mapped by Alumence
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 7 June 2024 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:03:598 - 00:08:663 - You should double check your snaps in this section, half of the piano notes mapped are in the wrong snap. Most of these if not all should fall under 1/6, not 1/4 or 1/8.

Examples:
00:03:695 (3695|3,3793|2,3841|1) - should just be 1/6 up to 00:03:793
00:05:254 (5254|0) - Should be 1/6 at 00:05:286 -
00:06:764 (6764|3,6812|1,6861|2,6910|0,6958|1,7007|2) - Should be 1/6

etc..

permalink

all 1/6 now :yayyippee:

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:11:780 - 00:12:599 - the right long notes in this are un-synced, there should be 2 long notes, adding the up long note which should be snapped on 1/8. Have the stairs at 00:11:293 - 00:11:780 spread out a little. The idea is really good.

permalink

you can hear a VERY feint piano at 00:11:780

i also fixed the snapping (its 1/6). Also, the piano notes are very loud as well, so the density is fitting.

in the future, dont put these as problem, put it to "suggestion"

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

Ah okay understandable. And it's my first time doing this so my bad.

permalink

00:19:415 (19415|0) - Should be 1/3 not 1/4

permalink

fixd

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:20:019 (20019|1) - Why stop mapping the 1/3 here and use a 1/2 note? Feels unnatural.

permalink

killed the 1/2 note with rocks and put 1/3 note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

Change every triple notes from 00:25:799 - to 00:32:826 - into doubles or even single notes since the difficulty and note density from 00:33:637 - to 00:41:475 - being easier than 00:25:799 - feels the map isn't expressing the gap of sound's intensity into note density.

permalink

changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:35:799 - third hand on this pattern is out of line with the rest, should be adjusted to keep consistent with previous triple hand idea

permalink

fixed (i didnt catch this originally)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:36:610 - placements on these long notes here should be readjusted to better have pitch relevance

permalink

rearranged (lns are now [1] [3])

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:41:205 (41205|2) - For a cleaner LN pattern I'd extend this to 00:41:475 as it just feels a bit ugly to have the releases play out like this currently.

permalink

okay yeah i see it
fixd

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:46:610 - 00:48:367 - What are the LNs here following? The piano notes are in 1/4 in this section and half of the LNs here dont really emphasize anything.

permalink

i was following the other piano notes earlier but i readjusted lns to follow 1/4

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

(following as in doing 1/2 )

permalink

00:50:394 - 00:50:935 This here feels empty as i believe this section should be mapped.

permalink

mapped it

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:53:637 - 00:54:043 - and 00:54:448 - are all the same repeated sounds but strangely the first one is different, I would suggest coming up with a repeatable pattern for this as it is a prominent sound throughout 00:50:935 to 01:08:232, and a notable consistency problem throughout this large section too

permalink

copied 00:51:205 (51205|3,51239|2,51272|1,51306|0,51340|3,51374|1,51407|2) - and replaced the parts with the same sound (mirrored a few in order to not have big anchors)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:54:989 - should probably be emphasized with a jump or hand to fit with your current pitch relevance on percussion

permalink

fix d

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:55:259 - needs some repatterning as it's quite similar to the sound at 00:50:935 - but doesn't follow anywhere near the same structure

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:55:529 - 00:55:729 the rework here is kinda weird as 00:55:732's note is right where the chord is met. This should be changed as it causes a miss easily. (The pattern itself isn't bad, i think it should be rearranged so it smoothly hits the chord.)

permalink

keeping the way it is. i believe the way it is now has good PR. It's stream, and it also leads nicely here - 00:55:799 (55799|3,55799|0,55799|1,55867|1,55935|2,56002|3,56070|2,56205|1,56205|0,56272|1,56340|2,56407|3,56475|2,56610|1,56610|0,56678|1,56745|2,56813|3)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence
permalink

00:55:799 - Confused at the sudden pattern change here to minijacks when the other patterns before and after it don't use this structure despite following similar rhythms. In itself is fine, but in context of the overall chart it's an inconsistent change.

