1. Easy (1,92 stars, 118 notes)
2. Hard (4,79 stars, 370 notes)
3. Mukku's Insane (5 stars, 458 notes)
4. Normal (3,77 stars, 178 notes)

Haneii wrote:

~General~ Fixed
Put Final Fantasy 13 OST under source and nothing in tags
Delete .osb file then full submission

~Easy~ Fixed
00:57:811 (5) - Spacing
00:58:046 (6) - ^
01:17:733 (11) - 1 down grid
01:43:515 (4) - bring it down 1 grid so it’s aligned with 3

~Hard~ Fixed
01:16:327(8) - looks a bit weird to me, maybe align with 7?
02:30:390 (1) - move up 1 grid to right
02:37:890 - remove kiai time

Slanox wrote:

[Easy]

- 00:42:577(x) : Add circle ? Didn't add

[Normal]

Good !

[Hard]

- 00:28:866(x) : Add circle ? Added
- 00:29:100(x) : ^ Didn't
- 00:32:265(8) : New combo ? Put new combo few circles ahead of this one

Astom wrote:

Hi~

[General]
-chocobo.jpeg resize it to 1024x768 or 800x600 or look for a better BG (remember full submit) Fixed

Nice~ Star

CracK wrote:

[General]
Delete .osb, please. Because of that, I have no BG while playing the map :#
You can add Square Enix to tags :3

[Easy]
01:42:108 (2) - maybe 1 down? Fixed

[Normal]
Fine

[Hard]
00:38:358 (1) - 1 right? FIxed

[Mukku's Insane]
Also fine.

Star ☆

1. Source: Final Fantasy XIII
2. Tags: Mukku OST

1. 01:15:390 (6) - new combo
2. 01:44:452 (7) - 1 grid down

1. 02:27:343 (5,6,7,8,9,10) - the OD is a bit low, so this pattern is not easily readable, players may have to go to Edit :S

1. 00:55:468 (4) - 1 grid up
2. 01:46:093 (7) - new combo
3. 02:17:265 (11) - ^
4. 02:32:499 (7) - ^
5. 02:36:952 (1) - not easy to find out which direction would the ball go, so add a SB arrow if possible.

NatsumeRin wrote:

Red: You must fix this.
Blue: You'd better do sth with this imo.
Green: Just suggestions.

[General]
there's an unused .osb file in your folder, delete it and full-submit again. Fixed
offset:+13 Fixed
when you want to add whistle on slider's beats, don't want to save time, just choose the slider and press W... this will change the sound of sliderslider, add hitsounds on every beats plz.
don't use the same green line to start (or end) kiai and change the hitsounds sample (or volume). add one more timing point before kiai to change hitsounds. example:00:30:390 Got it

[Easy]
00:52:890 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - spacing is different from before... and any reason to repeat the same shape (in fact same notes?)...? Wanted there small jumps, like in other diffs. Changed the pattern
01:00:390 (2,3,4,5) - here's some to nazi...5 is not align with (3)Fixed

[Normal]
00:54:765 (5) - new combo here... and why you like this shape so much.. Fixed and I like it beacuse it's "old fashioned" . You can see that pattern in the older maps.
01:11:640 (5) - new combo

[Hard]
HP Drain Rate-1 Fixed
00:39:530 (5) - move it left a bit Fixed
00:52:890 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ... Just jumps
01:52:890 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - it's more than a Hard imo.. make them closer? Made them closer
02:03:671 (2,3,4,5,6) - strange shape Made it a circle shape
02:19:140 (6) - the streams... orz... well new combo on this one. Fixed

[Mukku's Insane]
01:04:140 - 01:17:265 - no hitsounds..? Dunno if Mukku forgot to put there hitsounds or is it on purpose. I'll ask him, when he comes back from vacation
02:17:265 (11) - new combo here since this is too long ...
not sure about thouse streams... a little overmapped imo, but not a big deal

Colin Hou wrote:

[General]: Fixed

1. Source: Final Fantasy XIII
2. Tags: Mukku OST

[Normal]: Fixed

1. 01:15:390 (6) - new combo
2. 01:44:452 (7) - 1 grid down

[Hard]:

1. 02:27:343 (5,6,7,8,9,10) - the OD is a bit low, so this pattern is not easily readable, players may have to go to Edit :S Changed it

