mapped by Notredame
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 29 October 2022 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:00:364 (1) - This circle right here sadly doesn't hit the piano note precisely and there's no way to get it right without a new timing point, so, add a new timing point on the offset 373, snap it there, should be fine.
This is a 9ms difference, not noticeable while playing since it's just 1 note but takes no effort to fix.

permalink

thank you for noticing

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:04:109 (1) - Just as a subjective idea, move the "last" red anchor towards the slider head a bit more like this https://prnt.sc/07Md4gcHjJ4E
Technically ruins the symmetry of the top part but the 2nd part of that looks a lot smaller since it transitions into the wave and the first leaf-like shape looks bigger than the other because the sharp angle between the wave and the sliderhead is much deeper.

permalink

thanks i didnt notice it but i like this idea

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:09:493 (4,5,6,7,8) - Having the kickdrum on the slidertail of 4 feels lackluster because it's non-clickable, would suggest turning 4 into a kickslider and then adding a new note on the white tick to give more emphasis to the kickdrum

permalink

thank you for the suggestion, a lot of players from my playtest did point out that this part feels weird to play hopefully this feels better

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

This isn't much better/worse to play, it's just rhythm choice, playability and comfort are relative when you're mapping high star maps like this. It feels a bit better since osu players are more naturally conditioned into hitting triples or 5-note bursts and it was a 4-note burst, which is a tad more awkward, but people who play on this level shouldn't have any problems with something as simple as that.

permalink

okay thank you for the insight now i will be more careful

permalink

00:10:109 (8,9,1,2) - Make the jump from 9 to 1 smaller, so that there's better emphasis on 2 https://prnt.sc/Pm-gJdK1-0RG (Just copy-paste 8 and 9, rotate it by 70-90 degrees and just call it a day)

permalink

ok will do

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:12:570 (6,7) - Maybe you could rearrange these to not be covered by the slider? Like so https://puu.sh/IYi7A/0ee93a32e5.png

permalink

oh yeah sure!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:13:801 (5) - Contradicting to my previous suggestion if you do have to cover the hitcircle with a slider, maybe you could arrange it to be covered completely? like so https://puu.sh/IYi8r/35c447cd44.png

permalink

oh okay i will do it

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:17:185 (4) - Maybe move it to the right a little bit? https://puu.sh/IYi8Y/b4abfd672f.png

permalink

yes okay

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:18:570 (5,1) - Looks a bit disjointed because the stream, 5 as a whole, and the slidertail of 1 don't form a straight line with the previous stream.

permalink

i agree the stream looks weird so i changed the entire part can you check?

permalink

Rechecked, looks fine.

permalink
Marked as resolved by -eNVy-

00:27:493 (1,2,3,4,5) - Why is there such a sharp cut on 3? If it's due to the synth playing, there should also be such a sharp cut on 5. Otherwise this should be changed into a normal curve stream because it creates a wrong sense of emphasis.

permalink

oh that was just me being random i will make it into normal curves can you recheck if its okay now?

permalink

The spacing looks a lot bigger than before, might just be me though, the main issue is fixed now though.

permalink
Marked as resolved by -eNVy-

allright, but i didnt change the spacing

permalink

00:32:109 (4) - Maybe move the note up a little bit ? https://puu.sh/IYi9w/6396c8b6b0.png

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:39:493 (5) - Maybe a little more to the left? https://puu.sh/IYi9U/affc644573.png

permalink

okay done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

maybe group 00:40:877 (5) - differently, feels too connected but its a start to new phrase

consider making it stand out from 00:39:955 (2,3,4) - while making it feel more connected to 00:41:185 (6,7) -

maybe change slider shape and spacing to be more distinct from 00:39:955 (2,3,4) - ?

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:47:955 (8,1) - Would suggest making this either a clean overlap, or just space it a bit so that it doesn't overlap, for the sake of consistency.

permalink

okay done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:48:416 (1) - Maybe you could reshape the slider to match the opposite shape of 00:48:878 (3) - https://puu.sh/IYiaL/bc9f42cc9c.png

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

00:55:801 (1,2,3,4,5) - Not a suggestion but just wanted to point out how well the blanket is made here! Most of if not all your jumps could somehow fit this your map would be set!

permalink

okay i will put it to mind thank you!

permalink

01:05:801 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15) - Same topic as earlier, sharp turn on 10 for no reason whatsoever, creates a false sense of emphasis

permalink

okay done as you suggested would you recheck?

