mapped by menphiss
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 12 March 2024 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

Can you jack the notes for the same pitch like these ones? 00:02:860 (2860|4,3114|5) - 00:10:996 (10996|4,11250|3) -

permalink

I tried moving notes and LN's to check if this is a good idea but no. I dont like how change the map.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

this is subjective but there can be a note at 00:12:267 because it is the same as 00:04:131 although more quiet

permalink

same with 00:28:538

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

00:15:318 - missing rice

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

00:18:369 - seems missing a piano vocal here

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

00:26:504 (26504|3) - looks like excess note (should be same as 00:10:233)

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

00:47:860 (47860|1,47860|0) - why are there two LNs here? I dont hear any difference to the LNs before it, so I think it should just be one

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:10:230 - 01:32:298 - , Maybe it's just me but, I think there is some inconsistency about the drum being jack or not? Example 01:11:092 (71092|6,71264|6) - , 01:23:505 (83505|0,83678|0) - etc. jack on the drum, while others like 01:12:471 - , 01:16:609 - etc are not.

permalink

01:10:747 (70747|1,70833|5) - Currently they are isolated from each other. Making them closer with help to recognise that they are all for hithats.

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:11:781 (71781|4,71954|5) - I would suggest to swap there notes col. I don't hear this 01:11:954 (71954|5,72126|5,72298|5) - fit with any sound imo.

permalink

01:12:040 - seems no sound here, maybe we can modify like this: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18607369/a3d6

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:13:161 - I think here could be double, because 01:12:471 - here is triple and the sound is more heavy.

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:13:505 I think express the breaks LN + drum
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18649748/739d
example

permalink

Change everything else that looks like this part

permalink

I didnt understand this so i will not take this suggestion, and sorry for the late reply.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

The kudos is for the part. If i remember well, this means about the violin part.

permalink

01:13:850 - drum here need buffered, you can add a note in column 5

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:15:747 (75747|2) - I prefer to move this to column 7 so that this stair 01:15:661 (75661|5,75704|4,75747|3) - will be clearer to recognise

permalink
permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:17:040 Add one note

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:17:471 - I think here could be triple, you can add on column 1

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:17:471 Wrong snap here
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18649756/2f74
Placing my styles

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:19:195 / 01:19:367 Adjust the number of notes

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:26:264 - and 01:26:350 - could be double

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:27:643 The drum snap is wrong overall, so check it out.
I'm not going to say any more drum snap

permalink

?

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss
permalink

01:30:230 piano is 1/6 snap

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

There are piano notes audible at 01:32:471 and 01:32:643 so you should add notes for them.
Same for 01:37:988 and 01:38:161

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:40:057 - missed piano

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

I think those notes are fine.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:43:678 -, 01:46:436 - , 01:49:195 - , need double

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:48:505 - this burst is REALLY hard compared to everything around it. Definitely reduce the amount of brackets

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:54:109 - I do think you should add a note here for the sake of making the stream feel more continuous to match the buildup sound (there's also a quiet but audible snare sound here)

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

01:54:195 - i think it'd be better to make this a triple because the piano is significant here (even though you were layering the drum with the piano before)

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

02:01:264 - the intensity of the map should match the intensity of the song, so as the buildup gets more tense I think it should get more difficult. However, having LNs on three columns makes it easier near the end of the build up and you miss out on mapping all the fast intense sounds at 02:03:333. I would recommend remapping this buildup for that

permalink

The intense sound is represented by 02:03:333 (123333|6) - and each sound is with LN to show you how the sounds are intensified. But i will think in this. Maybe a remapping is better and im blind.

permalink

you do a good job in representing the intensity of the buildup at 01:52:988, so why not do something similar here? you could use LN density to reflect the different synths if you want

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

02:01:954 - this transition is a bit finnicky
first 02:03:161 (123161|6) should be moved up to 02:03:333 if you are mapping to the siren
There should be another note at 02:03:333 and 02:02:298 as well to make a chord.
You can add notes to fill in the empty space afterwards if you want
Something like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18820394/d44d (blue notes optional)

permalink

I will take some of this suggestion. Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

