@^ Talked in IRC to explain things and my intentions with the hitsounds.
forum
Utada Hikaru - Merry Christmas Mr. Lawrence - FYI [Osu|Taiko
posted
Total Posts
69
lol not much to even say
[General]
It looks nice, but the lighting kinda hurts my eyes during the kiai since it's so large comparatively to most lightings I've seen.
[Makar's Normal]
Just two things:
02:14:384 (1,2,1) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428971 That's the only overlap that kinda bothered me while playing. Maybe just rotate 02:15:855 (2) - anti-clockwise 15 degrees around slection center, and then select both 02:16:737 (1,2) - and rotate them anti-clockwise 15 degrees as well then place the beginning of 1 on 228,144 while still selecting both. Should look like this: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428972 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428973 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428974
03:22:619 (1) - http://puu.sh/140ts That slider is impossible to tell which direction it goes in without slider style 1. And isn't it kinda of breaking what you did with all the other long sliders anyway to not rebound at every tick?
[Hard]
Maybe add one to OD or Drain since this is the hardest diff, but it's still kinda easy?
00:26:736 (1) - Remove the sliderwhistle here? It seems inconsistent with the others when I listen.
03:27:030 (5,1) - most of your jumps here are at kind of odd angles for me here, but this one I actually like popped my wrist trying to hit it lol. Maybe something like this this http://puu.sh/140Sx ? Still essentially the same thing, just less straining to play.
Both taiko's are looking good so far, I'll make sure I take a look a those once they finish as well.
Hope that's helpful even though there really isn't much.
Again
[General]
It looks nice, but the lighting kinda hurts my eyes during the kiai since it's so large comparatively to most lightings I've seen.
[Makar's Normal]
Just two things:
02:14:384 (1,2,1) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428971 That's the only overlap that kinda bothered me while playing. Maybe just rotate 02:15:855 (2) - anti-clockwise 15 degrees around slection center, and then select both 02:16:737 (1,2) - and rotate them anti-clockwise 15 degrees as well then place the beginning of 1 on 228,144 while still selecting both. Should look like this: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428972 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428973 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428974
03:22:619 (1) - http://puu.sh/140ts That slider is impossible to tell which direction it goes in without slider style 1. And isn't it kinda of breaking what you did with all the other long sliders anyway to not rebound at every tick?
[Hard]
Maybe add one to OD or Drain since this is the hardest diff, but it's still kinda easy?
00:26:736 (1) - Remove the sliderwhistle here? It seems inconsistent with the others when I listen.
03:27:030 (5,1) - most of your jumps here are at kind of odd angles for me here, but this one I actually like popped my wrist trying to hit it lol. Maybe something like this this http://puu.sh/140Sx ? Still essentially the same thing, just less straining to play.
Both taiko's are looking good so far, I'll make sure I take a look a those once they finish as well.
Hope that's helpful even though there really isn't much.
AgainThanks for modding :3Fiya wrote:
lol not much to even say
[General]
It looks nice, but the lighting kinda hurts my eyes during the kiai since it's so large comparatively to most lightings I've seen. stfu this lighting is awesome jk ily zach ♥
[Makar's Normal]
Just two things:
02:14:384 (1,2,1) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428971 That's the only overlap that kinda bothered me while playing. Maybe just rotate 02:15:855 (2) - anti-clockwise 15 degrees around slection center, and then select both 02:16:737 (1,2) - and rotate them anti-clockwise 15 degrees as well then place the beginning of 1 on 228,144 while still selecting both. Should look like this: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428972 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428973 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/428974 SO NAZI OMG fixed
03:22:619 (1) - http://puu.sh/140ts That slider is impossible to tell which direction it goes in without slider style 1. And isn't it kinda of breaking what you did with all the other long sliders anyway to not rebound at every tick? What other logical direction could it go in? This kind of thing goes for -all- loop-type sliders, but people know what direction to go in because of flow. Also, it does rebound, it's just very slightly. I figured it was okay here since at 03:23:795 and 03:26:148 there are no drum beats at all while there are at the other points. Oh, and after making over 9000 art sliders eventually you run out of ideas for a specific type of slider.
