mapped by Stelar
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 19 November 2022!
nominated by Asherz007 and Syadow-
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:07:389 (7389|5,7389|6,7469|4,7550|3,7700|0,7700|1,7852|6,7852|5,8017|2,8017|4) -
I don't really think there is any significant difference among these drums, and considering this is Insane I think you can use double for all of them and try to come up with more Insane-ish pattern for 00:07:389 (7389|5,7469|4,7550|3) -

permalink

okii

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:08:673 (8673|4,9135|0) - same for these two: maybe mixing in some anchors would be great. Just saying

permalink

nope I'll keep it
although it have same sounds but it not really work for the anchors pattern , since the volume is not same enough

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:09:760 (9760|5,9840|4,10077|4,10157|5,10398|5,10478|4) - is that intend to focus on right side or there's other reason? i just worry the pattern not much represent the drumroll and left side just 1/4 grace pattern if take just col123 00:09:601 (9601|0,9680|2,9917|0,9997|1,10237|0,10318|2) - . so would suggest to make it more balance can be like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18065897/c29b

permalink

okok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

00:10:813 (10813|4,10981|3) - this is a bit awkward. I think doing both LNs or both rices are fine, but mixing LN and rice is a bit weird. The LN especially.

permalink

nya yeah so I'll change all of it to LN

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:11:399 - missing double for kick. can add to col4 not stack with previous or next notes

permalink

nice

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

00:14:646 (14646|5,14646|0,15291|5,15291|2,15291|6) -
maybe a bit of consistency issue? I think it is totally fine to just allocate three notes for dnb and have an extra LN for vocal.

00:14:324 (14324|2,14485|6,14969|4,15130|1,15130|0) - ^

permalink

nope I'll keep it since the change will break my mapping style

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:18:818 - i think need 1/2 LN for guitar ? cuz other LN like 00:17:044 (17044|5,18012|2,18334|4,18980|4,19302|5,19625|4) - follow guitar which is good to represent all the sound instead simplify them

permalink

cool

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

00:19:485 (19485|4) - 00:20:775 (20775|6) - : missing LN for the guitar layering?

because 00:19:162 (19162|0,19324|1,19808|0,19969|2,20453|2,20614|3) - from this alone i thought this part will be guitar-heavy, its slightly incomplete how this part being mapped at the moment

additionally, 00:18:840 (18840|6) - reduce the ln length by 1/2

permalink

00:18:840 (18840|6) - for vocal keep it
00:19:485 (19485|4) - 00:20:775 (20775|6) - right add it

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:19:808 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/16795111/cecf
Just an idea: try to find a bit more space for rices so that you can use pattern that better represents a drum roll?
btw I can hear piano at 00:20:130 00:20:291 00:18:840 00:19:001 and I think those are pretty clear, but I don't know if you want them or not...

permalink

nope although that way can more emphasize the drum roll , but it will change the thing I wanna focus , vocal is more important then the drum set at this part

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:21:743 (21743|2) - 01:13:356 (73356|4) - i feel like a flair can be added in this silent 1/1 part, there's a 1/4 melodious guitar sound here that can be added, https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17023209/6ba4

permalink

just think it is fine for the bass sounds and vocal , since they are rly obvious to hear . so add it wil be a little tricky for me , sorry will keep this

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:21:743 - 01:13:356 - there's some guitar you can layer along with the vocal, try this : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17023209/6ba4

permalink

same mod as #2585776 ?
if so , same reply at #2585776/7120214

permalink

seems done for it

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:26:399 (26399|2,26399|4,26480|0,26480|1,26560|6,26560|5,26641|0,26641|1) - and 00:27:689 (27689|6,27770|4,27851|2) - i think better make both of them have same amount note, just feel odd when u make them different while they give a same sound and emphasis feedback

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

00:32:689 (32689|1,32851|0) - a bit picky, how about move to col2 and 4 ? cuz beside of too over on left side, for 8 beats, it has only 3 notes on col4 00:31:238 (31238|3,32044|3,33818|3) - so better to spread them a bit so balance on left mid and right column

permalink

cool

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

00:37:044 - 00:37:367 - 00:38:334 - maybe can add note for hat sound here? giving 4 beats just for a LN feel empty imo. subjective issue anyway

permalink

added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

00:42:388 and 00:42:549 - you could map the piano here as well if you wanted although faint

permalink

kinda faint so wanna keep it

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:42:711 (42711|0,42872|1,43033|3,43195|4,43356|5,43517|6,43678|0,43840|1,44001|6) - I think you can arrange some fancy LN patterns on 012 456 while leaving thumb for finished. But again just saying; current pattern works perfectly fine

permalink

wanna keep it , tbh make some fancy LN here is kinda hard to play , just try it b4

