mapped by [ TNTlealu ]
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 5 December 2021!
nominated by Garden and Okoayu
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:21:837 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - gradually lowering the spacing instead for guitar pitch?

permalink

00:24:475 (1,2,3) - 你這3顆 做成小間距的一直線 音低沉了很多了 不要放辣麼大的間距

permalink

okok

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:25:958 (1,2,3,4) - 這邊改成 1/2滑條 單點 單點 1/2滑條 00:26:947 (5,6,1) - 這邊要是3連打 這節奏選擇比較好

permalink

用你的建議去放放看了 還是覺得00:25:958 (1,2,3) - 鼓聲+滑條的吉他會比較適合這裡

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:40:134 - 這邊有人聲但你卻停頓 建議加顆note 會比較好

permalink

加加

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:43:513 (2,3) - 3連打? unsanp?

permalink

喔 我看到你後面都在跟鼓聲 但這樣還是很奇怪 打起來不順手 還是3連打會比較好

permalink

紅線上的吉他聲太不明顯了 這裡的回饋感應該沒有那麼強烈 所以還是keep

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:44:090 (5) - 像你這個 長白線沒聲音聲音(鼓聲) 就選擇直接做一個1/1滑條拉過去 我知道你想要fit vocal 但你都是跟鼓聲 突然跟vocal 不太行 你整首有這問題的 要全部做修正

permalink

00:46:728 (6,7) - 像這種地方 如果你放1/1滑條 你滑條尾會有鼓聲 這樣就不能放1/1滑條 怎麼解決 很簡單 不要放滑條 就00:46:728 (6) - 單點跟00:47:057 (7) - 單點
把長白線空下來 NC選在前 在後 我覺得沒什麼差 你自行選擇

permalink

目前這樣跟吉他是可以的,順便對上了vocal而已,這樣說整首有問題其實蠻言重的

permalink

謝了lululu

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:52:827 (6,7) - these are 1/3

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:55:299 - 我覺得這裡可以加一個note~
因為有人聲和大鼓聲,而且你前面 00:53:980 (3,4) - 00:54:639 (2,3) - 都有加

permalink

+ㄌ

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:57:936 (8) - just too underwhelming and not a straightforward rhythm cuz nobody expects this in a top diff, just do a stream normally or triple + circle instead

permalink
permalink

00:57:936 (8) -> triple + circle
02:14:585 (1) -> stream

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:58:082 - 想說你這邊都clickable 那02:14:566 (5) - 呢

permalink

改了

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:58:101 - to 00:58:431 - is 1/3, having 1/2 mapped over it do be kinda weird

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

00:58:761 (2) - 到01:01:233 (1) - 插一個break

permalink

break

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:01:068 - 要不要從這裡當開始

permalink

可以 下禮拜改 這張圖被拿去當賽圖暫時不能改

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:04:035 - 01:06:013 -> Make new combo for all jumps.

permalink

good idea

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

免NC

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:06:673 (1,2) - 分開點嗎
就像我上次說的那樣

permalink

1往左一點了

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

第三段副歌一樣地方也改了

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:16:873 (1) - 不3/4嗎

permalink

副歌同樣的部分都用把滑條速率調低代替3/4 因為我不喜歡3/4滑條

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

我覺得這裡放變速滑條不優,因為音樂聽起來沒有拖沓或其他明顯的改變而需要用改變速度來強調。
認為這裡節奏可以改成和後面02:33:376 (5,6,7) - 類似就可以了~

permalink
Reopened by YamYA

或是變速後加一下NC? 01:17:222 (2) - 04:00:739 (2) -

permalink

我還是+nc好了 02:33:376 (5,6,7) -放慢聽其實跟前後一段的部分不太一樣所以才會用別的方法去做

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:23:486 (6,1) - 放遠一點 不要拉那麼近

permalink

跟第二段副歌一樣了

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:26:618 - could make thsi less sharp to be a bit more forgiving (angle of stream stuff)