Here is your dick's update
woohoo i can star this now \o/
Mod requested by Makar~
[General]
* Muzukashii doesn't have a BG~
* You don't use a Storyboard, do you? So delete the osb file and full submit
[Makar's Normal]
00:32:618 (3) - Not perfectly stacked with 1~
01:06:148 (1) - finish on start? Probably you dont like, I think you would have done if you liked
01:10:854 (1) - moe slider <3~
01:22:618 (1) - whistle on start? :3
[Hard]
00:21:883 (4,1) - Doesn't play well imo~
That's all I can do o.o
Beautiful map~ Good luck ^0^
[General]
* Muzukashii doesn't have a BG~
* You don't use a Storyboard, do you? So delete the osb file and full submit
[Makar's Normal]
00:32:618 (3) - Not perfectly stacked with 1~
01:06:148 (1) - finish on start? Probably you dont like, I think you would have done if you liked
01:10:854 (1) - moe slider <3~
01:22:618 (1) - whistle on start? :3
[Hard]
00:21:883 (4,1) - Doesn't play well imo~
That's all I can do o.o
Beautiful map~ Good luck ^0^
Thanks~Konei wrote:
[Makar's Normal]
00:32:618 (3) - Not perfectly stacked with 1~ It is, you just didnt update before modding
01:06:148 (1) - finish on start? Probably you dont like, I think you would have done if you liked Yeah don't like it ._.
01:10:854 (1) - moe slider <3~ Thanks~
01:22:618 (1) - whistle on start? :3 No because the piano stops playing here, which is what the whistles follow
taiko is done
update~
update~
Topic Starter
d'aww you didn't have tohipster3000 wrote:
woohoo i can star this now \o/
thank you so much, you're such a star (pun intended)~ 
Extremely thankful to Mark for finding all these mods and for keeping updated, posted and sending in regular updates. Really appreciate it. Thanks Becca for the taiko once more, seriously loving it
Also thanks to previous modders thus far, you've helped me greatly (even though I haven't applied mods yet)! I'll get to this once I get enough time to work on it (I also have other things to do before attending to this matter). Updates for both Haruka (finished version) and Mark have been applied now.
inb4 pointless and irrelevant post on my own topic
Surprise~~~~
Bold: Unrankable/must fix.
Red: You should fix it, but it's up to you.
Italic: Suggestion. Feel free to ignore this if you don't like it.
Blue: Comment. I'll give you my opinion, advice, or if i'm curious about something.
[General]
Preview times are inconsistent. make sure that they're the same in all diffs.
i think it'd be better if you can use the "snap" hitsound instead of the clap to fit the mood of the song.
[Moekar]
00:04:972 (1) - if you can move this a bit to the left, (3,4,5,1) will make a square. it's just my taste but i think the flow will increase a bit IMO.
00:09:678 (1,2,3) - do this instead. i think doing this will be a fun beginning for players. if you do this, add a circle at 00:11:736 and it should be here since it follows the vocals.
00:13:502 (4) - *nazi* not a big deal but...if you can curve it a bit more, this slider will blanket the next 93) since i'm guessing that's what you meant to do.
00:16:442 - add a circle here "if" you follow 00:09:678.
00:19:971 - since you have (3) as a circle, add a circle here for consistency and for a smooth slider-circle pattern.
00:38:796 (2,3) - if you can replace this for a circle and a 1/1 slider, it'll follow the instrumental and the vocals. yes i see the blanket and transition, but the notes doesn't feel right IMO.
00:41:149 (2,3) - ^
01:05:266 (2) - hmm...straighten this slider and move this slider here. as you see, it should be measured equally to make a trapezoid in this part.
01:10:855 (1) - omg this slider ;__;
01:36:737 (1,2) - hmm...try this instead? i think doing this will continue the flow from the previous combo since the vocals tone is the same.
02:00:560 (1) - if you want, you can make this a NC if you follow the suggestion above, since it repeats.
[Moekyie]
00:13:795 (7) - curve this slider so that the transition would look smoother to the next curved slider.
00:14:383 (1) - if you follow the suggestion above, curve this the other way so that the transition will increase like this.
00:18:501 (7) - move this slider here. the only difference is that this is at the middle of (6) and i think doing this would look neater IMO.
01:08:501 (5) - same as 00;13:795.
03:23:795 (4) - align this to the end of (3). the flow increases a bit as it follows the same vocal tone.
i'm only modding the standard diffs. not modding taiko since muzu isn't done...GL
Bold: Unrankable/must fix.
Red: You should fix it, but it's up to you.
Italic: Suggestion. Feel free to ignore this if you don't like it.
Blue: Comment. I'll give you my opinion, advice, or if i'm curious about something.
[General]
Preview times are inconsistent. make sure that they're the same in all diffs.
i think it'd be better if you can use the "snap" hitsound instead of the clap to fit the mood of the song.
[Moekar]
00:04:972 (1) - if you can move this a bit to the left, (3,4,5,1) will make a square. it's just my taste but i think the flow will increase a bit IMO.
