mapped by Voxa
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 22 October 2023!
nominated by Syadow- and DenYi
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:01:104 (1104|0,1104|3) - and 00:01:810 (1810|3,1810|0) - as well as 00:06:045 (6045|0,6045|3) - and 00:06:751 (6751|3,6751|0) - : I don't think you should repeat these doubles unless they're repeated in a pattern. Example: 00:01:104 - and 00:01:810 - the two doubles here are repeated but the doubles at 00:03:222 - and 00:03:928 - aren't even though they would line up with each other if you wanted to repeat doubles here.

and the doubles at 00:06:045 - and 00:06:751 - are repeated...but not at the earlier spots of 00:00:398 - and 00:01:104 -

All in all I think it's best not to repeat doubles unless you do it at consistent intervals. Otherwise it makes things feel inconsistent.

permalink

Opps, My mistake, rearranged.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:05:340 - missing double? (kalo bisa col 1)

permalink

00:16:634 - missing double? (col 4 biar konsisten kalo atas diapply)

permalink

No. I focus on high pitched sound there. And no drum there

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:09:928 (9928|2) - Ghost note, there is a sound here but it starts earlier than this spot, instead I think you should map out the sound at 00:09:751 - since you mapped out those sounds before

permalink

lol.. fixed!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:10:814 - sabi di add ini

permalink

00:33:402 - iki wes mbok edd betewe

permalink

Oiyo sip, probelm ndak konsisten, pikzed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:16:987 - Idea for this part, I think it makes for a really pretty pattern! :D
00:17:163 - to 00:19:281 - : https://puu.sh/BHWB3/357b087138.jpg
00:19:457 - to 00:21:222 - : https://puu.sh/BHWCS/ac1d79d30e.jpg

permalink

Okay accepted!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:21:222 (21222|0) - delete, hard aja cuma 1, masa normal 2?

permalink

Ummm. gini, jadi aku gak bisa mastiin. Soalnya hard itu GD nya dudehacker. Jadi beda mapstyle.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:21:928 (21928|0,21928|1) - and 00:22:281 (22281|3,22281|2) - shouldn't be a double imo since 00:22:457 (22457|1) - is a single and they all represent toms. Plus I don't think they deserve as much emphasis as the crash at 00:22:634 (22634|2,22634|0) -

permalink

Okay! Accepted!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:23:693 - to 00:31:810 - So there isn't much to go off of in the music but I think it would be a good idea to use different patterns instead of repeating the same 4 note pattern, I think it would spice up the section a bit

permalink

Rearranged!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:29:693 move the note here to 1st column so that it would be https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/12023568 (the sound kinda goes in 3/4 time signature, so it is better to represent the sound as 1-2-3-1-2-3-1-2-3...

Then, rearranging the parts after this as follow for balance https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/12023583 , https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/12023596

permalink

Okay resolved !

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:30:402 (30402|1,30755|2,31108|1,31461|2,31814|1,32167|2,32520|1) -
Dunno why you make it long stack, I think those notes have different pitch. Suggest rearrange it by
-> 00:31:108 (31108|1) - move to col 1 (1/2/3/4)
-> 00:31:461 (31461|2) - move to col 4

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

to maintain consistency , 00:32:869 (32869|1,32869|0) - should be single like this one 00:10:104 (10104|0,10193|1,10281|2) - also 00:33:045 (33045|3) - should be double like this one 00:10:457 (10457|0,10457|1) -

permalink
permalink

Thanks to point it out. But i'm prefer change this 00:10:281 - to double than change the entire similar pattern instead.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa
permalink

Okay nice idea. But i have my own arrangement there. But thanks for point it out

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

Fixed on previous mod

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:40:457 (40457|3) - , 00:41:516 (41516|3) -, and 00:41:516 (41516|3) - I recommend deleting these hihats since not all hihats are mapped out in this section. It'll make the drums and claps stand out more too

permalink

00:43:281 (43281|2) - and 00:45:045 (45045|3) - : applies to these too if you accept

permalink

On that note I kinda recommend deleting 00:45:134 (45134|2) - too since you didn't map out these drums in the following section

permalink

Disagree with this. I keep the pattern because they seems fit enough. And hit hat sound make the pattern variated.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:45:922 (45922|2,46275|2,46628|2) - don't think it's a good idea to have three stacks in a row here, consistently.

00:45:216 ~ 00:50:510 - / 02:04:275 ~ 02:09:569 - when looked at the entirety of the same part, the stacks for the drum and clap sounds were showing stacks of one.

