 (1) - I'd start this spinner on 03:59:498 since it should start on the long white tick where is snapped the (4)　If suitable for Normal. Done.

[Pokie's Insane]

1. 00:03:915 (1) - Same of Hard　Um, any supportable rules for this?
2. 00:19:943 (1) - Move this slider to x:224 y:224 because being an 1/4 slider its reverse arrow is semi-covered by previous spinner's hitburst and it could be unreadable: http://puu.sh/1bprU　Should be done in last update.
3. 00:57:751 (6) - 80% finish? It's be awesome together with 00:56:929 (3)'s one and 00:58:573 (5)'s　Um, no?
4. 01:06:792 (1) to 03:55:285 (3) - Hitsounds suggestions (I think you should follow to improve the consistency of your map):　Keeping consistency doesn't meant to be follow exactly. Anyway, done some of them. Thanks for pointing out all of them, although it was bit of meaningless here. Sorry again.

Mythol wrote:

I love Pokie's diff !!
gogo rank :3

1. I don't know if the taiko diff counts as a standard diff. According to ranking criteria the creator of the beatmap must map the same number of map or more than a guester. I mean that Pokie has mapped 2 standard diffs while you have mapped just 1 standard diff. According to rules a guest CAN'T map more standard diff than creator, but I'm not 100% sure about it since now the taiko mapset are rankable. I will ask other MATs/BATs about it. It's ok ;3

1. 01:22:819 (3) - (maybe nazi) Make it symmetric :\
   
   SPOILER

   
   
   (Using this slider I have also fixed the spacing of the next slider)
   

   416,200,82819,2,8,B|372:212|336:192|336:192|340:240|308:268,1,160
   316,360,84052,2,0,B|272:368|236:328,1,80,0|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0

2. Very nice.

1. 01:00:217 (1) - Finish on slider's head
2. 01:03:504 (1) - ^
3. 01:13:367 (2) - 5% is unrankable, I repeat. It's rankable just on spinner's end. According to this increase the volume of this slider's tail at least till 20% thanks
4. 01:54:463 (1) - Finish on the head
5. 02:20:765 (2) - Same of 01:13:367 (2)
6. 02:26:929 (2) - I'd use new combo here
7. 02:43:778 (1) - Remove new combo to keep consistency with 01:36:381 (3)
8. 03:11:724 (1,2,3) - I don't like this pattern, honestly. What about to make something symmetric like this?
   
   SPOILER

   
   
   

   340,40,191724,6,0,B|392:132|332:216,1,180.000006866455,4|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0
   256,284,192956,1,2,0:0:0
   175,209,193367,2,0,B|120:132|172:40,1,180.000006866455,4|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0

9. 03:28:984 (3) - Add finish here

1. 00:03:915 (3) - 20% volume, 5% is unrankable, again.
2. 00:11:724 (2,3) - I would CTRL + G the (2) and (3) too, it'd flow better IMO. I mean: http://puu.sh/1nX0Q and maybe also fixing the (4)'s placement if you think it's too far from the previous slider
3. 00:39:258 (4) - Why don't you use new combo here to keep consistency with 00:33:915 (1,2,3)? Also to advice about different spacing you used there since it should be 0.51x like the previous elements since it is on the same combo (and in this case is enough confusing IMO)
4. 00:58:573 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Players will hate you for this squares çwç
5. 01:24:874 (4) - New combo?
6. 01:34:224 (3) - This circle is overmapped and it sounds really bad with music and vocal sound IMO Then.. remove it.
7. 01:38:847 (2) - I guess you used finish on this slider's head for mistake
8. 02:06:792 (5) - New combo according to the vocal sound?
9. 02:24:463 (2) - What about to ctrl + g it?
10. 03:29:806 (3) - New combo

1. 00:03:915 (1) - You know.
2. 03:54:463 (1) - I'd move this slider some grid down because it almost touches the HP bar and it's bad c.c

Chewin wrote:

[ERT's Hard]

1. 01:34:224 (3) - This circle is overmapped and it sounds really bad with music and vocal sound IMO Then.. remove it.if you keep 25% to hear.you can hear some sound like base-drum.01:21:073 (5) - here has similar arrangement.I think that's ERT's thought
2. 01:38:847 (2) - I guess you used finish on this slider's head for mistakeehh...if you remove it.you can clearly hear a strong sound in music

Chewin wrote:

[Pokie's Normal]

1. 01:13:367 (2) - 5% is unrankable, I repeat. It's rankable just on spinner's end. According to this increase the volume of this slider's tail at least till 20% thanks　So can you provide a supportable rules that I mentioned last post? I could only find out this from wiki.
   