00:09:678 (1,2,3) - do this instead. i think doing this will be a fun beginning for players. if you do this, add a circle at 00:11:736 and it should be here since it follows the vocals.
00:13:502 (4) - *nazi* not a big deal but...if you can curve it a bit more, this slider will blanket the next 93) since i'm guessing that's what you meant to do.
00:16:442 - add a circle here "if" you follow 00:09:678.
00:19:971 - since you have (3) as a circle, add a circle here for consistency and for a smooth slider-circle pattern.
00:38:796 (2,3) - if you can replace this for a circle and a 1/1 slider, it'll follow the instrumental and the vocals. yes i see the blanket and transition, but the notes doesn't feel right IMO.
00:41:149 (2,3) - ^
01:05:266 (2) - hmm...straighten this slider and move this slider here. as you see, it should be measured equally to make a trapezoid in this part.
01:10:855 (1) - omg this slider ;__;
01:36:737 (1,2) - hmm...try this instead? i think doing this will continue the flow from the previous combo since the vocals tone is the same.
SPOILER
01:59:384 (3) - NC here. it'll follow the new lyric in this part of the song.308,128,96737,6,0,B|236:260,1,144,2|8
88,324,97913,2,0,B|164:192,1,144,2|8
02:00:560 (1) - if you want, you can make this a NC if you follow the suggestion above, since it repeats.
[Moekyie]
00:13:795 (7) - curve this slider so that the transition would look smoother to the next curved slider.
00:14:383 (1) - if you follow the suggestion above, curve this the other way so that the transition will increase like this.
00:18:501 (7) - move this slider here. the only difference is that this is at the middle of (6) and i think doing this would look neater IMO.
01:08:501 (5) - same as 00;13:795.
03:23:795 (4) - align this to the end of (3). the flow increases a bit as it follows the same vocal tone.
i'm only modding the standard diffs. not modding taiko since muzu isn't done...GL
Thanks for modding :3Byakugan249 wrote:
Surprise~~~~
Bold: Unrankable/must fix.
Red: You should fix it, but it's up to you.
Italic: Suggestion. Feel free to ignore this if you don't like it.
Blue: Comment. I'll give you my opinion, advice, or if i'm curious about something.
[General]
Preview times are inconsistent. make sure that they're the same in all diffs. The taiko's preview time is unsnapped :v
i think it'd be better if you can use the "snap" hitsound instead of the clap to fit the mood of the song.
[Moekar]
00:04:972 (1) - if you can move this a bit to the left, (3,4,5,1) will make a square. it's just my taste but i think the flow will increase a bit IMO. I didn't intend for this to be a square, and a square is too sharp for flow imo.
00:09:678 (1,2,3) - do this instead. i think doing this will be a fun beginning for players. if you do this, add a circle at 00:11:736 and it should be here since it follows the vocals. Again, too sharp for flow
00:13:502 (4) - *nazi* not a big deal but...if you can curve it a bit more, this slider will blanket the next 93) since i'm guessing that's what you meant to do. The curve is not meant to be a blanket. Also, because of the curve/direction of (4), I rely on drop off flow here to go to (1), which will not work as well if I turn it a bit more so its a blanket.
00:16:442 - add a circle here "if" you follow 00:09:678. Didnt change before
00:19:971 - since you have (3) as a circle, add a circle here for consistency and for a smooth slider-circle pattern. No because this is a new music phrase, it's meant to have a unique timing pattern.
00:38:796 (2,3) - if you can replace this for a circle and a 1/1 slider, it'll follow the instrumental and the vocals. yes i see the blanket and transition, but the notes doesn't feel right IMO. Again, this is a new musical phrase, and I wanted a unique timing pattern. Because of how the song is, you are limited to what kinds of timing patterns you can use especially on easier difficulties, so I decided to go with my own that still tries to fit the music.
00:41:149 (2,3) - ^ ^
01:05:266 (2) - hmm...straighten this slider and move this slider here. as you see, it should be measured equally to make a trapezoid in this part. Eh this is just really nazi and I don't care for the suggestion xD straight is boring so I'm going to ignore this.
01:10:855 (1) - omg this slider ;__; Thanks :3
01:36:737 (1,2) - hmm...try this instead? i think doing this will continue the flow from the previous combo since the vocals tone is the same. This is the same thing, it's just parallel with the previous combo, and angle here was intentional to prevent the patterns from looking boring.SPOILER01:59:384 (3) - NC here. it'll follow the new lyric in this part of the song. Ignoring because this follows the consistency in how my NCs work with the vocals, and the vocal pattern is the same.308,128,96737,6,0,B|236:260,1,144,2|8
88,324,97913,2,0,B|164:192,1,144,2|8
02:00:560 (1) - if you want, you can make this a NC if you follow the suggestion above, since it repeats. ^
Hi, from my modding queue.