00:45:922 (45922|2,46275|2,46628|2) - so the stack count for this note is inconsistent, and may require some pattern adjustment.

permalink

addjusted!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:55:457 for consistency, clap sound here should be played

permalink

No. that will increasing star rate. And that 1/4 note is enough for it. That simplification

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:55:987 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/12023525 like this so that the clap on 00:56:163 can be played

permalink

Similar like previous mod. I keep the star rate under 2.5

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

00:59:167 - single kyk e cukup sih, bukan yg climax bgt yg kudu di padetin

permalink

panggah oke

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

01:02:163 (62163|0,62163|1) - Shouldn't be a double since it's a much weaker sound than the drum at 01:01:810 (61810|3,61810|2) -

permalink

01:13:457 (73457|1,73457|3) - Same for this as well. Goes for all similar parts in both kiais

permalink

Ok accepted!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

Why? it emphasize sound there

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

01:13:461 (73461|1) -
Better emphasize the vocal in another hand like you did in 01:01:814 (61814|2,62167|1). So, suggest move that LN to col 4 (1/2/3/4) and move this note 01:13:814 (73814|3) to col 2

permalink

Also
02:32:520 (152520|1) -
03:00:755 (180755|1) - not for vocal but still have same sound

permalink

Its currently not follow vocal, its following the trumpet sound, so I think there is no issue

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

01:21:575 (81575|2,81928|1) - knp pada beda sendiri, padahal suara sama?

permalink

Jadi gini. Double nya buat mempresentasikan suara hight pitch yg gradually naik. Tapi ku pertimbangkan ini. Masi ragu juga soalnya

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

01:24:398 remove the note on 2nd column for consistency with how you map 01:21:575 and 01:21:928

permalink

So here the reason why i double it. Because i emphasize to follow pitch sound there like gradually up. Sorry

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

01:26:163 - suggestion that gets rid of the big anchor on 1:
Part 1: https://puu.sh/BLJxp/30067f8003.jpg
Part 2: https://puu.sh/BLJzt/bdae0eb0ff.jpg

permalink

you could do something similar here: 02:45:222 -

permalink

Fixed!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

01:30:398 - this section should be a little more pitch relevant. When the synth these LNs represent have pitches that are going down, put them to the left of the LN that came before it, otherwise put them to the right.

permalink

Nice idea! accepted!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

01:48:222 (108222|1) - move to 3 for hand balance

permalink

Great! accepted!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

01:50:516 - a star is a pattern that is very noticeable visually, I don't think you should use it here if you didn't represent these sounds with stairs elsewhere

permalink

Opps! Fixed!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

01:59:340 (119340|1,119693|1,120045|1) - try not to use a 3 note stack here, it visually looks strange if you don't use it elsewhere, applies to similar spots unless you're using 3 note stacks for a musical reason

permalink

Fixed! Applying on similar pattern

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

02:09:575 (129575|0) - move to 4 for hand balance

permalink

I prefer to change previous note here 02:09:222 - Anyway, thanks for remind me

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

Ok accepted!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

02:14:516 add a note on 4th column and then remove 02:14:693 (134693|3) - would be much more correct based on consistency and pattern

permalink

Well, i prefer make it same like 00:55:457 - . But thanks point it out ^^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

02:25:369 (145369|2) - 'tis a ghost note

permalink

Ahh... okay well. Delete it T^T

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

02:26:516 - tambah col 4

permalink

Resolved by previous reply. Fokus di sound pitch nya

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

02:27:575 (147575|2) - move this to 2nd column to prevent 02:27:222 (147222|2,147575|2,147928|2) -

permalink

Okay accepted!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

Resolved by previous reply. I'm emphasize that sound there

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

02:49:457 an LN is needed for the trumpet thingy. I suggest you rearrange the patterns so you can put it. (actually, changing 4th column note to LN then end it at 02:49:810 is also not a bad idea)

permalink

I liked the idea. But..... yeah I should rearranged all over my diff if i change this. But anyway. I keep this idea in my mind

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

02:49:461 -
Yo, missed a double since you use double here 01:30:402

permalink

That part has different layering where I only treat the double for half of 4/4. No changes

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

02:51:575 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/12023671 too much stuffy going on in the left side. Try rearrange some of them to the right side.

permalink

Okay. Balanced!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

following this section you are representing
02:55:457 - should be double and 02:55:810 - 02:56:163 - single

permalink

Thanks for point it out, Rearrangged

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa

03:06:751 (186751|3) - definitely move to 2 for hand balance

permalink

prefer to arranged other pattern above it. But thanks for remind me!

permalink
Marked as resolved by Voxa
/