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:49:302 (49302|3,49463|5,49625|1) - a bit curious which sound do u want to follow. vocal appear on 00:49:302 (49302|0,49786|3) - and no guitar piano sound imo. better leave it to SN n remove 00:49:463 (49463|5) -

permalink

same case on other 2nd kiai pattern.

permalink

not really hard to understand rokii's intention here and for me current pattern is better than just using SN which are too bland for kiai. this one has more aesthethic visual too

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

00:51:722 - maybe add note for tom? idk the name but it noticeable sound for me

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

00:52:388 (52388|3,52549|5,52711|1,52872|3) - these LN doesn't fit into any previous layering you did (vocal+drum heavy), nor any instrument that's currently playing. consider to simplify the LN to represent sounds & pitches that actually exist

permalink

oke change

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:54:969 from this point I can hear a lot of heavy piano chords (esp like 00:55:614 00:55:775 etc.), not sure if you want to incorporate them as they are really dominant imo

permalink

oki make some change here

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

00:58:818 - 00:59:141 (59141|5,59302|4) - 00:59:463 - making them a LN would be better i guess since all of them have guitar sound which support ur vocal emphasis. and also u did the same guitar structure on 00:57:044 - which need them being LN for consistency

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

01:01:904 - 01:02:227 - 01:02:549 - missing 1/2 LN for guitar?
considering these 1/2 LN 01:00:130 (60130|3,60291|2,60453|5,60614|3,60775|4,60937|5,61098|3,61259|0) - is probably layer the guitar melody, adding those LN will make up for the missing guitar rhythm

permalink

agree , add 01:01:904 - 01:02:227 - 01:02:549 -

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

01:02:528 - add note for ride sound ?

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

01:09:302 - i think need more 1 beat LN for the guitar transition to high pitch, almost same as this structure 01:10:592 (70592|3,70592|0,70915|4,70915|1) -

permalink

why not

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

01:10:372 missing a piano sound here?

permalink

not focus the piano sounds there , only focus drum sounds

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

01:11:098 01:12:388 I suggest adding 1/1 LN at these two places to represent the high pitch piano sounds.

permalink

the current pattern is fine for me , dont think it need some 1/1 LN to do something change , 1/2 LN show all of it is fine

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

01:23:657 - should be a note here, missing LN for vocal

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

01:25:109 - add another LN for "uwwwwuuuuuu" sound asdsadsadsda

permalink

unhappy without without without without u u u u u u, added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

01:27:388 (87388|1) - extend this to 01:27:711 to match the vocal

permalink

the vocal end at 01:27:549 - just have another vocal sounds that end at 01:27:711 -imo

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

01:37:549 and 01:40:130 - are the vocal LNs deliberately left out here (unsure why if they are)

permalink

wanna make the clearly piano pattern here , but seems I should add it .

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

01:41:904 (101904|0) - I think you can make this longer as it is a slightly stronger piano notes, and by doing that can fill the void after that

permalink

oki done

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

01:47:227 (107227|4,107227|6,107227|2) - this just feel way too excessive for a faint sound like that

permalink

it's fine for me since it only have a piano sounds and drum sounds , make some change at drum sounds to highlight it is fine

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

01:47:227 (107227|6,107227|4) - i feel like its rather overkill to have a 3 chord for a single rim sound, quite the opposite of how silent this part is. remove 1 or 2 notes.

apply the same to 01:47:872 (107872|2) - 01:49:808 (109808|2) - 01:50:453 (110453|1) - 01:52:388 (112388|2) -

permalink

yeah pretty agree , change it

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

01:52:872 (112872|4,112953|2) and 01:42:549 (102549|0,102630|1) - could potentially look more alike for the 1/4 piano trill thing going on if you wanted

permalink

the original is enough for me , wanna keep for it

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

02:04:808 missing a drum here

permalink

02:06:582 same here. I am actually not very sure what those 1/2 LNs are for. I feel like the constant bass in the background is more worthy to map

permalink

add all of the drum sounds

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

02:04:947 (124947|3) - intend to be triple notes for kick? i think u can move down to 02:04:786 - for same amount note for kick as a double

permalink

same copy 02:25:592 (145592|3) - :v

permalink

v

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar

02:24:001 feels like a ctrl H section? I think that's fine but a bit more rearrangement would help
02:25:453 missing a drum note

permalink

yeah a ctrl H section
since it's same like the other part , make some big rearrangement is kinda strange , guess ctrl H is fine

permalink
Marked as resolved by _Rokii

02:36:399 (156399|1,156722|5) - i think it should be like 02:37:044 (157044|1,157528|5) - for vocal emphasis ? since ur previous part mainly use vocal oriented represent on LN

permalink

its fine in this current state , keep

permalink
Marked as resolved by Stelar
/