[Hard]
The spacing is very weird, but it stills playable, so i think it's good.
[Normal]
Seems perfect to me, good job
Nothing found, sorry. I didn't mod Taiko because i can't, sorry.
Good job ! And good luck ^^
[Hard]
The spacing is very weird, but it stills playable, so i think it's good.
[Normal]
Seems perfect to me, good job
Nothing found, sorry. I didn't mod Taiko because i can't, sorry.
Good job ! And good luck ^^
Hi~ mod from the queue~
[Normal]
01:58:208 (1,2) - may be overlapped by HP bar. consider move them.
02:12:031 (1) - ^
[Hard]
Many beats are in the middle of a slider. Recommend to change slider tick rate to 2.
00:00:266 - Hitsound is not audible. Try raising to 30% as Normal.
00:12:471 (4,5) - questionable because it can be hardly seen in hidden. recommend manual stack.
00:31:295 (4,5) - unrankable. reason is the same.
00:36:001 (4,5) - ^
00:38:354 (2,3) - ^
01:38:501 (5) - may be under the hp bar (especially when user adds EasyMode).
02:35:854 (1,2,3) - ^
02:52:471 (2,3) - questionable.
[Taiko Muzukashii]
Too short. It is no good, you should make the length not too shorter than Taiko Oni. It is not in the rules, but XATs will dislike it.
SV -> 1.3?
BTW, the Taiko Oni diff has the difficulty same as common Taiko Muzukashiis. You may try to compose a level whose difficulty is close to common taiko futsuus.
[Taiko Oni]
Okay.
[Normal]
01:58:208 (1,2) - may be overlapped by HP bar. consider move them.
02:12:031 (1) - ^
[Hard]
Many beats are in the middle of a slider. Recommend to change slider tick rate to 2.
00:00:266 - Hitsound is not audible. Try raising to 30% as Normal.
00:12:471 (4,5) - questionable because it can be hardly seen in hidden. recommend manual stack.
00:31:295 (4,5) - unrankable. reason is the same.
00:36:001 (4,5) - ^
00:38:354 (2,3) - ^
01:38:501 (5) - may be under the hp bar (especially when user adds EasyMode).
02:35:854 (1,2,3) - ^
02:52:471 (2,3) - questionable.
[Taiko Muzukashii]
Too short. It is no good, you should make the length not too shorter than Taiko Oni. It is not in the rules, but XATs will dislike it.
SV -> 1.3?
BTW, the Taiko Oni diff has the difficulty same as common Taiko Muzukashiis. You may try to compose a level whose difficulty is close to common taiko futsuus.
[Taiko Oni]
Okay.
from my queuethat all
[General]
Haruka's Taiko Oni ,2 unsnaped
yellow line is not the same
[Makar's Normal]
tick+1, I hear a lot of sound in middle of slider. maybe you need find tick sound and use in you diff is more butter.
and good job,a lot of nice slider
[Hard]
00:14:383 (1,2,3) - a little close with 00:12:913 (6,7)
00:21:883 (4) - not good for look , play is ok.(found so many place, may be we have different think about this)
01:00:560 (3) - ctrl+r
01:05:266 (1,2) - good idea too start kiai,out of my think
01:36:148 (6) - close with 5
good luck and star~
I like the song~
JudgeTheDude wrote:
[Normal]
Seems perfect to me, good job \o/
Good job ! And good luck ^^
Flower wrote:
Hi~ mod from the queue~
[Normal]
01:58:208 (1,2) - may be overlapped by HP bar. consider move them. It is not touching D:
02:12:031 (1) - ^ ^
[Taiko Muzukashii]
Too short. It is no good, you should make the length not too shorter than Taiko Oni. It is not in the rules, but XATs will dislike it. It's not done lol
Thanks for the mod guys :3wantuole wrote:
from my queue
[Makar's Normal]
tick+1, I hear a lot of sound in middle of slider. maybe you need find tick sound and use in you diff is more butter. I tried this before and did not like it. Tick rate 1 fits better imo
and good job,a lot of nice slider Thank you~
that all
good luck and star~ yay :3
I like the song~
Hello, from CLANNAD modding queue~
Makar's Normal:
00:40:266 (1) - Whistle at the start
02:04:972 (1) - How about using 02:03:796 (2) ctrl+H?
Hard:
-- In some parts, I could barely hear the hit sound.. Consider increasing it
01:21:442 (1) - Symmetry?