permalink

a bit more forgiving

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:27:112 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 你這裡跟vocal就好 不要多放3連打 聲音逐漸下降 但間距還有一定的距離 不優 你改成類似這樣 https://i.imgur.com/Q0rQi8l.png 能比較好體現出來連打跟小間距之間的舒張力度 剛好也可以符合音樂情境

permalink

這裡的三連打用來build後面的大跳 聲音逐漸下降的情況我會選擇把01:27:112 (1,2,3,4,5) - 的間距逐漸縮小 也能做到一樣的效果

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:28:101 (1,2) - 02:44:586 (1,2) - just some playability concern on my end, I don't think it's that comfortable to start massive 1/2 jump right after a 1/1 pause, a smoother buildup would be nicer imo

permalink

01:27:771 (6) - 02:44:255 (6) - change to 1/2 slider

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:31:233 (4,2) - 看你要不要疊

permalink

沒有 這樣3跟4會太近

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:32:717 (1,2,3) - 這效果不錯

permalink

01:34:035 (1,2) - looks a bit meh cuz its just something between a tricky stack and a properly done overlap pattern, and sadly looks like neither of them, could change a bit the direction of 1 for slightly better visual clarity -> https://puu.sh/HO7Jh/7b6bbc0cdc.png

permalink

ok. changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:36:983 (1) - 這聲音好重 要不要BUFF一下ds

permalink

buff

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:37:002 (1) - could just place it further to have 01:36:838 (7,1) - spacing differentiated from 01:36:508 (4,5,6,7) -

permalink
permalink

yes

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:37:662 (3,4) - uh now that you changed rhythm of this I suppose you should have it differentiated from 01:37:991 (4,1) - with some pattern adjustments. current pattern worked as an interesting transition for the older rhythm but for current one it just looks like a misplaced pattern to me :(

permalink

其實我忘記我原本是放什麼樣子了,如果原本的不錯應該也可以改回去

permalink

https://puu.sh/HOfsl/12906a8632.png 原本是这样的节奏,两个1/4gap都拉得很开,我觉得这样改也会有人说所以其实可能基于现在的节奏改改梗会比较合理

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

覺得那兩個點的回饋感太重了 不適合這邊沒有樂器只有聲音的情形 所以還是保留滑條

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:51:901 - 沒有聲音啊 反而應該在01:52:066 -

permalink

01:51:901 有吉他聲

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

我耳背lol

permalink

01:52:167 (5,6) - ??? 你紅線鼓聲不跟?

permalink

跟 我耳包

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:52:250 (4) - more fitting to have 01:52:085 - as triple rhythm instead (similar to 01:53:403 (3) - ), guitar melody isn't the main instrument but rather a supporting role

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

01:52:662 (6,1) - ctrl-g rhythm? 01:52:991 - sounds more notable than 01:52:826 -

permalink

sounds good. changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu
permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:01:398 - this is a major pain to actually read, would consider making this easier to comprehend by using 1/2 sliders to map the 3/4 rhythm

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:05:354 (5) - . similar to #2408328 I think it's kinda dumb using 1/2 reverse in an extra unless it really fits ._.

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:06:508 - cool pattern i just don't get why this isn't being used in the kiai, it seems so random in that part because you don't really do that 1/4 slider business there

permalink

I think its cool and fit the vocal here, and I also change 02:08:980 - to kick slider make here not so random. kiai seems no good place can put this pattern so I dont do it :(

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:06:673 (1,2,3,4) - 這個pattern是很好看,但我覺得音樂強度不夠支持這邊放三滑條,
節奏用單點應該就可以了~ https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/16478842/ea7d
同樣擺成三角形應該也很好玩~

permalink

效果很好 但彼此之間間距太大 縮小0.8左右吧

permalink

知識這裡的意思是保留原本的東西縮小0.8還是變成一般的三角形縮小0.8?

