Starry wrote:

Nvm~

I'll star this.

terametis wrote:

Hi~
These are all suggestion.

[General]
You must encode the mp3 below 192 kbps. fixed
Please set to 2~3 seconds lead-in. 1 second is short. fixed
Remove Enable countdown. Easy, Normal, Insane doesn't have a margin of 3 seconds at the beginning. fixed

[Easy]
I feel clap sound to fit this song.　

00:19:575 (2)　　　　Add clap fixed
00:24:869 (5)　　　　^ ^
00:26:634 (2)　　　　^ ^
00:28:399 (4)　　　　^ ^
00:30:163 (2)　　　　Add clap at the slider's start. ^
00:30:604 (~)　　　　Add finish at the slider's reverse arrow. ^
00:30:046 (~)　　　　Change to finish at the end of slider. ^
00:31:928 (4)　　　　Add clap ^
00:38:987 (2)　　　　^ ^　　
00:41:634 (1)　　　　Remove clap ^
00:42:516 (3)　　　　Add clap ^
00:44:722 (2)　　　　Add finish at the slider's start. ^

[Normal]
00:01:406 (~)　　　　Remove clap on the end of slider. fixed
00:02:810 (4)　　　　Remove clap ^
00:34:575 (4)　　　　Remove clap. You are just here to use clap from 00:32:369 to 00:45:604. ^

[Insane]
00:01:406 (~)　　　　Remove clap on the end of slider. fixed
00:02:810 (5)　　　　Remove clap ^
00:11:634 (1)　　　　Remove New combo.　This is not a rational New combo. ^　
00:12:075 (1)　　　　^ ^
00:36:781 (7),(1)　 switch New combo. ^
00:42:075 (~)　　　　I want hitsound here. ^
01:03:252 (6)　　　　Add New combo. A big difference in DS. ^

That's all.

I wish your map is Ranked.
bye~

terametis wrote:

[Hard]
00:20:016 (8)　　　　Remove clap on the slider's start. No, feels empty if i remove this.
00:23:546 (6)　　　　^ ^
00:30:046 (1)　　　　Change to finish at the slider's start. Kay
00:31:046 (2)　　　　^ Kay
00:31:928 (4)　　　　add clap Kay
00:34:465 (~)　 　 　Remove clap on the slider's reverse arrow. I feel, clapsound doesn't fit to the blue tick on this part. Kay
00:36:229 (~)　　　　^ ^
00:37:994 (~)　　　　^ ^
00:39:759 (~)　　　　^ ^
00:41:524 (~)　　　　^ ^
00:42:847 (6)　　　　Remove clap or add clap on 00:42:737. Okay
01:16:487 (1)　　　　Add clap. Okay
[/color]

ikari_kyon wrote:

sorry for late >v< I started my job and asdsa well it doesnt matter anyways /o/

lets see if I can help you <: /me dl witouth video

[General]

1. hmm cant find significant tags to put here
2. hmm metronome sounds a bit weird on begin of the song, but it fits on the last part, maybe incorrect bpm
   suggested timing: fixed
   BPM: 136,025
   Offset: 640
   maybe you want to someone that can re-confirm this,

[Taiko]

1. Set all soundsets to default normal and make all the same volume lvl, using custom sounds on taiko mode dont have sense since taiko mode use its own custom hitsounds as default, volume changes are unnecesary too, your sections may looks loike fixed
   SPOILER

   
2. maybe OD 6 dunno maybe my test play got fail due timing fixed
3. wwwwww cant find a good image for make a bg >_< send me a image and Ill make a taiko bg for you, current is covering takumi's face I'll try to find one
4. 00:03:693 (1) - use finish here? ok
5. 00:24:207 (2) - don? due vocal change fixed
6. 00:32:369 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - well drums here are not like this, but is readable I think

I have no much to say about taiko, but is a bit repetitive, maybe variate a bit moar your patterns, and some 5 notes streams ;3 ok I'll try to do that it's my first time making a taiko diff so I dunno what I'm doing xD

[Insane]