02:11:442 (4,5) - 2 Grid Right looks good
Good map
Makar's Normal:
00:40:266 (1) - Whistle at the start
02:04:972 (1) - How about using 02:03:796 (2) ctrl+H?
Hard:
-- In some parts, I could barely hear the hit sound.. Consider increasing it
01:21:442 (1) - Symmetry?
02:11:442 (4,5) - 2 Grid Right looks good
Good map
Sonnyc wrote:
Hello, from CLANNAD modding queue~ Hey~
Makar's Normal:
00:40:266 (1) - Whistle at the start Inconsistent with my hitsound pattern, and I see no reason to have it here specifically.
02:04:972 (1) - How about using 02:03:796 (2) ctrl+H? Eh this is such a small issue ill just consider fixing it in the next update.
A really long wait. Finally I'm modding it.
— Overall
Preview time is still inconsistent.
Taiko Oni
— Overall
Awesome one. I love it.
— Mapping
— Mapping
Starr'd x2
— Overall
Preview time is still inconsistent.
Taiko Oni
- 03:32:620 (1) - Unsnapped circle.
- 03:35:267 (1) - Unsnapped circle.
- I really don't think that dividing last kiai into 2 kiais is a good idea. This makes no real sense, while playing playfield just turns black and red again for half of a second. Restarting kiai at the middle of a chorus makes no sense in taiko imo, because taiko has no fountains or stuff like that. I suggest you to make kiai the same as in all other diffs.
- Also that sudden 1.5x SV is really strange. I think it's not that needed and will only confuse players.
— Overall
Awesome one. I love it.
— Mapping
- 00:53:501 (3,4) - Here I see half of (4) number, but at 00:54:971 (3) - I don't see any number at all. Please choose consistent spacing for such pattern.
- 01:35:413 - Hm, I really think you should add a note here somehow. The vocal sound is pretty obvious.
- 01:44:089 (1) - This repeat is hidden just a bit. It is clearly visible and playable, but still it is not such a pain to move (6) end to the left to make it clear:
- 02:17:324 (5) - This spacing looks a bit ugly and cluttered compared to all similar previous patterns, just move (4,5) a bit up.
- 02:34:971 (11,12,13) - Try to place them at the same consistent distance.
— Mapping
- 00:38:795 (2,3) - 00:40:266 (1,2,3) - This rhythm sounds strange, it should be just 1/1, following vocals.
- 02:37:618 - Consider adding a note here.
- 03:22:619 (1) - I guess you'll have some problems with ranking this one, though it's really fine and follows the rules.
Starr'd x2
grumd's update~grumd wrote:
A really long wait. Finally I'm modding it. thanks for modding!
Taiko OniSuch a neat mapset, finish and rank it asap! apply mods, Xakyrie!
- 03:32:620 (1) - Unsnapped circle. done.
- 03:35:267 (1) - Unsnapped circle. ^
- I really don't think that dividing last kiai into 2 kiais is a good idea. This makes no real sense, while playing playfield just turns black and red again for half of a second. Restarting kiai at the middle of a chorus makes no sense in taiko imo, because taiko has no fountains or stuff like that. I suggest you to make kiai the same as in all other diffs. good point.
- Also that sudden 1.5x SV is really strange. I think it's not that needed and will only confuse players. originally there was no speedup, but a second opinion before uploading told me to differentiate the second half of the kiai to prevent the map from becoming anti-climatic; instead of heeding his words, I got really lazy and decided to just throw in a speedup instead. xD I'll get rid of the speedup for now and I'll remap the second half of the last kiai at a later time when I'm not busy.
Sorry Sorry!! From the queue!!
I took too long for the mod to be done since I was away from osu! modding mode T____T;;
My modding is not great, but here's my suggestions: feel free to ignore.
[General]
Umm.. your music beatrate is 320 kbps if I am not in mistake, lower it down so it should be 192kbps/128kbps etc. = UNRANKABLE
If not using storyboard, delete .osb file and full resubmit.
[Makar's Normal]
00:30:855 (1,3) - Sliderend of 1 and the circle 3 perfect overlap: stack circle at 00:31:589 (it will stack perfectly) and move it to the right time. That will work.
01:10:855 (1) - Very interesting.. oh my gosh. the slider
02:07:325 (1) - ^
02:29:677 (3,4) - Just a suggestion < if applied, also in 02:24:972 (3,4) for consistency.
03:22:619 (1) - Hmm.. slider slider XP
I won't mod hard... it seems fine to me (since I am still inexperienced modder)
Good luck mapping! And star for awesome map!
