Snowy Dream wrote:

把Easy改名Normal
把Normal改名Normal+
把Nomral+改名Hard
把Hard改名Hard+

• fine

• AR -1 OD -1
  others, fine

• AR -1
  nothing more to say about mapset, but I suggest you to make this diff more easier.
  it is because I feel the rise of difficulties from Easy is large, and this map has Normal+ diff so you don't have to make this diff so hard.
  how about remove circles on the red tick like 00:10:260 (4) and 00:19:124 (7) ?

• nothing to say

• 00:04:635 (1,1) - more closer
  00:51:660 (4) - rotate by 15° to anti-clockwise and it will be better to connect to next note, or move 00:51:916 (5,1) a little to left.

• 00:04:635 (2) - I think it's be kind to reduce the time of reverse. how about cut this slider at 00:05:317 ?
  00:10:430 (3) - only this note end on blue tick, so to unify through this section, how about use 1/2 slider here?
  00:27:135 (3) - more down and easily to aim I think
  00:29:842 - add note? and we can read rhythm easily
  00:37:512 (1) - same as 00:04:635, how about cut at 00:37:853 or cut at 00:37:683 and add note at 00:37:853 ?

spboxer3 wrote:

[

Taiko

• 
  Settings
  (For the setting. like Song Setup/timing or break time~)
  

1. 建議在Taiko diff中移除影片

這個不了>< 看video還不錯的嘛!

mapping
(These are about your patterns.Mostly for the suggest, Just some unrankable issue I will use red color to highlight it.)

1. 00:11:112 (85) - D? 好!
2. 00:24:749 (182,183,184,185) - 恩...只是建議而已(節奏): ~~我保留原本的>< 個人認為比較好聽啦~
   
   這樣認為比較適合

   

好像沒什麼能說的了...
good luck

wmfchris wrote:

/me slaps 22haha x 2098602398 times

Taiko looks ok to me.

Kawayi Rika wrote:

Hello ~ tutuhaha ~

Random mod for #modreqs ~



Red : Must be fixed
Pink : Should be fixed
Purple : Just suggestions

[Catal]

1. 00:04:602 (2) - Unsnapped slider.

[Rhythm]

1. 00:04:602 (1) - Unsnapped slider.

[Kana's Taiko Oni]

1. 00:59:862 - Change kiai end point here.

[Easy]

1. AR-1 much better play with beginner.

That's all ~ Really nice map and fun song ~

Call me back recheck ~ when you are ready ~

wmfchris wrote:

- I highly doubt that it's BPM176 in the beginning, BPM177 sounds off to me. Find some timing expert?

[Catal]
00:15:203 (1,2) - 看上去糾結 -> http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/395969 另外感覺(1)略吵 FIX
00:23:896 (4) - 放(3,5)右下方不就好了 現在不順手 FIX
節奏沒問題可是就感覺很亂...倒不如說歌曲本身很亂 特別是kiai前

[Rhythm]
00:58:157 (3) - move to (228,136) so that (2,3,1) looks equally spaced FIX

[Easy]
As for a 1/1 based diff tick rate 1 fits better here imo FIX


In overall the map is not a problem and I just pointed out a few nazi stuffs, but for the two insanes sometimes I feel like the triplets, even without whistles/claps, are too loud and covers the music a bit, and timing really needs double checking. FIX

lolcubes wrote:

wmf is right, the timing seemed off. Anyways here's some stuff in addition to the timing.

