As for rust, yes I do agree he seems scummy. However, I know personally that when I'm confirmed town with a decent power role, I'd prefer not to claim REGARDLESS of the strength of the role. I keep doubt in the minds of the mafia and SK and hopefully convince one to kill me if it's weak, or avoid being killed if it's strong. I would assume rust's role is weak from the fact that he does not have information, or it's a strong role that wouldn't have obvious effects unless he properly used it.
Let's see something here, so I can clarify for myself and might as well for others.
11 alive - 4 anti-town with one confirmed. (7 town)
If we mislynch, down to 6 town.
Next day, if SK and Mafia avoid eachother, we're down to 4 town.
With this in mind, we'd be in Lylo tomorrow? 4 townies, 2 mafia, 1 SK, 1 Lyncher. I think we'd have to hit the SK to win.
From my end, here's how things look.
1. LadySuburu - Town
2. Mashley - Anti-Town
3. Rolled - Town?
4. Lilac - Unknown
5. rust45 - Either Town or Scum, depending on Chris's sanity.
6. pieguy1372 - Scummy
7. foulcoon - Unknown, leaning anti-town.
8. akrolsmir - Town
9. Chris - Town?
10. bmin11 - Either Town or Scum, depending on Chris's sanity.
11. LunaticMara - Scummy
Assuming you and Chris are town, If we find out chris is sane or naive, not including his results from the next night:
1. LadySuburu - Town
3. Rolled - Town
8. akrolsmir - Town
9. Chris - Town
10. bmin11 - Town (Unconfirmed)
5. rust45 - Town (Unconfirmed)
2. Mashley - Anti-Town
4. Lilac - Unknown
6. pieguy1372 - Unknown
7. foulcoon - Unknown
11. LunaticMara - Unknown
That's 4 players to choose from, and we HAVE to hit the SK to still win. This list above doesn't take into account who is killed and who we lynch.
If chris is insane / naive:
1. LadySuburu - Town
2. Mashley - Anti-Town
3. Rolled - Town
4. Lilac - Unknown
5. rust45 - Unknown
6. pieguy1372 - Unknown
7. foulcoon - Unknown
8. akrolsmir - Town
9. Chris - Town
10. bmin11 - Unknown
11. LunaticMara - Unknown
At this point, I'm a bit stressed/tired to go over all of the possibilities. This is just a sliver of what I'm worried about here. If Chris is insane or naive we've basically already lost (is how it feels to me.). I feel safer going off of the assumption that he's sane.
However, if you can provide me some information (and convince me) on how we're not royally screwed if he's not sane, I'll go along with the rust lynch.
Let's see something here, so I can clarify for myself and might as well for others.
11 alive - 4 anti-town with one confirmed. (7 town)
If we mislynch, down to 6 town.
Next day, if SK and Mafia avoid eachother, we're down to 4 town.
With this in mind, we'd be in Lylo tomorrow? 4 townies, 2 mafia, 1 SK, 1 Lyncher. I think we'd have to hit the SK to win.
From my end, here's how things look.
1. LadySuburu - Town
2. Mashley - Anti-Town
3. Rolled - Town?
4. Lilac - Unknown
5. rust45 - Either Town or Scum, depending on Chris's sanity.
6. pieguy1372 - Scummy
7. foulcoon - Unknown, leaning anti-town.
8. akrolsmir - Town
9. Chris - Town?
10. bmin11 - Either Town or Scum, depending on Chris's sanity.
11. LunaticMara - Scummy
Assuming you and Chris are town, If we find out chris is sane or naive, not including his results from the next night:
1. LadySuburu - Town
3. Rolled - Town
8. akrolsmir - Town
9. Chris - Town
10. bmin11 - Town (Unconfirmed)
5. rust45 - Town (Unconfirmed)
2. Mashley - Anti-Town
4. Lilac - Unknown
6. pieguy1372 - Unknown
7. foulcoon - Unknown
11. LunaticMara - Unknown
That's 4 players to choose from, and we HAVE to hit the SK to still win. This list above doesn't take into account who is killed and who we lynch.
If chris is insane / naive:
1. LadySuburu - Town
2. Mashley - Anti-Town
3. Rolled - Town
4. Lilac - Unknown
5. rust45 - Unknown
6. pieguy1372 - Unknown
7. foulcoon - Unknown
8. akrolsmir - Town
9. Chris - Town
10. bmin11 - Unknown
11. LunaticMara - Unknown
At this point, I'm a bit stressed/tired to go over all of the possibilities. This is just a sliver of what I'm worried about here. If Chris is insane or naive we've basically already lost (is how it feels to me.). I feel safer going off of the assumption that he's sane.
However, if you can provide me some information (and convince me) on how we're not royally screwed if he's not sane, I'll go along with the rust lynch.