02:03:333 There's no reason for notes to appear
If you want to add a note, I think you should add a note just like a LN is added

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

02:03:333 (123333|1,123548|1,123764|1,123980|1) - I beg you, don't, just don't
Use 1/8 snap, (2356)x4
or24562356234623452 sth like this

permalink

Modified with the help of Outlasted and jeremkyurem.

permalink

Uploaded.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

02:16:005 - should only be a single with your current layering

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

02:16:092
1/6 is better

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

02:24:367 (144367|4,144454|4) - should avoid this irregular jack

permalink

I was fixed this but kudos as well for the mod.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

02:55:057 - I think here could move a note on 1/16 to more in tune with piano

permalink

03:04:712 -, 03:08:850 - is the same

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

03:02:988 - should be a single

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

03:05:402 - should probably have a rice double at least because this is definitely supposed to be heard as a chord

permalink

Sorry i cant understand because i dont hear a double here. More if i modify this mod #3988575. Can you explain this pls.

permalink

the musical phrase starting at 02:03:333 outlines an F# minor seventh chord. 03:04:712 (184712|4) is the F#, 03:05:057 (185057|3) is the A, and 03:05:057 (185057|3) should be the C# and the E. The two notes before it should be singles because the piano is playing a single note, but at 03:05:057 it comes to rest as it completes the chord with two notes, so it should be a double

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

03:10:230 (190230|4,190230|3,190747|2,190919|3) - it's not very clear what these are mapped to, if the piano is the rice what is the reason for having the funky LN spacebar release?

permalink

Because that looks pretty :(. Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

03:21:436 (201436|3) - this should probably be moved up to the white line, it feels awkward to have a staggered entry when all the strings come in on the same beat

permalink

same at 03:25:402 and 03:30:919

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

03:26:781 (206781|4,206781|6,206781|0) - release timing is weird imo. Try extending all of them by 1/2

permalink

Done.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

03:35:057 - maybe could release one or two LN here, the drum in 03:36:436 - need at least double to expression.

https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18607381/4c77

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

03:46:264 - here could be arranged like 03:46:609 - , I think they are the same.

permalink

I moved 03:46:609 (226609|3) - to 03:46:178 to make the same pattern and i think represent better the sound.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

03:47:988 (227988|0,228161|0,228333|0,228505|0) - anchor here didn't represent anything imo, would suggest to re-arrange it

permalink

03:57:988 (237988|0,238161|0,238333|0,238678|0,238850|0,239109|0,239367|0,239540|0,239712|0) - I would suggest to spread this notes, it seems a bit crowded at col 1

permalink

04:16:781 - 04:26:092 - sound in this section feel similar yet it mapped it a bit different. Obvious things I can find on this inconsistency is this shield 04:18:333 (258333|4,258592|4) - . section like 04:16:781 - , 04:20:919 - etc have no shield like that. I would suggest to re-map this a bit make all the pattern similar between section

permalink

04:35:230 (275230|0,275402|1,275574|0,275747|1,275919|0,276092|1,276264|0,276436|1,276609|0,276781|1,276954|0,277126|1,277298|0,277385|1) - One hand trill on here is not comfortable and didn't represent anything imo. Would suggest to spread it out

permalink

04:46:954 (286954|0) - minor thing, I would suggest to move this to col 7 or anywhere depend on your style, it's not creating 04:46:781 (286781|0,286954|0,287126|0) - , they not representing anything imo

permalink

05:01:092 (301092|2,302298|3) - and 05:09:195 (309195|4,309712|5) - I think LN these are a little redundant because sound here is weak and they didn't last very long, so that doesn't need to add them here.

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss

05:03:333 - what is the purpose of the rice here ? ?

permalink

05:07:298 (307298|0) - and this LN

permalink

The LN represent a sound at the background and i put it to dont leave nothing there. I can understand the reason to remove it. But the rice notes there are for the sound at the background too. The sound are strong to ignore and i think is not a problem to represent.

permalink
Marked as resolved by menphiss
/