If I may ask, why? Is there a flaw in my reasoning? If so, please point this out so I can avoid it in the future.LadySuburu wrote:
Unvote, Vote: pieguy1372
Might as well show you.pieguy1372 wrote:
If I may ask, why? Is there a flaw in my reasoning? If so, please point this out so I can avoid it in the future.
Anyway, no thoughts on who the SK is? It's imperative we hit the SK as soon as possible to stop the double NKs.
Alternatively, I guess we could just go for a mafia member today and hit the SK tomorrow, because we'll still have a bit of time if we hit a mafia today. However, if we miss it's practically game over. >.> aaaaaa
So it's impossible because you think it can't be true?pieguy1372 wrote:
The conclusion here is that Chris couldn't possibly be sane, because I really don't think 3 of those 4 could be mafia..
We know this for sure now? That's news to me. It's not good trying to convince others to go along with something unproven as if it's proven.pieguy1372 wrote:
Actually, you know what? Since we know Chris isn't sane
Oh, so we don't need to search between the other unconfirmed? Also, how is it a contradiction?pieguy1372 wrote:
So the assumption that Chris was sane is, definitely IMO, a contradiction. That means we still have to search for mafia among LadySuburu, rust45, akrolsmir, Chris, and bmin11.
Except that if he's sane it will come out true.pieguy1372 wrote:
I recommend "akrolsmir is town", in that case. True = naive and False = insane.
Not sure if he dies that we'll get his sanity or not.akrolsmir wrote:
That seems reasonable I guess, for some reason no one wants to lynch Lilac/foulcoon.
Vote: LunaticMara
I still have an investigative shot tonight, so who do I examine? And how do we get me to survive to show the results?
This seems horribly self-centered but perhaps we could have rolled bus me instead of chris. After all, if he dies then at least we'll know his sanity, and if he doesn't die then we grow more suspicious of him. But then, mafia could just block rolled and shoot me. Maybe I"ll be better off protecting myself tonight?
We know this for sure now? That's news to me. It's not good trying to convince others to go along with something unproven as if it's proven.Everything after I proposed Chris wasn't sane was assuming Chris was not sane...I had a "certain" tone in those posts, but that's because it was assuming it was true, not because it was necessarily "proven" (though at this point I estimate the chance of it being true is around 80%). Sorry if I implied the wrong idea.
Oh, so we don't need to search between the other unconfirmed? Also, how is it a contradiction?I already did that. Notice how I said "still". Also, by "contradiction" I meant when you assume something is true and then prove it leads to a contradiction, in order to prove it's not true (as in a proof by contradiction).
if you are willing to bet it why are you voting for pieguy and not himfoulcoon wrote:
Willing to bet he is the SK.
because I doubt anyone else is going to vote for him?Chris wrote:
if you are willing to bet it why are you voting for pieguy and not himfoulcoon wrote:
Willing to bet he is the SK.
I realized I remembered it wrong. Sorry for being forgetful.Chris wrote:
foulcoon killed Two
Mafia killed Wojjan
akrolsmir killed Rantai
Well, this was pretty much what my plan consisted of:LS wrote:
Oh, and unless Rolled (who for some reason has viewed the thread a few times since I've posted asking him for evidence that we're not already screwed if Chris isn't sane) gives me that said evidence/logic/ect... I'm going to continue to assume he's sane.
If you're town, it would be better not to hide tonight if you can hide on consecutive nights. Otherwise you're just confusing us more by making us unsure of both foul and your alignments.Lilac wrote:
You can't ask foul to NK me because he can't do it either. What a sham.
That said... Unvote, Vote: Mara. Victory.
WAT JUU SAILilac wrote:
regardless of possible language constraints.
http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Executioner, doesn't seem like Rantai's in charge of silencing.Mod wrote:
Rantai (Ephemeral) - Threadlocker (aka Executioner) - Nightkilled N2
Pieguy. Don't shoot anyone on Chris's confirmed list, please.foulcoon wrote:
I'd feel pretty comfortable shooting bmin or pieguy.
If you can, yes.akrolsmir wrote:
Meanwhile I'm supposed to be investigating foulcoon while protecting myself?
noooooo don't shoot meLadySuburu wrote:
Pieguy. Don't shoot anyone on Chris's confirmed list, please.
Lilac wrote:
I have almost no doubt now that foulcoon is the SK.
????Lilac wrote:
...If you want my opinion, I think foul and Kiddo are the remaining Mafia but my opinion on Chris still stands.
Rolled wrote:
Lilac wrote:
I have almost no doubt now that foulcoon is the SK.
I lose if I die.Chris wrote:
so what is the point of you existing then if you can't lose
Whats that? pieguy died and that's who I was supposed to kill? And you said this before you knew Rolled switched me and pieguy?Lilac wrote:
I have almost no doubt now that foulcoon is the SK.
Considering that he went against what he was allocated to do twice, it obviously means he doesn't give a care about the world. That or he's Mafia and was agreed to kill LS with his only other partner.
hahaha no.foulcoon wrote:
Also, for the lulz I targeted myself last night.
fixed that for youLilac wrote:
Vote: bmin. Congratulations, Chris's results have become completely null and I still don't know what role you claimed.
Lilac wrote:
and I still don't know what role you claimed.
bmin11 wrote:
I'm a 50% chance Detective. If I target the victim (NK'ed) of the night successfully, I'm able to draw the culprit's face. However, I only have 50% chance of doing so because of inconvinient reasons (probably indicating how Daru can't draw so often because of his real life =ㅅ=;;)
Then how do you suggest pieguy died?bmin11 wrote:
It's really really REALLY hard to believe you would shoot yourself guessing Rolled swapping you and pieguy.
And ya, Vote: foulcoon
Sorry, closed setup.Rolled wrote:
Mod: Would a Strongman be able to bypass bus driver's ability? If bus driver switched player x and z, and strongman targeted z, who would die?
I'm not sure if bus driver is considered a protective role.MafiaWiki wrote:
Strongman is a role modifier that signifies that any kills performed by this player cannot be blocked by any means - neither by Bulletproof, nor by Doctor or other protective roles, nor by Roleblocks.