Aeonnen wrote:

Oh, modding.

Easy:
00:13:874 (1,1) - Remove combo for next (1) or remove this (1) fixed
00:48:572 (1) - ^ ^

Normal:
Make circle size bigger by 1 no I think it's good as it is
00:05:380 (2) - Place under (1) fixed
00:05:922 (1) - Align with (2) no

Hard:
00:07:548 (1,2,3) - Align each other to make a triangle fixed
00:31:042 (6,7) - Align with (4,5) no
00:46:946 (4) - Align with (1) fixed

These are all suggestions, of course. Don't listen to them if you don't believe it'll help.

Verdisphena wrote:

General
-16 to offset

Hard

00:00:861 (2) - Make the rhythm like this http://puu.sh/looe . Do the same thing in 00:01:584 (1,2,3) - 00:03:030 (1,2,3) -
00:35:741 (4) - Spacing

Normal

00:00:139 (1,1,1,1) - Silenced sliderticks are not rankeable D:
01:03:753 (1,2,3) - Follow this rhythm http://puu.sh/loxv
01:09:175 (1,2,3,4) - Follow this rhythm ._. http://puu.sh/loyu
01:18:211 (1,2,3) - Same as 00:00:139 (1,1,1,1) -

Easy

00:00:139 (1,2,1) - Same as normal, silenced sliderticks are not rankeable. Also new combo in 00:03:030 (1) -
00:11:705 (4) - ^ ;_;
00:23:632 (4) - Move this note to 00:23:813 - . Do the same thing in 00:23:994 (5) -, 00:24:355 -
00:55:078 (1,1,4,6) - unrankeable stuff
00:55:078 (1,1,1,2) - ^
Fixed eveything

HellDawn wrote:

Easy

01:23:978 - remove whistle fixed

Normal

01:10:785 - this slider far previous note fixed
01:23:978 - remove whistle ^

Hard

01:02:472 - 1 grid left fixed
01:23:978 - remove whistle ^

Tony wrote:

Hello! You requested a mod in my mod queue (though you broke the most important rule...anyways) I do have 1 ranked GD

[General]
All looks good~

[Easy]
00:13:858 (5) - you can do same thing like you did here : 00:05:183 (5) -
00:23:797 (4) - I suggest to move this 1/2 earlier and to add a new circle here 00:23:978 -. The current pattern is confusing, and it does not fit as well
00:29:038 (3,4) - I don't know why you added claps here. It fits alot more better those soft whistles that you use in the whole section. Consider changing them.
00:44:942 (2) - remove whistle from the start of the slider. keep the whistle pattern(every 4 white ticks one whistle)
00:46:388 (4) - maybe add one repeat. It sounds kinda empty here 00:48:014 without any note
01:05:183 (5) - remove the finish from the end of the slider. It doesn't fit imo

[Normal]
Reduce HP by 1. It seems a bit too high for a normal
00:44:942 (2) - add whistle at the end of the slider. it fits very well
01:16:568 (3) - the rhythm of this slider doesn't fit imo. Try like this: remove the repeat and start the slider right here: 01:17:291 -

[Hard]
00:11:508 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - reduce the spacing between 1,2 3,4 and 5,6. It's not readable D:
00:20:906 (4) - add whistle. it fits there awesome
00:21:448 (6) - add whistle on repeat. to keep the pattern
00:22:352 (8) - add whistle. it fits there awesome
00:22:532 (9) - remove finish. It doesn't fit imo D:
00:35:363 (3) - maybe whistle instead of finish?
00:47:653 (1) - maybe make a slider out of this spinner and add a note here 00:48:737 - like you did in other diffs
Fixed everything
pretty good map for a new mapper. Have a star! Good luck~

Revengexsoyah wrote:

~Only Suggestions~


[Easy]
00:06:629: sound better with clap (delete whistle) fixed
00:08:074: clap ^
00:09:520: ^ ^

[Hard]
00:11:508(1,2,3,4,5,6): fix the spacing plz xDD fixed


lol fine map star and good luck BYE

ikari_kyon wrote:

hello <:!!!

[Easy]

1. what about use the custom soft clap moar constantly? ok
2. also I recommend to silence the slider slides and slider ticks of normal soundset, specially the slider tick, sounds a bit annoying I had them silenced at one point but someone said it's unrankable
3. 00:29:038 (3) - hmm I cant get the point of volume change of this slider, can you explain me a bit? forgot to remove it xD
4. 00:46:388 (4) - whistle on start, and 2 repeats? ok
5. 01:15:303 (1) - the spacing is decreasing, well it has a new combo and I think it may be ok
   nothing moar to point here

[Normal]

1. 00:21:809 (3) - no whistle on end of slider and ↓ fixed
2. 00:22:532 (4) - whistle here, just for follow your pattern ^
3. 00:23:255 (1) - whistle on end of slider, same to follow your pattern ^
4. 00:40:605 (1) - whistle ^
5. 00:42:050 (3) - whistle ^
6. 00:46:749 (2) - whistle on end of slider? feels a bit empty ^

[Hard]

1. 00:05:183 (2,3) - add clap to increase the effect of song and finishes? ok
2. 00:13:315 (1,2) - clap? simmilar as up ^
3. 00:16:568 (6) - no whistle on end of slider fixed
4. 00:18:014 (2) - ↑ ^
5. 00:18:918 (5) - whistle on start of slider? ^
6. 00:24:159 (5) - whistle on end of slider? ^
7. 00:46:930 (4) - finish instead whistle on start of slider ^
8. 00:55:966 (5,7) - clap ^
9. 00:57:592 (2) - clap ^
10. 01:00:846 (1) - finish to start of slider ^

also whistle to the final slider of all diffs sounds nice /o/ ok
that is all take your star

Verdisphena wrote:

Silenced sliderticks are not rankeable D:

Leorda wrote:

Hi there

[General]
* Heh? Did you silence the sliderslide and slidertick for normal hitsound? If yes, that's unrankable, remove one of them. Removing normal-sliderslide or normal-slidertick are rankable Well I only made the normal-slidertick sound like soft-slidertick but if it seems like it's silenced I can remove it.


[Easy]
00:03:014 (3) - New combo for new stanza? fixed
00:11:689 (4) - ^ ^
00:18:195 (1) - Remove new combo for your combo pattern? ^
00:46:388 (4) - Remove 1 repeating slider. I think end slider snap in red ticks are not fit.... ^


[Normal]
* AR +1? ok


[Hard]
00:25:062 (6) - Why finish? removed it
00:34:460 - Add note for following instruments? fixed


Once you finish, forum PM me for recheck

1. 00:26:147 (T) - Please turn the volume up to 55%. Current one is too low, it makes kinda badplay.
2. 01:18:195 (1) - Add finish to the top.

1. 00:37:171 (8) - Add clap to follow the drum.
2. 00:39:882 (6) - ^ to the top.
3. 01:16:930 (1,2,3,4,5) - Add clap to (1,2,4,5) to follow the bass. And remove finish from (5), it doesn't fit the music so much.

Suzully wrote:

[All diffs]

1. 00:26:147 (T) - Please turn the volume up to 55%. Current one is too low, it makes kinda badplay. fixed
2. 01:18:195 (1) - Add finish to the top. ^

[Hard]

1. 00:37:171 (8) - Add clap to follow the drum. fixed
2. 00:39:882 (6) - ^ to the top. ^
3. 01:16:930 (1,2,3,4,5) - Add clap to (1,2,4,5) to follow the bass. And remove finish from (5), it doesn't fit the music so much. ^

Call me back after fix. I'll rank.