abalee wrote:

Easy:
00:50:856 (1) - 1/2 forward?

abalee wrote:

Inaba
00:07:522 (5,6,7,8,9,10) - 這團東西太亂了... 大丈夫，没人打漏过，就读图来说应该ok的。然后属意是tsubaki那种乱七八糟的嚎。
00:09:689 (4) - 這裡沒人說過只要一個circle就足夠了?我觉得拖一下比较能突出tsubaki声嘶力竭的味道……
各種Hidden Slider就看著辦吧...反正你不擔心unrank我也不怕泡掉...不過還得另外找一個一個同樣粗心的才行.
多可爱啊（喂）……unrank我心里有觉悟了……但是很想试试看这样做效果好不好。以前也有图带那么一两个，我想应该不至于。真unrank了我改就是Q_Q
Easy:
00:50:856 (1) - 1/2 forward?fixed

Raging Bull wrote:

Easy:
Perhaps map to the end like the rest of the diff?

1. 00:45:856 (2) - Hard to see how many times this slider repeats
2. 01:00:856 (3,4) - Stacked notes (especially after sliders) are hard to click, newbies will probably hit these too early.
3. 01:28:522 (3,4,5,6) - This will make newbies go into panick-mode lol

1. 02:32:522 (2) - A bit too close to (1)?
2. 01:04:522 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - This combo is quite long, consider splitting it up into more combos
3. 01:23:189 (3) - New combo? because the spacing changes here.

1. 00:09:689 (4) - Maybe remove the slider and place a note here instead? at 00:09:856 - you don't hear anything in the song yet you make this sound with the sliderend
2. 01:48:189 (9) - This feels a bit weird, kill the jump here?
3. 02:09:356 (6,7,8,9) - Place these closer to eachother? distance snap 1.30 instead of 1.70, alternatively you can use new combos to make this jump better noticeable
4. 02:53:189 (11) - same as 00:09:689 (4)

happy30 wrote:

[Yuki's Easy]
No errors here, but it got some parts which aren't newbie-friendly
Few examples (I won't list them all)

1. 00:45:856 (2) - Hard to see how many times this slider repeats
2. 01:00:856 (3,4) - Stacked notes (especially after sliders) are hard to click, newbies will probably hit these too early.
3. 01:28:522 (3,4,5,6) - This will make newbies go into panick-mode lol

wait for yuki's respond

[Normal]

1. 02:32:522 (2) - A bit too close to (1)?
2. 01:04:522 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - This combo is quite long, consider splitting it up into more combos
3. 01:23:189 (3) - New combo? because the spacing changes here.

all changed

[Inaba!]

1. 00:09:689 (4) - Maybe remove the slider and place a note here instead? at 00:09:856 - you don't hear anything in the song yet you make this sound with the sliderend
2. 01:48:189 (9) - This feels a bit weird, kill the jump here?
3. 02:09:356 (6,7,8,9) - Place these closer to eachother? distance snap 1.30 instead of 1.70, alternatively you can use new combos to make this jump better noticeable
4. 02:53:189 (11) - same as 00:09:689 (4)

all changed

I will recheck after you've considered my suggestions

Lissette wrote:

Add collab and collaboration to tags?

Inaba!
Add spinner to vary scores?
quinche
00:09:689 (4) - remove the slider, make it one note?
00:19:856 (1) - don't stack under the prev 3, is kinda hard to notice that this is a slider didnt change this
01:07:689 (5) - this slider fits better starting at 01:07:522 - didnt change this
01:35:856 (1) - same as 00:19:856 (1) - didnt change this
01:48:439 - end kiai on a tick with a note (looks weird on taiko T.T)
NanaDesu
01:03:523 (9) - make it one beat slider, without the reverse

TS's Taiko!
02:10:856 - end kiai here 02:10:522 -
03:17:356 - looks weird this end of kiai, maybe end here 03:16:522 -

mmm i guess i wont change this

Licnect's Hard!
Add spinner to vary scores?
00:09:689 (1) - would be nice if you silence slider slide
01:49:772 - end kiai in a tick with a note - (same reason of Inaba!)
03:13:772 - ^

ill let licnect to decide for the first one, but changed the kiai

Normal!
Same suggestion about adding a spinner
02:32:522 (2) - new combo

changed.