[Insane]:

1. 00:55:468 (4) - 1 grid up Fixed
2. 01:46:093 (7) - new combo Fixed
3. 02:17:265 (11) - ^ Fixed
4. 02:32:499 (7) - ^ Fixed
5. 02:36:952 (1) - not easy to find out which direction would the ball go, so add a SB arrow if possible. Don't know how to do that

star~

Sweyax wrote:

Hi
Mukku's Hard :

[00:23:599](4,5) Bad Spacing Arrange this Put new combo to 5 so it looks like a jump

xD and Good map

STAR~

Sakura301 wrote:

[Mukku's Insane]
02:36:965 (1) - Even with the arrow i dont think this is fine, people cant be expected to look at the arrow while they are still hitting notes on the side of the screen Then how did all the other maps with storyboard arrow warnings get ranked? I am puzzled. No changes.

Odaril wrote:

Insane:
00:43:996 (3,4,5,6,7) - Either stack them all, either don't stack any note. Okay, moved it.
This difficulty is overmapped. Okay. o-o

Sakura301 wrote:

[osz File Scan!]
Empty .osb file.
Incoherent mapping, make all diffs have the same length Not going to lenghten Normal and Easy, because there are lots of maps in which easier difficulties are shorter

[Hard]
02:32:512 (1) - This spinner feels out of place. Replaced with a slider

[Normal]
This diff is too short

[Easy]
This diff is too short
00:56:653 (1) - Anti-Jump? Fixed

Odaril wrote:

Easy:
00:55:246 (5,6,7) - Don't space them out like that, especially if you change the distance snapping right after. Fixed
02:01:809 (7) - Place it at the center of the screen. Nah
02:15:403 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Can you modify this pattern so that the last note is in the center of the screen ? Did that[/color]
You should map the rest of the map, too. Not gonna do that

Normal:
00:52:903 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - I think you shouldn't introduce those "jumps" when the distance snapping changes back to 0,7x right after. Removed jumps

Hard:
I really don't like the streams, I think they don't fit the song, but there are too many to remove them.

• Resnap these Time Points:
  00:30:390
  00:45:624
  01:49:140
  etc..(Also in other diffs)
  
  00:44:465 (4): Whistle
  01:10:715 (4,5,1): Distance

• 01:56:184 (3): Remove Clap at the end of this slider

• 01:17:395: Spinner starts here
  01:56:184 (3): Remove Clap at the end of this slider
  01:59:465 (1): Remove Clap at the beginning of this slider

• 01:03:684 (8): Finish
  01:46:692 (6): Delete this Circle
  01:56:653 (1): Add finish at the beginning of this slider
  02:36:379: Move this arrow a little earlier

Neethime wrote:

Pink words:You have to fix these,they are mistakes.
Black words:Just suggestions.

[Easy]
00:18:215 (5) - use whistle instead of finish? Done
00:25:715 (4) - ^ Done
01:56:653 - Add something here? Done
02:16:809 (4) - Clap and whistle on same note don't feel too good for me here,remove one of them? Done

[Normal]
00:16:809 (3) - remove whistle Done
00:17:278 (4) - whistle on start Done
00:18:684 (7) - use whistle instead of finish? Done
00:21:965 (7) - use whistle instead of clap? Done
01:36:028 (3,4,1) - Clap and whistle on same note don't feel too good for me here,remove one of them? Done
02:12:121 (2) - ^ Done
02:18:918 (2) - 2 grid left,2 grid up Resnapped the whole combo

[Hard]
01:16:809 (9) - new combo Done
01:52:903 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - orz...maybe a bit too hard. Fixed
02:04:153 (6) - 1 grid right Doesn't look good if I move it.
02:16:340 (4) - new combo Done

[Mukku's Insane]
01:50:090 (7) - new combo Done
01:59:465 (7) - ^ Done
02:15:403 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - xoooxooox x=whistle o=none Done
02:25:715 (2) - whistle Done

impossiblexu wrote:

Hi~~

My suggestions:

[Easy]

• Resnap these Time Points: [color=#FF00FF]Got it, won't resnap the ones that take place in breaks, 'cause they don't matter that much [/color]
  00:30:390
  00:45:624
  01:49:140
  etc..(Also in other diffs)
  
