Guest
home
beatmaps
rankings
community
store
help
beatmap discussion
discussion

Identity (TV Size)

Sakai Mikio

2.35
AlexDemon's Salad
0.00
Leomine's HSS guest difficulty by Leomine
1
1.51
Kegare's Cup guest difficulty by Kegare-
2.35
AlexDemon's Salad guest difficulty by AlexDemon-
2
3.19
Rew's Platter guest difficulty by rew0825
4.14
Sadu's Rain guest difficulty by Sadu
5.30
Overdose
5.33
GIGACHAD's Overdose guest difficulty by GIGACHAD
5.80
Verti's Overdose guest difficulty by Verti
6.60
Dizzy and Rew's Challenge guest difficulty by rew0825
Filter by user
Everyone
Baron
DizzyOracel
Eunie
GIGACHAD
MILK_16
rew0825
Sadu
Sypervenya
Tachibana Gekka
Mine
0
Notes
0
Resolved
8
Pending
2
Praises
6
All
16
Guest difficulty by AlexDemon-
1:27
248
72
144
mapped by DizzyOracel
submitted
last updated
Beatmap Page
Hype Train5 / 5
Nomination Status0 / 2
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Timestamp
ctrl-c in edit mode and paste in your message to add a timestamp!
PraiseSuggestionProblem
Discussions
Sort by
Eunie

00:31:446 (2,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Sure you want to keep this spacing? Currently everything is set as a walk which doesn't give much emphasis to the cymbals on every beat. You can consider making 00:31:446 (2,1) a dash as a solution.

Last edited by Eunie .
permalink
AlexDemon-

kept 00:31:204 (1,2) - as a dash for the vocal emphasis and put a dash here 00:31:446 (2,1) -

permalink
Marked as resolved by AlexDemon-
Eunie

00:36:769 (3) - Consider reworking this patterning? The down beat on 00:37:011 is currently not emphasized as it is at the end of the reverse slider and the loud cymbal makes it very noticeable. You add a dash on the loud cymbals in the rest of the section, however, you decide not add a dash here. Ex:
00:38:462 (2,1) -
00:40:156 (2,1) -

I would follow this structure here as well.

Last edited by Eunie .
permalink
AlexDemon-

In this song I have put the main emphasis on vocals, so
here 00:38:462 (2,1) - its vocal + cymbal,
00:38:462 (2,1) - same (voice starts a some seconds behind but its almost the same in salad)
and here 00:36:769 (3) - I got 3 important vocal sounds so I decided to make it a reverse slider, I think it should be fine but I want to take other opinions

permalink
DizzyOracel

I agree with Eunie here mainly because of 00:40:156 (2,1) , not emphasizing 00:37:011 with a dash feels pretty underwhelming

permalink
GIGACHAD

disagree cuz vocals arent that strong on that timestamp compared to alrdy mentioned timestamps

instead maybe nerf 00:40:156 (2,1) - to a walk for structure reasons given u follow music phrases with ur dashes (eg, the music is in 2 downbeats, high at 00:35:075 - and low at 00:37:011 - repeated, so it makes sense to somewhat keep that but change the other)

permalink
DizzyOracel

i would still implement it for consistent dash usage and because of 00:40:156 (2,1) having simmilar intensity imo. leaving out both downbeats would mean that both relatively strong vocal and cymbol would be underemphasized especially with a sliderend for the 1st one.

If not applied i think you should still make contrast between 00:36:769 00:36:890 and 00:37:011 by doing something like this:

permalink
Eunie

00:47:777 (1,2) - Sure you want to keep this? The cymbals on 00:48:140 (2) - are the loudest sounds in this section but they are currently emphasized as a walk. Consider making 00:47:777 (1,2) - a dash for the loud cymbals.

permalink
AlexDemon-

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by AlexDemon-
Eunie

01:27:212 (1) - Sure you want to follow this patterning? There is a cymbal on 01:27:333 that isn't emphasized right now. You can provide emphasis to this sound by deleting 01:27:212 (1) - and adding a note on 01:27:333. You will then be able to dash from 01:26:970 (3,1) - for the loud cymbal.

permalink
AlexDemon-

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by AlexDemon-
/