Also be more considerate with how surrounding patterns transition into it, you have a weird triple minijack at 00:55:732 (55732|1,55799|1,55867|1).

permalink

rearranged the chord off the LNs to be 134 and moved the doubles in col 2 to 4

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:57:826 - I think the pitch relevancy here would feel a lot nicer if this stream flowed towards column 1 (1/2/3/4) as well with the prior

permalink

done and rearranged

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

00:59:178 - I do think there could be a rice note here to emphasize the very soft click sound here, and to leave this break in the song with a lot more impact

permalink

added (i originally didnt add it cause i thought it was soft but i see what you mean)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:00:394 to 01:00:664 - I feel like there should be some change in patterning or stream flow here to help contrast to the largely different sound here from the rest of the section

permalink

fixed rah (did roll off jump to change flow)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:07:759 (67759|2,67759|3,67826|1,67826|0) - Considering the rhythm here I'd make these singles as it doesn't feel right to continue the jumptrill for half a beat after a measure, since the music starts focusing on other instruments.

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:09:043 - Very long and uncomfortable anchor in column 3 here (1/2/3/4), should be removed
01:12:286 - Ditto

permalink

fixed anchor and added hand

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:16:880 to 01:20:935 - there is a noticeable hand imbalance here, and my left hand certainly did not consent to whatever you are doing to it. please balance out the handstream here a bit more

permalink

cleaned up and rearranged to keep hand balance

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:16:880 - to 01:23:699 - , 01:47:422 - to 02:07:965 - , 02:30:047 - to 03:12:654 - , and 03:44:100 - to 04:18:694 -

-redo these sections

permalink
permalink

01:21:205 - to maintain your long note stream flow here, I think the rice notes immediate here, and a little bit after should be adjusted to be long notes fitting to the streams that follow

permalink

made the rc notes noodle

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:21:205 (81205|1) - secret rice note hidden under LN

permalink

01:22:087 and 01:22:690 - is there any specific reason for these hands in particular being rice notes? it seems out of place and would fit better as long notes

permalink

didnt hear anything coming off of it so i made it rice instead of ln, but i made it rice

but i made ln as per your comment

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:28:346 (88346|2,88427|2) - I don't really understand what the purpose behind this minijack is, as it is mapped to sounds that were previously just mapped as jumpstream and feels out of place. these should be repurposed to streams to fit in

applies to 01:33:563 as well and other reiterations of this pattern here

permalink

done and killed with rocks

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:28:998 - the minijack here feels far too intense for the given sounds here, and makes an unreasonably uncomfortable and out of place pattern for a such a faint sound. i'd suggest killing this minijack with rocks.

along the same lines, all of the minijiacks throughout 01:34:052 to 01:36:661 seem to yield no actual purpose other than difficulty without any song representation, and would feel better being removed

permalink

killed the mini jacks with rocks and made it a wee bit more stream y

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence
permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:40:248 - has a rather uncomfortable pattern, and is an entirely different way and different note density of mapping the same sound you previously mapped at 01:27:204. it's quite inconsistent, incredibly uncomfortable from the minijack and split trill, and should probably be adjusted

permalink

fixed and kept a roll type pattern to keep in line with the sound (as i hear it, it doesnt change so i kept it going one way)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:41:960 (101960|2,102001|3,102041|0,102082|1,102123|3,102204|2,102245|3,102286|1,102327|2) - What are these LNs for? Whatever it is, the sound is too subtle to warrant this much attention between the bursts.

permalink

fixed to rc

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:45:628 (105628|1,105628|2,105628|0) - This is just a kick so it would be more suitable as a double

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

01:47:096 - 02:07:965 this whole section makes no sense. Why is it mapped on 1/12? I believe you should instead map it to 1/8 as i remapped it myself and it's more playable and smoother. 1/12 here just doesn't make sense.

permalink

in my opinion, i think 1/8 would be a little too dense to me. If I did this as 1/8, I would have to remap that entire section. I don't want to restructure it

Also, its 1/6, not 1/12

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

02:03:074 - This part in general is a bit too messy with the mix of LNs and bursts, this is just one example but when you layer too much you start leaving more room for random pattern choices that don't feel intentional. The sudden strain on col 4 at 02:02:911 (122911|3,123074|3,123237|3,123346|3,123482|3,123563|3), the weird trill with 02:04:867 (124867|0,124976|0,125031|1,125085|0,125194|0,125248|1) and 02:05:737 (125737|3,125846|3,125954|3,126090|3,126253|3), etc..