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by -eNVy-

01:11:647 (3,4,5) - There's no sound playing on 4. Could be justified with 01:16:109 (2,3,4) and 01:34:109 (4,5,6) for consistency but I don't see a point in it since mapping this as two jumps would fit into the whole section just as nicely. This critique point also applies to the other spots aswell obviously.

permalink

oh okay i will remove all the triples

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

01:17:339 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - consider changing this curve

permalink

okay done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

01:21:032 (5,6,7) - i would rework this line into something like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17928843/7b22 I think it looks more visually appealing since the follow point leads directly into the slider.

permalink

ok will do it

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

01:22:724 (2,3) - triple here would be nice

permalink

ok!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

01:27:262 (5,6) - this plays rly badly compared to 02:50:955 (5,6) - I would just ctrl g the slow slider

permalink

will do

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

01:37:032 (3,4,5,6) - the spacing for these jumps isnt really justified, would be better if they were smaller to emphasize the upcoming jump section. try something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17827154/7756

permalink

okay done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

01:40:262 (3,4,5,6,7) - these jumps feel kinda off because you suddenly start ignoring the snare, id suggest extending 01:39:955 (2) - to 01:40:262 and just keep going with 1-2 jumps after that

permalink

03:03:647 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - same thing here

permalink
permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

01:57:647 (1,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - Also another well mapped portion!

permalink

thanks!

permalink

01:57:647 (1,1) - imo its not a good idea to do a perfect stack like this 2 minutes into the map for the first time, i suggest trying a different placement

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

02:12:416 (1,3,5,7) - I think these specific notes could have some sort of consistency here, whether its in a straight line or a zig-zag. Personally i suggest making them a zig-zag like so. https://puu.sh/IYida/0216c8518e.jpg

permalink

oh okay nice didnt notice that will do it

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

02:35:801 (6) - Maybe you could move it a little to the right? https://puu.sh/IYiek/36293a55b8.png

permalink

okay

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

03:16:878 (4,2) - Maybe I would suggest seperating tese two apart a little? Like so https://puu.sh/IYifx/eeb7e8a6e2.png

permalink

okay will do

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

03:21:339 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Love this portion too!

permalink

thanks!

permalink

03:30:570 (1,2,3,4,5) - Maybe move this stream a little to the right? Like so https://puu.sh/IYiga/fc90e8c3e2.png

permalink

okay done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

03:31:185 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6) - i LOVE these keysounds but there's no hitnormal feedback. i would make these keysounds whistles so there would be feedback like u did with 01:16:801 (6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - (not sure why the keysounds are paired to claps here either, they should be whistles if anything)

permalink

ok will do it

permalink

ok done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

03:31:185 - starting here with the 1/3s, i feel like you could've made this a lot more interesting by increasing the spacing between the circles since they have the exact same distance as the rest of the 1/4 streams in your map.

permalink

i mean, you could also do something else, like turn them into tiny 1/3 jumps to show contrast but just a suggestion to make this part more unique.

permalink

ok done i increased the spacing and changed entire section shape could you recheck?

permalink

looks a lot nicer :D

permalink
Marked as resolved by Einja

03:40:724 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - really unjustified spacing for pretty much all of this, compare it to 03:45:647 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - which has much stronger sounds but the 2 parts currently have the same spacing

permalink

okay i nerfed the part before

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

03:47:339 (10,1) - can't find a reason to stack this

permalink

ok remapped it

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

04:02:416 (4) - missed big sound on 04:02:570

permalink

okay fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

04:31:185 (3,4,5) - this felt very underwhelming for a buildup. you used a lot of 1/2 jumps in similar patterns earlier yet here you didn't use them.

permalink

i guess the other buildups are a little bit different since they are in the middle of kiais like 01:25:339 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - but i would still use jumps to express the buildup in the song, maybe not as intense tho.

permalink

you are right i will change it

permalink
Marked as resolved by Notredame

05:21:032 (1) - Such an amazing slider art

permalink

hahah thanks!

permalink
/