   
   The end of a spinner (or even the entire spinner) the sliding sound of a slider, and the end of a slider can be silent, but only do it if it makes sense.
   
   But anyway. Seems you're sure it couldn't be a rankable stuff. Me fixed.
   
2. 02:43:778 (1) - Remove new combo to keep consistency with 01:36:381 (3)　My fault.
3. 03:11:724 (1,2,3) - I don't like this pattern, honestly. What about to make something symmetric like this?　As you expect.
4. 03:28:984 (3) - Add finish here　On (1) too.

[Pokie's Insane]

1. 03:54:463 (1) - I'd move this slider some grid down because it almost touches the HP bar and it's bad c.c　Done.

AmamiyaYuko wrote:

我是pocky腦殘粉

AmamiyaYuko wrote:

我是pocky腦殘粉

Kotone wrote:

AmamiyaYuko wrote:

我是pocky腦殘粉

me 2!

Garven wrote:

Don't you need to provide more difficulties than guests have provided? Your one easy vs. Pokie's 2 difficulties...

Garven wrote:

Oh derp. Assumed TaiGu was another guest difficulty. Why not name it like a normal taiko difficulty considering your nomenclature for the Easy? Anyway, I'll mod when I get a chance then. Was waiting due to the diff thing.

Garven wrote:

[General]
Tick rate 2 fits this song bestehh...as before,I don't like it at all,neither playing nor sounding.
[Taiko]
This feels... really unbalanced. You have a really easy map until the chorus. Then it just goes crazy. It might be better overall if you could spruce up the slower parts between the chorus' so that the map is more consistence difficulty-wise.Yeah maybe you're right.but I'm still a noob mapper of taiko.I don't know how to map a full Oni diff.I just map this according to the drums in music.but in kiai time I use d to follow all drums and k for other sound.So it seems a little unbalanced.But I think it's no problem

[Hard]
00:19:943 (1) - You may as well center this so it doesn't look so ugly with the hitburst misaligned.k
01:34:224 (3,4) - This curve with the 1/4s is a little sharp. Maybe shape the 2 slider so that it flows into that curve a little better?hmm this is good enough imo
03:06:792 (3) - New combok
03:07:614 (1) - remove new combok
03:11:107 (1) - ^k
03:11:724 (1) - ^ehh I think this is fine

Garven wrote:

The name is fine. Was just confused as to who did it at first.

[General]
Tick rate 2 fits this song best

[Normal]
00:05:970 (1) - remove new combo
00:07:614 (2) - New combo
00:09:258 (1) - Remove
00:12:546 (1) - ^
00:42:135 (1) - ^
01:24:052 (1) - ^
02:15:833 (1) - ^
03:03:504 (1) - ^
03:06:792 (1) - ^
03:10:080 (1) - ^
03:24:874 (1,1,1) - It would be nice if there was a more unified spacing amongst these.
03:26:518 (1) - Remove new combo
03:29:806 (1) - ^
03:33:504 (1) - ^
03:34:737 (2) - new combo
03:36:381 (1) - remove


[Insane]
00:46:655 (1) - Not a fan of single note combos like this

Nice set. Let me know when things get fixed up~

Kuria wrote:

gogo

No_Gu wrote:

as you want

I won't change anything about the taiko diff.Sorry if you're expecting this map.
update eveless diff and let's get this map unfinished like the song's name.
How funny the ranking system is =3=

No_Gu wrote:

as you want

I won't change anything about the taiko diff.Sorry if you're expecting this map.
update eveless diff and let's get this map unfinished like the song's name.
How funny the ranking system is =3=

goodbye wrote:

其实不需要啊，把我的难度删了然后rank吧。

sospk0011 wrote:

The beatmap should be returned to pending!