mapped by Tofu1222
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 10 July 2018!
nominated by Rivals_7 and Unpredictable
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:15:582 (15582|2) - 这个note的重音应该和00:15:693 (15693|3) - 的音高是一样的,可以考虑4col叠

permalink

就不叠了吧, 打起来会比较吃力啦

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:15:693 (15693|1,15693|3) - i think that this timing should have both notes sticking together for a better representation of that piano sound, how about this? :: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/11012423

permalink

Good idea. Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:21:026 (21026|2,21138|1,21249|2,21360|1,21471|2,21582|1,21693|2,21804|1,21915|2,22026|1,22138|2,22249|1) - like we talked about irc, let's just remove it and put and LN from 00:21:693 - to 00:22:360 - for the piano that's emphasized here

permalink

Fixed owo)b

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:22:360 - All the 3 diffs layering here is literally the same. I personally believe that the hardest diff can use a huge difference in the layering here for the piano echo like this https://puu.sh/AsuVQ/f204ebdd3c.png so it could gives off different feeling of emphasize towards the overall diff in this specific section instead of being the same 1 note

permalink

Make them into LNs instead.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

continue from yesterday
00:22:471 and 00:22:582 , from these 2 timestamps, i guess you can add 2 notes here as you can hear a gentle grace note here, you can leave it if you do not want to, just purely a suggestion :)

permalink

I think it's ok for now as I used LN for all these 1/1 pianos.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:22:915 - 00:24:915 - add note for follow piano pitch?

permalink

I don't properly hear any pitches in the said part.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:23:693 i like how you follow the notes' pitches from here. But from here you can hear the piano is gradually getting louder and heavier, so i think you can add 1 more note to each of these timestamps to emphasize the volume of the piano starting from 00:23:693, then to 00:24:360 , 00:25:026 , 00:25:693 , 00:26:360 . and to avoid clashing with CS' diff, imo it should be a "little" bit harder :3

permalink

You see, I made them into LNs.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:26:360 - This bell melody gives off a distinct feeling of melody pretty far from the piano. It's way too empty here I would say since the song starts to build up in volume and background sounds start to kick in from this point to the 1st chorus. I would do something like this https://puu.sh/Asv2h/54d8ced520.png to layer the bell and fill up the gap for the build ups

permalink

I fixed with your previous mods.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:29:249 - could you change the direction here so its not too much the same direction that goes for the whole section

permalink

The pitches of the triple notes are consistently going downward for the first three bars, so essentially I don't come up with a better idea that the 3rd one should be fliped I guess.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:38:026 - ups add note here, kick snare

permalink

00:38:249 - you do not add sv or anything, better to add notes, whether single or double, but single is better

permalink

i agree at 00:37:915 - i would just continue the jumptrill

permalink

This feels quite logically correct. Thanks!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:38:138 (38138|2,38138|1) - these 2 here, i am pretty sure that you are following the vocal here, like what you did here for 00:37:915 (37915|0,37915|3,37915|2) - and 00:38:360 (38360|1,38360|0,38360|3) - , adding 1 more note to there would be better for the consistency~

permalink

I have changed to jumptrill then. Thanks for your input.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

suggest to make it double, 00:41:360 - 00:46:693 - since you made a double in this area for a drum kick 00:42:138 - and here 00:44:026 - and also it can make the player can distinguish the sound from the tap

permalink

It makes sense to me. My mistake here.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

It's kinda hard to prevent that since the triple notes are already well-positioned in my opinion. Also such 1/1 stacks actually don't add too much pressure too.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:51:804 (51804|0,51804|3) - make [23] the sound repeats from 00:51:471 (51471|0,51471|3,51582|1,51582|2) - and also [23] followed from 00:51:582 (51582|2,51582|1) -

permalink
permalink

I don't quite get your idea here but I think the current pattern looks fine to both for consistency and for pitch relevancy.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

