You can't know if Suburu and "kuu" are telling the truth, unless you're an assassinEcho wrote:
I'm not too sure what you're saying here.BagelBob wrote:
Echo is pushing for the us to believe Suburu and "kuu", with no way of knowing they're telling the truth unless Echo is a wolf
OK, so in this case, Suburu could be an assassin, and no one has any way of knowing whether or not that's true and you call that "On track?"It's there - it's the second one. That's because there IS no way to definitively determine whether she is an assassin or not from the NK.BagelBob wrote:
None of these possibilities include Suburu being an assassin
But you said that if Suburu dies, "kuu" is a wolfOK, if you want it straight, they can be either both innocent or both assassins. But by saying what I've said I've influenced tonight's kill in such a way that I myself will be absolutely sure which is the case. What I said was more for my benefit than for everyone else's.BagelBob wrote:
Echo even says that if neither is night killed, then they both are not assassins
(if two people who are dangerous to the assassins are not night killed, they are not assassins)
Doesn't Suburu have to be the insomniac to die tonight which would make Suburu town and "kuu" a wolf?
Suburu shouldn't die because even if "kuu" is a wolf, the real guardian angel could protect SuburuWhich is why if Suburu dies kuwarudo MUST be a wolf. (Not "if kuwarudo is a wolf then suburu will die")BagelBob wrote:
Also, the third thing Echo says isn't even a possibility. Even if Suburu is the insomniac and "kuu" is an assassin, the real guardian-angel can still protect Suburu
You may be right about it not influencing today's vote, but it could give the town something to think about overnight.I'm holding onto the information because it's the end of the day, and anything I say will only influence tonight's kill and not the voting. If we still had 3 RL days to go I'd happily post it.BagelBob wrote:
Furthermore, withholding information from the town is never good. Everyone should be posting their opinions and thoughts and no one should say "I have thoughts on the matter but I'm only going to PM them to a few people in case I die rather than tell the whole town"
(on a side note, What happens in the event of a tie of lynch votes? We may need to do something...)