I took too long for the mod to be done since I was away from osu! modding mode T____T;;
My modding is not great, but here's my suggestions: feel free to ignore.
[General]
Umm.. your music beatrate is 320 kbps if I am not in mistake, lower it down so it should be 192kbps/128kbps etc. = UNRANKABLE
If not using storyboard, delete .osb file and full resubmit.
[Makar's Normal]
00:30:855 (1,3) - Sliderend of 1 and the circle 3 perfect overlap: stack circle at 00:31:589 (it will stack perfectly) and move it to the right time. That will work.
01:10:855 (1) - Very interesting.. oh my gosh. the slider
02:07:325 (1) - ^
02:29:677 (3,4) - Just a suggestion < if applied, also in 02:24:972 (3,4) for consistency.
03:22:619 (1) - Hmm.. slider slider XP
I won't mod hard... it seems fine to me (since I am still inexperienced modder)
Good luck mapping! And star for awesome map!
Twice_old
Topic Starter
shush, you.Haruka wrote:
http://puu.sh/1edqs
... 2 weeks later and you still haven't applied mods.
[General]
- Inconsistency in PreviewTime:
- [Hard] : 65265
- [Haruka's Taiko Oni] : 64971
- [Makar's Normal] : 65265
- [Taiko Muzukashii] : 64971
Make them the same
- 01:08:208 (3) - Add a finish here fits music
- 01:17:619 (3) - ^
- 01:43:501 (2) - ^, slider end
- 01:55:265 (4) - ^, slider end
- 03:01:149 (3) - ^
- 03:10:560 (3) - ^
- 03:22:619 (1) - Make the middle 2 node overlapped would looked better, like thisSPOILER
192,112,202618,6,0,B|136:100|96:156|124:204|124:204|196:172|258:235|258:235|288:304|368:308|368:308|336:396|256:356|256:356|176:396|144:308|144:308|224:304|259:219|259:219|316:172|390:204|390:204,1,1008,2|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0
- 03:36:442 - Add a note here better imo, and maybe you use a spinner after it instead of 03:36:736 (1), lasts to 03:37:913, might be a short spinner as a normal diff, so slider is fine, too
- 01:08:207 (4) - slider end, add finish?
- 01:15:266 (5) - Finish
- 01:17:618 (4) - ^, slider end
- 01:24:677 (3) - ^, slider end
- 01:43:501 (6) - ^, slider end
- 01:45:854 (3) - ^
- 01:52:913 (6) - ^
- 01:55:265 (3) - ^
- 02:02:324 (2) - ^
- 03:01:148 (4) - ^
- 03:08:207 (5) - ^
- 03:10:560 (4) - ^
- 03:17:618 (3) -
- 03:32:620 (1) - Unsnapped circle
- 03:35:267 (1) - Unsnapped circle
@Breeze: I went through the finish suggestions, and I do not like them and it feels very out of place to me.
As for the slider suggestion, I had it like this before, however, it is harder to tell which direction the sliderball is supposed to go (I got complaints about this from MATs/BATs in a previous map, and one from a MAT in this diff).
As for the note suggestion, I wanted to make the ending more calm and fit the piano, so no change.
Thanks for modding :3
As for the slider suggestion, I had it like this before, however, it is harder to tell which direction the sliderball is supposed to go (I got complaints about this from MATs/BATs in a previous map, and one from a MAT in this diff).
As for the note suggestion, I wanted to make the ending more calm and fit the piano, so no change.
Thanks for modding :3
Topic Starter
Hmm, not sure if I should wait to get a storyboard...Regardless of how long it takes, I was hoping to get one. I'm also searching for some nice skin elements to add to the mapset.
+update
+update
Unrankable, problem, plausible problem. Yay good stuff.
[General]
This is the color of Combo 3. It's too bright; namely, 03:03:796 (1) in Makar's Normal gets the worst effect (bright color + kiai + large slider = too bright for me). Maybe darken it somewhat?
Neat hit bursts.
[Makar's Normal]
03:22:619 (1) - Normal players shouldn't be subjected to overlapping sliders, especially if you don't really know where you should go when a beat lands on the intersection. (If I hadn't remembered that the slider snaked bottom-right-ward before looping clockwise to top-right, I probably would have missed it.) Most likely either make it not overlapping, or don't put a red point in the intersection.
[Hard]
Many spacing violations, but having BPM under 120 and no extremely annoying mistakes make it not really a problem.
Hm that's all I can see? Normal has no problem besides that one. Hard has many but all minor violations, although that many might make someone think that it's an Insane...whatever. Your choice. Good luck!
jonathanlfj asked me to take a look at this, so-
Taiko mod~
All are suggestions unless in red.
