Mashley wrote:

Okay NoHItter's gambit was terrible but obv we can't lych him.
Best lynches right now are pieguy and Backfire I think, due to general lack of or low quality posts. Thoughts, guys?

foulcoon wrote:

nohitter for being scummy and for there already being a tracker, and mashley partially for the original reason, and also for claiming he picked something most would perceive as town (70s pop or w/e).

bmin11 wrote:

I'm going to believe in NoHItter and dkun for their claims. NoHItter's rebalance and the edit on dkun's role PM seems like a convincing alibi. Normally, there wouldn't be much of a reason for the mod to edit their role PMs.

pieguy nohitter and you still had votes on me even at the end of the day what is this shit I COULD HAVE BEEN LYNCHED

IT'S MY LIFE ON THE LINE

fos: nohitter. his claim is believable (because of dkun's claim) but that doesn't mean he isn't scummier than a swamp

Sync wrote:

maybe

let's try that post again

pieguy nohitter and you still had votes on me even at the end of the day what is this shit I COULD HAVE BEEN LYNCHED

IT'S MY LIFE ON THE LINE

fos: nohitter. his claim is believable (because of dkun's claim) but that doesn't mean he isn't scummier than a swamp

Sync wrote:

god dammit i'm totally up for a nohitter lynch but let's at least wait for another person's input

NoHItter wrote:

Two, isn't that claim too convenient?
You claimed Setup Sleuth who conveniently got info about three investigative roles and how two of them have "bad intentions" just when you "obtained" a vig role from someone which you could use to verify that statement?

Besides, how does a motivation give you a Vig Kill? Motivations usually upgrade the ability you already have. How can an investigative role like Setup Sleuth get a Vig Kil from being motivated?

Two wrote:

convenient is expecting people to forget the bottom line: you claimed cop day 1 and claim to have both not been killed and not been roleblocked

as for why I got a vigilante kill, the only connection I can make is sleuth->detective->copish->cops have guns

I'm not wojjan

NoHItter wrote:

So basically the reason why you're suspecting me is because I'm alive and I successfully delivered a result?
You're forgetting the fact that the setup here is not known.
If there was a confirmed Mafia Roleblocker, then sure my staying alive and being unroleblocked would be suspicious, but there isn't.
Your argument about "me staying alive and being unroleblocked = scum" is basically WIFOM surrounding the Night Actions and roles.

Incidentally, an even more basic contradiction, how can a Cop be Mafia?
Cops investigate people to be guilty/not guilty.
You yourself are saying that I'm Cop, yes?

Two wrote:

no, I'm saying I assume a mafia cop would function as a role cop in addition to what it normally does

Chris wrote:

nohitter you're not going to deliver a result because you know your only option would be actually verifying a town member

if you picked mafia after we lynched you that'd be two down~

NoHItter wrote:

Wrong Chris.
You are pushing too hard on so little info that it is very scummy.
You only have Two's claim. You YOURSELF have no information whatsoever yet you are pushing HARDER than Two.

@Rantai
Like I said I am not willing to out him yet, but I gave a hint as to who I investigated.

Rantai wrote:

So uh if that 3 is worth anything I take it it's me?

NoHItter wrote:

Well then Chris, if I do get lynched and you're town then please reconsider your Mafia play style.
If you're Mafia then I congratulate you for successfully lynching a investigative role.

@Two
Also, if you really believe that a Cop = Role Cop, then at least PM Wojjan and inquire regarding it.

NoHItter wrote:

@Chris
Well what I did say to animask was true.
You really should change that "I'm all-knowing" play style.

@Two
So you're not going to even bother at the very least, to inquire about it?

NoHItter wrote:

I'm asking you guys to please NOT listen to what Two and Chris says immediately and at least try to think about this situation yourself.

NoHItter wrote:

Incidentally, if he WAS given that information at the start of the day along with his Vig Kill, why didn't he claim the info first?
If he knew that among the "three investigative roles", two had "evil" intentions, then it would make more sense to claim it before shooting.
The only reason I can think of by not claiming it at the start was that he was planning to change what Wojjan "told him" in case dkun did flip scum.

Wojjan wrote:

Please refrain from quoting PMs exactly, but seeing as it's remarkably easy to forge info, I won't modkill over it if you don't take a screencap. That's pushing it.