It's important to be careful with how you structure more than one pattern to consider as it can easily get messy in gameplay due to unintentional stuff like these.

permalink

readjusted 02:03:074 and make js
reduced strain on col 4 by rearranging some of them for the js
removed the note where the lns are to emphasize on that

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

The density and difficulty of patterns from 02:30:047 - to 02:35:297 - was too easier than patterns in intense sounds in general.

Should utilize minijack or 3+ jacks even more to make it more difficult and intense to balance the overall difficulty/density of this mapset.

permalink

e.g.

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

03:12:875 - 03:13:536 Good patterning but should be synced right to the big sounds (unsure if this intentional or not). Should be more consistent with these sounds.

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

03:14:911 (194911|3,194978|2,195046|1,195136|3) - This is definitely not 1/4, the piano is a lot faster here.

permalink

made 1/6 instead

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

03:20:046 (200046|3,200063|2,200113|0,200130|1,200181|3,200198|2,200248|0,200265|1) - This is barely following the amen breaks with how it's structured, especially since they're just jumptrills.

permalink

fixed and used this 00:28:907 (28907|0,28975|3,29043|0,29088|3,29133|1,29178|0,29223|3,29268|2) - (i was gonna get to copying that over)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

03:30:688 (210688|3,210721|2,210755|1,210789|0,210857|3,210890|1,210924|2,210992|0) - This should only be 1/4..the piano doesn't go any faster than that.

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

03:38:154 - This 1/4 LN jumpstream is really monotonous and barely follows what the music is doing. There's some short pauses in between like 03:38:492 (218492|1,218559|3,218559|0,218627|2) but you keep the same jumpstream motion. It'd be nice to change this up a bit, especially since you seem to do it the first time with 03:37:884.

permalink

switched around the js, and removed ln for some of the break sections.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

03:41:397 (221397|0,221431|1,221498|0,221566|1,221600|0) - Not a nice transition to play with the bursts, as you have a left-hand trill starting and then quickly going to rolls leading to the left. It's really chokable and not fun to do with the movement needed.

permalink

fixed and balanced to both hands

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

03:57:073 - Really heavy on the right hand suddenly with how this plays out (look at the col 4 anchor compared to everything else).

permalink

killed anchor with rocks (it is gone now)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

04:12:208 - 04:13:289 Weird start for 2nd section of the chordjacks. Should be rearranged formally.

permalink

rearranged the section to hopefully balance out each hand (as well as slightly rearranging the ln section before)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

04:12:208 - This jack structure makes no sense with the music. It's not just a 1/2 percussion rhythm. I'd suggest re-evaluating the pattern choice here and accomodate as necessary with how the drums and cymbal is played out.

permalink

redid the section

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

04:19:235 - 04:26:938 should somewhat switch hands but can move back to right hands if needed so (for switch ups and more louder/lesser sounds).

permalink

ill keep the way it is. cause if i move the chord over to the left hand it the lns before the chord would be too left hand heavy. keeping the chord on the right hand evens it out

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

04:42:166 - What's with the long quad anchors here. You don';t do this anywhere else, having it come out of nowhere when the music is still following the same rhythm feels so out of place and is quite a difficulty spike with how it's arranged.

Also you're ignoring an obvious 1/4 rhythm at 04:43:355 (283355|2,283355|3,283355|0,283355|1,283487|1,283487|0) -

permalink

i wasnt intentionally trying to ignore it. i felt it didnt have enough significance to do anything

but i did this to restructure the anchors - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/19105825/e2f0
and this to add the 1/4 rhythm - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/19105827/5b0e

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence

04:58:246 - 04:58:726 These short LNs are unsynced. Should sync them on time.

permalink

synced

permalink
Marked as resolved by Alumence
/