permalink

整體縮小0.8倍 但滑條長度不變

permalink

0.9好了

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:12:607 (6,7) - thats some random massive 1/2 spacing on nothing in a calm section, rly pops out of nowhere

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

NC

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:17:552 (1) - 你break有動到 at 02:16:975 (1) -

permalink

是要拉到02:16:975嗎 還是要取消掉 我看這裡是沒有拉到的

permalink

取消即可

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:22:497 - 1/4 slider this ? your hitsounding suggests that 02:22:579 - should be a slider end

permalink

yea, make 1/4 slider here

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:36:838 (2,3,4) - minor one but could move the triple -> by some pixels, just some visual spacing concern

permalink

agree

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:41:124 (6) - visually, 6 looks off from this stream is this really a straight line ?

permalink

its straight line now

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:41:536 (11,1) - think you should change flow at 1 instead for consistency with like most of your other streams 02:43:019 (6,1) - 01:11:865 (4,1) - etc.

permalink

02:49:201 (1) - 1/4 gap into 02:49:530 (2) - at current spacing is just a huge miss which breaks the flow of movement badly, you can keep current shape and movement but make 02:49:201 (1) - 1.5x and a 1/2 slider instead

permalink

02:49:201 (1) - 1.5x 1/2 slider

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

02:58:760 - i dont see any instrumental or song reason as to why you should increase spacing this much here

permalink

nerfed it

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:00:060 - 串要不要從反過來從dc小的stack逐漸增加ds,因為pitch變高

permalink

最後一段變小是想凸顯後面接的大跳 不過這可以考慮一下 先解決

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:13:431 (2) - 做5連打就好了拉 不用特意去跟吉他的效果

permalink
permalink

還是覺得五連打沒有很fit這邊的節奏 先保留使用來回滑條

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:17:552 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - yea this is the reason i will never nominate the other ghost set, but at least it was consistently introduced in that map while ur doing it only 3 minutes into the song which sucks in terms of player expectation

permalink

normal stream now

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:21:654 - add note?

permalink

平緩的地方我想從人聲起

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

滿不錯的 改了

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:25:775 (4,5,6) - maybe全NC?

permalink

可以耶

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:25:794 (1,1,1) - 滑條尾都沒對到音 建議開1/12去聽

permalink
permalink

感謝 當時沒有仔細聽

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:27:607 (5,1) - ctrl-g rhythm? snare and the long vocal both started on redtick

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:28:906 - triple嗎

permalink

這段我盡量不去跟樂器 因為我覺得這裡很慢 回饋感沒有到那麼重

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:31:728 - this is super simplified, cant you make this more active like meg & aerous did ?

current rhythm for the 3/4 vocals is pretty lame

permalink

changed 03:33:046 (1,2,3) - but 03:31:728 (3) - keep

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

03:36:343 (2,3,4,5) - 間距拉小拉

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

added

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

04:14:750 (4,5,1) - that movement is super weird and just looks like you ran out of space ? ? ?

you know, flow wise 4->5->1 is pretty shit, like even https://i.imgur.com/kqGU22M.jpeg is better i dont know uddudududfudfdufsfdkalsdfh

permalink

its shit I follow your suggestion to fixed it

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu
permalink

有試過 但不太好看也沒有我想要的效果 就改回來了

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

04:19:859 (2,3,4) - triple is at 04:20:107 -

permalink

yes its problem for me
fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

04:21:178 (2,3) - similar to #2408341 but you could even do more here cuz now you have 04:21:343 - drums to map, using same rhythm for consistency does not make enough sense

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

04:30:720 - 1/4 reverse如何, 一方面給後面3/4緩衝, 另一方面04:30:802 - 感覺還比04:30:720 (4) - 明顯

permalink

認同 改了

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu

04:32:717 (1) - 1/8滑條 來回一次

permalink

來回一次

permalink
Marked as resolved by TNTlealu
/