[Taiko Muzukashii]
Use alternating colours next time~
I'm guessing this is still WIP. So far I really like the patterns though, good job.
[Haruka's Taiko Oni]
02:34:971 - K
Wow, uh, it's a really good map. Sorry I can't find much wrong with it~
Taiko mod~
All are suggestions unless in red.
[Taiko Muzukashii]
Use alternating colours next time~
I'm guessing this is still WIP. So far I really like the patterns though, good job.
[Haruka's Taiko Oni]
02:34:971 - K
Wow, uh, it's a really good map. Sorry I can't find much wrong with it~
quick update
oh yeah and I have a mod too, gg me
oh yeah and I have a mod too, gg me
CoroQuetz wrote:
jonathanlfj asked me to take a look at this, so- haha thank you both -w-
[Haruka's Taiko Oni]
02:34:971 - K done on purpose because there are no vocals to emphasize here like the same parts of its kind; also, k, harmonizes with the piano, so that is why it's not a don.
Wow, uh, it's a really good map. Sorry I can't find much wrong with it~ ye thanks~
http://puu.sh/1pmBI
release rar then copy codes in .osb file into .osu :3
30th design work
signature update
no kds plz
we are going to uuuuuu~aaaaaa(*˘︶˘*).｡.:*♡
release rar then copy codes in .osb file into .osu :3
30th design work
signature update
no kds plz
we are going to uuuuuu~aaaaaa(*˘︶˘*).｡.:*♡
Topic Starter
Update on Haruka's Taiko Oni, muzuhashii, and added storyboard. Maybe I'll wait to rank this as a Christmas map LOL (even though the song has nothing to do with Christmas as the title is extremely misleading orz).
Thank you sososososo much sherrie for the storyboard! It's so lovely like you >< ♥
Edit: thanks to Makar for storyboarding the lyrics onto the taiko difficulties xD
Edit2: thanks sherrie for adding effects :3 it's amazing (*ﾉ▽ﾉ)
Thank you sososososo much sherrie for the storyboard! It's so lovely like you >< ♥
Edit: thanks to Makar for storyboarding the lyrics onto the taiko difficulties xD
Edit2: thanks sherrie for adding effects :3 it's amazing (*ﾉ▽ﾉ)
holy shit
SPOILER
Also you were not supposed to put the lyrics in the taiko diffs silly =w= though if you want I can adjust the code so it works with Taiko as well (like in Hikari) just talk to me in PM later if you are interested o.o
;_; yesXakyrie wrote:
Thank you sososososo much sherrie for the storyboard! It's so lovely like you >< ♥
this should be in OP <3sherrie__fay wrote:
we are going to uuuuuu~aaaaaa(*˘︶˘*).｡.:*♡
lmao yeah so misleading :cXakyrie wrote:
Maybe I'll wait to rank this as a Christmas map LOL (even though the song has nothing to do with Christmas as the title is extremely misleading orz).
Also you were not supposed to put the lyrics in the taiko diffs silly =w= though if you want I can adjust the code so it works with Taiko as well (like in Hikari) just talk to me in PM later if you are interested o.o
[General]
AiMod says that Taiko difficulties have got a different preview time
[Hard]
00:11:736 (1,2,3,4,5) - Why don't you stack this pattern on 00:10:266 (3) - ?
00:22:030 (1) - Whistle on this slider since you did the same 00:26:736 (1) - here
00:27:324 (2,3,4,5) - You should use the same spacing for this pattern
00:44:971 (1) - Shoudn't be there a whistle on the end?
01:08:501 (1) - New combo
01:13:060 (6) - You should add a circle here
02:09:530 (6) - You should add a circle here too
02:20:854 (3) - I suggest to move this slider a little more far from 02:20:265 (2) -
03:06:001 (6) - You should add another circle here
03:09:089 (2) - I suggest to make this slider more adherent with 03:08:501 (1) - 's end
03:14:383 (1) - I suggest to fix this slider form (to make the first curve use one more point, the curve will be better)
03:36:736 (1) - I suggest to change this beat in a slider that finishes at 03:37:324 (2) -
[Normal]
I suggest to use AR3
00:27:619 (2) - I suggest to move this at x:220 y:288 and move 00:28:502 (1) - this on 00:25:855 (3) - this
03:03:796 (1) - Move the 5th point (bottom-center) to x:256 y:348 to fix a little the ticks
03:22:619 (1) - Try to fix this slider too (same problem as above)
AiMod says that Taiko difficulties have got a different preview time
[Hard]
00:11:736 (1,2,3,4,5) - Why don't you stack this pattern on 00:10:266 (3) - ?