1. 00:01:928 (3) - tryin to follow vocals a bit better, whistle to the end of slider? and ↓ fixed
2. 00:03:031 (6) - whistle to start of slider ^
3. 00:07:663 (1) - this finish is a bit annoyin for me, it is following your finish pattern, but other patterns are 1/2 sliders, the second circle of the stream is enhancing the finish a bit bad for me, dont change if you dont want to ^
4. 00:11:193 (1) - sounds different than pointed up, maybe the pointed up was due vocals or something, this sounds better
5. 00:18:252 ~ a moar constant claping sounds more nice for me, maybe add some claps on 00:19:354 (5) - repeat, 00:20:457 (8) - , 00:21:340 (4) - (no whistle) ~ you may notice the pattern fixed
6. 00:21:119 (3) - no whistle? hmm the whistleing sounds weird, as this part is soft whistles should be more constant and have equal times of repeteances ^
7. 00:28:178 (6) - stack on 00:29:281 (3)? ^
8. 00:29:281 (3,4) - copy paste 00:28:840 (1,2) re-scale them by x1,8 then stack (3) on 00:28:178 (6) - that way looks moar elegant, if youliked that, make the same for 00:29:722 (6,7) ;3 ^
9. 00:32:590 (1) - use higher volume? I even was especting a finish /o/ ^
10. 00:36:781 (1,2,3,4) - this part is hmm well as the previous slider was a slowdown, and (1) is stacked the back to normal spacing of circles is so weird, maybe unstack (1) or of course you can space it to x1, but you have some objects like that previously also 00:37:443 (4) - should follows a better flow ^
11. 00:54:207 (4) - overlaps with 00:53:104 (7,8,9) - looks dirty, try to place (9) on y axis and stack all combo 00:53:546 (1,2,3,4) - with (9) ^
    SPOILER

    
12. 01:04:134 (1) - space this x2 distance from previous, antijump wwww dunno :w ^
13. 01:25:090 - add circle with clap O:? ^

[Normal]

1. 00:00:163 (1) - tryin to make whistles follow vocals, whistle on repeat fixed
2. 00:01:928 (3) - whistle on start/end, not on slider body ^
3. 00:03:031 (5) - ↑ ^
4. 00:04:134 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6) - this section is far different than the rest, make like others patterns please, 00:11:193 (1,2,3,4,5) - it was moar simple and that way you dont have that rhythm downgrade ^
5. 00:32:369 - hmm dont use slowdown? ^
6. 01:09:428 (4) - finish? ^

[Easy]

1. 00:46:928 ~ aaand normal slider tick sounds weird >w< fixed

no much to say here, simple rhythm as I like but just a maybe curve moar your sliders >w< ok

SPOILER

asdñlfkasndlkñaeljer xDDDDDDDDDD

http://www.zerochan.net/937198

that is all ;3 wush wush

Konei wrote:

This could get poor ._.



General

Maybe add " ed " to the tags? because if I look for an ending of an anime I always search ed ok

All of your timing sections are unsnapped and need to be snapped oh xD forgot to resnap them when I fixed the timing, thanks

Easy

01:00:629 add a short end of kiai time for a fontaine? nah I'll leave it as it is



Find nothing wrong with it

Just fix the timing sections.

Good luck~

Katty Pie wrote:

hi from my mod Q

General

• It will be sound better if you use volume 50% fixed
• Lead in better make 2000 now it 2004 ^

Insane

00:21:481 - remove this note, not sound here fixed
00:32:619 - start this slider on blue tick 00:32:509 ^
00:33:722 - remove finish. not sound here ^
00:42:544(6,7) - stack better ^
01:25:109(7) - maybe you put so http://puu.sh/GMBm ^

Normal

sound fine~ But looks chaotically and ugly. Maybe you make symmetric patterns or put notes triangle, square e.t.c It's will be looks better ok I'll try to re-design it

Easy

Fine~

Good luck~~

Katty Pie wrote:

Hard

00:12:218 - remove this note, not sound here ok
00:12:108(4) - add clap ok
00:19:276 - remove clap and add on note 3 No, i think fits with the song
00:22:805 - remove clap and add on note 1 Same reason above
00:21:040 -remove clap No
00:59:857(2,3) - stack it better Made another thing
01:17:170(3,4,) - correct spacing between this notes ok
01:21:029 -remove this note, not sound here No no no, listen to the song carefully then you will hear a sound here.

Nagisawa wrote:

Hi!From my Q!

General
~timing is wrong. please offset here 00:00:198 - fixed

Easy
00:12:549 - add note fixed
00:16:078 - ^ ^
01:16:067 - ^ ^
01:23:125 - ^ ^
01:25:330 (1) - end this spinner here 01:28:418 - ^

Normal
~Unsnapped green lines! fixed

00:46:072 - add note fixed
00:57:100 (1) - x:140, y:252 ^
00:57:982 (2) - x:316, y:168 ^
00:59:967 (1,3) - symmetrick will look better ^
01:09:892 (5,1) - ^ ^
01:25:330 (1) - end this spinner here 01:28:418 - ^

Insane
~good for me

Good luck your map for ranking!
Star~3

340,116,44307,5,0
332,196,44749,2,0,B|376:200|404:168,2,80.000000596046,8|8|2

Chewin wrote:

Hi PainSinger, mod request from my modding queue.