  00:44:465 (4): Whistle Fixed
  01:10:715 (4,5,1): Distance Fixed

[Normal]

• 01:56:184 (3): Remove Clap at the end of this slider Fixed

[Hard]

• 01:17:395: Spinner starts here Moved it to the red tick
  01:56:184 (3): Remove Clap at the end of this slider Fixed
  01:59:465 (1): Remove Clap at the beginning of this slider Fixed

[Mukku's Insane]

• 01:03:684 (8): Finish Sounds good enough
  01:46:692 (6): Delete this Circle Didn't delete that, but fixed (7)
  01:56:653 (1): Add finish at the beginning of this slider Nah
  02:36:379: Move this arrow a little earlier Good enough where it is

Good map~~

*STAR*

Aakiha wrote:

Easy:
00:26:653 (1,2,3) - "1" covers the end of slider "3" maybe its hard to read for an "Easy". Fixed
Normal:
00:44:465 (6) - add finish at the end of this slider? Fixed
02:21:028 (1) - add a normal-finish in the end of spinner? Added soft finish

Hard:
00:22:903 (1,2) - spacing ,it is a little far,I thinks it's ok to a hard dif but still looks not so good. Fixed
02:31:340 (6,7) - ^ Fixed

nice dif~

Insane:
02:18:332 (6) - remove this note? Don't think so

fun dif.gj Mukku ^^

That's all. Nice map:)

1. BPM 128.
2. Offset 417.

1. Increase Drain Rate by one.

1. Map till 02:37:917.

GladiOol wrote:

[General]

1. BPM 128. Fixed
2. Offset 417. Fixed

[Timing Sections]


Mukku's Insane
00:30:166 - Delete this one.
00:45:633 - Make this one start 1/2 earlier.
01:48:675 - Delete this one.
02:04:621 - Make this one start 1/1 earlier.

Hard / Normal / Easy
00:30:283 - Delete this one. Fixed
00:45:633 - Make this start 1/2 earlier. Fixed
02:04:612 - Make this start 1/1 earlier. Fixed


[Mukku's Insane]

1. Increase Drain Rate by one.

00:45:399 (x) - Add An Extra Note here please.
02:31:354 (5) - Add New Combo.
02:31:588 (1) - Remove New Combo.
02:36:979 (1) - Wow, this is REALLY ugly. Please remap or something.


[Hard]

02:28:307 (1) - Remove New Combo. Fixed
02:28:542 (2) - Add New Combo. Fixed


[Normal]

1. Map till 02:37:917.

Guess I'll map it
01:07:917 (1) - Remove New Combo. Fixed


[Easy]

This Difficulty is a litteral copy from [Normal], just with some deleted notes.
NO. Won't mod.
Remap is needed. Will remap then

NoHItter wrote:

General
Delete the .osb file and full submit.

Easy
00:29:463 (5) - Remove the slider whistle and replace the whistle at the end of the slider with a normal-sampleset finish (not soft-sampleset). Fixed
00:30:869 (x) - Add note here. Sounds better WITH a note here. Fixed
00:42:118 (x) - ^ Fixed
01:16:334 (2,3,4) - IMO, don't stack these. Fixed
02:16:329 (3) - Start the spinner here and make it end that the same time. Fixed

Normal
00:23:604 (3) - Swap this with two sliders with one repeat each. (The other slider at 00:24:307) Fixed
00:28:760 (1) - Spinner doesn't fit the music. (Make sure whatever you replace it with has a finish at 00:30:400) Fixed
01:17:271 (5) - Don't stack this. Form a hexagon instead. Fixed
02:19:845 (6) - Move the slider 1/2 forward. Make it repeat only once. And then add a note here. Fixed

Hard
00:29:463 (1) - Finish here Fixed
02:27:813 (8,9,10,1,2,3) - The rhythm pattern here is weird. Changed it

Mukku's Insane
I don't like Insanes like this that constantly changes spacing.
00:30:400 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - The spacing here is not constant and confusing.
02:36:953 (1) - The heart slider is good and all, but I really don't see the point of putting it there. Plus it needs it's own SB.

You've posted after the 3 post limit, but I'm modding it anyway since it's from a game. (see my signature)