00:22:030 (1) - Whistle on this slider since you did the same 00:26:736 (1) - here
00:27:324 (2,3,4,5) - You should use the same spacing for this pattern
00:44:971 (1) - Shoudn't be there a whistle on the end?
01:08:501 (1) - New combo
01:13:060 (6) - You should add a circle here
02:09:530 (6) - You should add a circle here too
02:20:854 (3) - I suggest to move this slider a little more far from 02:20:265 (2) -
03:06:001 (6) - You should add another circle here
03:09:089 (2) - I suggest to make this slider more adherent with 03:08:501 (1) - 's end
03:14:383 (1) - I suggest to fix this slider form (to make the first curve use one more point, the curve will be better)
03:36:736 (1) - I suggest to change this beat in a slider that finishes at 03:37:324 (2) -
[Normal]
I suggest to use AR3
00:27:619 (2) - I suggest to move this at x:220 y:288 and move 00:28:502 (1) - this on 00:25:855 (3) - this
03:03:796 (1) - Move the 5th point (bottom-center) to x:256 y:348 to fix a little the ticks
03:22:619 (1) - Try to fix this slider too (same problem as above)
oh wait it's graveyarded
Topic Starter
Thanks everyone. I'll be going over the mods I previously never had looked at and hope to finish this in a couple of short days. I'll be working towards a pending status and shoot for a rank hopefully by Christmas since it's sort of related to it.
Muzukashii is still not done; will need to be finished. Taiko bgs will also be fixed asap.
Muzukashii is still not done; will need to be finished. Taiko bgs will also be fixed asap.
omg
hype
hype
Topic Starter
Taiko bgs are modified as best as they could possibly be (aka: share the same bg as the standard diffs as well as placement).
All mods applied; time to get some standard mods for this baby.
Edit: Muzukashii is complete! Beatmap pending; time to get taiko mods as well.
All mods applied; time to get some standard mods for this baby.
Edit: Muzukashii is complete! Beatmap pending; time to get taiko mods as well.
from m4m
Your map is look good
Hard
01:23:795 (3) - too near of 01:23:207 (2,4) - suggest to put(3) jump more eg. x:328 y:112
01:43:795 (1) - reference 01:47:618 (4,1,2) - suggest to jump more eg. x:428 y:72
01:52:618 (6) - add finish or whistle on 01:52:913 - here have a some music
01:54:677 (4) - ^ on 01:55:265 -
03:17:324 (4) - ^ on 03:17:618 -
02:01:736 (5) - reference 02:58:207 (5) - suggest to jump too more and put over upper left (feel not well
02:56:442 (6) - add whistle
I can't mod any thing in Makar's Normal...it is perfect
You just only give me insane or hard is OK
Your map is look good
Hard
01:23:795 (3) - too near of 01:23:207 (2,4) - suggest to put(3) jump more eg. x:328 y:112
01:43:795 (1) - reference 01:47:618 (4,1,2) - suggest to jump more eg. x:428 y:72
01:52:618 (6) - add finish or whistle on 01:52:913 - here have a some music
01:54:677 (4) - ^ on 01:55:265 -
03:17:324 (4) - ^ on 03:17:618 -
02:01:736 (5) - reference 02:58:207 (5) - suggest to jump too more and put over upper left (feel not well
02:56:442 (6) - add whistle
I can't mod any thing in Makar's Normal...it is perfect
You just only give me insane or hard is OK
fixed the ending stream and the end time of the last kiai (mine was different than the other diffs for some reason) http://puu.sh/5UGpv
also quick mod for the muzu, as requested:
[Muzukashii]
I really like this.
a lot.
also quick mod for the muzu, as requested:
[Muzukashii]
- 01:06:589 (141) - idk this pattern is probably okay... but how about moving the d back one tick? doubles starting on the offbeat can be a little bit weird
- 01:08:942 (149) - same thing here from the previous suggestion, and likewise to similar parts in the kiais.
- 01:22:618 (186) - k also sounds good? (if so, apply in the other kiais too)
- 02:21:883 (340) - for these doubles, you can just completely remove them and it'll work well.
I really like this.
a lot.
Topic Starter
tyty sis, will apply and update with your diff tomorrow and stuffs.
I KEEP POSTING ERRYWHERE BUT NO ONE SEEMS TO LIKE UTADA
Edit: talked with Haruka irl about mod; updated.
I KEEP POSTING ERRYWHERE BUT NO ONE SEEMS TO LIKE UTADA
Edit: talked with Haruka irl about mod; updated.