[General]
There is inconsistency in kiai times in the "Sawa's Hard" diff. I guess it is for some unsnapped green lines.
Set Kiai #1: Starts on 00:04:168, ends on 00:18:283 and Kiai #2: Starts on 00:46:514, ends on 01:11:215 plz
This BG is really LQ >w< Consider to change it ok, I'll look for a better one
Offset: 176 is better to me. Try it and don't forget to resnap all elements and green lines after timing changes. fixed

[Easy]
00:44:749 (2) - You could move it in this way to make a blanket: http://puu.sh/N3Dz fixed

340,116,44307,5,0
332,196,44749,2,0,B|376:200|404:168,2,80.000000596046,8|8|2

01:00:188 (1) - Remove NC here and use it on 01:00:629 (2). It fits much better since the vocal starts on 01:00:629 (2) and you used a finish hitsound. fixed
01:05:481 (2,3) - Improve the blanket: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/387422 ^

[Normal]
00:21:812 (1) - Remove this finish? It sounds too loud for me or you could decrease his volume. fixed
Good map

[Insane]
00:04:168 (1) - Unsnapped slider's end fixed
00:05:933 (1) - ^ ^

That's all =w= Good luck!

Chewin wrote:

[General]
There is inconsistency in kiai times in the "Sawa's Hard" diff. I guess it is for some unsnapped green lines. Ok resnapped all notes
Set Kiai #1: Starts on 00:04:168, ends on 00:18:283 and Kiai #2: Starts on 00:46:514, ends on 01:11:215 plz Ok

[Sawa's Hard]
00:18:283 (1) - Finish on this slider's head? Okay
00:24:459 (10) - I highly suggest you to use a single New combo here to advice the players about the SV change Ok
00:25:341 (3) - Same of 00:18:283 (1) Okay
00:44:749 (8) - Same of 00:24:459 (10) Okay
00:53:571 (5) - Finish Okay
01:25:330 (1) - Unsnapped spinner's end Okay
I like how you used 1/4 snap divisor here :3 Good job OMG *--* Thanks

JudgeTheDude wrote:

Hi, from my modding queue

[Normal]
00:50:020 (1,2,3) - Try to do a better pattern fixed

That's all
Good luck

DakeDekaane wrote:

Hi, mod time~

This will be short as the map is fine to me.

[Easy]
00:45:167 (2) - What about removing the clap in the reverse arrow? fixed

[Normal]
00:31:053 (5,6) - This looks a bit closed in my opinion, you could try putting 00:31:935 (6) in x:164 y:140 and make the start of 00:32:376 (1) stack with it. fixed

That's all, good luck c:

JudgeTheDude wrote:

Hi, from my modding queue

[Normal]
00:50:020 (1,2,3) - Try to do a better pattern

[Hard]
00:06:351 (6,8) - You can place them better, align them and put their start/end aligned vertically Really don't see a reason to put them aligned...
I really didn't like your superpositions, but it's your choice, I reported them, tough.
00:47:483 (6,7) - You can stack them better Ok
00:52:776 (2,3) - Same here Same
00:54:210 (7,8) - ^ I really don't want to change this...
00:55:974 (2,3) - ^ ^
00:55:974 (2,3) - ^
01:03:363 (2,3) - ^ ^
01:17:478 (5,6) - ^ ^
01:01:708 (3) - Not straight Ok

That's all
Good luck

DakeDekaane wrote:

[Sawa's Hard]

I like streams in general but parts like 00:10:762 (8,9,10) and 00:28:626 (4,5,1) , I don't know but I feel weird, maybe the spacing between the notes are small, you could increase a little, because the speed change in these pattern annoyed me, well, it's only my opinion. [color=#FF0000]Will consider this but no changes for now[/ color]

That's all, good luck c:

wantuole wrote:

[General]
write "Heidi." in Artist fixed
all start at 00:00:176 is butter well it's up to the GD's creator where he/she wants to start
yellow line is so bad，other place like 00:45:829 fixed
[easy]
01:16:044 (2) - remove 2 is butter fixed
[Normal]
00:32:376 (1) - more high, overlap 6 isn't good，fixed

SPOILER

00:42:081 (2,3,4) - so poor do somework of this 3 I think it's good as it is so I'll leave it for now
01:24:867 (4) - there is butter，end must do more clean( I‘m miss this where with FL mod) fixed

SPOILER

[Insane]
00:30:502 (8) - move a little fixed

SPOILER

00:35:244 (4) - not use short low slider there， play so strange ^
01:03:474 (2,4) - ctrl+g(old is "ctrl+r")，you change direction so fast ^

SPOILER

that all
if you can fix Sawa's Hard audio vol , maybe it's all ready for bubble
good luck

raririn wrote:

sorry for huge delay >.< and here's my noob mod

[General]
remove 'ed' from tag since it can't be searched and is unnecessary as you have already put 'ending' fixed

[Easy]
fine diff,but you use patterns like slider-circle-slider a bit too often :> try changing some of them okay I'll change it up a bit later