00:53:360 (53360|3,53360|0,53471|0,53471|3) - would change it to [34] here so i would have this weird balance that it currently does

permalink
permalink

Personally ok with them cuz the sound pitches are the same, and actually even though i don't stack the sounds with same pitches before, here is the end of each repetition so I think it's reasonable to have some difficulty.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:03:693 (63693|0,63804|0,63915|1,64026|0,64138|0,64249|1) - Could use some re-arrangement because this one is rly left hand heavy. Tried to play it without problem but maybe it would hassle to the player of 3* caliber. 01:03:915 (63915|1) - just move this to the |3| will do <3

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:03:915 (63915|1) - i personally think it goes better in column 3 for hand balance and a better flow of pattern

permalink

Fixed with DNM's mod.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:07:582 (67582|0,67693|0,67804|0) - i don't like how this column repeats 3 consecutive times, how about moving 01:07:582 (67582|0) - this to column 3 and 01:07:693 (67693|2) - this to column 2?

permalink

Rearranged.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:09:693 - this could be more than just 135 bpm jumptrill

http://puu.sh/ALCsW/21d740c13c.jpg

permalink

Applied!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:10:360 (70360|2) - i don't think this timing deserves to have 3 notes, the sound doesn't support it. Moreover, i don't quite agree about column 3 having a sudden column repetition there, if it were to have them it should be in these 01:09:693 (69693|0,69804|1,69915|0,70026|1,70138|0,70249|1) -

permalink

Made into double then.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:21:026 for this part i think it has to be a little bit more intense as the song is gradually building up to its climax, i'd suggest adding 1/4 notes for the piano starting from here. Some notes may have to be double according to the pitch of the piano notes.

permalink

Anyway added for here and for the beginning.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:21:360 - add a note for drum bass?

permalink

It's too weak for me here.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

assumed that you have followed the suggestion that i gave above, 01:24:026 these notes can be changed into LNs to have a clear difference from the 1/2 from before, which is of higher pitches, and the LNs for the lower pitched piano notes. I'd suggest something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10999891 but you can try to rearrange the pattern to your liking~

permalink

Fixed in a different way.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:25:471 (85471|2) - I dont think there is actually bass piano here. If there is, it's pretty inaudible compared to the latter ones. I would suggest to remove it

permalink

It's about the synth sounds actually changing here so yeah the LNs are following the synth.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:29:360 (89360|0) - hold on this is reeeeeeeeeealy ambiguous to be worth noticed. i dont heard any low piano like any other places you did

permalink

OK then. To me they are indeed a bit too weak to be noticed. Deleted.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:29:693 (89693|0,89915|0) - i think there were just more than a two pianos

http://puu.sh/ALDKm/bd26a84ae3.jpg

permalink

Anyway just deleted those notes.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:30:138 (90138|1) - 移动到1,(说实话,这里的钢琴没怎么听清)

permalink

改了

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:31:471 (91471|1,91582|2) - sound of violin is better presented with sliders

permalink

All the way after are violin sounds. It's a bit weird to have LNs here.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:44:249 - just one thing actually. should this be separated LN?

permalink

Yes, fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:50:471 - add a note for violin

permalink

same here 01:50:915 -

permalink

Added.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:52:471 (112471|1,112582|2,112582|3,112693|0,112804|1,112804|2) - 建议https://puu.sh/AtgYa/3d53ae3ae3.jpg (其实主要是最后三个note你看看跟pitch要怎么排

permalink

放在中间也很有气势的感觉,我觉得OK。

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:52:804 (112804|2) - made into a slider to cover the sound of a wave of hat?

permalink

Fixed.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:55:804 (115804|2,115915|1,116026|3,116138|2) - change these into minijack to complement with the piano sound. Probably something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10999926

permalink

Quite weak pianos at last so I think it's unnecessary to add more pressure by creating jacks.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin

01:56:582 - you follow the piano, add one note at 01:56:582 - in col 1 the sound of the piano still sounded rather audible and not too small to ignore

permalink

The others are echoes merely.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Shima Rin
/