[Timing]
BPM 176 Offset 198 <- use this offset, but fix your green line first, because if you don't put your green line to offset 198 first, you will crash. FIX
BPM 173 Offset 4268 FIX
BPM 176 Offset 5649 FIX

I SSd the Insane diff while putting OD9 with this, should work good enough. I checked the taiko too and the 173 BPM works a lot better at the start, your 176 BPM red line was on an incorrect downbeat too. FIX

[Rhythm]
00:04:263 (1,2) - These 2 notes should not even exist. Your repeating slider should start where these two are located, because that is where the drumline starts punching. If you had similar things in other diffs, you should change them too. FIX
00:10:601 (5,6,1,2,3) - This plays terrible. There is nothing in the music to justify a jump from 5 to 6, you should fix this spacing, even more because like this it plays terrible. FIX

Other than that, nothing really bothered me that much while playing, so this is all what I've got for now.
Don't use such negative offsets if not really necessary, offset 198 is musically correct.

tutuhaha wrote:

I SSd the Insane diff while putting OD9 with this, should work good enough. I checked the taiko too and the 173 BPM works a lot better at the start, your 176 BPM red line was on an incorrect downbeat too. FIX

lolcubes wrote:

tutuhaha wrote:

I SSd the Insane diff while putting OD9 with this, should work good enough. I checked the taiko too and the 173 BPM works a lot better at the start, your 176 BPM red line was on an incorrect downbeat too. FIX

Use OD8. I don't want you to misunderstand that I am suggesting OD9 here, I am just saying that the timing is good enough for OD9.
Apologies if you misunderstood.

1. Video Offset is circa 230
   
2. All diffs are critically non-nazi'd. Almost all blankets are not precise
3. The Hard+ is considered harder than the Insane by the stupid Star Rating just because it doesn't have as many 1/2 and 1/4 repeating slider, which is the thing Star Rating consider harder than most, yeah, even more than continuous streaming. You don't need to change anything

1. 00:01:561 (1,2,3) - Put them like a sphere
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:40:251 (6) - Curve like 00:39:569 (5) -
   
   SPOILER

   

1. 00:16:558 (1,3) - I would have liked a different shape, stay sure the triangles formed by their start and (2) and (3) end, 00:17:751 (4,1) Stay
   
   SPOILER

   
   
2. 00:38:376 (1) - Blanket its end
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:53:887 (2) - Blanket the next slider instead
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 01:05:819 (1) - Curve like 01:05:478 (9) -
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 01:11:444 (2) - Curve like 01:11:103 (1) -
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 01:18:262 (4) - Blanket
   
   SPOILER

   

HakuNoKaemi wrote:

Graphic is not refined as it's finest here (no nazi mod at all ?) but that's not something I can block your map, and probably the other pattern curvification I had to suggest wouldn't have been accepted probably, since they countered your mapping style

The Hard+ is considered harder than the Insane by the stupid Star Rating just because it doesn't have as many 1/2 and 1/4 repeating slider, which is the thing Star Rating consider harder than most, yeah, even more than continuous streaming.

Video Offset is circa 230 (+-15ms)

HakuNoKaemi wrote:

Video Offset as now is 0, and it about a quarter second off, so most scenes feel off

( the complain with star rating is mine, you don't need to move anything, since the rhythm is perfectly fine )

EDIT: Post organised better

HakuNoKaemi wrote:

Well, If you don't know that converting something to mp3 add a starting RANDOM offset actually.

(I structured the post better, and I added the rest too)

HakuNoKaemi wrote:

Another "I don't want to pop my bubble" I guess.

Yeah, many ranked map could have that problem, but nearly none of the maps modded by me, ziin, Inamaru and so have it. you mean all have video map need to have check for your guys？？
Plus I know you won't consider it... but it isn't time to refine those blankets? and refine the graphics in general ? (refine =/= redo, redo if they were bad, refine if they are good, but not precise. and it won't take a lot to find them, since all blankets are bad and I pointed the "refinable" graphics.
Plus you can just ask the XATs who bubbled to pop and rebubble. They won't make problems to rebubble since they arleady bubbled it. (Just remember to ask the pop, so they don't lose their monthly bubbles)

HakuNoKaemi wrote:

you can simply change the .osu

SPOILER

1) Open the .osu
2)Search the row(it should have a 0 instead of the selected part)

3)Insert 230
4)Repeat for all

It's nothing hard.
I still can't quite understand the reason, try other ways to explain?

HakuNoKaemi wrote:

Well, If you don't know that converting something to mp3 add a starting RANDOM offset actually.

(I structured the post better, and I added the rest too)