mapped by YMP
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 19 October 2023 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:17:518 (4,1) - For visual purposes this overlap on top of the slider looks visually off so you might want to change that

permalink

It's a small visual cue, I don't see a problem here

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:18:852 (6,7,1) - This overlap is also kinda visually hard to see, the way the slider overlaps the circle looks weird to the player and should be considered to change

permalink

unstacked it

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:19:417 (2) has an awkward overlap with the sliders at 00:20:145 (1,2) - visually hard to follow may consider changing

permalink

I changed it to similar pattern before. It was scuffed

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

wrong timestamp, though i just moved it a little to make it cleaner, not noticeable in gameplay

permalink

00:24:461 (3,4) - 00:30:279 (7,8) not having these as long sliders when everything else is feels off

permalink

It's a variation because of the sounds there

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:29:508 (3) - might wanna move this up a bit to make the square cleaner

permalink

Will look at it, I think these patterns are not all equal in spacing anyway

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

Actually this one is the odd one out of them. I changed all of the later ones into this rhombus shape

permalink

00:30:054 (6) - might wanna make a big jump here like you did on 00:31:508 (4) - and 00:25:690 (4) - , a ctrl+g should be fine imo

permalink

Agree

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:34:281 (5) - this slider is only a 1/4th slider

permalink

Sounds are wonky here

permalink

1/6 because it is wobbly around here

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:35:054 Kiai section could start here instead due to the instrument getting added here

permalink

There is a kickdrum I wanted to highlight before the next part

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

Could you point out which kickdrum you mean, since to me, it feels like the song pretty much remains the same from 00:23:417 to 00:35:054

permalink
Reopened by Joyy

00:34:417 (6) - if you mean this then highlighthing it with kiai wouldn't really be consistant with the rest of the section beforehand

permalink

Kiai can be used for anything you want to highlight. So I highlight the jump part just before the next part

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

while yes what you choose to highlight with kiai is subjective, the way the kiai is currently set is inconsistant with the intensity consider that the whole section beforehand is a repetition of notes that are the same as part you've chosen to highlight, if say 00:23:417 to 00:35:054 was all kiai the highlight would be consistant

permalink
Reopened by Joyy

If you watch how the section looks in autoplay, it works exactly how I want it to (with the stars flashing at that part). That is all I wanted to do.

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:45:007 (2,3,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,3) - i think you underestimate how difficult this is to play, maybe nerf this

permalink

It is aim control. I think it's reasonable. The star rating and speed/aim only spikes slightly compared to the stuff before

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:45:190 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - spacing is huge and I dont think the music really supports it.

permalink

I guess I can see people not expecting to get aim control tested after the stream section. I will think about something more flow aimey maybe

permalink

i think the doubles are fine but they feel really jarring due to the sliders prior being tilted then just a regular square where they are. i think aiming the 1's towards the middle would make it look more appealing as well as lowering the spacing on them

permalink

This was changed, but I could look into changing the angle

permalink

00:46:281 (1) - having this be a slider instead of circles is kinda weird considering there isnt a change warrenting a slider here.

permalink

00:43:372 (4) - Same slider before the downbeat, it's just a kind of finisher

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:46:326 kiai here could be extended until 00:46:690 (1) since the intensity here remains the same

permalink

yes

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:46:643 (1) - make a slider here like you did at 00:49:552 -

permalink

Just let the player vibe for a moment, give it some closure for the section

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

00:58:326 (1)- move this slider so that the head isn't under the last slider

permalink

no problem. it's a different kind of emphasis

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

01:21:963 (5,6) - the change in stream spacing is cool but I don't think this part of the song calls for it

permalink

It's a stream in 2 parts, I think it's fine

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

01:22:281 feels weird not have a circle here, or at least a slider on 8 so that every part of the piano is accounted for

permalink

Preference, I just want a stop here and have only circles

permalink

No biggie

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

01:34:281 (5) - theres no reason that you should ignore the piano considering its the main instrument here

permalink

01:34:554 (6) - This important note is mapped. Not mapping every sound is fine and the sliderend is on the less important sound

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

01:35:281 (1,2,3,4) - this is so unreadable, plase at least move 01:35:281 (1,2,3) - a bit so its not perfectly overlapping with the tail/red anchor of 01:35:554 (4) -

permalink

I think there was stuff before that was similar, I see no issue really if it was hinted at

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

01:48:508 (1,2,3,4) - i feel like you should ctrl+g 01:48:690 (3,4) - , since the current pattern breaks the pseudo-circular flow created by 01:48:235 (2,3,4,1) -, which makes the pattern feels unnecessarily hard even for the map's difficulty

permalink

I changed it to work similar to 01:45:235 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) -

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

01:51:009 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - this pattern is nice but its pretty hard to read, which usually wouldn't be too big of a deal with a repeating pattern, however, the change in flow at 01:51:736 (1,2,3,4) - is very hard to read considering it overlaps with the rest of the pattern. I understand the musical reason behind the change in flow, however, I dont think it is justified enough given the unreadableness of the pattern. it could work if you made it a bit more readable or something

permalink

This one is definitely cutthroat. Probably will alter this one somehow because I changed it various times and was not really satisfied

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

Really think this particular arrangement is just weird to read. Probably can rotate it to make more sense

permalink

01:53:554 (1) - 01:56:372 (4) - i think something more than just a cutstream would be appreciated because the rest of the map doesnt have anything like this. the last 4 is a nice change but it doesnt make sense to have it like that if the rest of it is just lines.

permalink

It is just more aim control, spacing inflates and deflates real fast. For the last 4 it sounds different to the rest also because of sounds like 01:56:372 - I decided this angular stuff would fit the music change

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

Also mapped to the video and I made sure that it makes musical sense

permalink

01:53:645 why ignore the snare here? the spacing makes me think unintentional tho

permalink

I know the spacing is low but I just want a rhythm stop before the last killer pattern. On this difficulty no player will misread I think it's not an issue.

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

01:50:645 (1) - 1/2 gap is expected

permalink

01:54:554 (4,1) - way too big. same 01:54:918 (4,1) - here but not quite as big

permalink

Yes it spikes here but it's the climax and I think it is not that unreasonable

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

01:56:508 (1) - this slider has this really odd curve here

removing the grey anchor under this one

make it looks cleaner imo

permalink

used to sliderticks to adjust

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP

Actually gonna sliderart for real

permalink
Reopened by YMP

a

permalink
Marked as resolved by YMP
/