[Normal]
fine , but whatever try AR4 , AR5 is really hard for a normal diff fixed
00:05:911 (3) - finish here instead of whistle? i think its sounds better no change, it sounds a bit awkward because of the upcoming finish

[Taiko]
00:24:878 (3) - K ? fixed
00:28:627 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - boring for players :/ ^
00:33:259 (9) - D ? ^
00:39:654 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - a 10 note stream with only d is quite boring , try changing the ② to k ？ ^
im noob at taiko but this diff really needs more mod :/ yeah, I know, this is my 1st time making a tako diff

[Insane]
CS5 makes it hard for players to play with HR ,so i suggest using CS4 no change, I like smaller circles here
00:50:461 (2,3,4) - you can make the DS larger , for example 1.00 between ① and ② , 1.20 between ② and ③ ,1.40 between ③ and ④ fixed

i didn't see the 'really unrankable issues' here , but this map can surely be better ,sorry if my mod is necessary/ \
work on , make it better and good luck on rank , i believe you can do it :> Thanks :3

wantuole wrote:

[General]
all start at 00:00:176 is butter I feel my diff start is fine, and really don't want to start here.

[Sawa's Hard]
00:04:145 (1) - not repeat，music play1212121223232323。follow you diff isn't like this song It's not a bad idea use 1/4
00:13:629 (2) - clap in end Ok
00:16:496 (1) - clap Ok
sorry,so poor aduio sound get me tired find all，this song not use audio sound at blue line is butter.
[/spoilerbox]

raririn wrote:

[Hard]
00:19:143 (3,4,5,6) - a little hard pattern for a hard diff ,try reducing the spacing? Hm...no, since i can pass this easily
00:31:493 (3) - i think it would be better if you change them into 3 circles :/ I think slider plays better
01:15:382 (3,4,5) - like this ? i think it's more interesting Good! Like it! Ok fixed

SPOILER

01:23:102 (4) - add a 2nd point at (x=312,y=304) ? Seems good like this so no

KuronumaSawako wrote:

I feel my Hard is more a Hard+/Insane like a normal Hard now orz...

NewibornCLivee wrote:

req. Taiko Mod from mod queue

All of them are suggestions.

[Taiko]
It's better to tell people the difficulty of the map. You can change Taiko to Taiko Oni so people know this is an oni level. fixed

00:31:714 - kd fixed
00:33:037 - kd ^
00:36:566 - kd ^
00:40:095 - kd ^
01:21:117 - k ^

I think that's all nice music and map.

Kuroneko-sHerald wrote:

[General]
Sawa's Hard has a different preview time. I suggest to set it at 46491, like the other diffs. fixed
Artist shouldn't be capitalized in that case. Change "Heidi." into "heidi." ^
I suggest to change the Title in "∞ Loop (TV Size)" and to leave Romanized title "Loop (TV Size)" ^
I thing you should change kuronumasawako into KuronumaSawako in tags. ^

[Easy]
00:07:675 (1,2,3) - Change the Combo Color to another one fixed
00:11:204 (1,2) - Combo Color 3 ^
00:12:968 (3) - New combo + Combo Color 2 ^
00:16:497 (3,4) - New combo + Combo Color 4 ^

01:14:722 (1) - Combo Color 3 ^
01:16:486 (2,3) - New combo + Combo Color 1 ^
01:18:250 (1) - Combo Color 4 ^
01:20:015 (2,3) - New combo + Combo Color 3 or 1 ^
01:21:779 (1,2,3,4) - Combo Color 2 ^

[Normal]
00:07:675 (1,2,3) - Change the Combo Color to another one fixed
00:11:204 (1,2) - Combo Color 3 ^
00:12:968 (3,4,5) - New combo + Combo Color 2 ^
00:16:497 (3,4,5) - New combo + Combo Color 4 ^

00:34:135 (3) - New Combo? ^
01:14:722 (1,2) - Combo Color 3 ^
01:16:486 (3,4,5) - New combo + Combo Color 1 ^
01:18:250 (1,2,3) - Combo Color 4 ^
01:20:456 (4,5,6) - New combo + Combo Color 3 or 1 ^
01:21:779 (1,2,3,4) - Combo Color 2 ^

[Insane]
00:11:204 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - Combo Color 3 fixed
00:12:968 (1,2,3,4,5) - Combo Color 2 ^
00:14:733 (1,2,3,4) - Combo Color 1 ^
00:16:497 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Combo Color 4 ^

01:12:516 (1,2,3,4,5) - Change the Combo Color to another one ^
01:14:722 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Combo Color 3 ^
01:18:250 (1,2,3,4) - Combo Color 4 ^
01:21:779 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Combo Color 2 ^

Kuroneko-sHerald wrote:

[Easy]
00:14:733 (1,2) - Combo Color 1 fixed

[Normal]
00:14:733 (1,2) - Combo Color 1 fixed

Don't kudosu this post.