Alright let's see what I can find. Found this on #modreqs. if you ignore any of my suggestions, please give a me a reason why you ignored it. there's modders like me who won't take no for an answer unless you put a reason on why you ignored it.
Bold: Unrankable/must fix.
Red: You should fix it, but it's up to you.
Italic: Suggestion. Feel free to ignore this if you don't like it.
Blue: Comment. Just putting this for fun
[General]
I think the lead in is too long. set it to either 2000 or 1000 so that it'd starts quickly, but at the same time, it gives players some time to get ready.remove the letterbox during breaks since you're using a video.[Easy]
hmm maybe a bit "too" easy for beginners. increase the HP by 1.00:28:840 (1,2,3,4,5) -
for this 1 remove all claps and add claps at every 3rd downbeat starting at (1). it sounds a lot nicer and it fits with the song IMO. if you ignore this, then add clap at the end of (2,5) to make a nice clap pattern.00:36:289 (2) -
if you add a clap at the end of (2,5) do the same thing here. same reason as above.00:39:599 (4) -
^00:54:496 (4) -
maybe Ctrl+J? i think the path looks hard for beginners judging by the direction it's taking.00:57:806 (1) -
add a finish to match the vocals?01:09:392 (1,1,1) -
i think this would be hard for beginners because since the notes have their own combo, it'd be hard for beginners where to go, so remove the NCs at the 2nd (1) and at the 3rd (1).01:34:220 (5) -
don't stack this note because it'd be hard for beginners when to hit this note, and since the hitburst is covering it, that makes it even harder for them, so unstack it to make it easier and less confusing.01:37:530 (1) -
same as 00:57:806.01:49:944 (1) -
replace this for a 1/1 slider and a circle, remove the NC for the 1/1 slider because the vocals are still going and the circle should be a NC because of new lyrics and it follows the long pause.02:08:151 (4) -
same as 00:57:806.02:12:496 -
remove the break because it's unnecessary and the HP bar doesn't decrease that much.add claps at the end for all 1/1 repeat sliders. since you have a clap at the repeat arrow, it'd sound a lot nicer if you can add claps at the end.[Laurier]
00:11:203 (2) -
replace this for a circle followed by a 1/1 slider to follow vocals. the 1st note in the combo follows the instrumental.01:09:496 (1) -
hmm maybe space out this spinner? this might surprise players as it starts right when the note is it.01:26:771 (3,4) -
i see a better pattern, so align these notes to (1,2) so that it'd make a zig-zag pattern. make (3) a curved slider so that it'd flow a lot nicer to the next note.wow i like this diff. pretty fun to play.[SakiK]
01:41:254 (3) -
move this somewhere else. IMO the overlap looks bad during gameplay.there's a few more problems but it's nothing big.[Insane]
change the diff settings because these settings are the same as DN's diff.00:07:903 (5) -
make this a NC like the 1st and 2nd combo. the lyrics change from there.00:12:703 (8) -
^00:36:703 (5,6) -
how about moving these notes here? it looks fun and gives a great challenge for players. IMO going around in circles looks too easy as players might clear that easily.00:59:047 (3) -
change the direction of this slider. in other words make it like this so that it'd make a border around (1). IMO the overlap looks bad during gameplay.01:11:668 (4,5) -
hmm stack this on (3) (no DS or grid snap). it looks more neater and nicer if you do this.01:14:358 (9) -
this should be a NC because that's where the guitar starts.01:15:185 (1) -
remove the NC if you follow the suggestion above.01:16:013 (6) -
if you follow both, make this a NC because it follows the long pause.01:22:634 (4) -
add a finish at the beginning to match the vocals, and make this a NC because of new lyrics.01:36:289 (1,2,3) -
try spacing this out a bit. maybe 0.2 spacing for the 3 notes? stacking is too easy because players don't move their cursor.01:42:703 (5,6,7,8) -
if this is supposed to be a diamond, make it nicer. i don't like the shape at all.02:00:909 (1) -
either move this somewhere else or adjust this slider. the overlap looks bad during gameplay.02:06:496 (2,3) -
hmm how about switching spots? this looks too easy and it's near the end of the song.[D.N.Angel]
00:29:668 (1,2,3,4) -
re-arrange this to a diamond. IMO this looks too easy for this diff, if you ignore this then extend the jump to challenge players.01:03:806 (6) -
add a clap at the end to keep the consistency.not to my expectations but overall, this is a nice diff.I guess that's it. GL
