mapped by Lung_P
submitted
qualified
This map is estimated to be ranked on 31 March 2025 if no issues are found. It is #17 in the ranking queue.
Hype Train14 / 5
Nomination Status2 / 2
nominated by Maxus and AWMRone
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:03:781 (3781|6) - release timing pretty weird, shorten to just red line at 00:03:931 - works imo

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

00:04:006 - should be 1/8

permalink

fixed

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

00:08:206 - until 00:09:181 - i think these parts make it slightly confusing on which part you emphasize with normal notes and which part you are trying to do with triple long note, because it feels rather inconsistent here.

my recommendation is to consistently use normal note everytime there is distinct loud normal kick, to differentiate it with other sound, which makes your layering more consistent.

something like this will be preferable for layering consistency:

permalink

adjusted

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

00:18:706 (18706|3) - here is good so I think 00:18:406 - also should be seperated

permalink
permalink
permalink
permalink
permalink
permalink

all fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

00:45:331 (45331|3) - think you can just make it col 5 to make consistent shield as the structure you build at 00:45:031 (45031|6,45181|5,45181|6,45331|5,45481|3,45631|3) -

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

00:47:206 (47206|2) - personally i think you can just turn this LN into normal note instead for several reason:

  1. given the loud clap emphasis here, it feels weird to just have 3 direct 1/2 long notes
  2. given the other 2 other clap use rice note, this one deserved one too imo
  3. the pattern structure after this part seems to also have much more breathing space room as well, so it makes sense for this one to also be the same.
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

fixed to 4 note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

01:04:531 (64531|6) - move this to col 1? the notes condensed at col 6 and col 7 felt out of place imo

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

01:04:981 (64981|4,65131|4,65281|4,65731|4,65881|4,66031|4) - this part seems oddly have a bit more stacked than others

i think can move 01:04:981 (64981|4) - to col 6 instead, how about it?

permalink

No problem, can move

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

01:21:931 - I guess i felt awkward you sort of ignored this vocal, given you try map something like 01:24:331 (84331|3) - which have far less prominent sound.

Even if you do it intentionally but given the vocal is pretty distinct, it feels missing for me. plus you map the vocal at 02:29:131 -

permalink

I've rearranged the format, I'll have to check it again.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

01:28:231 - 01:29:431 - generally i know you intentionally try ignore this sound but given they are same sound as 01:27:031 (87031|1,87031|4) - , it ended up struck me as awkward and inconsistent instead.

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

01:33:631 (93631|3) - think you can change one of the note to LN to maintain the consistency with previous double 1/4 LN such as 01:32:881 (92881|2,92881|1,93181|1,93181|6) -

permalink

changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

01:45:331 - This roll seems not fit the music well . I mean the drum are here 01:45:331 - 01:45:406 - so do sth like this ?

permalink
permalink
permalink

fix slightly different from the original

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

01:50:731 - and 01:51:931 - are longest vocal so how about do sth LN stair tails here ? its all up to you and OK if keep

permalink

Keep it :3

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

02:06:481 (126481|3) - 02:11:281 (131281|3) - i think both of these can be changed to normal note, emphasizing the crash , doesn't disturb your structure and give better pattern contrast as well there.

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

02:13:681 (133681|6,133718|5,133831|2,133868|1) - i think you can just go ham with full 1/8 LN here given that there is no clear differentiation of what you try to differentiate with 02:13:981 - , and i think sync better with current pattern idea.

permalink

owo

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

02:14:881 - 02:15:481 - These two seems clear drum , so how about delete the grace

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

02:45:818 - How about make an echo for 02:45:181 (165181|4,165218|5,165256|6) - ?

permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

02:58:606 - love love love

permalink

♥♥♥

permalink

02:58:831 - 03:00:031 - The heart pattern is cool but I think its unreasonable to set a grace here . hou about this

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

I suddenly find space LN can be longer

permalink
permalink

Better than old ver but I think redline should not be a grace

permalink

03:12:031 - Main lead needed ?

permalink

I think leaving it like that would make the timing look much better

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

OK

permalink

03:42:481 (222481|0,222481|2,222556|4,222556|6,222631|0,222631|2,222706|6,222706|4) - i think this doesn't fit to be trill sound given 03:42:481 - have its own distinct sound and i think this one should be triple instead.

do something like this will be more fitting imo

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

03:48:143 - seems gap is too short and make a jack on col 1 ? not a big problem for playability but how about change some

for reference only

permalink
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

03:50:206 (230206|1,230206|0,230281|2,230318|1,230356|0) - Seems the only jacky this song ? also 03:50:206 - chord size too big ?

permalink

Re-pattern this part and make some minor changes

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P

04:21:931 - it feel like jack yeah but I think current ver is very easy to miss (end part miss is soooooo )
how about this

permalink

fixed xD

permalink
Marked as resolved by Lung_P
/