Yuki's Easy!
01:04:522 - 01:23:189 - i'm not fan of weird shaped slider, but these ones are really nice, fit very well <33
01:36:522 (3) - remove one repeat
01:49:522 - same about kiai end as others diffs
add a lilttle break-time somewhere since this is the easiest difficulty, i think is needed

waiting for yuki's respond

happy30 wrote:

[Yuki's Easy]
No errors here, but it got some parts which aren't newbie-friendly
Few examples (I won't list them all)

1. 00:45:856 (2) - Hard to see how many times this slider repeats
2. 01:00:856 (3,4) - Stacked notes (especially after sliders) are hard to click, newbies will probably hit these too early.
3. 01:28:522 (3,4,5,6) - This will make newbies go into panick-mode lol

Lissette wrote:

Yuki's Easy!
01:04:522 - 01:23:189 - i'm not fan of weird shaped slider, but these ones are really nice, fit very well <33
01:36:522 (3) - remove one repeat
01:49:522 - same about kiai end as others diffs I think It is already same with normal ?
add a lilttle break-time somewhere since this is the easiest difficulty, i think is needed It's only 2 mins and actually It's kinda hard to find space to put one :l

Sakura Hana wrote:

Please stop finding things after maps get ranked, its not fun to unrank maps you know, not for the BAT, not for the community.

Sakura Hana wrote:

Please stop finding things after maps get ranked, its not fun to unrank maps you know, not for the BAT, not for the community.

Charles445 wrote:

Sakura Hana wrote:

Please stop finding things after maps get ranked, its not fun to unrank maps you know, not for the BAT, not for the community.

Wait, uh, what?

Isn't finding unrankable things GOOD?

Shiirn wrote:

lincet's hard

00:29:856 (4,5) -

SPOILER

uuuuhhhhhh

great map

Natteke wrote:

Lol those sliders were no harm at all, you just hold the cursor and that's it, what the fuck is wrong with you all, guys

Shiirn: your nazi full of personal preferences shitpost sucks, 0/10

Usotsukiya wrote:

The sliders are completely readable and playable, unless you are blind or not paying attention to the map, just re-rank it so everyone can stop complaining.

Usotsukiya wrote:

The sliders are completely readable and playable, unless you are blind or not paying attention to the map, just re-rank it so everyone can stop complaining.

Elly-chan wrote:

Just because you people had no difficulty reading those sliders doesn't mean that everybody else didn't have trouble reading them. For example, I had trouble reading it therefore I got a combo break.

So you know what? Just stop complaining yourselves about getting this re-ranked. It's already unranked now, and it'd just be plain out silly to rerank it without changing anything.

Stuff happens. Get over it. Now, stop posting in this thread if all you're going to post is 'Those sliders are completely readable and playable!'. Stop quoting everybody saying that, too. It's getting annoying.

Thanks.

Elly-chan wrote:

Just because you people had no difficulty reading those sliders doesn't mean that everybody else didn't have trouble reading them. For example, I had trouble reading it therefore I got a combo break.

Usotsukiya wrote:

Let's unrank every ranked map that you can't read/play then.

Sakura Hana wrote:

I personally checked the slider (on a screenshot) now, i'd say it's a gray area, i personally wouldn't bubble/rank it but i wouldn't say it's 100% unallowed, it is highly recommend you do change it tho

Natteke wrote:

Uh, there are easier diffs in the mapset if you didn't noticed, just for your skill. Go play then, what's the problem?

qinche wrote:

wah..

ill edit this post after checking the map, now, can everyone say happy birthday to me:D?

its a great day to get my ever 1st unranked map...

Love wrote:

I smell trolls that need to learn to play osu! standard

Alace wrote:

Sakura Hana wrote:

I personally checked the slider (on a screenshot) now, i'd say it's a gray area, i personally wouldn't bubble/rank it but i wouldn't say it's 100% unallowed, it is highly recommend you do change it tho

<Hard>00:29:856 (4,5) + <Inaba>00:19:189 (4,1) should be considered

Personally i can play this kind of slider well because you don't even need to move after clicking the sliders,it means that you don't
even need to read the direction of slider. but as i quoted, overlapped sliders are not allowed....

I hope we can make this one rerank as soon as possible, it's a really fun mapset. If you download the mapset because of the flamewar.
Close the thread and try it

Natteke wrote:

Uh, there are easier diffs in the mapset if you didn't noticed, just for your skill. Go play then, what's the problem?

Blue Dragon wrote:

Natteke wrote:

Uh, there are easier diffs in the mapset if you didn't noticed, just for your skill. Go play then, what's the problem?

I thought people had the freedom to play what they wanted. Or are you against freedom?