00:17:113 (17113|3) - inconsistent with 00:14:664 -
also top diff doesnt have a note there so maybe delete
00:41:297 - imo with the amount of varied movement the right hand gets, the left hand could use some more "motion" kinda hard to put it to words but https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/16954988/0b3f
instead of anchoring the loud echo clap i think a motion like this could make for an interesting emphasis
Hmm, I've wanted it to be symmetrical with the right hand so that it makes it much easier to read and play, but I think I sort of understand what you mean. Having the notes be put on col2 and 4 makes the notes feel like they represent the synth in the accompaniment better so I've applied your suggestion. But yeah, just wanted to say why I made it symmetrical in the first place. I think your suggestion is good and wouldn't make it toooo much harder.
00:55:589 (55589|7,55742|4,55895|7,56048|2) - I'm not completely sure on the layering choice; 00:54:518 (54518|6,54824|8) - suggest vocals, but these suggest something other than vocals - I can hear the kick drum but maybe consider sticking to one of the two? and in case you do keep the kick, you missed it at 00:58:957 - and 00:56:508 - and 01:00:487 - and 01:01:406 - which I'd say are from the same section where the new phrase begins at 01:02:477 -
The reason why not every single sound there it's supposedly representing is added is to make it a little easier. I made it so that 1/4 patterns on a single hand are avoided. Notes are added at points that make the pattern/sound representation easier to digest. If players are looking for full representation, then they should play the hardest difficulty!
01:31:865 (91865|8) - sounds like this to me, can you corroborate? https://lunar.s-ul.eu/dYJ78Z36 same here 01:36:763 (96763|7,96967|6,97171|5,97375|7,97579|6,97783|5,97987|7,98191|6,98395|5) - and here 01:34:314 (94314|9,94518|7,94722|5,94926|9,95130|7,95334|5,95538|9,95742|7,95946|5) - same here
If you put it at 25% - you can hear that the vocals are more on point with the 1/3 snap than 1/4
I tried changing (in the Autum diff) to 1/3 for that part. I'd say personally it's smoother and easier to play, but might just be me.
Anyhow, I think this really should be 1/3 and not 1/4.
Tho idk how you would go about representing the drums (particular 01:32:878 and the likes are in 1/4 but the vocals are in 1/3) - maybe some notes on left hand for them (in Autumn), or just omitting them might be viable?
Tho idk how you would go about representing the drums (particular 01:32:878 and the likes are in 1/4 but the vocals are in 1/3) - maybe some notes on left hand for them (in Autumn), or just omitting them might be viable?
Well previously when it was on 1/3 snapping, having each hand represent each voice made the left hand able to play 1/2, 1/4 (percussion) while right hand played 1/3s (vocals), which felt pretty reasonable to me. So representing the drums and whatnot won't be an issue.
Anyway, I'm pretty unsure about this now and will leave it open. I'll see what the BNs have to say about it. I'm leaning toward 1/3 since that's what it was initially, but I want play it safe. Thanks though, Ping!